Added: 5 years ago
From: laurenlw
Views: 140,743
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (205)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i wonder why they pick zac play troy ? the real troy is on the stage.. luv drew so much..

  • i dont understand why he didnt play troy in the movie since drew isnt even ugly haha even though i loved zac in hsm. boy charm lol.

  • i was at this concert

  • when they came to my city and i saw this i was like who the fuck is this where's zac but when drew started to sing i was like he's cute and can sing ok i can get into this then i found out it was drews voice n not zac's i was like then y the fuck did he not play troy in the movie thts messed up it would have be easier n not let us down in the end

  • Dude, why wasn't Drew casted for Troy instead of Zac? Nothing against Zac...

  • i read somewhere that it was drew that were singing instead of Zac using hes own voice...

  • NOOOOOOOOOO.. ZAC IS SOOO MUCH BETTERRRR... AND HOT, DREW LOVES VANESSA BUT SHE LOVES ZAC, AND SHE IS RIGHT!!!!sahuashuashus

  • hes the one that sang the song in the movie idk why they didnt make him troy he prob looked to old or something.

  • Zac isn't singing this song in high school musical its Drew's voice...

    and I'm not lying....

  • he does sing in all 3 movies i like zac hes hot sexii and everything but drew should of been the one in the movie cause zac is talking all the credit when drew was the one singing

  • umm.. why is it drew and not zac in the first place?. shouldn't they keep the originals? hmm.. wow. but i say tht zac and vannessa goes together. but i <3 drew seeley. hes manlier, cuter, hotter, sexier, and better than zac; no offense to any zac fan. haha

  • He should've been troy than Zac....but Zac is very hott......hmmm i dunno.

  • wow ashley kissed zac and drew seeley on suit life of zack and cody XD

  • drew is so hot and better then zack

  • y dont just let Drew be Zac in HSM

  • Drew I love you <3

  • watch?v=6-EQQ5s-sBM&feature=re­lated

    just watch it... it will end all your speculations and doubts:D

    zac efron did sing in HSM 1, but he just sang the beginnings and endings of the songs because he was casted late and the songs were prepared an octave higher than what zac can sing.. so they decided to get drew..:D their voice blend perfectly right?:D

    in HSM 2 and HSM3 it was all zac efron:D but you can't deny how amazing drew's voice is also:D

  • & the reason why he or anione looks like they're lip syncing in HSM1,2,3 is cause they were. they recorded the songs before they film. nobody actualy sings during the real set. -_-. tht was why zac sucked at lip syncing in the movies. cause he doesnt lip sync. make perfect sense right?

  • Zac efron wasnt lip syncing. his voice and drew's are combined together to make it sound nicer and harmonised in HSM3. Zac wasnt there because he was filming hair spray. c'mon guys. pay attention.

  • I love both, but Drew looked too old for the part, and zac did not lip sing.That is just another rumur.

  • You guyz are all idiots! No offense but if U listen 2 his voice ZAC EFRON DID NOT LIP SING!!!!!!!!!! Think about how Zac's voice sounded in HSM. They both have different pitches. I love Drew Seeley, but there was a reason he didn't get the part of Troy. Zac Efron was perfect 4 this part. Drew duzn't sound very good in this, but he duz have a BEAUTIFUL voice in Another Cinderella Story.

  • didnt u guys kno??

    zac never actualy sang any of the hsm songs he always lip syncs its obvious in the first song in the first movie

  • yea he does lip sync in the first movie only thats why drew is singing in this video cause zac didn't sing the songs he only sang the beginning of each song then drews voice came in.

  • whas zac lip singin?

    and where is he?

  • Zac was make a new film.

    I think that was 17 again!!

  • hairspray, NOT 17 AGAIN

    stupid

  • jajaja you are stupid.

    I'm not addicted to Zac.

    I can life without watch the film!!

    lol

  • I lovee drews voice.. os great, and well if zack dont sang the songs... drew do it great.. but i think that for drew is kind of hard that he sings and he is not the one who acts.. jajaj he must be like "?":S

  • Its Only Because His Voice Hadn't Broke Yet And It Was All High At One point :L Bless

  • i cant belive zac was lip singin

  • Really ? he was lip singin ?

  • he is filming hairspray anyway drew seeley sang for zac in HSM 1

  • vanessa sounds diffrent lower it's not good

  • Drew Seeley is singing hsm 1!not zac efron

  • oh i wish isney could think of another FILM for Drew!!!!!Droolin Drew!!!

  • Why is singing Drew it?

  • because zack ef. is filming hairspray at the same time.

  • Because it's Drew who's singing in the movie (HSM1). When Zac opens his mouth in the songs, it's Drew's voice coming out.

  • OMG!...Isn't it weird??? They're voices sound  A LITTLE like eachother...right?

  • people say zac couldnt reach the notes but idont know for sure :))

  • Why didnt they just put him in the first movie, he is hot enough

  • haha vanessa ruins the song

  • i dont think so :)

  • wow hes so much better than zac

  • drew did zac's voice in high school musical 1

  • OMG! Is Drew Seeley Zac Efron's Understudy? OMG!!!!!

  • zac was in canada when the hsm concert happened and drew was a guest

  • actually.. drew did zac's voice in the first movie when he sang ^^

  • hes better than zac

  • drew is tottaly hot and all why wasnt he in the movie??????

  • i wonder y he was singing that song with her

  • he sings in the first movie. not zac

  • whoa man that drew guy can sing totally agree with ya on that one they should have casted drew instead of zack true they have looks but as the singing drew wins hands down

  • i think zac is cool and all, buut drew could have played him instead! :P

  • Im sorry for all you lovers out there, but vanessa hudgens sucks! no talent. that drew guy sounds really good though

  • i hate her too!!!

  • Drew, Drew, Drew, Drew

  • They're really good, too bad the video quality isn't that good.. :D

    Did Drew Seeley sing with Savannah Outen too?

  • drew good vannessa, not so much

  • no offense but i sorta like drew better than zac.

    yeah zacs hot,

    but drew idk has more to him ya know?

  • i can´t see very well this video, but drew is better tan zac!!

  • wait.....i thot zac efron sing this song..

    buht now i found out..ahaha!!

    hez better den zac efron..

  • i guess troy is just looks...

    but drew also has looks..

    hsm should have just casted him... at least

    even just as a minor char coz he's a preety good singer, very talented!!

  • umm, actually.. drew seeley sang for zac for hsm1. x)

    but zac efron practiced, and after hairspray.. he could sing.

    so he sang for hsm2 and hms3 (: (: yum :9

  • why is drew sealy singing with her. why not zac???

  • drew would make a better troy bolton don't see the big deal about effron seriously he has to have another guy sing for him, cant act its just for his looks and still nothin special. drew has it all!

  • i agree

  • that song SOMETIMEs

    makes me emotional , and KIND OF cry

  • i bet zac is damn jealous cus he's not singing with his girlfriend..

  • actually i like drew seeley better...he is awsome in the movie Another Cinderella Story....i love him

  • zac is wayyyyy hotter..most deff in hsm3..but i must admit drew has a better voice and much more stage presence not to mention he is more manly lol

  • @breya4 kinda but i sooo SAY THUMBS UP!!!!!!!!!

  • Drew is amazing!

  • .. amazing and hot!! Totally a fan of his after watching Another Cinderella Story.. I actually wish he starred in HSM as Troy rather than just singing for him.. I mean come on, he totally has the looks!

  • Oh, I know. I completely agree with you. He's so hot!

  • good

  • Drew seeley is so hot, i like zac to, but hes not as hot, and i dont think zac should loose his spot on hsm just because of it, but i really like drew, and i am in love wit hJoe Jonas

  • for both or which songs??

  • wait zac didnt sing in hsm?? did he sing in hairspray cause it sounded like he did n he was good (n i luv drew) someone pleez pm me n explain

  • Drew is the singing voice for Troy in High School Musical

  • i think drew is better than zac :0

  • i agree!!!

  • drew is amazing he gives me chills. i dont like Zac. =/

  • same here

  • i went to their concert

    in missouri :)

  • Drew sang the high pitches because Zac couldn't hit them. they voices were blended

  • i mean i see how drew could have done the vocals on HSM 1 but if you listen to zac's vocals in HSM 2 and hairspray you can tell that its the same person and that it sounds completely different from drew

  • what i dont understand is why if zac cant sing did he get a part in hairspray?

  • he got a voice couch

    or whatever its called

    =]

  • his voice is recorded and they remixed it

  • drew seeley and zac efron' voice is combined together to sound like troy's singing voice. you can't give all the credit to zac efron nor drew seeley.

  • What is this stuff about combined vocals? Seeley does all the vocals and Efron has repeatedly stated he does not sing. Give credit where credit is due! One can act, the other can sing.

  • If you listen to the soundtrack version of this song, u can hear that Zac sings the first lines,

    "We're soaring, flying... there's not a star in heaven that we can't reach"

    and then you can hear an obvious vocal change. So, Drew sings the rest of the song.

    I like the was Zac sounds, but I LOVE Drew's voice!!!

    Anywho, great song! This part of the movie gives me the chills! It's that great! : )

  • why need to confer Zac and Drew?

    Zac isn't better than Drew and Drew isn't better than Zac...they are both talented, the only bad thing in Zac that he couldn't sing the higher notes but his voice is good so.

    please stop the shit talk just let's love them!

  • exactly! thank you!

  • highly disappointed by vanessa's performance. she's extremely flat for most of the song. poor vanessa. at least she's cute.

  • I actually feel bad for Drew he has more talent then the whole cast of highschool musical combined but zac efron is the one who blows up. It's totally not fair but i guess thas how it is, the people with no real talent sometimes become famous. I would say there is way more talent on youtube then there is in the actual music industry.

  • You don't know that. Vanessa and Zac are actually both very talened. In fact, the whole cast is. If they weren't talented they wouldn't be able to handle what they do. I think everyone is taking for granted how hard it is to make a musical. Also, just because Drew's a good singer doesn't mean he's a good actor and dancer. Being in High School Musical requires a lot more than just being a good singer. The whole cast is very talented, even Zac.

  • I know rite? they have grt voice!

  • Drew is a fantastic dancer as well as singer, and I can't say he's a great actor, having never seen him in anything, but it's not hard to be a better actor than Zac Efron. He's not terrible, but he's nothing spectacular either.

  • Well, considering the fact that he did the actual musical, I would definately say he is a great actor and dancer, since in my opinion it takes way more talent to do a live performance than just spend 4 hours filming one song at a time.

  • Yes, but if you've ever been on set, you'd know how much work that is. The lights are hot, you're dancing and singing... It's not easy at all.

  • The cast is all talented but I agree with you about hoe talentless people become famous. Have you ever heard Rianna live?

  • she sang even higher notes than this. this note is not a problem vor her voice. i don't think so.

  • Vanessa can't hit the high note at 2:19. She probably recorded it, then they amped up the sound in the studio to make it louder and higher.

  • disney had a contract wiv zac that he uses his own voice to sing in hsm2 but he broke it. So in hsm2 zac is lip singing but drew is singing. BUT ZAC IS STILL SOOO SEXY

  • Its only hsm that zac doesnt sing, he does in hsm2 :D lol

  • wow. im sorry but thats pretty dumb. get your facts stright before you think you know everyhting. ZAC DOES ALL HIS OWN SINGING IN HSM2 IN HAIRSPRAY. if you still dont beleive me, then compare zac's voice in HSM2 to hairspray. its EXACTLY the same. do yuo honestly think drew would sing for him in hairspra, too? its totally zac singing in HSM2 and Hairspray and if think its drew your on some kind of drug.

  • lol it's just the voice quality in the video guys. Drew Seeley, the guy singing with her, did most of the songs in the first High School Musical. Zach lip sang the rest, but he did some parts. Zach didn't have the vocal range for most of the songs that's why. That's why his voice is altered a lot in Bet on It in the 2nd High School Musical. Zach did sing all the songs in the 2nd movie though.

  • his voice is not altered. they wrote the songs too high for zac in the first one cuz they were written b4 they knew who was singign them so in HSM2 they were written lower and its him singing it.

  • No, Efron is not singing all the songs in HSM 2. Do the research and you will see. Plus look at the song credits on your HSM 2 CD. The ones where Efron is credit as the singer are his vocals. The ones credited "Troy" are actually Seeley.

  • they have no chemistry whatsoever

  • its not about chemistry

  • Yeah... It kinda is...

    They need the chemistry to feel the song!

  • Completely agree....

  • with who?

  • the person whos comment i replied 2 ? nickjsoffdachain...

  • yes it is. they need chemisty to complete the feeling of the song.

  • its a tour for all those people who can't get enough of HSM

    they only care about the fact that "Gabriella" is right in front of them

    I think the producers might have realised (unlike you) that they dont need to have chemistry as long as the singing is good and people come away satisfied

    STOP HATING!

  • i hate it when they make other people substitute for celebs, it bugs me

  • i think this one is LIVE. i've seen most of the concert through dvd and most of them aren't live.

  • nunca canta Zac Efron?? ni en la 1º pelicula ni en la 2º???

  • Él te canta el musical 1 de la High School secundaria y 2 que apenas pulimentan encima de su voz considerablemente en el estudio.

  • zac canta en hsm2

  • zac doesnt sing in the original one. thats all drew seeley. in HSM 2 though, its all zac.

  • Zac sings a TINY bit in the 1st HSM. it saysd so on the trivia page on IMDb. go check for urself if u don't believe me.

  • how do you know all this? I umst say if it is true they've done it well because you don't really hear it.. and it's a bit weird to because Zac's voice don't sound that low...:O

  • does drew sing in hsm2? or is it zac?

  • it's zac in hsm2 i think ! x

  • zac in hsm 2

  • Wow, I never new Drew was the voice of Troy in HM1. I bet he wished he could have done that role. He probably would be just as big as Zac right now.

  • well...vanessa...i mean she's cute and sweet and pretty, so we normally forgive her 4 everything...i respect her and all but i think that she gets tired so fast...i know she's human and all but that is just one of the worst performances i ever saw...i mean drew is okay...he's dancing and singing at the same time and his singin was great...and vanessa also sucks at dancing...cuz that was a disaster..=S

  • thats good seats !!

  • omg, you were actually in the front row?

  • um, they say that drew seely was the real voice of zac efron... and i believe that. but why dont drew seely just be in the movie and replace zac efron? i mean, it causes SOOO much confusionn!

  • so...yall saying drew and zac's voice is mixed? wait who does the most singing?? in hsm1 and hsm2???

  • let me get u all straight in hsm 1 zac and drews voice were blended. now in hsm2 that is zacs real voice

  • oh ok. thanks for the info. atleast he's using his real voice now. i think he used his own voice in Hairsray as well.

  • yeah

  • it's really hard singing live and dancing, it's really tiring and you can't redo it til it's perfect. That's the only problem with it really. :-( Vanessa is still a good singer.

  • dis iz just my opinion yh,i fink dey dont connect as much as zask nd nessa,it feels lik 2 solos,but i stilll fink dey are gr8 singas,PEACE

  • uh..vanessa isnt really good at singing live is she?

  • vanessa is a awesome singer live but she was sick during the tour, and she was singing and dancing at the same time, or when she sings a slow song, she sang it after doing a fast song. But when vanessa isnt singing adn dancing at the same time, shes really good at singing live.

  • if u listen carefully u can hear that the first sentence (''we're soarin', flyin', there's not a star in heaven that we can't reach...'')is not sang by drew...it's zac...i totally figured that out when i listened to it...I'm still shocked, though...

  • omg...that really sucks...till now I thought it was Zac...i thought that he's perfect...I mean it was like: he can sing, he can act and he's cute...disappointed a lot!

  • well it wasnt him singing in hsm 1. but in hairspray and hsm 2 im pretty sure its all him singing. so i guess he's been getting some voice lessons. lol

  • he doesnt need singing lessons he zac only didnt sing in hsm because he had to do 3 weeks of intensive basketball training for the movie so he did a mini recording and his voice and drew's were mixed together. i watched access hollywood lol.

  • oh i c..lol

    well im just glad that in hsm 2 and hairspray he did all the singing. =)

  • yeah zac efron can't sing. all he has is the looks and he becomes big all over the world along with the high skool musical cast.drew should be more famous than zac.

  • lol i totally agree. i dont even know why they even hired zac(someone who wasnt a singer at the time hsm was being filmed) to play a character in a musical! they shoulda just hired drew and leave it as that instead of having all these conspiracy about who really sang the song.

    but i do have to agree that zac did great singing some of the songs in hairspray. i thought it'd be just as awkward as hsm1 but he did prove me wrong.

  • they really really should have just used drew. i mean he sings, he's cute, and i dont really think he'd be that bad at acting.

    And anyways zac doesn't even play sports.

  • lol i know. if he can sing. im pretty sure he can act as well. i mean there is a few singers out there turned actors and vice versa. =/

  • they WERE going to use drew! but he couldnt cause of schedualing conflicts or something so they had zac do it but had drew come back to do the vocals cause zac couldn't sing these songs the way disney wanted them to

  • oh haha. that sorta sucks.

  • # Zac Efron's singing voice was that of Andrew Seeley, who was also considered for the role. Seeley sang the entirety of "Get'cha Head in the Game" and the reprise of "What I've Been Looking For." Efron only sings the first four lines of "Start of Something New," the first sentence of "Breaking Free," and during the scene on the balcony. The reason for this is because Efron's natural voice was too low for that of a tenor and the producers wanted a tenor to match the role.

  • zac efron can not sing

  • why they were at it they should have got some1 to dance for vanessa

  • o__O i didnt know! tht sucks now knowing it wasnt zac singing in the movie =( lol ... so its drew singing in the second part too?

  • who the heck is drew?

  • drew seeley, the guy whos voice was blended with zacs for the film as zacs voice was too low....

    basically drew sang for zac in high school musical.

  • nah ah! r u seriuos?????/

  • yep - 100%

  • the guy that sings 4 zac cuz zav sucks ass and only has looks which is apparently aall he needs to get in fame

  • drew is really hot. i love how he looks at vanessa. he's just got that smile..... zac is cute too.

  • yeah the way Drew looks at Vanessa is so sweet =)

  • im confused. they gave this concert on disney channel and evryone was lipsyncing. but they're not lipping here. what?!?

  • they played the actual tracks on disney channel to give it better sound

  • wow.. i think that Drew Seeley should have played Zac Efron's part.. Drew is much cuter and better!!

  • i agreee :)

  • i think Zac is better than drew

  • i agreeee :)

  • yh i thnk drew's voice is amazing. but i still really prefer zac to drew. and am so hapz that he's singin by himsef in hsm2. Zac has an amazing voice too! check out hairspray's trailer. And zac and vanessa are going out!!! whoo!

  • but zac never sang in High school musical, it was all a voice over done by Drew Seeley..

  • Man you were close no fair!

  • i think that drew has an amazing voice but i much prefer zac plus in HSM 2 he's singing all his own songs !

  • I dont get why they laughed at the end and why was she laughing and it sounded like she was still singing...? hmmmmmm.....?