Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (522)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • R.I.P John Marston. You and Your Words of Wisdom Shall Be Remembered Forever in Our Hearts.

  • This game was great, but it could have had more emotion in it. All it was was anger, and impatience. Like when he finally comes home, hes wife is just like: "oh your back. Well that's good. Uncle is being a huge douchebag, so go talk to him." And Marston mentions his past, but hes never really reminiscent. He never cries, he's never really happy, and the only other main character is Jack, who's kindof a dick. The story was great, it just needed more emotion.

  • i was difficult to play jack, i was to use to john :(

  • The moral of the story is:... Despite your death, your children won't learn a fucking thing.

  • five minutes.... forty one seconds.... thats how long i cried during the credits in the middle of the night.... nothing to light the room but the glowing words of the credits.... game of the year... every year... blessed are the peacemakers....

  • If only they had started playing this right before John opened the gates to his barn...

    

  • this reminds me of better times. the world of red dead means something more to me than a video game. it is truly amazing. from casa madrugada to blackwater this is an amazing game. it feels like an entire other world. a world where im happier. thinking about how much this game means to me almost brings me to tears. well done rockstar. well done.

  • 5 ppl were killed by john marston

  • This song gives me goosebumps of emotion, when it came on the credits I got hopeless of why this had to happen, but it did have to, everyone pays for they have done and shows that nobody is able to escape their past and live happily ever after. Very realistic story line, so believable. I wish this was a book, I would read it so many times. But personally I think the game story line itself is better than any story ive heard or read. Great job Rockstar this game will stay in my heart forever.

  • this has to be one of the best games ever made

  • sad

  • god damm man this song sad :,(

  • 5 people didn't survive to the savage western life.

  • the moral of the story is:... YOU CANT TRUST THE SYSTEM

  • this song is so fucking beautiful

  • This is my funereal song...

  • @DJclangaming i was thinking the same thing

  • Rockstar, don't make another. This one was so amazing, nothing would be better and you would ruin it.

  • Awesome and Sad at the same time

  • Best rockstar game ever made.

  • Those piano keys sink my mood every time I hear the first notes. Just plain depressing after the ending of the game.

  • Best game ever

  • Lesson learned from this game.

    Life's a bitch, then you die.

    Great game though.

  • 5 people don't like beautiful music...

  • so ... haben John und Jack Marston sterben? weil ich nur noch ein komisches Gefühl jack starb in Undead Nightmare, die vor Red Dead Redemption passiert war. aber ich weiß, dass John in Red Dead Redemption gestorben, aber wenn er stirbt u zu-Buchse, die in Undead Nightmare gestorben ist, so ist dies der Beweis, dass ich ein komisches Gefühl haben, ändern

  • @kooldude292 Undead Nightmare passiert zwischen zwei missionen auf deiner ranch am end aber was in Undead Nightmare passiert ist non-cannon, es hat keinen effect auf die normale geschichte

  • A shit load of people commented on my comment and they should know that's not how I entirely feel it's just wat I thought most people MIGHT be thinking. Guess I was wrong : /

  • On my Ipod in 3...2...1.. :D

  • I remember starting up the game, thinking what the future missions would be like as the opening cutscene rolled. I didn't expect such a beautiful and fun game, with unforgettable characters and amazing environments. Thank you Rockstar.

  • IM gonna learn how to play this... better than the one song i know... axel f lol. Would this be hard for an about 4 week keyboard player who practices everyday?

  • Kinda sad

  • Sadish

  • Kinda sad

  • Sadish

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 ditto bro

  • SOMEONE PLEASE MAKE A VIDEO ON HOW TO PLAY THIS ON PIANO

  • Comment removed

  • The has to be another Red Dead game

  • Ross, you gave me a gun. I should've used it on you when I had the chance; instead i had my son use it

  • Anyone know where I can download this?

  • HERBERT MOON!!!!!!!!! :D

  • this reminds me one of the themes in LOST, but i forgot which one exactly.

  • @DiMak2109 Life and Death theme. Or find the quiet place (:

  • I really think John Marston was the best male video game character ever created.

  • Niko Bellic went through Alot too. People, please, stop bashing on Him. I RESPECT both of them, because they went through more than i can imagine... please, you NEED to stop. Sincerely, Sims2mw

  • @sims2mw People, these guys are only characters, people created them, so stop being so dramatic. Yes they are great characters, I know that, but don't fight because of them....

  • @l3raml3ruins THANK YOU! For saying it so I dont have to!

  • @sims2mw Yeah, but Niko was boring and depressed, and constantly bitched, and always felt bad for himself. Marston did not.

  • I agree with the second top comment. The thing with John Marston that makes him unique to tall the Rockstar protaginists is that he is doing something for people other then himself. All the other protaginists as badass as they have been, have been heartless, selfish, drug addicted bastards while John is doing everything for his family and he shows it too. He even dies for them while all the others only care for themselves. With the exception of Niko Bellic and Carl Johnson.

  • red dead redemtion was my favorite movie of 2010

  • This game doesn't teach me anything except life sucks and there's no such thing as a second chance. :|

  • @smorinator Really? I learned a lot, including: Men are born, and then they're formed.

  • Comment removed

  • @strife93 *clap* *clap* *clap* *stands up* *claps louder and faster* *Everyone in comments starts clapping*

  • @NarkoHunt Yay, 3 months later....!

  • @NarkoHunt people automatically thumbs up whatever is already thumbs upped, even if it contradicts the previous top comment...

  • @NarkoHunt *CLAP CLAP C;AP*

    OH NOES THAT CLAPPING IS BEING REPLACED BY C;APING

    *CLAP*

    there it is again

  • @smorinator Your blanket statement brings to mind a line said in the game from the Native American to the Professor, "enlighten me about the ways of the world from the couple of hours you spent in the comfort of your hotel room."

    But joking aside, it's just a very well-written game. If that's what you got from it, sorry.

  • @smorinator you miss the big point of it, John wanted best for his family and mostly for his son because when he was in the gang he didn't have time for jack and he felt bad, when the government killed john jack knew he did that for his future and he even told jack to not do what he did in his past and not to kill..but he shot Edgar ross after tracking him...he might not have a second change but he will always be known by his son and friends with his good deeds and Redeemed his life

  • @smorinator Welcome to real life

  • @smorinator if that is all you got from this beautiful game, then i feel bad for you, friend.

  • this gives me chills everytime. john is byfar the best character in any video game and maybe in movies. a movie version of this would be awsome.

  • SPOILER

    I cried when John died, but I felt satisfied when I shot Edgar in the face.

    END OF SPOILER

    I hope in GTA V that R* puts a nod to John in there somewhere.

  • @l3raml3ruins until you get killed anyway

  • Great music to relax, and think about your problems and realising, it all will be allright.

  • BLESSED BE THE PEACEMAKERS

  • It was also very gratifying to kill that agent cocksucker who had John killed anyway :) Rockstar never fails when it comes to storylines. I wish they would make more games like this instead of GTA. I prefer to play a charachter such as John instead of some jackass slinging cocain and cock smacking hookers...GTA is fun but it will NEVER live up to this game. I can honestly say that I've never been so emotionally attached to a game as this one. It was like playing a movie. Money well spent.

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 I agree, but R* has pleased me with Niko. He actually cared about people. He wasn't just a murder machine. CJ was close to that to, but the "It's my constitutional right, bitch!" line sort of ruins it for me on the soft side. More people like John and Niko is what I want.

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 Correction. They failed with L.A. Noire.

  • @AnonDude2

    They didn't make L.A. Noire, they published it.

    Team Bondi made L.A. Noire

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 GTA 4 was just as serious in tone as RDR, and had almost as great a story. Although the dialog form civilians and other things were usually comedic and satirical. Like, there's a company in the game called Getalife, and the Statue of Liberty has Hillary Clinton's face. Not to say RDR didn't have it's own satire, like Herbert Moon. And the gameplay is pretty much the same. The only major differences are cars instead of horses, no deadeye, and taking place in the modern day.

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 I have to agree with you, mynamesnotjosh05, Red Dead Redemtpion is better. How good did it feel when you planted 6-15 bullets in Edgar Ross on the riverbank. It kinda made me feel sorry for Jack, actually. Seeing his father dead by the government's hand. But then again, that's vengeance.

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 exactly

  • @mynamesnotjosh05

    Can't say I hated Niko in gta 4. He wasn't as cool a character as John imo, but he was still interesting and enjoyable. Both are fantastic games.

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 Gta is great for causing chaos though. I will admit, this game was better for story, but for free roam i gotta give to like GTA san andreas

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 could not have put it better! such an emotional game! :'(

  • @mynamesnotjosh05 Amen to that... coulndt say it better ^^

  • I hate that John died but if you look at the story as a whole it actually is well done. John had killed many people throughout his life and regreted his younger years. He left the outlaw lifestyle behind and became a rancher and started a family as if some way of seeking redemption. But you cant run away from your sins and he realized this before he opened those barn doors. His death became his ultimate redemption of the crimes he committed. Best storyline I've ever seen in a game.

  • Best game ever. The story mode ever. It won game of the year for a reason.

  • I haven't finish the game yet... but sadly, I know the end... and I'm crying like a baby. I'm a girl and I just LOVE westerns... that is the best game that I have ever played... I thought that I was just a stupid girl to be so into the story... but reading the comments I saw that it's normal... God! How I love this game...

  • reminds me of lost

  • I also finished the game and was in deep thoughts while staring at the credits., I actually began to cry a little , I really miss my childhood , when I had no worries , no stress me and my friends played outside every day as if we where in the greatest adventures. *sigh* and I couldn't wait to grow up ..... :(

  • Without a doubt the best game ever played, only game that I became emotionally attached to the protagonist in. Anyone who thinks GTA is better than this is obviously crazy.

    R.I.P John Marston

  • @bobsyouruncle1998 thumbs up x100000000000000

  • The 4 Dislikes where Bill Williamson, Dutch van der Linde, Javier Escuella, and Edgar Ross

  • @Streetmaste ... 5.. and the woman u trew to the train to get the achievement

  • I think I beat this at the perfect moment. It was real late at night, I was alone in the living room, got really pulled into the game. Then I finished it.. swallowed sadness, killed that asshole Ross, then this song and Deadman's Gun came up. My heart sank and I just sat there and watched the credits. Weirdly, the feeling was like I lost a family member and I was thinking about the times with that person. But I lost Marston.. jerked my tears and sunk my heart. No doubt Rockstar's best game yet.

  • @beomonkey I'm going to the beach in a few hours. I got up and randomly decided to pick up RDR again. I hadn't played in 3 months or so. It turned out that I was at the last mission with John. I hate that he died. I'm downloading this and puting this on my iPod. I'm gonna listen this on my way to the beach. : )

  • @pkcrossing89 Epic man! I don't know why, but the song is just plain out beautiful. It just makes you think a lot too, like what John did and everything. It basically fits every sad moment of our lives as well as John's. That beach ride must have been a great feeling!

  • @beomonkey Not really. My little cousin ruined it. He's a brat. Though I did listen to this in the hotel room late at night looking towards the beach and the ocean.

  • @beomonkey dude i dnt no how u did it but thats EXACTLY wut happened 2 me i was just ther feeling empty like losing a family member and crying the BEST game ever

  • i dont think people would believe how emotionally attatched i am to this game and this soundtrack. i kinda freak myself out with how much i literally love this shit.

  • The beginning sounds a lot like 'Please Don't Go' by Barcelona.

    I don't mind; it's beautiful.

  • i think it was better when he died because it make a stronger ending if you get what i mean like that bit of sadness you get makes the ending good where is if he lived sure you would still like it but then it wouldnt be as powerful if i was the creators of this game i would of done the same thing because its rare when a main character in a game/movie dies because you make a bond with them and then it strikes you =)

  • @Bobert1016 ha ha

  • R.I.P John Marston :D

  • @falloutman211 hey sut up hey was bad assss

  • @mrgw22 jesus christ hes a VIDEO GAME CHARACTER

  • @mrgw22 jesus christ hes a VIDEO GAME CHARACTER and btw learn how to speak english

  • @falloutman211 Speaking English? First remember to use the Apostrophe "He's" not "hes"

    Secondly Jesus Christ is a name and in every country that uses Latin alphabetics they write names with a big first letter

    Thirdly you just yourself commented "R.I.P John Marston" so you are too attached to a VIDEO GAME CHARACTER

    Have a Nice Day =)

  • @uselessdave2 be quiet, troll

  • @sims2mw You might piss somebody off

  • @uselessdave2 your pissing me off for being a troll

  • @sims2mw "You're" remember the apostrophe ;) because you just said that my pissing is you off for being a troll.

    Damn I should be an English teacher...

  • @uselessdave2 English Teachers don't swear though...=-)

  • @sims2mw Maybe I'm that bad teacher who hates every student and the "bad guys" like him and good children reports about me to the principal

  • @uselessdave2 you would be better than my english teacher =-)

  • this song is very sad for me but is excelent

  • This song makes wish there was a way to change the ending of this game..

  • I hate how everyone says "I miss John Marston..." Because I haven't even beated the game yet!

  • Does the beggining remind you of Minecraft? anyone?

  • @SuperKnifeable Minecraft music<3

  • This really makes me cry...

  • Someone said, further down the list said "We Don't need L.A Noir", but perhaps we do. Simply to get over the pain and betrayel, characters from this game left with us. And to heal our pain of john marston, it may not be better than Red dead redemption, but perhaps it acts as, a distraction, in a way...

  • Anyone know where I can download this song?

  • @pissodick There is a different version of this song in the sound track (which I am sure you can find if you look). However this is the only place I know of with this version of the song :/

  • This song has a bitter sweetness to it that cannot be adequately described in words.

  • es el unico video donde pienso que los 4 dislikes fue porque se equivocaron al puntuar...simplemente una cancion hermosa

  • This game needs an alternate ending like I am Legend. I think they went to far with killing john. He is like the Niko of the wild west.

  • @Roflcop360 ah, it seems someone hasn't seen the extra ending.

  • when us guys cry over video games our girls look at us like were idiots but they truley dont know how guy emotions work xD lolz

  • Edgar Ross, Javier Escuela, Bill Williamson, and Dutch dislike this.

  • @MrWackypackages Thats probally about right lol :)

  • @MrWackypackages looks like allender did too

  • @MrWackypackages

    And now, Colonel Augustin Allende doesn't, either.

  • @MrWackypackages So does Archer Fordham

  • @MrWackypackages shut the fuck up you dickhead motherfucker

  • @MrKiller66613

    Dude, what's wrong with you, do have a coconut up your butt?

  • @RockStar51588 you are an unfunny piece of shit whose comment made old people die from cancer, it was so stupid and gay and unfunny and unoriginal

  • @RockStar51588 al so who the fuck says butt, are you fucking 7 years old?

  • @MrKiller66613

    What does it say about my age if I'm using the word "butt"? Idiot..

  • @MrWackypackages actually, i like dutch and bill but i hate edgar ross bcause he is a cop

  • @MrWackypackages

    dont forget Irish

  • @MrWackypackages and De Santa xD

  • i miss john marston and this song is sad but good

  • Edgar,Javier,bill, and Dutch must have gotten out of there graves just to dislike this video.

  • Sheet music to this?

  • Now that i think, this game eventually will come as one of those classic golden ones.

    Every time i hear this song its hard to retain tears

  • I loved this game, john marston was a badass , but he was... at the same time , such a incredible person , really felt bad when he was killed.... made me think a lot about how sometimes a great person can be busted for greed n ambition and human shit .....

    incredible deep personaje at the point that his death made me cry like a little girl.

    a tons of things came up to my head, this game was a huge experience.

    i lov it,

    john marston... outlaw al the way towards th end... we lov you john

  • Rockstar have missed out on making a lot of money by not selling this beautiful touching song on iTunes. :') :'(

  • RIP John Marston, he might be just a videogame character, but he was a completely hero!

  • where can i download this song, a safe site plz

  • @kangInc go to fetchmp3.com and search this video click on it and then it converts it to an mp3 for you

  • can any one tell me what is that screaching noise at 4:00

  • @kangInc its a violin

  • @kangInc

    string orchestra (cellos,bass,violins)

  • the universe is endless with endless posibilties. What ever you think may be reality in some other part of the universe. this fictional john Marston may be fictional here but he may be a real person, i so wished to meet him.

  • @kangInc I there are infinite universes. Then somewere you're being molested by a giant elmo with an english accent

    :P

    just kidding but lol

  • I am sorry God, but i feel Red Dead redemption is worth living for. i live in the 21st century but now i want to go and see the original wild west, and see how life was like. i thank you God for making Rockstar Games.

  • The first couple minuets remind me of Aeris's theme from Final Fantasy 7...Yet another game that made me cry. Then it reminds me of the beginning of red dead........straight to the end.

  • this game needs to be made into a movie.. i'd tottaly go see it! and i'm not a cinema man, because sometimes when i go i get head ache... i'd tottaly go to this :')

    I <3 Rockstar

  • The very first mission with John,

    Exodus in America.

    Dead Man's gun,

    the very first mission with Jack

  • Thumbs up if you started crying when you heard this in the ending credits. I know I did.

  • @TheMrFlamingskull i was going to but i was playing with a friend so i didnt cry.. so i just waited for him to leave and heard in here on youtube.. and cried :(

  • @TheMrFlamingskull I really did.

  • @TheMrFlamingskull hush your bringing back those same feelings sniff this is the first game to ever make me cry!!

  • @TheMrFlamingskull amasing so did i

  • This apparently sounds like a lot. I think it sounds like redemption, red dead redemption.

  • YEAH, IT SOUNDS LIKE KINGS OF LEON,, BUT RED DEAD REDEMPTION DOESN'T SUCK...

  • un juegaso sin duda.......a pesar que hace mucho que cruse el juego la oigo y se me pone la piel de gallina solo de recordar toda la mierda que tuvo que afrontar john para ese horrible final :'(.... espero con emocion L.A noire para otra gran historia

    Viva Rockstar :D

  • Where would you find this song? I can't seem to find it anywhere but here :\

  • @Spartibartfast download it from youtube my man! with Free Youtube To MP3 converter v3.9.33 :D

  • Reminds me of Minecraft music.

  • @DrCashews55k Minecraft music is not AS sad sounding as this hahaha

  • When this came on the credits, I finally broke down into tears after seeing all the shit that happened at the end of the game.

  • why wasnt this version on the soundtrack?

  • @haaallleee glad im not the only one then :)

  • @thijsyo Wow, exactly the same melody. I think Kings of Leon lost their inspiration, 'cuz this came out first. ^^