Aikido Shudokan Joe Thambu Sensei - Demonstration 2008

[Kimusubi007]

Great demonstration. powerful, yet full of Aiki, especially the sanindori jiyu waza. I'd like to feel his technique. When i go to melbourne, hopefully i could drop by.



[Kimusubi007]

Great demonstration. powerful, yet full of Aiki, especially the sanindori jiyu waza. I'd like to feel his technique. When i go to melbourne, hopefully i could drop by.

[packoftwenty]

1:24 - freeze it right there! That sums up 'Fake-ido' in its entirety! A willing 'victim' who doesn't know how to fight properly, holding his hands out like an idiot.

The problem that the cretins who follow 'Fake-ido' have is that it DOESN'T WORK, and there is no EVIDENCE that it works, so they spend their entire lives trying to defend their stupid 'art', saying "We don't use it for fighting" and other such bullshit. Who are the cretins who PAY to learn this crap?

[bigbooger121]

@packoftwenty That's Kumai you fucking idiot it's the stance that you learn Aikido in and it's formal to do it before performing a move...did you think he just decided to put his hands up and then back down?

[indigo251000]

@packoftwenty ur an Fake-ido idiot if you thing tht the Kumai stance is bullshit, we know tht people on the streets arent going to come up to us standing like tht & they may throw wild punches at us, but tht stances is wat we (the person defending themselves) uses to remind ourselves of the power of forward movement & centring urself. if you watch ul realise tht wen they are stood like tht, unlike karate or judo: everything is 4ward we arent turned 2 the side, meaning all powr is utilised. twat

[the26thhour]

@packoftwenty

Hi 8)

Just so u know (as in I'm not trying to be a dick), a mate of mine was head doorman for yrs for a very popular bar in my city

He's a kickboxer

After yrs of xp he said that Aikido, Hapkido, Jujitsu, Kick Boxing & basic Wing Chung where the best things he saw on the street but Aikido students where the only one's where age, size & strength seemed to be irrelevant to their ability to defend themselves.

Again, just for info's sake 8)

[CheetaReborn]

@packoftwenty its a stance you dumbfuck...it had no correlation to the actual attack

[CheetaRevised]

@packoftwenty Your a dumb ass...the stance is there because aikido is from sword fighting. if they both had swords they would hold them up to each other as a way to prepare to block. Since this is an Aikido demo. Thambu let his guard down as a way to offer a peaceful resolution and his uke denied it so he attacked.

[cp123456789123456789]

@YourTearsDontFall606

ur sensei

[cp123456789123456789]

@YourTearsDontFall606

:)

[kungfufyr]

So sad to see this hack (Joe Thambu) and Christian Tissier appear in the same sidebar. I've met Joe: he's an egomaniac dressed up as a humble man. It's sick- just like his branch of Aikido (Yoshinkan- see Takeno Sensei's videas for proff of this). Tissier is intensely proud, perhaps to a fault, but at least he is an excellent martial artist. Joe is mediocre to say the least.

[crunchytoast76]

Douglas, I was sad to see your comment! I was going to ignore it but unchallenged flames by armchair martial artists get taken far too seriously. I am curious, what is the difference between "intensely proud" and "egomaniac"? Surely it couldn't be that Tissier reinforces your tiny world view and massages your ego, whereas Thambu did not?? Too bad. If you had managed to get past your own insecurities you might've learned something from a great teacher.

[kungfufyr]

@crunchytoast76 My experience is that Yoshinkan is a sick martial art and part of a sick martial culture promoted by its teachers and many students. But don't take my word for it: go and train in one of their dojos. Ask yourself: Why do joint locks have to hurt during training? Why do we learn 1930s breakfalls? Is a tense and low guard really optimal? Why do seniors and teachers do big and hard throws in demos but rarely get thrown? Far better alternatives exist. And yes: Thambu is an egomaniac.

[kungfufyr]

I stand by the comment about Tissier: he is a true pioneer of martial arts in the Western world. More importantly, while an exceptionally proud man, he promotes values which are acceptable to Western societies: non-violence, care for one's training partner, dedication, the pursuit of excellence, and innovation within the art. In stark contrast to many Western Yoshinkan practitioners, Tissier has not created a cult-like following in-spite of a large number of long-term and dedicated students.

[crunchytoast76]

Douglas, I have experienced Yoshinkan Aikido under many teachers. It's funny, I would describe Thambu the way you describe Tissier. I've known a few MA egomaniacs and Thambu isn't one. I wouldn' t claim he is ego-less, but who is?? Certainly not you, judging by your ill-informed claims. Then again, I don't really know you or what you're about. It's a big world, maybe Tissier Sensei can help you deal with that?

[kungfufyr]

@crunchytoast76 It's Dougglas- two gs. Hard to miss twice.This is a pointless exercise where we will disagree. I will just point out that I have trained with Thambu and many other teachers though I am not a convert of any specific brand of Aikido. As I stated earlier: I encourage people to make their own judgements. My opinion is clear: I don't like Thambu or his style as per above. But ask your own questions. Don't be swayed by the culture of the organisation or Thambu's disposition... or mine.

[crunchytoast76]

Dougglas, not surprising since I typed it twice but looked only once. My reason for posting also remains: the net is full of armchair MA buffs with little experience and even less talent passing judgment. I simply wanted to ensure that someone less informed doesn't take your vilifying comments as factual.

[kungfufyr]

@crunchytoast76 On that we can agree: armchair MA buffs are a pain in everyone's collective backside! I assure you: I'm not 12 and I hold a reasonable rank in a well recognised traditional martial art. I'm also certain my vilifying comments are factual in a post-modern kind of way. But as I have said several times: I encourage others to make up their own mind. In doing so, exercise some tenacity and rigorous evaluation in the questioning process. And don't forget: Tissier rules! ;)

[crunchytoast76]

It appears my subtlety was lost. Dougglass, "you" sound just like the hordes of net warriors who fancy themselves as technically expert based on a measly few hundred hours experience. Perhaps you could follow a football team instead of Aikido teachers?? Last I checked, no qualifications are required to be a Chelsea fan.

[kungfufyr]

@crunchytoast76 lol!

[GoweExile]

@kungfufyr Sensei Thambu is definitely NOT an ego-maniac. He is a stickler for correct ettiquete and for form who expects the respect he shows to his Senseis. As far as being a 'hack' Sensei Thambu has earned a world wide reputation for excellence. Your opinion seems to be based on dislike rather than observation.

[jackslash101]

Definitely Yoshinkan Aikido. The Aikido Shudokan group is part of the Aikido Yoshinkai Foundation.

[Chubearishere]

Wait a minute. That's Yoshinkan Aikido not Shudokan. Am I wrong on this?

[SenseiStrange]

@Chubearishere

Looks like yoshinkan. I am willing to bet Shudoakn is their groups names. Don't confuse with shodokan, a totally different style.

[TheNascar42]

Sorry but you lost the doftes of aikido. This video looks like something like personal defense

[stiffilus]

Really guys don't even waste your time on this 'Mr.A' from what I've read here he is one of 'those' people, always speaking from his 'vast' experience. We have people like this come to our dojo often, but they ALWAYS leave with a better appreciation for Aikido.

My sensei's grandson has trained with Thambu sensei on a few occasions. He is indeed someone with whom I have much respect. So, Mr.Sleepy, try some of the senshusei training, it's not for the faint hearted.

I doubt you would last 5mins.

[ABCMontreal]

Mr Awakener, I'm not familiar with Turner-sensei' technique, but I don't think you're talking about the same style of aikido? Thambu Sensei trains & teaches Yoshinkan Aikido, whereas I believe Turner-Sensei is quite likely Aiki Kai style? If that is the case, it would be like trying to compare apples and oranges. My suggestion is for you to try Riot Police or Senshusei training at Tokyo's Yoshinkan Hombu dojo, or try challenging or sparring with Takeno-, Chida- or Thambu-sensei. Good luck! lol

[ABCMontreal]

as a practioner of yoshinkan aikido for 16 years, I can tell you that this art is extremely efficient. I have met and trained with police officers, military, etc. in Japan, Canada and abroad who use yoshinkan aikido as part of their jobs to neutralize an attack with extreme effectiveness. It's apparent that you do not have real personal experience with this art, and I would encourage you to open your mind and try it!!!

[yummynuts]

mr awakener you should mind what the fuck you say, Thambu sensei is a good caring and patient teacher, things which i think you dont have. im not even his student but i have been to his dojo on several occassions and was most impressed. as for size who cares its nothing a knife or bullet between the eyes cant fix permantly a mate! OUSS!!!!!!!

[zjohnsto]

I take it you haven't actually tried it? Strength is not a factor, size is not a factor. It takes little energy from oneself to lock the attacker up and put them off balance, and not necessarily in that order. I'd say very efficient.

[0ri0InYourLife]

that guy has a great idea of ukemies

[yoruketseki]

Thambu sensei's Aikido is powerful and impressive. He seems to be an effective teacher (I learned a lot from him in one day) and he's a very interesting person (really nice and really cool).

[RijjardAlan]

Muy bien, por fin se ven ataques reales,gracias por ponerlo!!

felicitaciones

[tomikikai]

Although I am a Tomiki Aikidoka I think Joe Thambu is one of the finest Aikidoka around today. Fantastic demo.

[kaiten34]

Fantastic!! loved it much respect!!!

[mosher987654]

awesome demonstration by an awesome sensei!