In my opinion, the finest folk singer this country has ever produced. The power and sincerity he puts into every flicker of the voice just astounds me every time... The album he did with andy has to be one of the best i've been priviliged to listen to.
I. was a young apprentice at Paddy O Callaghans garage in Killorglin. One Puck Fair morning we found a red VW van parked in the yard. I. later learned that this was a group called Sweeneys men .they were booked to play at The Railway Hotel I went along and became a fan. Andy, Johnie and Joe were the members then later andy went to Romania so Terry Woods joined. . Just last year I learned of the death of Joe a great loss to folk and ballad. RIP.
You are quite right in what you say. However, I don't think that Paul would sing a Dylan song as well as Dylan. Nor did Dylan sing "The Boxer" as well as Simon and Garfunkel.
@noruga hi noruga, the young Kevin Burke clip is from the Bothy Band - Live at the Embankment, Dun Laoighaire ( I think ) - possibly The Green Groves of Eireann - their on youtube - all brilliant stuff. Have fun searching!
Anybody got any clues as to the provenance of this song? It's been sung by many performers over the years (latterly by Bob Dylan I notice). I have looked to see who colelcted it etc. but have only drawn blanks.
One of my true favorites as well. If you like this, then get The Liberty Tapes cd from Compass Records. It's a live 1978 concert from this time period. SO good!!! The tapes were lost for 25 years. When found, they sound so great. A must have.
There are so many people whining 'where are the tabs", "give me the notes", just because they are too lazy to open their ears and learn to use them...
This stuff isn't easy. There is a lot going on here. Hybrid picking, alternate tuning, a lot of sustained chords on the ways up, not to mention distinguishing Andy from Paul at times. I wish someone would come along and break this down. I can play my own version but that doesn't help my technique like a case study would.
Yes! two legend musician's producing a classic recording of a great song. Every time I hear this it brings a smile to my face and my head goes from side to side in disbelief, got to get out my new 00015 Martin to try it out in my humble way! Humble smile.
Two Legends of Irish music at its best ! Wonderful song, great arrangement. No words can describe the perfect work and feeling for this song played by this genious musicians.
by the way, i got my mom to watch this, and she was so concentrated on finding out why his hair " looked like that" than the beauty and awesome of his talent + voice. psh. :[
paul is a nigel?.....ha i dont think so, i know his cousin who's just like him...and theyre both misunderstood, moody gits but talented as can be...what a song
for almost 20 years from the Scott Nygaard's 1st solo record 'no hurry". That's great to hear where he got the original version to make his own which is fantastic!
I've loved their recording of this since I first heard it back in the '80s, but this is the first time I've ever seen them play it. I owe you a pint for posting it. "At last I've found my treasure". Indeed!
Hi Micromaid! It's brilliant to see this again. I haven't seen this in years. Do You have Andy Irvine backing David McWilliams singing Lay It on the Line or David McWilliams singing Twenty Golden Years Ago?
This is still so fresh..It's a pity and a wonder that there wasn't a lot more collaborration bewteen these musicians considering Brady was such an innovative and original guitar player at the time. Andy went on to play with a lot less competent guitar players in my opinion. On the video it looks like Andy is playing the harmonica upsidedown as when he moves left as he plays the notes increase in pitch. Anybody an ideas!?.
now i am fascinated? My name is Tony O' Neill and I come from Courtmacsherry and wonder who the devil is watching with me video's of Andy Irvine on You Tube?
I visit quite regular and watch my old mates the herons on Timoleague bridge so let us know
Firstly I suppose I am a musician who marvels at this music and its brilliant musicianship and try to copy it myself. Secondly I live in Wexford but was Cork city born as a child and my grandparents roots on both sides are west Cork, Ballinacarriga/Dunmanway My grandfather worked on the old narrow gauge trains that went from Bandon though Timoleague I guess and out to Courtmacsherry. Terrible weather but great for drinking porter. Regards to you Tony where are you based?
Looking at this video brings back my youth living in England but being knocked over by musicians like this guy and the interpretation of traditional Irish music!
Lot older now but this stuff stills knocks me over.
I am based in the UK but travel a great deal, Wexford hmmmm whats it like trying to make a living in booming Ireland? I come to Ireland a great deal as my company I run has two large customers in Dublin
Hi Tony "terrible weather but great for drinkin' pints". This confusing quote in my last correspondence refers to last New Year's Eve when my family had a reunion which lasted four days and took place mostly in The Anchor Bar in Courtmacsherry due to Atlantic storms.We didn't complain that much. Think I have the right pub name the one closest to the old school on the shore. Regards to you.
fair play to you! The music scene in B'ham in the mid/late 80's was ABSOLUTELY ACE !! (Kevin Crawford / Joe Molloy / Ivan Miletitch / Mick Connelly / Brendan Boyle and many, many more !!! & the pubs in Digbeth were VERY accomodating!
smacclutch, in all due respect, I differ. This is way better because unlike the Liberty Tapes, Paul and Andy are here to SEE as they play that gorgeous stuff.
May YouTube live forever. This is amazing stuff being uploaded.
Anyone else notice that Andy plays harp upside down? Bass notes on his right, higher ones on his left.
YouTube is fantastic, where else would you get footage like this from 1977. I wonder does anyone have Paul singing Arthur McBride from the same era? It would be great to see.
Is the rest of the show uploaded here somewhere? I would love to see what that fellow at the end is about to do.
Faltaz 2 weeks ago
Is that standard tuning?
clunkz 3 months ago
Probably my fave song ever, followed closely by Arthur McBride and Lakes of Pontchartain.
mephistofleas 10 months ago
So bad ass.
braktheconqueror7 1 year ago
i reckon he plays BETTER on balcony t.v he dont pick it there his touch is so confident and sure
hanghang71 1 year ago
GOD I love this song!
Feckinpaddy29 1 year ago
This is such a masterpiece. Brilliant playing from both of them; Brady's voice is so effortless... It all just gives me chills.
strangestfascination 1 year ago 2
savage playing, lovely voice...but the glasses.
Should've gone to spec savers!
...
louthleviathan 1 year ago
Paul Brady and Andy Irvine at their very best! Nobody can touch them!
peter74213 1 year ago
Did he ever do Four Green Fields ?
josephonwhidbey 1 year ago
This is very good....but I must admit I have a soft spot for Bob Dylans version
singularitygirl 1 year ago
This is a Child ballad, right? The Trooper and the Maid?
ddayiv 1 year ago
Anyone here who knows what key and type of harmonica Andy is playing here??
Holm182 1 year ago
@Holm182 the guitar is in open g so i think just a g harmonica should work
rossbj138 1 year ago
@rossbj138 nope - its in A flat (or else my electroinic tuner is a semitone off)
echoceleste 1 year ago
@echoceleste cheers dude
rossbj138 1 year ago
@Holm182 G sharp or a flat.
johnkeppel90 9 months ago
legend!!!!!!!!!!!!!
butcherboy45 1 year ago
In my opinion, the finest folk singer this country has ever produced. The power and sincerity he puts into every flicker of the voice just astounds me every time... The album he did with andy has to be one of the best i've been priviliged to listen to.
gob1309 1 year ago
FROM THE MIND OF GOD TO HIS LIPS
josephonwhidbey 1 year ago
My fave of the Paul Brady YouTube collection
Sporoon 1 year ago
Three members of Planty came and played in Hull 42 years ago (!) and I saw them. The music has enchanted me ever since.
Gwyhir 1 year ago
They sound just as good live as on the album
locomotive1804 1 year ago
wat a legend
lookinwell 1 year ago
The lads can certainly play. Paul's voice is mesmerizing, I can listen over and over and over...
GoddessOdd 1 year ago
Cool, didn't hear this before. Paul Brady's brill
BackStabbathno1 1 year ago
he looks so relaxed singing like as if it was effortless
MrDamoirish 2 years ago
damn. yet another paul brady i cant stop listening to.
fellowvoyager 2 years ago
paul brady tune that is.
fellowvoyager 2 years ago
I. first met Sweeneys Men in 1966.
I. was a young apprentice at Paddy O Callaghans garage in Killorglin. One Puck Fair morning we found a red VW van parked in the yard. I. later learned that this was a group called Sweeneys men .they were booked to play at The Railway Hotel I went along and became a fan. Andy, Johnie and Joe were the members then later andy went to Romania so Terry Woods joined. . Just last year I learned of the death of Joe a great loss to folk and ballad. RIP.
TheJackduggan 2 years ago
is he playin the harmonica upside down?
matthewmaclennan 2 years ago
absoloootly fantastic!!!!! .. search Bob Dylan version .. a friggin joke ..
gazgoon654 2 years ago
You are quite right in what you say. However, I don't think that Paul would sing a Dylan song as well as Dylan. Nor did Dylan sing "The Boxer" as well as Simon and Garfunkel.
josephonwhidbey 2 years ago
How did Andy Irvine ever become so awesome?
DwnAszPunk 2 years ago
wow!!! why did paul brady change his style so much since this ?
evostik1 2 years ago
beautiful song...very sad though! Typical Irish lyrics, love, loyalty, death...
joeygsmom 2 years ago
Kevin Burke appears in the last second of the clip... Anyone knows if that clip is available..?
noruga 2 years ago
@noruga hi noruga, the young Kevin Burke clip is from the Bothy Band - Live at the Embankment, Dun Laoighaire ( I think ) - possibly The Green Groves of Eireann - their on youtube - all brilliant stuff. Have fun searching!
silenagig49 1 year ago
ach. when he smiled my heart beat twice in the space of one.
shazam15 2 years ago
This is just a guess, but id imagine its from the north
EddieAlexanderRocks 2 years ago
Andy's playin' that harp upsidedown!
Great, great performance..
AdamReddick 2 years ago
Yeah he always plays it upside down and blows when you should suck and sucks when you should blow. So he says himself anyway!!!
ConorSod 2 years ago
He must be "left mouthed"! lol
leftystagg 2 years ago 2
Anybody got any clues as to the provenance of this song? It's been sung by many performers over the years (latterly by Bob Dylan I notice). I have looked to see who colelcted it etc. but have only drawn blanks.
Thanks
sneakyam 2 years ago
its even better with a whistle in place of the mouth organ.
strasheep 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
Isthistakenn 2 years ago
One of my true favorites as well. If you like this, then get The Liberty Tapes cd from Compass Records. It's a live 1978 concert from this time period. SO good!!! The tapes were lost for 25 years. When found, they sound so great. A must have.
CindySweetwater 2 years ago 2
A proper guitar tablature for this song does not seem to exist on the interweb; only the simplified chords for the Dylan version. What a shame.
levitateForever 2 years ago 2
And from where do you think Paul got the tab in the 1st place ? From his mind. Why ? Simply because he *is* a musician...
edelahaye 2 years ago
No shit sherlock!
I think you missed my point - it is a shame more attention hasn't been paid to Bradys guitar style.
levitateForever 2 years ago
OK, I missed your point. Sorry.
There are so many people whining 'where are the tabs", "give me the notes", just because they are too lazy to open their ears and learn to use them...
edelahaye 2 years ago
This stuff isn't easy. There is a lot going on here. Hybrid picking, alternate tuning, a lot of sustained chords on the ways up, not to mention distinguishing Andy from Paul at times. I wish someone would come along and break this down. I can play my own version but that doesn't help my technique like a case study would.
JPhill9990 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
absolutely amazing. possibly one of the best songs ive ever heard!
kalebb2008 2 years ago
Paul Brady could sing the telephone directories and make them sound interesting
jammiebeez 2 years ago 33
This comment has received too many negative votes show
interesting observation smartass - go fuck y'self
Mossman67 2 years ago
I love how this song floats along. I can listen to it over & over.
HiddenFormula 2 years ago
Yes! two legend musician's producing a classic recording of a great song. Every time I hear this it brings a smile to my face and my head goes from side to side in disbelief, got to get out my new 00015 Martin to try it out in my humble way! Humble smile.
sillyfan 2 years ago
かわいい曲です。複雑なコードフォームに最初びっくりしましたが、3コードらしい・・・。ポール・ブレイディさんの凄いギターテクと神々しい歌声が合わさった傑作だと思います。
yascelt 3 years ago
Two Legends of Irish music at its best ! Wonderful song, great arrangement. No words can describe the perfect work and feeling for this song played by this genious musicians.
schabe66 3 years ago
first class sir great artist nice player
korgow5rd 3 years ago
Good song!
eteleneni 3 years ago
by the way, i got my mom to watch this, and she was so concentrated on finding out why his hair " looked like that" than the beauty and awesome of his talent + voice. psh. :[
shazam15 3 years ago
anybody know where i can download this for free?
shazam15 3 years ago
You can download it onto your pc with realplayer which is free to download too. I think then you can copy it to a disc ect.
sillyfan 2 years ago
What make and model of guitar is this ?
thanks,
Murlach
murlach1 3 years ago
Its a Yamaha FG(Folk Guitar)180. One of the good'uns. Made in Japan.
jimbutler1950 3 years ago
yqamaha f series
epiphone06 3 years ago
marvellous rendition ........even beats Old blind dogs version
cheerydavie 3 years ago
best thing ever on you tube.....without a doubt..awesome.paul is amazing.andy is without pier
klanger 3 years ago 6
been listening to this song for 15 years now, absolutely love it, didn't know there was video to it, Brady is such a nigel though
iohifear 3 years ago 2
paul is a nigel?.....ha i dont think so, i know his cousin who's just like him...and theyre both misunderstood, moody gits but talented as can be...what a song
dokmdk 3 years ago
an example of folk perfection. i love his subtle passion, very sedate
brucefetter 3 years ago 3
Real music from real musicians. A joy to behold!
manatthewindow 3 years ago 2
I've been listening this song as an instrumental
for almost 20 years from the Scott Nygaard's 1st solo record 'no hurry". That's great to hear where he got the original version to make his own which is fantastic!
Lightbluechevy 3 years ago
I've loved their recording of this since I first heard it back in the '80s, but this is the first time I've ever seen them play it. I owe you a pint for posting it. "At last I've found my treasure". Indeed!
kink1man 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
What album is this on?
Bowietastic 3 years ago 2
Andy Irvine and Paul Brady, the eponymous album.
volgodon 3 years ago
Good to see and hear such great talent
Gerrynz 3 years ago 2
Paul Brady's best interpretation of a traditional song. In fact, I can't think of a better one by anybody. A desert island disc.
26664u 3 years ago 2
I like the way Andly is playing that harp. Looks upside to the way I play mine.
hamrzlawnlake 4 years ago
Apparently he learnt to play it upside down because of the influence of Woody Guthrie, who also played it like that.
Conanmcd 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DisKan's is better i think...
lukaduke 4 years ago
Andy Irvine does a great job of recreating the instrumental break on his harmonica! Great song.
NameNotaNumber 4 years ago
Five stars, TEN stars if I could give it.
professorV 4 years ago 18
Hear Paul sing The Coleraine Regetta, brilliant.
lorgain2 4 years ago
I have this tune on CD, it's great to see it played. I've listened to this and sug it with my family for years.
Except I think the harmonica was an accordion.
Awesome tune. Go raibh maith agat.
goodirishman 4 years ago
What key/tuning is paul Brady playing
stoneyhorsebox 4 years ago
He's using DGDGBD = Open G tunning With the capo on the 1st fret for this song. so it's in G sharp
TomAJoad 4 years ago
Thanks Man been tryin to work that out for ages. Fair play to ya!
stoneyhorsebox 4 years ago
great song - great performance - I wish it was fol. revival time again
ggddvvtt 4 years ago
It's from the same program sessions from the 70's
Thanks again!
TomAJoad 4 years ago
Hi Micromaid! It's brilliant to see this again. I haven't seen this in years. Do You have Andy Irvine backing David McWilliams singing Lay It on the Line or David McWilliams singing Twenty Golden Years Ago?
Thanks For your Clip
TomAJoad 4 years ago
This is still so fresh..It's a pity and a wonder that there wasn't a lot more collaborration bewteen these musicians considering Brady was such an innovative and original guitar player at the time. Andy went on to play with a lot less competent guitar players in my opinion. On the video it looks like Andy is playing the harmonica upsidedown as when he moves left as he plays the notes increase in pitch. Anybody an ideas!?.
courtmacsherry 4 years ago
Hi Courtmacsherry
now i am fascinated? My name is Tony O' Neill and I come from Courtmacsherry and wonder who the devil is watching with me video's of Andy Irvine on You Tube?
I visit quite regular and watch my old mates the herons on Timoleague bridge so let us know
What a great track brings the memories back.
radiotarifa 4 years ago
Hi radiotarifa
Firstly I suppose I am a musician who marvels at this music and its brilliant musicianship and try to copy it myself. Secondly I live in Wexford but was Cork city born as a child and my grandparents roots on both sides are west Cork, Ballinacarriga/Dunmanway My grandfather worked on the old narrow gauge trains that went from Bandon though Timoleague I guess and out to Courtmacsherry. Terrible weather but great for drinking porter. Regards to you Tony where are you based?
courtmacsherry 4 years ago
Hello Courtmachsherry
Looking at this video brings back my youth living in England but being knocked over by musicians like this guy and the interpretation of traditional Irish music!
Lot older now but this stuff stills knocks me over.
I am based in the UK but travel a great deal, Wexford hmmmm whats it like trying to make a living in booming Ireland? I come to Ireland a great deal as my company I run has two large customers in Dublin
radiotarifa 4 years ago
Hi Tony "terrible weather but great for drinkin' pints". This confusing quote in my last correspondence refers to last New Year's Eve when my family had a reunion which lasted four days and took place mostly in The Anchor Bar in Courtmacsherry due to Atlantic storms.We didn't complain that much. Think I have the right pub name the one closest to the old school on the shore. Regards to you.
courtmacsherry 4 years ago
Anchor Bar run by Billy Fleming my very old good friend went to school with him
Well four days in a pub is what I call a reunion!
Too old for that now but if you speak to Billy next time he will remember fond days "Tipping it up to Nancy"
Autumn here too very lovely
radiotarifa 4 years ago
I love the life boat myself. God bless and take care lads
danmey73 4 years ago
Andy plays harmonica in the 'W Guthrie' style, turning it the other way around - he explains it all on his web site
festnoz10 4 years ago
Thanks festnoz10 ..I will look it up. I saw Andy recently in Carrig on Bannow Wexford with The Wise Family. A lot of good harmonica that night.
courtmacsherry 4 years ago
I think you're right about the harmonica
BenDirks 4 years ago
wonderful song.very nice versions of this song are sung by : LUCY KAPLANSKY and EDDI READER and BRIAN McNEILL
folkneverdies 4 years ago
- LUCY KAPLANSKY : 5/5
- EDDI READER : 3/5
- BRIAN McNEILL : 3/5
edelahaye 2 years ago
Superb to see this. I am glad I was `switched on` to Irish Music as a teenager born in Birmingham of Irish parenst
JimmyGoggin 4 years ago
hahah same here im 14 and i love irish music but i still like rock n thrash metal
Davegillis 4 years ago
fair play to you! The music scene in B'ham in the mid/late 80's was ABSOLUTELY ACE !! (Kevin Crawford / Joe Molloy / Ivan Miletitch / Mick Connelly / Brendan Boyle and many, many more !!! & the pubs in Digbeth were VERY accomodating!
festnoz10 4 years ago
Yes, you meant "The Long Acre" band...
edelahaye 2 years ago
absolutely brilliant
shaskeen1 4 years ago
an amazing song; well done.
jackbilk 4 years ago
smacclutch, in all due respect, I differ. This is way better because unlike the Liberty Tapes, Paul and Andy are here to SEE as they play that gorgeous stuff.
May YouTube live forever. This is amazing stuff being uploaded.
Anyone else notice that Andy plays harp upside down? Bass notes on his right, higher ones on his left.
alonzogarbanzo 4 years ago 2
this is terrific, but Paul and Andy's version of this on The Liberty Tapes is even better. this version is a little fast for me.
smacclutch 4 years ago
please don't ever take this off, its amazing
rcb0683 5 years ago
do u have more of sessions from the seventies i think i recognize kevin burke after the clip
dickdujour 5 years ago
wow
dickdujour 5 years ago
a rare treat everybody deserves to see this work of magic
elaineicus 5 years ago
great stuff!
rcb0683 5 years ago
Andy & Paul....one of the best dou-work ever
davidreimer 5 years ago
YouTube is fantastic, where else would you get footage like this from 1977. I wonder does anyone have Paul singing Arthur McBride from the same era? It would be great to see.
mageesg 5 years ago
I presume by now you've found the multiple versions from different years (3.5 at last count) right here on YouTube.
alonzogarbanzo 4 years ago
Great video, thanks. I could listen to the voices of Andy and Paul all day long (not to mention their gorgeous musicianship!)
Paul looks about 12 in this clip-lol!
firenze6 5 years ago
Effortlessly and beautiful... from my favourite album of all time.
spoombung 5 years ago
Er....em.... I think you mean Paul's Guitar work & beautiful voice + Andy's intricate work on Mandolin?
Ptarmi 5 years ago
great clip, thankyou, really enjoyed the intricacy of andy's guitar work behind paul's beautiful voice.
jillgra 5 years ago
I second that! One of my favorite songs and duos ever. So together, what a blend were Paul and Andy!
leftyodoul 5 years ago
Please don't remove this video! I love it so and listen to it at least once or twice a day. It is such a pleasure to see this little clip.
cebrownf 5 years ago