ya deje a mariah en paz se olvidan de los 90 osea es mariah carey pierda o no pierda su voz ella sera la mejor cantante nadie posee su registro nadie posee esaas habilidades vocales osea cuando canten una cancion como lo hace o hacia mc me avisan mc es la mejor cantante i love you mc
she hasent lost her voice she is sopposed to sing the song that way ,in a soft voice..and i lovee mariah carey soomuch i would give anything to met her.....you rock mimi
OMG she was sexy here !!! Now it's like she is getting more and more fat at each show.... I love her but she has to take care of her weight !! Hope she is not pregnant as she drinks alcohol !!!
shes not lipping, ive listend to this so so many times and in the verses she always sings it in her head voice, but in this she sings it in both, she changes quite often.
this isnt bad, u can tell there are some lipped parts and yeah its due to the damaged nodules. from what i saw one time on an interview on E! that its a 50/50 chance if she gets them removed she wont ever be able to sing again
most parts are lipped. It is obvious. It sounds exactly like the CD version, exactly, without any variation or change. And how can u explain this flawless quality here VERSUS the Letterman that was a real live on all parts? It proves that this is not live at all. SHe only sing the beginning and the whistles.....
Yes but the whispearing effect on the studio version is technically impossible to sing live because it is enginered. Even if Mariah were at her best vocally, she coudn't sing exactly these whispearing parts live, there would have been some variations, whearas here, it is EXACTLY LIKE THE CD. Listen well please.
what a lot of fans dont understand is some times when artist sing they play the song in the background for a more harmonized and rich beat.when mariah does it its fake,but when beyonce does it its nothing?cause clearly you dont believe shes all over the stage dancing and can still give a good vocal performance
Beyonce doesn't make people call her THE VOICE. She is just a performer, and when she dances, people won't judge her on her voice, they will evaluate her stage presence, and it's obvious that she can't sing all parts when she moves. Mariah is called THE VOICE, this is her main talent, so people just expect from her that she SINGS LIVE, nothing else.
i dont want ppl to think i have something against beyonce because i tink she is a great artist but i tink all artist should be held to the same standards
HA HA HA idiots are still arguing about this? Mariah Carey has vocal damage/nodules. She CANNOT sing live all the time and has to preserve her voice. She could do so many years ago before the all the vocal wear and tear. If she needs to lip sometimes instead of having surgery and losing her instrument then so be it. Either way it is still HER VOICE and SHE RECORDED IT!!! 0.o LOL! Mariah can sing her butt off and has proved that from day one. So what is the problem with you haters..?
Yes but when you pay to see her in a concert, it is for a live version, not a partly live/pre recorded version, I am sorry. Mariah does less live promo than before, she doesn't make tour, so she has time to preserve her voice now... I just think that she has not the same posssibilities than before, but she doesn't face it, and she make us believe that she is perfect. I don't ask her to be perfect, I just want her to be sincere, and propose her what she can. I am not a hater.
lol, she has lost her voice now. If she really wanted to preserve her voice, she wouldn't make all these ridiculous concerts (only for stupid fans) in which she does partial playbacks, or awfull performances. Mariah is very commercial and money-oriented. As the album is a flop, she needs to do lots of concerts....when does she preserve her voice, and IMAGE? Also, recording songs is easy nowadays. Even Pussicat Dolls, or Rihanna, without any huge voice, make albums with great voice effect.
LMAO you are sooooooo right! I will never ever pay a ticket to see her to sing all the belts in playback. Some people really believe she is always singing live, how stupid they are, I can't describe. And the worst is that she started to do that since 1997.....
@aaxlm The glitter album sold @ 3mil.... Charmbracelet sold @ 4mil... E=MC^2 sold @5mil ... MOIA sold over 3 mil and more since then. All very platinum. Why are those flops for her, when everyone else is hoping and wishing to sell that much?
Come on now guys, I'm a hardcore lamb and i love her to death...but even I know that this is lipped. Some of it was live, like the high notes...and little stuff.
It is a song she's capable of doing live however it's not fully sung live here. I don't understand why she needs to lipsync or sing along the track to some parts of the song though, maybe because there's many background vocals?
Her thickness here is sexy...and I'm a straight woman.
Mscmgc82 5 months ago
I Love you soo much from the Bottom of my heart, Always and Forever CRT
ILoveMcWhMj4ever 10 months ago
OMG i'm just crying, this song is so sad and sweet at the same time, it is the best song on MOAIA
lemonchel0 1 year ago
ya deje a mariah en paz se olvidan de los 90 osea es mariah carey pierda o no pierda su voz ella sera la mejor cantante nadie posee su registro nadie posee esaas habilidades vocales osea cuando canten una cancion como lo hace o hacia mc me avisan mc es la mejor cantante i love you mc
WJESUSM 1 year ago
mariah always the best
nobody is topping her not even beyonce
TRUTH975 1 year ago
she hasent lost her voice she is sopposed to sing the song that way ,in a soft voice..and i lovee mariah carey soomuch i would give anything to met her.....you rock mimi
casser98 2 years ago
yall in vegas were lucky.. as well as nyc.. cuz she not singing this song on her tour no more.. I was sad and emotions..
babymariah 2 years ago
OMG she was sexy here !!! Now it's like she is getting more and more fat at each show.... I love her but she has to take care of her weight !! Hope she is not pregnant as she drinks alcohol !!!
teddy37300 2 years ago
shes not lipping, ive listend to this so so many times and in the verses she always sings it in her head voice, but in this she sings it in both, she changes quite often.
audrinaismyhero 2 years ago 2
this isnt bad, u can tell there are some lipped parts and yeah its due to the damaged nodules. from what i saw one time on an interview on E! that its a 50/50 chance if she gets them removed she wont ever be able to sing again
MCRebaFan 2 years ago 2
she doesn't lip sing ever.. she doesn't need to cuz she is great..
donnachang16 2 years ago 3
i hope mariah doesnt get her nodules removed then her voice is gonna become deep and hoarse sounding like whitneys is now
ccwe23 2 years ago
most parts are lipped. It is obvious. It sounds exactly like the CD version, exactly, without any variation or change. And how can u explain this flawless quality here VERSUS the Letterman that was a real live on all parts? It proves that this is not live at all. SHe only sing the beginning and the whistles.....
aaxlm 2 years ago
@aaxlm - Umm, you don't know that because Mariah's voice can change as she sings...
mariahcarey50 2 years ago
Yes but the whispearing effect on the studio version is technically impossible to sing live because it is enginered. Even if Mariah were at her best vocally, she coudn't sing exactly these whispearing parts live, there would have been some variations, whearas here, it is EXACTLY LIKE THE CD. Listen well please.
aaxlm 2 years ago
I'm a huge fan... Some parts were def lipped
robertrpmrob 2 years ago
what a lot of fans dont understand is some times when artist sing they play the song in the background for a more harmonized and rich beat.when mariah does it its fake,but when beyonce does it its nothing?cause clearly you dont believe shes all over the stage dancing and can still give a good vocal performance
NALDO9111 2 years ago 7
ur completely right ! its just a back track to make it sound more smooth & complete .
mariah is a perfectionist !
people like to hate only cus shes 1 of the best if not THE BEST
iluvmylay 2 years ago 2
Beyonce doesn't make people call her THE VOICE. She is just a performer, and when she dances, people won't judge her on her voice, they will evaluate her stage presence, and it's obvious that she can't sing all parts when she moves. Mariah is called THE VOICE, this is her main talent, so people just expect from her that she SINGS LIVE, nothing else.
aaxlm 2 years ago
i dont want ppl to think i have something against beyonce because i tink she is a great artist but i tink all artist should be held to the same standards
NALDO9111 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i luv this song
NALDO9111 2 years ago
HA HA HA idiots are still arguing about this? Mariah Carey has vocal damage/nodules. She CANNOT sing live all the time and has to preserve her voice. She could do so many years ago before the all the vocal wear and tear. If she needs to lip sometimes instead of having surgery and losing her instrument then so be it. Either way it is still HER VOICE and SHE RECORDED IT!!! 0.o LOL! Mariah can sing her butt off and has proved that from day one. So what is the problem with you haters..?
al3826 2 years ago 11
omg so if she removes it her voice is gone for sure ? do u think shell evr remove them ?
iluvmylay 2 years ago
Yes but when you pay to see her in a concert, it is for a live version, not a partly live/pre recorded version, I am sorry. Mariah does less live promo than before, she doesn't make tour, so she has time to preserve her voice now... I just think that she has not the same posssibilities than before, but she doesn't face it, and she make us believe that she is perfect. I don't ask her to be perfect, I just want her to be sincere, and propose her what she can. I am not a hater.
aaxlm 2 years ago
lol, she has lost her voice now. If she really wanted to preserve her voice, she wouldn't make all these ridiculous concerts (only for stupid fans) in which she does partial playbacks, or awfull performances. Mariah is very commercial and money-oriented. As the album is a flop, she needs to do lots of concerts....when does she preserve her voice, and IMAGE? Also, recording songs is easy nowadays. Even Pussicat Dolls, or Rihanna, without any huge voice, make albums with great voice effect.
aaxlm 2 years ago
LMAO you are sooooooo right! I will never ever pay a ticket to see her to sing all the belts in playback. Some people really believe she is always singing live, how stupid they are, I can't describe. And the worst is that she started to do that since 1997.....
theoneandonly2503 1 year ago
@aaxlm The glitter album sold @ 3mil.... Charmbracelet sold @ 4mil... E=MC^2 sold @5mil ... MOIA sold over 3 mil and more since then. All very platinum. Why are those flops for her, when everyone else is hoping and wishing to sell that much?
Mscmgc82 5 months ago
i was at this concert!! good videos!! idk how u managed to record this with all the security!! mariah is soo beautiful!! thnx for posting!
justnstylez 2 years ago
no need to call my phone cause I changed my number today
a matter fact, I think i'm moving away (away)
sorry, the frustrations got me feeling that way.....
I LOVE U MARIAH !!!!!
alexlg07 2 years ago 5
cant people not enjoy a show without a debate whether its live or not?either way its still her voice.................
bombayg 2 years ago 2
OMG wow so beautiful
imsofucingtired 2 years ago
I This Not Lipped The Song Is Just Playin The The Background Cuz Theres Not Background Singer Duh
moedave 2 years ago
Come on now guys, I'm a hardcore lamb and i love her to death...but even I know that this is lipped. Some of it was live, like the high notes...and little stuff.
teemac82 2 years ago
Duh! She only lipped the last part...
the "i cant wait to H A T E U can't wait to make you go" part!
Not actually lipped... she's singing along to a backing track..
But the rest defo it's LIVE!
oh puhlease here we go again!
Some fans are acting like they watched the concert saying it's lipped...
alwayzbemybaby 2 years ago
Parts live parts lipped... This song is great... waiting for the official release of this song as a single
kloskal 2 years ago
It is a song she's capable of doing live however it's not fully sung live here. I don't understand why she needs to lipsync or sing along the track to some parts of the song though, maybe because there's many background vocals?
AlwaysThere4Me 2 years ago
Im with you michelle anyone that thinks she is really singing this is delusional! I am really disappointed in her too.
drugismymusic13 2 years ago
You're such a dumbass. She is clearly singing live, and there's a backing track for the rich background harmonies.
RelicHunter321 2 years ago
You seem a tad defensive....must be because you know you are wrong.
drugismymusic13 2 years ago
Nope. I'm defensive because I'm annoyed by idiots like you.
RelicHunter321 2 years ago
That is a sad excuse for a performance. Mariah is really disappointing me lately.
Michellej1980 2 years ago
lately? Where have you been the last 10 years
BoiCrayze 2 years ago
You have a point.
Michellej1980 2 years ago
No, this is live, I can hear differences from the recorded version. This is a song she can do live.
Lyricium 2 years ago
plz i can't believe she lipped the whole song yet again
gcsilva2 2 years ago
was totally live. i was in front row and u could hear her voice .
aod2k9 2 years ago 3