Crisis in Egypt and its Effect on Israel: Watch Rabbi Hier's NBC Interview

[mmitwaly]

Really... The US asks a rabbi on the Egyptian revolution... How much is the USA infested by these zionist bastards?

[lilbeaveymac]

@mmitwaly alot we are a christian nation bitch

[Scientologee]

Tom Cruise is best pals with the cult leader of Scientology, named David Miscavige. Cruise and Miscavige have both enjoyed the benefits of Scientology’s de facto SLAVE LABOR - including child labor. Scientology is one of the most human-rights abusive cults in existence. It does have numerous front and PR groups that - per founder L. Ron Hubbard - to cynically exploit the emotional “buttons” of “human rights” and “humanitarianism.” Wake up Simon Wiesenthal Center! And stop doing anything for $.

[pulman7]

be ready for the real Houlcoast Lair scum pigs Jews

[SnakesWithGuns]

@pulman7 im not jewish how could you hate so intensly?, you sicken me you slime ball

[pulman7]

@SnakesWithGuns who is talk with you ?

[SnakesWithGuns]

@pulman7 who is talk with you? fucking idiot

[pulman7]

@SnakesWithGuns you did stray sheep !

[SnakesWithGuns]

@pulman7 dont know what thats suppose to mean, well have fun with your whole, second holocaust thing, im sure it will happen

[NUVISI0N]

WDH!! that's a LIE!!!!!

That's the thir RABBI I see and said something different!!!

Wdf!! Well I don't beleive those Jews!!

The Muslim brothers or whatever you call them, they didn't even speak about the protest!! They came in the middle of it!!! Some student started it all because he saw and got the taste of the real democracy! So he burnt himself alive! WDH!!! and the president of isarael came on live tv, he didn't have NOTHING to say about the Muslim gropus, he just looked down flipping

[steve11fox]

Is our loyalty with the US or Israel? Anyone who questions israel is labeled a 'anti semite' or 'terrorist' by the Zionist agents in the West. Israel IS the terrorist state and their foundation of terrorism can not be denied. Any more wars for israeli (war mongering) zionists would totaly bankrupt us. It would take decades for our economy recover...Americans FIRST not israelis!!

[1Silas11]

Who are the supremacists? Those who think they are the chosen people of God and are attempting to extirpate an indigenous population from their homeland at any cost, even genocide and piracy on the high seas or those who believe in standing up against evil?

[1Silas11]

Read the Konig Memorandum. See what this Zionists were preaching on how the Arab should be treated. See what caused all that terrorism in the middle east. Who are the true wackos the crazy Jihadists or those who unleash the fire power of a modern army on civilians, have driven countless thousands from their ancestral homeland and caused mayhem in the mid-east by destabilizing the entire region?

[potjhm1]

Slowly but surely the world is realising that zionism is the real threat no one else. IDF kills without giving any thought to defensless palestinians inc' babies or humanitarian workers (who try to snatch kids from IDF bullets & some volunteer human shields in the hope to make it more difficult for israelis to kill locals. IDF murders defensless people & humanitarian workers in execution style. The recent murders of the Gaza flotilla is another example.

[steve11fox]

I hope iranian style hardliners come to power in Egypt. It's what the israelis deserve for putting the U.S. through so much misery.

[Lipush]

דברי כבוד הרב טובים ונכונים. ישר כח. תחי ישראל

[beancube2010]

Can psychopath understand pain? Yes but they are in some lack of compassion ways.

[beancube2010]

Who is controlling Gaza? Jews, not those residents in Gaza. People there are resisting Israel's military invasion force. Israel is using Hamas to sell invasion to all Jews. Israel can always create any Hamas for that purpose. Can Israel create Hamas in US? Sure. Jews can always turn you into your own enemy. Who had turn Jews into their own enemy? Perhaps it is the Jews again? It is because they know how to use pain and hardships.

[Cobradave999]

Egypt is filthy toilet full of shit, work it out for yourself.

[weah9]

Israel point of view???? Lol we watching u.s tv.

[LaynesAngryChair]

No need to watch the full interview, here's the gist of it....." BLAH, BLAH, BLAH....Iran....BLAH, BLAH BLAH.....Iran....Iran....Iran "

[dionisio454]

Btw is very funny israel afraid of islamic brotherhood. We must remember the fanatic religious of all tendecies in the knesset preaching a never seen before islamofobia in israel. This zealots are as dangerous as any islamic brotherhood which btw has a non relevant importance among the vast majority of progressive democratic egyptians. Israel lets rememb. is a democracy MIXED with a theocracy and a very racist and ferocious one. It gives me the chiils to know that the chosen people has nukes

[debunkingdebunkers]

@dionisio454 I couldn't agree more. The israelis are afraid because Egypt was paid well to stand down while israel committed its crimes against the Palestinians. So they're afraid that they might choose someone that actually wants justice.

[dionisio454]

we must not forget israel has the harder line of gov. ever. Netanyahu, the berlusconi of the middle east is a hard line ( a heir of betar and jabotinky which kept secret contacts with mussolini at the time ( check '51 documents' by Lenni Brener ). Israel has in the past the same behavior of south africa racist policy - theres a huge islamofobia inside our dear eretz israel - and has cooperated with somoza in nicaragua. Israel has no interest in democracies in the area for obvious reasons!!

[dionisio454]

There's absolutely no sign that the egyptians want or will admit a theocratic gov. Who should be afraid of real democracy in the region - among arab dictatorships - is Israel who loves to brag being the only democr. in the area but israelis need dictatorships and radical movements cause than they can claim - hipocriticaly - that is impossible to talk with them.Btw israel helped hamas long ago in order to create a division inside palestinians with arafat, thus they don' have to seat and negotiate

[dionisio454]

Just listening 6o seconds of this station we can perceive it is jewish owners..fuckers!! Even the cnn - pro israel - has already made dozens of analysis and interviews showing the progressive democratic liberal western model is the tendency among the thousands of egyptians claiming for changes. Inside the islamic brotherhood the very radical are insignificant and the great majority of egyptians won't accept a theocratic state..maybe like in turkey. They wish real secular democracy!

[boody19]

hahah fucken liar im egyptian in cairo they never said that

[jojo1ukuk]

watch out jews ur time is up. go back home where ever u come from. FREE PALESTINE LAND NOW. go and live in gay usa. BYE BYE JEWS.

[101nomis]

Palwatch.org

[saadasim]

Israel's Hypocrisy

Israel crossed a WORDWIDE blockade on APARTHEID South Africa to give it WEAPONS/TORTURE Equipment but complains when the WORLD wants to give FOOD/MEDICAL aid to impoverished Gazans?

Israel caused murder, destruction of property, kidnapping and destruction and with-holding of evidence.

And Israel is saying it was an act of self-defense?

Am I missing something here?

And US gives NA tionalistic ZI onists money why?

[sachibunda]

Why do we have extreme views on this issue?

Islam, Christianity and Judaism have their origin in the same geographic area, same cultural background, same forefathers, same concept of prohecy, just tribe and clans differed. Children of the same forefathers fighting over the land of their forefathers-common ancestors. Muslims go for halal food but if no halal available they are allowed to go for kosher. Why? Both wear caps, designs changed to suit their changed identities? script right to left

[artbiz45]

israel has no choice but a real practical peace, no more garbage it will not work.

[zzzerichxx]

Nothing will make the palestinians stop their violence and hatred towards Israel!

It`s not about giving away more land! There are vast acres of land for arab muslims in the countries surrounding Israel!

They just want the jews annihilated, then it will be the west, their islamic ideology tells them to accomplish a worldwide caliphate where muslims reign supreme and others are murdered or become dhimmis( 2nd class citizens ) It would be hell on earth!

[41Doris]

@zzzerichxx Don't know whose version of history you are reading but it sounds like Zionist propaganda to me. As I said earlier, "two wrongs don't make a right". There is plenty of blame to go around. All Muslims and/or Arabs or Palestinans want to end the country of Israel. Not all Muslims preach or believe in jihad. Hope all those who want peace can come together someday.

[41Doris]

Two wrongs don't make a right. The Israeli government and Rabbi Hier seem to have forgotten their own beginning history. They burned Arab villages and forced the Palestinans from their land to form their new country. Watch the movie "Exodus". It explains that Arabs and Jews lived peacefully together at one time. They are doing the same thing to Palestinans that was done to them by Hitler. They have detention camps and force the Palestinans to jump through all sorts of hoops.

[zzzerichxx]

@41Doris .....Absolute rubbish, if there are detention camps for palestinians it`s because it suits Hamas and Arafat before him to keep some of the palestinians living in bad conditions so they can falsely blame it on Israel! They are given millions of dollars in aid, have you seen the plush shopping mall that was opened over a year ago now. I think you can still see the pictures on `HONEST REPORTING` website, fancy restaurants etc.

Israel sends in truckloads of food and clothes etc. weekly!

[saadasim]

@zzzerichxx Liar. Here's the real truth:

My Early Years in Occupied Palestine: Archbishop Elias Chacour

watch?v=poeLkbt7dZ4

Israel has blocked various food items like chocolate, jam, sage and books and crayons from coming into Gaza or allowing Gazans to leave for getting medical care abroad.

alternetXorg/world/147132/7_qu­estions_for_defenders_of_israe­ls_inhumane_siege_of_gaza?page­=entire

[zzzerichxx]

@41Doris ..contd, they were not forced out of their homes by the Israelis when the jewish people first came to live in Israel! The Middle East countries instructed the arabs in Israel to leave their homes as they were going to make war on the jews and they said when the Israelis were defeated they could go back to their homes!

They didn`t defeat the jews, so by the time they went back their homes were occupied by Israelis!

The Israelis often offered to build homes for them, but arab .......

[zzzerichxx]

@41Doris ..authorities refused because it suited them to keep them in refugee camps, once again to give Israel a bad name!

You are obviously not used to the lies and deceptions of these people who insist on spewing their hatred and lies about the jews at every turn!

It`s these lies and false scenarios that have caused the anti-semitism in Europe and UK etc.

This demonisation is wicked and all I can say is God is watching!

[darkhose1]

The zionist MEDIA are falsely bringing the muslim brotherhood to the force front of the egyptian REVOLITION, PS; just you guys tell MOSHY BARAK no money for israel cause you starving in USA . and ISRAEHELL is ROGUE staste, believe me sometime TERROR is better than PEACE . az you see 5 year no terrorist attack in isreal , and they do not want PEACE

PEACE

[zzzerichxx]

@darkhose1 The reason the terrorist attacks have been curbed is the wall the Israelis have built!

This hasn`t stopped palestinian arabs trying to murder Israelis though and recently there were those poor american ladies who were repeatedly stabbed by palestinians, one died, the other survived by playing dead, she then struggled to get help! Very sad!

You are paranoid about Zion, this is a word from the Bible meaning the land of Israel! The muslim brotherhood are behind Hamas and Hezbollah!

[darkhose1]

@zzzerichxx no more cheap GAZ deliverd to israhel jst stop supporting the zionist your chritien so go no and red the talmude of the jews abd you will see, anyway peace can not be kept by force it , can only be achieved by understanding , you shoulddn't forget dude every side has it's own idiots

[Lorraine834]

well said to both Deborah & Jude

[CommentsbyMichael]

The idea that Israel can surrender its central highlands is dangerous nonsense and a formula for national suicide. Giving this vital military resource to Arabs will make the Arab dream of conquering Israel so much more realistic a war to achieve that aim becomes almost inevitable at some point. The head of an organization that arose in response to the last Holocaust should not be advocating policies that will enable the next Holocaust.

[CommentsbyMichael]

Stylistically, Rabbi Hier’s presentation was weak at best.  He needs to learn how to present the meat of case quickly and concisely.

The Palestine Media Watch has just published a translation of ‘Jihad is the Way’ by Mustafa Mashhur, who headed the Moslem Brotherhood from 1996-2002. It is must reading.

[DjBall]

Was Rabbi Hier OK with the dumping of chemical weapons/white phosphorus on the woman and children of Gaza ?

[halnove000]

I'm from Italy, and I'm so much afraid of what is going to happen in Egypt now.

The feeling I have is that Egypt is going to turn into a Islamic republic, same as it happened to Iran when about just only thirty years ago, the last king (Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi) has been overthrew after anti-Shah demonstrations made of just few hundreds people in october 1977, but raised, few weeks later, to a total of 6 to 9 million (more than 10% of the country) that marched against the Shah throughout Iran

[nalood100]

So, No to democracy in Egypt in order to protect Israel. I get it, loud and clear.

[jude118]

I am amazed that anybody really believes that the Muslim brotherhood want democracy, they want Sharia Law, they are runnung the riots, not the Egyptians who mistakenly believe they would get democracy. Look at Iraq, there are none so blind as those who will not see.

[ConsolesR3worked]

@jude118 I am amazed how anyone can believe you zionist jews that you are the victims biggest bunch of pussy suck up knife in the back dogs Fuck all zionist jews you give jews a bad name

[stevarda]

Emanuel- in order of a democracy to succeed you need a social contract among the people in which they agree to abide by the rule a an independent judiciary, respect and protect the rights of all minorities, have a free press and be free to express yourself without fear. This social contract does not and has not ever existed in any Arab country including Egypt. "Democratic" elections in not enough. A well organized minority can control the country.To attain democracy Egypt must proceed w caution

[EmanuelRavelli]

I'm astonish by the number of people who think democracy is good for Americans and Israelis, but dangerous for Egyptians.

[EncompassedRunner]

@EmanuelRavelli, especially confounding when coming from people in the US who don't object to American democracy leading to the election of a Muslim Brotherhood stealth jihadist tool in our own country. Freedom now for nations to be stupid and self-destructive, if that's what they democratically choose; I don't like it, but I support it rather than the alternative of repression & imposition.

[haidian123]

This uprising is a movement of the Egyptian people, genuinely, not manipulated nor directed by anyone else, and they want democracy and freedom. This Hier should not merely say "*Theoretically*, democracy is wonderful." He, and Israel, should be fully supporting the people's movement for democracy in Egypt, but he's not interested in doing that, apparently. All he does, for people who are not mindlessly brainwashed supporters of everything Israeli, is to make us beging to suspect Israel more.

[deborah592]

The Israelis remain reasonable and sane....AGAIN! No Hamas. No Hezballah. No Hatred. Stop this madness. Treat life as the blessing it is. Reverence life and those who consider it sacred. God Bless Rabbi Marvin Hier.

[saadasim]

@deborah592 Top Israeli Rabbi Advocates Mass Murder of Gazans jpostXcom/servlet/Satellite?ci­d=1180527966693&pagename=JPost­/JPArticle/ShowFull

Gaza Flotilla - Facts vs Israel Fiction.

watch?v=9Q8X3HSV3-M

Holocaust Survivor Protests Israeli Massacre in Gaza

watch?v=DaDGHB_pB5s

[ConsolesR3worked]

@deborah592 Are u serious man ?????? Israel is doing what the nazis did in nuremberg to the palestiniens your a bigger dickhead than this dickhead for blessing the dickhead .

[deborah592]

@ConsolesR3worked Go back to school and learn how to write an eloquent, coherent argument without obscenity and then we'll discuss the issue. I can respect differing opinions, but you have to have a valid, cogent argument.

[gershon1949]

Hier is brilliant... If "Democracy" in Egypt includes "freedom of religion" and "freedom of expression" then I will be thrilled.... however I guess that an Egyptian "democracy" will only be tolerant of a very narrow range of democratic ideals: the vote & possibly a couple other things. In general I am very negative about this uprising. The "Brotherhood" and other Jihadic groups are waiting patiently in the background to slowly turn Egypt into a radical Muslim state.