Indonesian Idol 4 Rini: Reflection

[donifrisdi]

tubuh mungiilll...suaranya tengiillll...kereenn

[MissClarissaiero]

Harusnya idol dikasih fasilitas les Bahasa Inggris, biar pronunciationnya bagus.

[finallyrealasyhari]

rini itu christinaa aguilera nya indonesia :)

[SnoozleBerg75]

Kok gw nangis y dgr lagu ini dibawakan ama rini, kenak banget gitu_

[squirelistupai]

your voice is great , but you failed at falseto couple time or more , very rought at the end

but still you saved WHOLE seasone!!, that seasone would suck without you XD

im not watching next seasone regulary, because they real suck XD

kapan album 2nya keluar nih T_T, ada pendapat lagi nih lagu "bukan boneka" sebenernya udah bagus banget sayang terlalu singkat dan diulang over and over, bikin lagunya cepet jatuh dari pasaran

[leomaruli]

Apa Smansa Medan gudangnya talenta ya? ;-) Ini aransemen kakak kelasnya Rini, tonton Friska Sinambela (watch?v=Z4oi0q7Nwvk) di channel gw leomaruli.... peace

[MizzXScarlett]

love it gurl great job!!

[asnan]

dia ni rini ni ada pelajaran tinggi bukan mudah jadi seseorang bintang ..yang fropesional ....rini mungkin .boleh jadi seperti anggun siscasmi..amazing global

[ariccccccful]

@asnan setuju

[marioandreacarey]

soundny jelek banget

[thePOOHZ]

epic face. epic face. epic faCe, ePic fAce!

[sillysamantha93]

Wah! Ini hebat sekali. Dia seorang bintang! :) Saya harap dia bersukses dengan menyanyinya.

[ridhalolypop]

rini.. u are a bright star..the real star

[hortatory]

i listen to this, and "The Truth is" by charice pempengco. then i thought it kinda li'l bit similar. i mean the voice..

[bunnytjeee]

emang di indonesian idol bisa pilih lagu sendiri yg mana di nyanyiin? kok rini selalu nyanyi bahasa inggris???????????? tolong ada yg tau?

[rickyaco0802]

@bunnytjeee "selalu" .. perlu pemahaman lebih lanjut tuh

[bunnytjeee]

@rickyaco0802 hahh? kok boleh milih lagu sendiri, kan harusnya di pilihin ama jurynya?

[rickyaco0802]

@bunnytjeee ini msh workshop

klo dah spektakuler stiap mnggunya ada syaratnya baru

[rickyaco0802]

@bunnytjeee kan sudah ada theme nya di tiap show perform, nah all the finalists have to choice

[bunnytjeee]

@rickyaco0802 aah soo okay thanks for the reply!

[rickyaco0802]

@bunnytjeee oke

[kuplag]

i first heard this song sung by a filipina lea salonga...

[ZacreyIsland]

sengau

[kanazef]

@ZacreyIsland <== kebiasaan dengar METAL = MELAYU TOTAL..!

[adityaalqamal]

it's really awesome

[rzqmzq2003]

ini pas workshop y? soalx panggungx kecil..

[natskennedy]

too karaoke

[MrRiefqie]

she's amazing .

two thumbs up for this perform :)

hope she will be an international singer

[fuckhilaryduff]

i love her voice

[Fairyfairus]

I do agree if the language of the song does matter..

the song tells something...

[Nukanikugi]

No, she even not transpose the note into lower,so she sing in christina's note...salute!

[moniiczkaaxd]

woooow.. beautiful. :)

[c0th34]

one of my fav idol selalin judika, nania, dan winda

kenapa gk lo aja rin waktu asian idol.. mike bagus, tapi powernya kurang... klo rini suaranya makin abis makin sexy :P

[tyotheduke]

@c0th34 ga bisa kalogitu , ntar rini kebanting sama si malaysian idol ,

kalo mike kan tipe nyanyinya beda , jadi masih bisa lebih bagus dari si malaysia

[Eartheroes]

@Sl1mze OVERPROTECTIVE bukan OVERPROTECTED....teliti donkk..

[ariccccccful]

kerrrrrrrrrrrrreeeeeeeeeeeen bgt rinnnn

[Eartheroes]

Single terbaru Rini uda keluar judulnya Overprotective.. Tapi kayaknya belum ada yg upload klipnya tu..

[Sl1mze]

ah overprotected mah singlenya britney spears

[OzzieAquisto]

rini mana niy albumnya? sayang bgt penyanyi sekelas dia ga keluar2 albumnya...too bad.. =(

[chillinatomato]

I agree with Kynima. For mmeakida..we are in globalization era...like it or not English is important...

[kyokushinfighter78]

she is even better than miss Aguilera herself, amazing...

[125070098]

guys,,gw tw lgu nya tp ga tw jdul nya,,ad yg tw ga??

lirik nya gni,,

"meskipun terasa indah,,selingkuh tak membawa bahagia"

gw cm tw s'gt..

ad yg tw ga jdul nya ap n sapa yg nyanyi??

thx y..

[mmeakida]

yang nyanyi christina aguilera - reflection ,,, soundtracknya mulan kalo gag salah ...

[ssbb522]

bagus rini! love your voice.

[LuvPikanie]

nice vocal

[doromantehe]

her prnnciation is good enuv here, i thought...evryone hv 2 practice a lot 2 get a word of perfection..n so does Rini..

basically, the asians hv different tongues,.,so it doesn't matter if rini's prNnciation is not as good as christina's which is usin' english as her daily language..

keep a great job rini..

regard from Australia..

[kit04ain]

eww. she sounds like she is shouting in tune. certainly not singing..

[biarinaja]

shes singing! cant u tell? or maybe u're just a bit deaf

[rezunayaka]

i love it

wlopun cempreng tp ada serak seksinya..

ga kalah deh ama jordin sparks jg..

[hiblackie]

her vocal is good but she has problem with English pronunciation.

[ssbb522]

u hav a problem that she needs to know English pronunciation. all Indonesians have problem with English. they don't care about it. u know i'm indonesian, and u can't tell me or indonesian people to what to do. u got tht hiblackie!

[kynima]

Without the english pronunciation whats the point of singing an english song? If we can't understand her the voice means nothing. Here, prononciation is everything, no matter what language you sing in. They WILL take off if you cant do it right.

[kynima]

If she wasn't able to pronounce the words she should have sang a song in her own language. And NO, not every Indonesian has a problem speaking english. If they try, they can speak it just fine. Trust me, I know. It's just like me, I've had to sing in German, Hebrew, LAitenm, Spanish and so on. If you dont pronounce it right, the people your singing for wont be happy.

[ssbb522]

all the people indonesia will like me singing. my cousin, she is famous singer in the whole wide world.

[WoozleWuzzle666]

yea dumbass, just speak the words right, thats all that matters when you sing, who cares if you hit all the wrong notes

[mmeakida]

because english is not our mother language ...

so that's not important for us .... the most important is vocal ... :)

[125070098]

bkn lgu yg d nyanyiin dy..

yg gw mksd lirik yg gw tulis it lho..

ap jdul nya..??

[mmeakida]

oh...selingkuhnya monita bukan?

kalo gag salah itu...yang nyanyi monita, judulnya selingkuh ...

[125070098]

owh..

ok2,,nti cb d cr dh..

thx bgt y..

[kynima]

but if we can't understand her, the vocal means nothing...

(i can understand her fine here though ^.^)

y didn't she just sing a song in her own language then? im just curious...

[Wescogolf]

ancurrrr

[landakkeceprut]

suara jelek, pengucapan ga tau.. yg mesti suara jelek. cm nadanya pas so bisa msk indonesian idol.. aq aj buka ini ga sengaja alias kepencet.. hehe.. maaf bagi penggemar rini.. plis.. hadapi kenyataan.

[Elovesujufull]

@landakkeceprut like you can do better! she actually csn sing and her pronunciation is good.. get a grip man! how daft can you be..

even I'm not a fan of Rini, i admit it that she can sing..

[novelholic21]

drastis bgt beda notnya... pronouncenya paraaaahhh.. cma dpp s.. pdahal suaranya bguss... bgusan nyanyi lgu indo dy... lagu eng Gaby masternyaaa

[dwiagusbbb]

ni salah satu the bestnya rini, nice improve for rini

[siskamartina88]

Wow, powerful voice..but very bad pronunciation of her..:(

[asnan]

baguslah suara dia aku sokong kamu 100.peratus ok paling ok ..kamu pasti juara indonesia idol karna karisma kamu ...100.perarus .boleh jadi penyanyi antara bangsa

[pszlr]

Someone's clone

[novelholic21]

putrihafiza? spa tuh?

[darkraivscresselia]

Pronouncenya jelek especially kata yang berakhir dengan huruf R

[kanazef]

kok..banyak orang pinoy sih di video music indonesia ? terus mereka sirik2 aj gitu yah all.. ? keliatan bgt klo music kita tuh jauh lebih berkembang di bandingin music2 lain di kawasan asia tenggara..! disini suaranya rini dikit mirip ma suarna X-TINA..luv it..! tau aja nih sih rini klo ini lagu kesukaan gw..huhu.. :) !

[hortatory]

ga cuman pinoy,, orang malay n s'pore malah lebih banyak yang comment di video artis2 indo,, setuju banget kalo musik kita lebih b'kembang daripada mereka..

suaranya mirip Xtina di lgu ini?

lagi2 aku setuju ma kamu..^^

[preston07]

putang ina nyo di ko maintindihan comments nyo!!!

[taminf]

she's ok

[hortatory]

walaupun suci, winda ama nania idol 1 digabung nyanyi lagu ini, rini tetep lebih bagus buat nyanyiinnya<<<

[pszlr]

Dimana bisa lihat video Suci,Winda,Nania nyanyi "Reflection"? Kecuali ada videonya..I don't think I could make a judgement.

[littlecherlie]

tempo e kok lebih lambet --

[smileyyrainbow]

Mrrinnddinng . hhi .

[CindyXink1407]

bgs si suaranya. cuma kalo dia nyanyi terlalu cepet ahh.. buru2 gituu jadinyaa.

[BabyGirlon7]

OMG!!

UR SOO AMAZING!

I LOVE UR VOICE!!

[putriahafiza]

sepanjang 5 musim indonesian idol the best (quality) woman singer is ' Rini ...

[pszlr]

She cannot be compared to Joy, Winda, Sisi, Maria, Helena, Dela and others who already have some prior professional experience..but amongst 'ABG' Idol she's one of the best..personally I would rank her #1 or #2..She and Gea are interchangeable..Both of them were far more consistent performers week to week than the others like Monita, Giselle, Ibeth, etc.

[ferror]

agree .. as a teen oke lah, tapi kalau mau dicompare ama diva idol, rini masih hijau

[pszlr]

Kl mo compare jg musti reasonable..Joy udh punya brp album,Sisi,Dela,Judika n others mereka prnah menang Asia Bagus..Ada pula yg udh pny record deal prior to being on Idol..Rini (n also Gea)..r just 17 year old girls..anak SMU yg blm pny byk pengalaman..but look at them..With limited experience she's got good stage presence, confidence on stage,and carries herself better than the rest of the competitors..She looks really comfortable there on stage, singing n improvising effortlessly.

[pszlr]

Remember when II 4 juz started, Rini didn't even get the spotlight..I believe org2 lebih notice Sarah n also Marsya, Risma n Priska..Normally yg pny pretty face lbh cpt dikenal org..But Rini's performance every week makes her stand out as an early favorite to win..You can say Fandy, Gaby or Sarah should have won but the rival that they

[pszlr]

have to win against in the final is none other than Rini.

[ferror]

trus mau di compare ama siapa? gea? gaby? gisel?

[pszlr]

Don't you think there are many more teenagers in II besides those three girls? The past three seasons were dominated by teenagers..Lihat comment yg gw reply..Gw ngga setuju kl the best (quality) woman singer sepanjang 5 musim indonesian idol is Rini..Same with Gea, Gaby n Giselle, gw ngga setuju mereka disebut kl the best (quality) woman singer sepanjang 5 musim indonesian idol..I hope you get it.

[ferror]

got your point .... i mean as a teen idol .... jauhh kalo rini mo dibandingin ma joy .. nania ....

buat gue rini hanya bisa dicompare sama cewe2 dari idol 2,3,4,5

[pszlr]

Yeah but it seems like you cannot tell the difference between me n putriahafiza -_-'

[ferror]

i agree with you .... santai aja. rini bukan yang the best, tapi untuk "seukuran" teen idol, dia yang lebih bersinar

[pszlr]

Duh!Are you putriahafiza? -_-'

[ferror]

siapa tuh?

[yuna20042004]

she does look like mulan

[irockvery]

Rini emang pantes jadi juara... she deserves it.

[bender962]

thats really good!

[kaylashaw123]

made me have

tingles

and goosebumps!!!

beautiful

[danoe847]

i think rini always the best for idol female n i love ur voice rin...

but i dont like ur vibration voice its too slowly, n flat

for idol male i think mike is very perfect

go RINI go...

go mike go...

:)

[zjengz]

waktu dia nyanyi ini, suaranya dia lagi ilang.

[Acupofhope]

ada yg putus2 wkt dia nyampe suaranya gk nyampe... tp bagus koq..

yah namanya jg msh belajar, manusia belajar ampe seumur idup koq..

[MadAlexCota]

wow, she's awsome

[riskiputro]

yes she won!

love her!!

[demonwind92]

shes a great singer, did she win?

[cewephob]

Diadu ma Aji II5 yuk . . .

Rini nyanyi nie,

Aji nyanyi Ordinary Peoplex John Legend,

we'll see which one will b the winner!

[pszlr]

They have different styles of singing so don't compare them..n I haven't yet seen Aji singing that song..or maybe I missed it.

[toytoy12]

she makes me shiver all over!

most beautifull voice ever!

[prszl]

@semutmerah: May I know who's your Idol in II 5? I wanna know if your idol has way better technique than Rini

[semutmerah1987]

Maria Mamamia...

Idol sekarang cem SAMPAH!

[semutmerah1987]

teknik vokalmu masih parah rin

[prszl]

I found out that you support Gisella in II 5. You'd better say that to your Idol too k?

[semutmerah1987]

iya... giseL juga emang PARAH!!!

[ndayucul]

Suaranya agak kering gitu yah? Napasnya juga pendek. Tapi dia lebih cocok nyanyiin lagu yang ng-beat.

[vivamilanisti]

kenapa sih banyak yg sirik ama nie? rini masih jauh lebih bagus daripada ihsan, dirly ama wilson kan?

[prszl]

lol Ask any other II 4 contestants and the remaining female contestant in II 5 to sing this song. Bet they could not sing better than Rini!

[Hansenwork]

damn rini definetly can't sing this song.

[brianangg]

kok kayanya napasnya pendek banget ya?

[WoozleWuzzle666]

shes badass

[niceliem]

ing nya kurang yah.. huehue.. no offence ^^

[jephalexander]

What is this all about??? korea vs Japan or what? i dont like Japanese song .,, very very hate it. I dont really like korean, as well as indonesian,, i like American hahahaha, but Rini is good,, huh

[juzzlikethat]

nyanyinya almost flawless tapi pronounciationnya kurang banget

[rosyhar]

Charice Pempengco - Reflection

[devon1810]

100% agree with u both :-)

Rini is not bad, but still ain't that good. She still has to improve her singing skill.

[sunni341]

she aint have the deep voice as jordin sparks and the exploting sounds as jordin spark has and there is somewhere that i feel that is missing and most important of all she didnt add her feelings into the song it could be felt from here. im telling you as a musician i know there gona be like 10thumbs down but anyways idonesia has still a long way to go in the music world

[LINHAOZHEN]

I think her voice is not bad at all. If compared to Jordin Sparks, each of them has something special. But I think Rini's voice is not qualified enough to be an "idol". I have heard people singing this song in a much more better quality ~ and they were not competing to be an idol. So, Rini, you better work hard improving urself =)

[prszl]

Well if you think Rini is not qualified to be an idol, pls name a contestant in II 4 that supposedly won? I am pretty sure there is always undiscovered talent out there and that applies to every Idol show.

[piyoXD]

ya terang ajalah jordin sparks lbih bagus,orang dia orang barat ya udah biasa ngomong inggris lah,jadi ya kesannya dia lebih bagus,padahal rini ga kalah bagus tuh

[devon1810]

Ini saya gak ngomongin masalah pengucapan bhs Inggris loh, tapi masalah kualitas vokal...!

[prszl]

Well..why is it that we have to compare her with Jordin?II is not even close to AI in terms of quality.

[devon1810]

@prszl:Saya m'bandingkan Rini dgn Jordin krn bnyk komentar2 disini yg b'lebihan muji2 Rini, say that her voice is so perfect, even say dia lebih bagus dari Christina Aguilera, dll. aya pilih Jordin sbg p'banding krn mnrut saya masih selevel:1.Sama2 juara pertama kontest idol,2.Sama2 masih penyanyi amatir sebelum ikut idol,3.umurnya juga sama.

I think it's fair enogh.Jika saya m'bandingkan Rini dgn Whitney Houston, atau Celine Dion.. itu baru tdk fair.

But overall, I am agree with ur comments.

[prszl]

I've read all the comments here and ngga ada yg bilang her voice is better than Xtina.The only comment yg bndingin mereka is someone said she enjoyed Rini's version than Xtina's.And kl cm blng her voice is so perfect..what's wrong with that?That's just one fan's opinion.

[devon1810]

Ok, u r right. Nothing's wrong with them who enjoyed Rini's version than Xtina's. And there's nothing wrong too if I compare her with another idol's winner, right? I think i'm still make a fair comparison.

[prszl]

Of course nothing's wrong with that.I juz didn't understand why we should compare them.Rini is Rini n Jordin is Jordin.

[devon1810]

Saya org Indonesia, tp kuping & otak saya masih bisa objektif utk bilang : Rini ISN'T good enough.

Coba lihat. Rini kebanting JAUH..! Compare to Jordin, Rini is still nothing!!

[prszl]

If you think Rini is not good enough to win, why don't you try to compare other contestants in II4 that you think is better to win the Idol title with Jordin?

[devon1810]

Coba check comment saya, apa saya pernah bilang dia gak pantas jd pemenang Idol 4 ? Gak ada kan. Becoz at that time, no one of her competitors is better than her.

I just said : Rini isn't that good, isn't that outstanding as many people said to her, she still need to improve her singing skill, becoz there's still some idol's winner that better than her, such as JORDIN. Got it..

[prszl]

Okay that's a misunderstanding.I thought u mo blng she isn't good enough to win.I never said that Rini is an exceptional singer either.And of course there are many Idol winners out there that are better than Rini.

[hortatory]

riniiiiiiiiii!!!! good job galllll!!!!

[bayibayiloetjoe]

To sunni341, shame on you for being so arogant! Every nation has its own good! Far out! I just hate it when people look down on others. Just turns me off to even think that people like you still exist in this world! My Korean mates'd be outraged hearing those comments! Unbelievable!

[baddumb]

koreans smell like garlics =) hahaha...

[puffiedoll]

HELLOOO MR.Moron ? Korean music rules Asian Music? Yeah You WISH,I Guess you never listen to any other music,huh ? Have you ever heard of the Great country called Japan? Listen to some of japanese music. If you don't have anything to prove that Korea has the best music, its better for you to shut the hell up. I like Koreans, but not you asshole. not you.

[puffiedoll]

HELLOOO MR.Moron ? Korean music rules Asian Music? Yeah You WISH,I Guess you never listen to any other music,huh ? Have you ever heard of the Great country called Japan? Listen to some of japanese music. If you don't have anything to prove that Korea has the best music, its better for you to shut the hell up. I like Koreans, but not you asshole. not you.

[sunni341]

i guess you dont hear music moron k-pop rules!!! boa, dbsk, rain, seven, shinhwa etc you dont know Korea's got the 5th biggest entertainment buissness and NUM.1 IN ASIA??? RETARD YOUR THE BITCH THAT DOESNT KNOW SHIT AND TALKS and talking about great countries japan killed raped and torchered s.e asia korea china bitch and your the asshole im a musicion bitch!!! i play piano guitar trumpet and im vocal in a band that has played several times i know more about music than you loser!!!

[puffiedoll]

So u were sayin that Korea nvr torture, rape and kill ppl?

u're so retarded, 'people' killed, tortured, raped everywhere, not only in Jpn,besides, we're talking bout music,NOT history moron.AH,,you can sing?O gee..Whr did u performed?ah,,let me guess!On an empty street near the garbage area?Mr.retard if u want ppl to appreciate ur music,try to appreciate other's music,and DONT talk shit bout my country's music asshole.I suggest u to read ur own page.Shame on u.I won't reply to u,so wtevr u say.

[sunni341]

ur funny your the one who started with "great japan" retard and i never talked shit about your country and yea your wrong im only a high schooler but i've been to the first round in auditions in the YG group. and what do you know about music only thing you have is your pathetic national pride. talking about your "great japan"most japanese dont even know indonesia exists and its funny how countries like indonesia thailand philpines taiwan worship Korea and japan while we dont even care about you

[sunni341]

and dont talk about Korea cause i bet you dont even know the basic history of Korea. Korea is known to be peaceful Korea is called the land of the morning calm. i cant belive im talking to a retard like you. and yea your indonesian idol is a fuckin american idol copy its Shitty with a capital Y

[sunni341]

im Korean but i think filipinos are way better man filipinos are good seriously good

[sunni341]

wtf is this a american idol copy???

[JayRdL08]

IDOL is an international show now..

American idol isnt even the original version.

POP idol from england started this franchise.

neways.. theres also a pinoy idol (philippines' version)

[aku192]

she sounds in pain when she sing. she just didn't nail the song for me

[drawsy]

no offence but it guess it was a lil pitchy. she needs more voice control and stuffs.

[phawzee]

WHAT A GREAT VOICE !!!! LOVE THAT !!! RINI . . . you're still young, but You Really do Have Talent ! *proud to be indonesian*

[sunni341]

i say Koreans rule in Asia

[glavinagal]

STFU you mofo! keep your shit to yourself bastard!!

[kags36]

shes better at the higher notes,I think shes very beautiful in her own way

[elfranca77]

you better check your ears

[hiduto]

people who think with brain and have a good hearing should agree with me that american idol is a miles better...

and if indonesian idol a miles better than indonesian idol..?? Why CANT Indonesia WoN even a contest like ASIAN IDOL..??

American Idol go to WORLD IDOL..!!

and She will cry if she heard what Simon Cowell will said to her...!!

[elfranca77]

I never said AI is better than II, moron! If you think this was a bad voice, why keep listening it? doh!

[prszl]

Ngga penting comment lo.

[rezarahardian]

kayak lo selalu comment penting aja, hehehe...

Inilah yg namanya euforia, bung...

[elfranca77]

Indonesian Idol a miles better than yours

[hiduto]

Yeah and IHSAN, DELON is better than RUBEN STUDDARD??? CHRIS DAUGHTRY??? CARIE UNDERWOOD??? DAVID ARCHULETA??? DAVID COOK??? CLAY AIKEN..?? IN YOUR DREAMS..!!

the one who have a good voice in Indonesian Idol is only Mike...

[elfranca77]

I mean it's better than your attitude and mouth, dude

[hiduto]

no no...

it's just about you who cant accept the truth with nonsense words

[venomscorpion]

@hiduto, Januarisman's voice is better than Chris Daughtry's. Judika's rendition of Making Love Out of Nothing at all is better than Carrie Underwood's rendition. If you idolize American Idol so much, why do you even care to comment here?

[the3rdarda]

good voice, good technique, but less power.

i think she's more beautiful when she came to spectacular stage. before that, she's a lil bit messy (in indonesian usually called kumel):D

anyway....she's great, i love her so. and yeah...she's the 4th indonesian idol....:D

[potcfanatic]

So...do they know what they're saying? lol

I love the crack in her voice, and her vibrato. Indo Pride!

[dimasu84]

what?? she's Indonesian, not philipine.. wakakakak.... lol

[vBreee]

zou wel uber zijn als je dan op dat podium staat en eerst een liedje schrijft en dan een rini laat

[schapuhherder57]

als je dan meedoet aan idols en je heet rini zo van ik laat een rini hij laat een rini zij laat een rini wij laten een rini en wij hebben een rini gelaten dan neem ik je dus al niet meer serieus

[Fadiem14]

shes great!!!!

[cat0813]

rini looks different.....see her during d selection.