Hey dictash! I did other reading on GULAG besides AS's "pulp fiction". Ever hear of Eleanor Liper or Alexander Dolgin? They both surviveds of GULAG. You seem to be anapologist for Stalin's system, so cheer up! With the nut cases we have in Washington now, we're headed in the same direction: the direction of mediocrity lack of initiative, and rule by the promoters of jealosy and envy. By the way, every year I get older, but I don't get old. Anyhow, I really like Ipolitov-Ivanov's music. Slava!
I am surе that the name given by composer was JUBILEE MARCH and name VOROSHILOV MARCH was a kind of nickname given by people or propaganda specialists. The marcn was written in occasion of 10th or 15th anniversary of the Red Army (year 1928 or 1932). That is why it was named JUBILEE MARCH.
dictash: Holy wee wee! Yeah, as a mater of fact I am 70. Just couldn't help commenting on some of the things I learned from reading Solzhenitsin's monumental work: The GULAG Archihpelago. Was he brainwashed? If he was, they were unable to erase his memories of Novi Jerusalem and Ekibastuz. As for my being brainwashed, I reckon 24 years in the army might have destroyed a few braincells, especially jumping out of perfectly good airplanes, but I can still do the simple Sudokus and cross word puzzls
When Voroshilov was defeating the White Army and the foreign interventionists did he know he was creating the foundation of Stalinism with GULAG, the NKVD, and the other organizations which terrorized the Russisn people and the rest of the world for 60-some years? In a way he helped to string the barbed wire and raise the watchtowers in such hell-holes as the Kolyma, Vorkuta, Dzhezkazgan, thoughtfully provided by Stalin et al. Ho Hum - ; just (20, 30?) millions of unintended consequences.
J'adore cette marche comme la plupart des chants russes (militaires ou non). Merci pour le partage Tousavec Nintendo, j'apprécie particulièrement tes vidéos, avec un petit plus pour les chœurs de l'Armée rouge. ;-)
No need to put brackets when u say something like that. Voroshilov was a hero of the revolution and he was a great commander during the civil war (against the white army) and also against foreign intervention forces. It was during those times that he and other commanders obliterated both the internal and external forces of opposition against the revolution. Thats why there were songs made about him. Dont believe what wikipedia says about him.
Excellent, I have heard several songs about Voroshilov, but never heard about "marsh" Voroshilov. Thank you for sharing it. Any new bit of information helps :-)
Hello my friend. Unfortunately i don't know exactly when Ippolitov-Ivanov wrote this work (between 1920 and 1935 I think. He was directory of the Conservatory, in Moscow, from 1905 to 1924) and why (he his very little-kown in France today and it's pity). If you read the russian, maybe the wikipedia's page can help you?
Очень красиво и сильно. Создаётся впечатление быстрой и неудержимой атаки.
Mizerov1994 5 months ago
Hey dictash! I did other reading on GULAG besides AS's "pulp fiction". Ever hear of Eleanor Liper or Alexander Dolgin? They both surviveds of GULAG. You seem to be anapologist for Stalin's system, so cheer up! With the nut cases we have in Washington now, we're headed in the same direction: the direction of mediocrity lack of initiative, and rule by the promoters of jealosy and envy. By the way, every year I get older, but I don't get old. Anyhow, I really like Ipolitov-Ivanov's music. Slava!
Tannenberg71410 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am surе that the name given by composer was JUBILEE MARCH and name VOROSHILOV MARCH was a kind of nickname given by people or propaganda specialists. The marcn was written in occasion of 10th or 15th anniversary of the Red Army (year 1928 or 1932). That is why it was named JUBILEE MARCH.
Haritonov46 6 months ago
Comment removed
Haritonov46 6 months ago
Comment removed
Haritonov46 6 months ago
Comment removed
Haritonov46 6 months ago
dictash: Holy wee wee! Yeah, as a mater of fact I am 70. Just couldn't help commenting on some of the things I learned from reading Solzhenitsin's monumental work: The GULAG Archihpelago. Was he brainwashed? If he was, they were unable to erase his memories of Novi Jerusalem and Ekibastuz. As for my being brainwashed, I reckon 24 years in the army might have destroyed a few braincells, especially jumping out of perfectly good airplanes, but I can still do the simple Sudokus and cross word puzzls
Tannenberg71410 9 months ago
@Tannenberg71410
old man, read some valid historical research, not solzhenitsin's pulp fiction
dicthash 6 months ago
When Voroshilov was defeating the White Army and the foreign interventionists did he know he was creating the foundation of Stalinism with GULAG, the NKVD, and the other organizations which terrorized the Russisn people and the rest of the world for 60-some years? In a way he helped to string the barbed wire and raise the watchtowers in such hell-holes as the Kolyma, Vorkuta, Dzhezkazgan, thoughtfully provided by Stalin et al. Ho Hum - ; just (20, 30?) millions of unintended consequences.
Tannenberg71410 10 months ago
@Tannenberg71410
1000000000000000000000000000 millions )))
dicthash 9 months ago
@Tannenberg71410
holy cow! you are 70 and totally brainwashed
dicthash 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great march and video. Thank you.
ovaltrack1 1 year ago
Great march and video. Thankyou
ovaltrack1 1 year ago
J'adore cette marche comme la plupart des chants russes (militaires ou non). Merci pour le partage Tousavec Nintendo, j'apprécie particulièrement tes vidéos, avec un petit plus pour les chœurs de l'Armée rouge. ;-)
republicain85 2 years ago
Merci à toi, ça me fait très plaisir.
TousavecNintendo 2 years ago
why did he write a march about Voroshilov?
tri2061990 2 years ago
I said that I don't really know... Because of the period i think. On fact he was "sacred", "people's artist".
TousavecNintendo 2 years ago
No need to put brackets when u say something like that. Voroshilov was a hero of the revolution and he was a great commander during the civil war (against the white army) and also against foreign intervention forces. It was during those times that he and other commanders obliterated both the internal and external forces of opposition against the revolution. Thats why there were songs made about him. Dont believe what wikipedia says about him.
Okhlopkov 1 year ago
Excellent, I have heard several songs about Voroshilov, but never heard about "marsh" Voroshilov. Thank you for sharing it. Any new bit of information helps :-)
Kalinin1917 2 years ago 2
Hello my friend. Unfortunately i don't know exactly when Ippolitov-Ivanov wrote this work (between 1920 and 1935 I think. He was directory of the Conservatory, in Moscow, from 1905 to 1924) and why (he his very little-kown in France today and it's pity). If you read the russian, maybe the wikipedia's page can help you?
TousavecNintendo 2 years ago
I will try that, thx once more ;-)
Kalinin1917 2 years ago
A very nice march and clip!
Okhlopkov 2 years ago 2
It would only have been better if there was less footages of Trotsky and more of Voroshilov himself!
Okhlopkov 2 years ago
Yes, I agree.
But is not really easy to find it!
I've made that clip with what I had!
TousavecNintendo 2 years ago
No problem, u still did great on it :)
Okhlopkov 2 years ago
Thank you ^_^
TousavecNintendo 2 years ago