Reading some of the comments....and I thought 'guitarists' were a bunch of pretentious critics. Let me just say zcilingir...a fine performance! Enjoyed it! Keep up the good work!
Very good! I played this work ( the piano part) and I love it! As about if turkish people can understand the german music...well, as far as I know hindemith organized the turkish conservatory in Ankara and a lot of turkish pianists studied in Germany (Idil Biret by W. Kempff) and in France. Nationality is not important for the music.
WaltersQuincy : Have you ever played the Hummel Trumpet Concerto? I recommend this for the audition. It's a great standard in the trumpet world, and shows of many different styes of your playing.
Andante et Allegro is considered a level 5 solo so you get 4 less points than you would get from a level 6 solo. One of which is the hindemith. So I guess it really depends on the situation...it's your choice
Hindemith's Sonatas were actually duo sonatas, not solo and accompaniment.
The name (trumpet/tuba) sonata refers to the instrument who has the melodic/thematic material, with the piano displaying technique....though the solo parts are technical and hard to play
I am working on the piano accompaniment for a friend. That part where he messed up at 2:17 is so tricky for me and throws my trumpet friend off when I play it right. You gotta hand it to them for picking it right back up again.
Really good. The only thing I would really suggest is to really open your throat. Especially at the "Breit" on the high B natural. This piece only works wonders if you force alot of air through the horn. Also try keeping your corners of your embouchur really tight....you'll need it for this one. But over all Bravo!!!
I am told by someone who performed this piece with Nadia Boulanger (a long time friend of Hindemith) that the composer said specifically "no vibrato"!
Nice job "zcilingir"! I'm working on it myself and I'll be happy when I reach the stage when I can get through it as cleanly as you do. How did you get on in the contest? This was the first round, right?
thanks for the comment. I wish the best of luck to you in yours, I'm sure you'll do a better job than me. It really is not easy to perform this one on stage.
This was actually the second round of the competition. I played the Neruda concerto in the final round. Although, the sound quality of the recording is more problematic on that one, I have still uploaded the 1st movement. Other movements will be here soon too.
My playing does not represent the whole city/country. Just like the fact that you're arrogant doesn't mean that German nation is necessarily the same way.
I love Dr. PAul!!!!!...even over all those heavy, colorful and dissonant quartal harmonic sonorities,one can still sang those glorious and majestic melodies!
I love Dr. PAul!!!!!...even over all those heavy, colorful and dissonant quartal harmonic sonorities, can still sang those glorious and majestic melodies!
recently I showed this piece to him Eric Aubier, said q to me in the main phrase is q to maintain it, for example from the beginning until I number 1 is the same dynamics. and not to lower the shade.bye
I think you have a nice sound, but I wish you could use a little vibrato and I think this piece needs a very orchestral style consistently throuhgout the whole piece which you seem to lose a little bit of that as the piece went on. Overall, great job!!!!;)
very well played bravo, in the future just watch you rhythem it was a little flakey at times...over all tho great job, i just played this peice for a audition, its a blow
hey thanks... but i was wondering which parts are rhythmically flakey, cos I gave special attention to the rhythm and I was surprised that I had still missed stuff. So please let me know, that's important to me..
i think it is one of my favorite recordings of it, and i like the alternate fingerings you used. and all your notes were extremely crisp and clean with no clams:)
I agree. The room doesn't resonate at all, but that's not really the problem. Hold your notes out, slow it down and remember, "Mit Kraft" = with strenth. I think the piano is outshining you. It needs to be the other way around. Also, pitchy. Love you though :)
I'm playing this for solo and ensemble! :D
MrGreenGamer64 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Your performance is good, but the audio quality of the video uploaded have a noise that distrurbs a lot.
felixnauta 9 months ago
Comment removed
felixnauta 9 months ago
I am working on this solo as an all state audition solo do u have any suggestions?
sanso408 11 months ago
Love your trumpet playing please more
Freknaruto 1 year ago
i really loved this performance! ill be using this for music school auditions! any advice for the piece?
s93lnknprk 1 year ago
Reading some of the comments....and I thought 'guitarists' were a bunch of pretentious critics. Let me just say zcilingir...a fine performance! Enjoyed it! Keep up the good work!
proggoth 1 year ago
where's the sheet? :D
alzira1991 1 year ago
Very good! I played this work ( the piano part) and I love it! As about if turkish people can understand the german music...well, as far as I know hindemith organized the turkish conservatory in Ankara and a lot of turkish pianists studied in Germany (Idil Biret by W. Kempff) and in France. Nationality is not important for the music.
Dankbarkeit1980 1 year ago
I like to breath support and lack of vibrato on the long sections. Excellent.
al345464 1 year ago
great articulation on the quiet parts!
very nice :)
LivingInBox5 1 year ago
Strong playing and breath support, even on the quiet passages.
Vibrato is actually a relatively recent development in style, and if you listen to recordings of Hindemith playing the viola, he uses no vibrato.
ybravura 2 years ago
I love how everyone is a critic on the Internet. Great job.
kevincatch22 2 years ago
What kind of trumpet is that?
codeman953 2 years ago
Bb trumpet
conorstev 2 years ago
@codeman953 looks like a xeno but i don't know
matters9319 1 year ago
Glenn Gould at the piano!!!!!
jesemus33 2 years ago
lol @ the piano player
jsteuernol 2 years ago 3
WaltersQuincy : Have you ever played the Hummel Trumpet Concerto? I recommend this for the audition. It's a great standard in the trumpet world, and shows of many different styes of your playing.
Good Luck!
wvumusic1 2 years ago
Would anyone reccomend this piece for a youth orchestra audition, or should I gow with Andante et Aleegro by Ropartz?
WaltersQuincy 2 years ago
Andante et Allegro is considered a level 5 solo so you get 4 less points than you would get from a level 6 solo. One of which is the hindemith. So I guess it really depends on the situation...it's your choice
matters9319 2 years ago
You should play the piece that you sound best on.
guitarslim56 2 years ago
No Andante et Allegro...that is bad bad bad. If you can play the Hindemith do eet! XD
trumpetdemon 2 years ago
i love this piece so much and that was awsome!
trumpetmaster345 3 years ago
So cool!
WaltersQuincy 3 years ago
great job
hensheler20 3 years ago
Bravo Zeynep!Great progress the last 2 years.
trompetissimo 3 years ago
As to the post earlier
Hindemith's Sonatas were actually duo sonatas, not solo and accompaniment.
The name (trumpet/tuba) sonata refers to the instrument who has the melodic/thematic material, with the piano displaying technique....though the solo parts are technical and hard to play
drxtuba 3 years ago
informative!!!
altonoir 3 years ago
Very beautiful sound !
crissotine 4 years ago
interesting how the piano part is harder than the solo trumpet.
qazxswcdevfrbgtnhy 4 years ago 3
yeah the accompinament is pretty hard
ryanzawesome65 3 years ago 2
my dad is dreading the day he has to accompany me for this piece..
ZJBallard 3 years ago
Not perfect, but great job on a difficult piece!
OMFG4K 4 years ago 4
2:17-2:23 your accompanist had an "oh Shit" moment - priceless. =)
Really fine trumpet playing! A little on the quick side, but I thoroughly enjoyed it nonetheless!
radudeATL 4 years ago 5
I am working on the piano accompaniment for a friend. That part where he messed up at 2:17 is so tricky for me and throws my trumpet friend off when I play it right. You gotta hand it to them for picking it right back up again.
mickinla 3 years ago
Also, if you have not listened to Wynton Marsalis' rendition of this, you just gotta listen to it!!!
andantea09 4 years ago 2
Thomas Stevens has a phenomenal recording of Hindemith
ZJBallard 4 years ago
Really good. The only thing I would really suggest is to really open your throat. Especially at the "Breit" on the high B natural. This piece only works wonders if you force alot of air through the horn. Also try keeping your corners of your embouchur really tight....you'll need it for this one. But over all Bravo!!!
andantea09 4 years ago
I am told by someone who performed this piece with Nadia Boulanger (a long time friend of Hindemith) that the composer said specifically "no vibrato"!
Nice job "zcilingir"! I'm working on it myself and I'll be happy when I reach the stage when I can get through it as cleanly as you do. How did you get on in the contest? This was the first round, right?
robwushu 4 years ago
thanks for the comment. I wish the best of luck to you in yours, I'm sure you'll do a better job than me. It really is not easy to perform this one on stage.
This was actually the second round of the competition. I played the Neruda concerto in the final round. Although, the sound quality of the recording is more problematic on that one, I have still uploaded the 1st movement. Other movements will be here soon too.
zcilingir 4 years ago
@zcilingir
This was an awesome performance! Did you win? I am willing to bet that you got first (even though I didn't hear the other performers).
michaelbme 1 year ago
hindemith kötü ama ingilizce iyi:)
ilginya 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I do not think ,that Ankara-Turkey understand the culture of Hindemith.----------and the Tempo is much too quick.
music8hour 4 years ago
My playing does not represent the whole city/country. Just like the fact that you're arrogant doesn't mean that German nation is necessarily the same way.
Thanks for the comment.
zcilingir 4 years ago
Nice playing! :) It'll be a while before I can play this as well as you.
TheBlackPage1 4 years ago
I love Dr. PAul!!!!!...even over all those heavy, colorful and dissonant quartal harmonic sonorities,one can still sang those glorious and majestic melodies!
altonoir1 4 years ago
I love Dr. PAul!!!!!...even over all those heavy, colorful and dissonant quartal harmonic sonorities, can still sang those glorious and majestic melodies!
altonoir1 4 years ago
recently I showed this piece to him Eric Aubier, said q to me in the main phrase is q to maintain it, for example from the beginning until I number 1 is the same dynamics. and not to lower the shade.bye
srotceh 4 years ago
I think you have a nice sound, but I wish you could use a little vibrato and I think this piece needs a very orchestral style consistently throuhgout the whole piece which you seem to lose a little bit of that as the piece went on. Overall, great job!!!!;)
javianmb 4 years ago
this very well, but needs but feeling, a little vibrato would not do damage to him to the work.but in any case this executed very well
srotceh 4 years ago
very well played bravo, in the future just watch you rhythem it was a little flakey at times...over all tho great job, i just played this peice for a audition, its a blow
Bachstrad37 4 years ago
hey thanks... but i was wondering which parts are rhythmically flakey, cos I gave special attention to the rhythm and I was surprised that I had still missed stuff. So please let me know, that's important to me..
zcilingir 4 years ago
Stop it, Stop it Now!
judgedredd118 4 years ago
i think it is one of my favorite recordings of it, and i like the alternate fingerings you used. and all your notes were extremely crisp and clean with no clams:)
SkaDork660 4 years ago
good job though. :)
judgedredd118 4 years ago
no mercy please :)
zcilingir 4 years ago
I don't like it. Maybe its just my interpretation though. I think she could use more air and less lip muscle.
judgedredd118 4 years ago
I agree. The room doesn't resonate at all, but that's not really the problem. Hold your notes out, slow it down and remember, "Mit Kraft" = with strenth. I think the piano is outshining you. It needs to be the other way around. Also, pitchy. Love you though :)
Dermon17 4 years ago
wow...
27Tatjana 4 years ago