Hello, I am a keyboard warrior, I see I am not alone here, there are many, many more below my comment. Anyway, instead of giving constructive criticism, I am going to try my hardest to make myself look as big a douche bag as I can be, and thus, my comment my be filled with derogatory words aimed at you and your band, because I clearly have no respect for musicianship and the practice it takes to get to doing what you guys did, and I can do it better anyway, good day.
a little bit of tuning the instruments would have been a nice idea...
and not that i'am too much of an expert, but i am part of a band writing their own ska-punk songs since 2 years and as far as i'm concerned this song lacks the ska...
You need to learn what ska is. this video is not only misleading, but the instruments all sound flat. learn up on music before you try to make a cover. and never call this sort of garbage ska. never.
so i think that this could've been more horn involved, it would've been kinda kool if you could've changed the mood of the song to make it better, all i say in this was you performing a cover of a cover with some horns in there. And i don't think he's a bad singer, this just isn't the kind of thing he should be singing. other than that stuff, nice job
call me a critic if u want, i dont giave a crap but... vocals: Sucked... horns: even worse... overall 1-10 1 being the best and 10 being the worst: 10. not enuf ska, too much distortion, too slow, u shouldve practiced for about another year b4 you performed this in front of ppl. if they thought this was good, they chould go listen to the song b4 they make tht call. sry... NOT! u all suck!
So if they listen to the original song, then listen to this song and call it crap? You are wrong. Very, very, very wrong. This is their own cover, they are not making an exact copy. You dont just listen to the original song and then compare it to a cover and say its bad. YOU SUCK.
@Mazza4Azza it dont matter if they r making an exact copy or not. they suck at playing and theres too much low brass and not enuf trumpet. so stick tht in your juice box and SUCK IT!!
@Mazza4Azza HA! u dont know who ur talkin to. I konw wut music is. ive been in band since 5th grade, ive been in a band for 2 years, ive been playin guitar for 5 years, my dad and my rhythm guitar player's dads have been in a band together for 18 years, and his dad still is, and my dad and I have a bigger music collection thn ANYONE we know. and he know ALOT of ppl. so get ur head out of ur ass and listen to so9me ACTUAL music. PEACE!
sorry,vut i wouldn't call this a ska cover, ska is nomall sped up off beat and the bassest isn't doing very much in comarision to a song like wrong way
definitely agree that the horns should've been an octave higher. at least the trumpet, it sounds so sick when it just blares up there. other than that, sounds good boys.
acttually its awesome !! i play the sax tenor on a ska punk band in tijuana baja california call MALA SUERTE ( BAD LUCK ) thats what it means check us out just put in ritmos criminal skate day on the search barr here on you tube greattings and to bad u just did that one time.... u guys sound awesome
I never said metal is for only for young people...you did
I only said "grow the fuck up and open up to new things" so put down the emo kid for one second and listen to what you say and what others say cuz youre only going to make yourself look like a bigger idiot than you already make yourself sound like...just becasue YOU dont like SKA doesnt mean it sucks, it only means YOU THINK it sucks.
99 STUKA sing this better over ENGLAND, is a german song boys
TheDynamoblitz 1 month ago
Having trumpet and trombone in a song doesn't automatically qualify it as ska...
yapurehefty 3 months ago
Fcking awesome SKA! wahaha
NGEFTIC 4 months ago
anybody have a copy of ska humbug doing this? circa 1993. The song really does work in ska style, keep practicing.
thomeyes 5 months ago
Whoever contract them ask for ur refund they sing awfullll n they stainnned the word (ska)
dierova 5 months ago
Who ever told that guy he could sing?
Youtubican 6 months ago
this is awesome
ConvinceTheWorld 6 months ago
Hello, I am a keyboard warrior, I see I am not alone here, there are many, many more below my comment. Anyway, instead of giving constructive criticism, I am going to try my hardest to make myself look as big a douche bag as I can be, and thus, my comment my be filled with derogatory words aimed at you and your band, because I clearly have no respect for musicianship and the practice it takes to get to doing what you guys did, and I can do it better anyway, good day.
evanescencerawks 7 months ago 3
this is about as SKA as the Queen of Spains Tits
NorthernSoulGer 8 months ago
Tell your 'bone player to stop being a pussy and play it in the correct octave.
imnotmitchturino 8 months ago
Ska? I'm thinking two practices were not enough.
48154815Bp 8 months ago
vokal-terrible, where is the SKA????????? Very, very bAAAAAAAd cover.
wiolinga07 8 months ago
The German vocals part sucked. Other than that, great job!
sidwerd1hater 9 months ago
nigga yr bass player sucks dick
747ior 9 months ago
a little bit of tuning the instruments would have been a nice idea...
and not that i'am too much of an expert, but i am part of a band writing their own ska-punk songs since 2 years and as far as i'm concerned this song lacks the ska...
bit off-beat would've been nice
nomorefearimhear 10 months ago
I have to say, that was very good. Nice cover!
subject2change13 10 months ago
You need to learn what ska is. this video is not only misleading, but the instruments all sound flat. learn up on music before you try to make a cover. and never call this sort of garbage ska. never.
AndyKenny730 10 months ago
Wow. It was good until he started screaming.
StuPadazzo 10 months ago
just cuz there is trumpets and stuff it doesnt make it ska!!...IDIOT
sluttyemily69 10 months ago
where's the ska ?
DerPunkfreundGER 10 months ago
buy a faggot ballon?
666alikat 11 months ago
As a true lover of music, you guys did a great job!
hutch1111111 11 months ago
eww, wtf did you guys do with the horns??
iplayguitar420 11 months ago
personally i think the vocals are great
BlistersOnMehFingers 1 year ago
Yeah, Cool Stuff! .... Skank the Scum away ;-)
Please support our Channel, too!
Cocoheadnuts 1 year ago
Nena did this originally circa 1984.
blueberries4ever 1 year ago
great idea
DanDYpr88 1 year ago
Great punk rock show guys!
wintertaler 1 year ago
hate to be a troll but the vocals were terrible.
captgjohnson 1 year ago 11
this is funny but great. :)
dpa04 1 year ago
@0edward0cullen0 sorry i wan't aware that this was originally hers there is still some irony though
caffinatedchad 1 year ago
isn't ironic that the band that originally did the song , goldfinger, is a ska band but they just left the horns out of their version of the song
caffinatedchad 1 year ago
Comment removed
0Edward0Cullen0 1 year ago
@caffinatedchad Nena did it originally. :b
0Edward0Cullen0 1 year ago
nice cover man, i like the vocals, i don't like audio fixed vocals :)
BeezTrollin 1 year ago
The German Part -> Fail !
XxPunk248xX 1 year ago
Das Rockt!
yseaw1 1 year ago
wicked don't listen to anyone else
thomsy14 1 year ago
It sounded great. I don't know why everyone's panties are in a bunch.
Necrophiliac7 1 year ago
the vocals mess up the whole song
rocko562 1 year ago
the vocals suck big time
djbraindeath 1 year ago 6
Vocals are great, but the instrumental...
the vocals are punk rock!
mightysh33p 1 year ago
awesome.
evilreapinb14ch 1 year ago
Nice! I love it
LongRangeBullet 1 year ago
keep it rude boys effing epic effort
samarchist 1 year ago
thats awesome! those 97 who dislike it must have seen another video... ;)
bekloepptchen 1 year ago 2
This is god awful. Oh geez
upskirtdrummer2212 1 year ago
@upskirtdrummer2212 This is actually good.. lets see you do better
DJGibsonSG 1 year ago
is liked the end, when it was over
refentil 1 year ago
Goldfinger is so much better <3 This sucks soo hard. Vocals are bad. D:
MelanieVampireFreak 1 year ago
Pretty good for a one show type thing. Goldfinger's cover is awesome tho!
ManicRant 1 year ago
this is good :) it's kinda catchy :) makes me smile lol
Danny55022 1 year ago
Absolutely awful singing. Try the Reel Big Fish version, it kicks this one's ass.
SamChiliPepper 1 year ago
@SamChiliPepper HA..HAHA! don't you mean Goldfinger's version?
trifectaepsilon 1 year ago
@trifectaepsilon No, I meant Reel Big Fish's version; they're a ska band ..
SamChiliPepper 1 year ago
@SamChiliPepper ha alright. please send me a link where i can listen/see RBF playing 99 red balloons.
trifectaepsilon 1 year ago
@SamChiliPepper reel big fish never covered 99 red ballons it was goldfinger
ernestryles 1 year ago
Work on your vocals, but other than that I like where you went with this.
AylatheRaichu 1 year ago
That sounds like much fun =) Nice job guys =)
flowermusic1997 1 year ago
so i think that this could've been more horn involved, it would've been kinda kool if you could've changed the mood of the song to make it better, all i say in this was you performing a cover of a cover with some horns in there. And i don't think he's a bad singer, this just isn't the kind of thing he should be singing. other than that stuff, nice job
GrapefruitMachine 1 year ago
the band is good ^_^ ..
ronaXleigh 1 year ago
i like his singing i think it sounds fine
brandonparrish18 1 year ago
nice singing.......NOT. :D :D :D
MrTrombone94 1 year ago
u suck at singing but the band is good
datseeman 1 year ago
Shouldn't really complain should they, I dont see them doing a better Job. :P x
JennyLeik 1 year ago
one thing I can say is good job in the way you added the brass to the song...other then that nothing good to say so won't say anything.
vampirepunk24 1 year ago
Vocals and guitar sucked.
xarealpersonx 1 year ago
nice, uhhm are the shoute or singer of your band? oh and btw listen to the original by Nena not GoldFinger then try again
08154711n 1 year ago
Hate to break it to you all, but that guy can't sing....
sadierfe 1 year ago
@sadierfe not breakin any news to the sane people :) lol sorry guys but this song just isnt very good...
EmoLifeOver 1 year ago
Isn't the defention of ska a backbeat, that this song misses and therfor you fail.
Jontenn 1 year ago
wow o.o that was actually rly good
RontoWolfBackUp 1 year ago
i actualy liked the vocals, they arent too bad
plimptonrocksmysocks 1 year ago
Looks like you had fun. There's no sign of ska here, but keep playing and keep enjoying the music.
BusterDeacon 1 year ago
Vocals are pretty shite. Und das deutsche ist shiesse.
sabradan 1 year ago
dude you can play guitar and i qeus math but you cant sing
213mark132 1 year ago
wow. these kids did good.
L74L 1 year ago
I gotta be honest, that was awesome!
birdbrain5381 1 year ago
haha this is awsome
WolfStorms44 1 year ago
The vocals could use work. But it takes balls to sing in front of a crowd.
HigherGround93 1 year ago
call me a critic if u want, i dont giave a crap but... vocals: Sucked... horns: even worse... overall 1-10 1 being the best and 10 being the worst: 10. not enuf ska, too much distortion, too slow, u shouldve practiced for about another year b4 you performed this in front of ppl. if they thought this was good, they chould go listen to the song b4 they make tht call. sry... NOT! u all suck!
shraeder80 1 year ago
@shraeder80
So if they listen to the original song, then listen to this song and call it crap? You are wrong. Very, very, very wrong. This is their own cover, they are not making an exact copy. You dont just listen to the original song and then compare it to a cover and say its bad. YOU SUCK.
Mazza4Azza 1 year ago
@Mazza4Azza it dont matter if they r making an exact copy or not. they suck at playing and theres too much low brass and not enuf trumpet. so stick tht in your juice box and SUCK IT!!
shraeder80 1 year ago
@shraeder80
Shut it. You don't know what music is.
Mazza4Azza 1 year ago
@Mazza4Azza HA! u dont know who ur talkin to. I konw wut music is. ive been in band since 5th grade, ive been in a band for 2 years, ive been playin guitar for 5 years, my dad and my rhythm guitar player's dads have been in a band together for 18 years, and his dad still is, and my dad and I have a bigger music collection thn ANYONE we know. and he know ALOT of ppl. so get ur head out of ur ass and listen to so9me ACTUAL music. PEACE!
shraeder80 1 year ago
@shraeder80
Haha. So now you start to talk. Ok, if you know so much about music, why dont you respect it?
Mazza4Azza 1 year ago
@Mazza4Azza i respect GOOD music. and GOOD sounding music. i mean they dida mediocre job but it wuznt rite. tuning wuz horible too
shraeder80 1 year ago
@shraeder80
I can give you that it has an awful sound, but music is music. Good or bad.
Mazza4Azza 1 year ago
@Mazza4Azza yes but good music makes ppl happy
shraeder80 1 year ago
@shraeder80
lol like Living in the sunlight loving in the moonlight by tiny tim
Mazza4Azza 1 year ago
@Mazza4Azza i prefer to live in the Limelight. tht way i dont have to worry bout getting sunburn lol
shraeder80 1 year ago
@shraeder80
lol!
Mazza4Azza 1 year ago
@Mazza4Azza plus limelights a good song so yea
shraeder80 1 year ago
@shraeder80
yeah :)
Mazza4Azza 1 year ago
pretty good
punkandoi69 1 year ago
at first i thought the vocals weren't THAT bad..... then i listened a little bit more
SporeKore 1 year ago
Oh WOW I would be so embarrassed to sing that badly! Someone listened to a little too much Rock Lobster before the show
TheSchnok 1 year ago
nice cover but not really ska...u might want to speed it up a little
vester8099 1 year ago
lindo cover
CHIMIFEDE 1 year ago
ya nice... but...
can you tell me.. where is the ska part in this video? cant find one...
fjende 1 year ago
@fjende maybe its the fuckin horns section cuz you know um thats a pretty big part part ska dude
isukatlax 1 year ago
this was wonderful! :D
iAmTheLurch 1 year ago
Refreshingly different - I like it. Pity the recording didn't pick up the vocals better.
Thanks for posting ;-))
peddytheviking 1 year ago 26
sorry,vut i wouldn't call this a ska cover, ska is nomall sped up off beat and the bassest isn't doing very much in comarision to a song like wrong way
synth77 1 year ago 2
This is pretty sick!
yes the vocals aren't the best but this is amazing XD
PeaceLoveShianne18 2 years ago
thank you for doing a ska cover of one of my fav ska songs!
dakotagonz 2 years ago
it was good...they had the ballz 2 go up der an any of u tlkin shit should get kicked in the clit
mazter101 2 years ago
Good job boys. Try harder and you'll ace it!
TheKlaySniper2 2 years ago
A little more practice on everything, + faster, would have been good. But nice nice.
CyperOfficial 2 years ago
This is pain for my ears
MBKSKANABIS 2 years ago
Good job boys. Too bad ur not an "actual" band. You should think about doing this on a regular basis. I'd be interested in hearing you guys progress.
ttocsrekrap 2 years ago
stop talking crap people i meen for real......
khalifdove 2 years ago
you need more guitars and a bass lol.
still fun. good job. 3/5
JOHNNYQUESTCHOKEHOLD 2 years ago
They have a Bassist
narutouzumakie 2 years ago
The vocals suck.
dropzer0schecter 2 years ago 72
@dropzer0schecter jajaj yes
sandraixoye 1 year ago
@dropzer0schecter at least he's trying :D ... I've seen worse in bands pretending to be bigger
SergiuFruja 1 year ago
This is pretty hard.
CierraGunderson 2 years ago
agreed. definitely should have been an octave higher.
faqjzed 2 years ago
definitely agree that the horns should've been an octave higher. at least the trumpet, it sounds so sick when it just blares up there. other than that, sounds good boys.
bondproof2 2 years ago
If the horns could take their stuff up an octive it would have been so much better
AFLoneWolf 2 years ago
omg dman ok this is the goldfinger guitar with an other trumpets and horns... ok its just ok
nanycoy 2 years ago
Very good
PunkDirector86 2 years ago
make more and my dad will offer u a contract
kdogchamps55555555 2 years ago
i like this version better than goldfinger's even though they are both relly good this version uses more brass instruments which is awesome
TFOT54 2 years ago
sounds like the goldfinger version ! great job!
alvarez1337 2 years ago
great job.=D
MattNintendo64Nerd 2 years ago
The concept was interesting but the horns were way out of tune and the singer murdered it hard
MrSmrtynikkers 2 years ago
awesome, this vid makes me smile. <3 it
charm52283 2 years ago
Love this! it's so cute; what a great idea and the performance is good !
JeSuisMonAmiPourTu 2 years ago
awsome
c0mmissarKar 2 years ago
Not bad
LOAblue 2 years ago
acttually its awesome !! i play the sax tenor on a ska punk band in tijuana baja california call MALA SUERTE ( BAD LUCK ) thats what it means check us out just put in ritmos criminal skate day on the search barr here on you tube greattings and to bad u just did that one time.... u guys sound awesome
streetlegaldrift 2 years ago
for me nothing will ever beat the german version but this is ok.
SuperTravisbickle 2 years ago
awesome
ralado10 2 years ago
It's definetely fun to watch.
plencz 2 years ago
cool now sing the original german version :D XD
silverrook 2 years ago
haha not too bad.........but please tune your horns
SManifestosSkatastic 2 years ago
Very cool
BraveNewAtheist 2 years ago
the sax is way out of tune but overall decent
GiantOgreNV44and45 2 years ago
its cool=) i like it. im german, and this really rocks=) fine=)
schokobrain 2 years ago
not bad guys. keep rocking.
HenHouseSuprise 2 years ago
Best Cover! ;)
Greatings from Germany.
Bone2050 2 years ago
Awesome
pcsbyte 2 years ago
drums sound very solid
davidbball13 2 years ago
i fail to see the 'ska'
Trampless 2 years ago
not bad for a non-group one time thing
politicalBG 2 years ago
need to work on it alot more
and the singing needs a lil work
and the horns need to tune themselfs
but i like the atempt!
punkrckr3 2 years ago
I like your attempt at spelling attempt. Good effort punkrckr3. You'll get them next time. I just know it!
Streetlight7329 2 years ago
lol spelling was never my strong point
punkrckr3 2 years ago
horns are badly out of turn and need more work
mcmeekz 2 years ago
The balloon, at the end, really made me laugh!
smugglertrev 2 years ago
dit is doch keen SKA... scheiß ami-pogo-müll
atzewellblech74 2 years ago
That's not a bad cover of a cover of a cover at all, for two practices.
OneZeroFour104 2 years ago
its not even ska its more like a punk beatish sht
Rudy0HWow 2 years ago
ooooo. He needs to work on singing
Cobainpunk74 2 years ago 18
speak german
KrunchyGoodness 2 years ago 3
You suck then, Ska kicks ass
ThatTallskaterguy 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
SKA SUCKS
robbberttto 2 years ago
HOW DARE YOU let me guess...you like...KINGS OF LEON!!!!! and ARCTIC MONKEYS!!!
JWBails 2 years ago
no i neithar like that i like AC/DC, zz top,metallica,megadeth,motorhead,led zeppelin,sodom,pantera,sepultura
robbberttto 2 years ago
no offence,but out of all of your list,only led zeppelin is good.
darkmortality 2 years ago
fucking metalheads criticizing anything that isnt Classic rock, grow the fuck up and open up to new things
ChemicalCrimson 2 years ago
Comment removed
robbberttto 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you grow up SOB you can suck my dick AND HEAVY METAL IS NOT ONLY FOR YOUNG PEOPLE JACKASS YOU ARE AN ASSHOLE CAUSE SKA SUCKS
robbberttto 2 years ago
(sigh)..you seriously need therapy or something.
I never said metal is for only for young people...you did
I only said "grow the fuck up and open up to new things" so put down the emo kid for one second and listen to what you say and what others say cuz youre only going to make yourself look like a bigger idiot than you already make yourself sound like...just becasue YOU dont like SKA doesnt mean it sucks, it only means YOU THINK it sucks.
ChemicalCrimson 2 years ago
Nice sound for the time alloted, but would it kill you guys to move around a bit?
sodapopinski12 2 years ago
Too bad you couldn't get a better singer. And you weren't really energetic. But the instruments sounded good.
Ek0shi 2 years ago
voice sound be a bit deeper
mitchelitis12 2 years ago
Excellent cover... liked the drum parts... good job...
pedrorific 2 years ago 2
i really like this.
you put it into your own way.
nice job.
and the outfits were a plus haha
mgshortyx14 2 years ago 3
You absolutely butchered the german part...
bourn4theAF 2 years ago
that was good, only I think that the brass should be a little higher pitched.
Also, you guys need to have some fun while on stage. everyone is just standing around.
KyleLovesSka 2 years ago 2
look at the info bar thingy haha they arnt a band just messing around.
PaintballProductions 2 years ago
i relized that after i made the comment. lol o-o
KyleLovesSka 2 years ago
gooood!
adricarde 2 years ago 3