I got a question for Machu in the crowd here. What is the relation between the Wanyan clan of the Jin Dynasty and the Aisin Gioro of the Manchu dynasty? Are the Aisin Gioro descendend from the Wanyan directly or are they descedend from a different clan or tribe?
@GodsCommand I really doubt everything about this aspect of korean history is fake. The chinese and japanese are in a way just as guilty if you accuse koreans of fabrication. This is one big downside to the asia approach to history it is way too politicized. I think there some compelling things that point to Korean ties to Manchu.
@BATURUSHA what do you object to about Manchus and Koreans. I am not claiming that Manchus are Koreans but they've have dealings long before the Manchus became what they were under Nurhachi and Hong Taji.
@BATURUSHA I'm not claiming that koreans are manchus but they did have extensive dealings since the manchu/jurched/malgals have been living in roughly the same neighborhood.
There is no Manchu, Chinese claimed Manchu ancestry to avoid One child policy. There is even no manchu speakers, holy mountain my ass, Jangbaek-san was named baekdu long before manchus. Half of Mt. baekdu was given o China as gift from Kim Il Sung.
@consoleman09 the name 'Manchu' was given to all the different peoples united under the 8 banners by Huangtaiji, it was totally not given by the Chinese government.
Changbaisan is Chinese Manchus territories forever ! Mao Tse Tung under North Korean flatteries and begging give out half of the Tianji Lake to North Korea only in the sixties. Before that the whole area was under Chinese control.
Don't believe Paektu is your land , only because that name appears in you folk songs. Find the facts do some research.
@Thak11 true. throughout history there has been migration from china into korea. However both Japan and Korea kids are taught to be proud of their homogenous culture so it has to be how koreans and japanese are taught.
You can't deny that they have got descendents from Manchus and Hans, they became Koreans now. Culturally, Korean culture are not related to Malgal , Manchus cuture and vice versa.
Some of your ancesters came from China, you can't deny that , those were Sino-Koreans came from Shangdong, Inner Mongolia, Manchuria. Those are Chinese territories not Korean territores which you people like to steal from us Hans and Manchurians.
You are another crazy southern ignoramus!tell u the truth, I am a Manchu from Heilongjiang,and I studied genetics and history! Pls read more before barking with your southern mouth! Koreans got nothing related us,they are closer to you southern hans and southeastAsians!the socalled dongyi/shandong/mongolia/or tungus related concepts are all from their wet dreams,all fake
@meticulous3 I agree. But we've been neighbors for quite a long time. They may have been some intermigling between koreans and manchus or rather the ancestors of Manchus.The term dongyi is a very generic term. Mongolia are even further apart from Manchu.
Remember illegal occupation of Tibet, East Turkestan & Genocide in Darfur. The rest of the world will never forget nor forgive endless disgusting crimes against humanity by PRC. Not only BBC and CNN but even AlJazeera TV strongly condemns disgusting HATE crimes against mankind by Chinese regime&its people in this century.PRC did sabotage dispatch of full UN Protection force in UN security council.PRC supplied AKs, grenades&other killing machines to African dictators for blood oil.
The 3Miao tribes were established during the Warring States of China. Our Han brothers have acknowledge our existent for thousand of years. There was this one Miao girl, while taking her DNA blood test, she share a common root with the Korean while some Miao show great mixture of Southern genes and Northern genes. We Miao only recognized two groups; the Ancient Chinese and the Nanman as our closet relatives.
There are ethnic Manchus that still speak the language, just not in fuckin communist China...I'm both Mongol and Manchu adn Korean....We fled from the communists and most of us manchu speaking/ tibetan buddhists live in Canada, Korea, Japan, and Taiwan. The true Aisin Gioro Crown Prince lives in California.
@braveryofmanchu You don't even need to be suspicious,anything from korea related to history,origins and so on is simply fake,they are the most shameless liars in asia,there is reasons behind why koreans r hated so much by both China and Japan,China and Japan people hardly have any conflicts regarding ancient history but the koreans always have conflicts with Ch/JP when it comes to history,cultural and origin issues
dracokaiser, if you are a real Manchu then tell me what your surname and hala is and speak to me in Manchu. The people that speak the Manchu language perfectly are confirmed that they are only in China.
mongol fag. Give me a fucking break! Like I said, by ur preposterious logic, there is NO more black people in the US since they have adopted White culture and customs. Have they been identified as White-American? Get some fucking sense. U don't even fucking understand what Manchu means, yet dares to define what it is. BTW, your ethnic Mongolian brothers in China will get assimilated just matter of time. Are u going call them "chink" too? hahah... dumb ass
Hey mongol fag. What the fuck are u talking about? Manchu is a name for an ethnic group. There are about 2 millions Chinese identified as ethnic Manchu in China. By ur fucking logic, then there are NO more black people in the US. Here are some of the famous Manchu Chinese: 關中(Vice President of the Nationalist party), 郎朗(world class pianist), and 郎平(US Women's national volleyball team coach). Get ur facts straight before opening ur shit mouth. -- From a proud Manchu Chinese!
Omg I am a manchu too! I have been searching for so long to learn more about my culture and language.... Thank you so much for posting this, this is the first time I have ever heard of my language being spoken (sing), would you have to happen to have anymore avaiable??
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
Is the song manchu tongue? Sounds altaic. It's ironic that the manchu once ruled china and tried to assimilate all ethnic groups. Today, majority of Manchu have been assimilated. Were they performing a Shamanistic ritual around the fire place?
60% is NK, the other 30% is part of Yanbian.
ghoststrider45 4 months ago
Dirty china.china is an axis of evil.
cuwnrdlwkrlawjddlf 4 months ago
Koreans, Manchus, so what?
TheHaraboji 8 months ago
@TheHaraboji shut the fark up kimchirian and get out of this vid! You guys originated from negritos and kaidais!
GodsCommand 8 months ago
I got a question for Machu in the crowd here. What is the relation between the Wanyan clan of the Jin Dynasty and the Aisin Gioro of the Manchu dynasty? Are the Aisin Gioro descendend from the Wanyan directly or are they descedend from a different clan or tribe?
redwhitedude 8 months ago
@redwhitedude different clan
GodsCommand 8 months ago
@GodsCommand okay so aisin gioro has nothing to do with koreans then. I got a little suspicious from those claims.
redwhitedude 8 months ago
Comment removed
GodsCommand 8 months ago
@GodsCommand I really doubt everything about this aspect of korean history is fake. The chinese and japanese are in a way just as guilty if you accuse koreans of fabrication. This is one big downside to the asia approach to history it is way too politicized. I think there some compelling things that point to Korean ties to Manchu.
redwhitedude 8 months ago
@redwhitedude I don't think so
BATURUSHA 6 months ago
@BATURUSHA what do you object to about Manchus and Koreans. I am not claiming that Manchus are Koreans but they've have dealings long before the Manchus became what they were under Nurhachi and Hong Taji.
redwhitedude 6 months ago
@BATURUSHA I'm not claiming that koreans are manchus but they did have extensive dealings since the manchu/jurched/malgals have been living in roughly the same neighborhood.
redwhitedude 6 months ago
DAM MANCHU DOGS
ninjafromchina 1 year ago
There is no Manchu, Chinese claimed Manchu ancestry to avoid One child policy. There is even no manchu speakers, holy mountain my ass, Jangbaek-san was named baekdu long before manchus. Half of Mt. baekdu was given o China as gift from Kim Il Sung.
consoleman09 1 year ago
@consoleman09 Did you forget to read the comment below by Tungusda?
WuTangtst 1 year ago
@consoleman09 the name 'Manchu' was given to all the different peoples united under the 8 banners by Huangtaiji, it was totally not given by the Chinese government.
Deuszxable 1 year ago
Coohiyan ume jai Golmin Xanggiyan Alin be holtome tuwara de baime gvnin banjibure,Suwe coohiyan erebe ejebu,Enduringge Golmin Xanggiyan Alin oci muse Manju i ningge inu.
韩国人不要再窥视剽窃长白山了,你们给记好了,神圣长白山是我们的,哪怕咱满族还剩一个活人,长白山都轮不着你们管。就算你们在长白山也有历史,那也是我们给你们写的,所以别得寸进尺了。
tungusda 1 year ago
这就对了嘛!在这一点,大江南北,全国各地的汉人通通地无条件地支持满人到长白山天池献祭。至少也让韩棒子以后觊觎我国辽东领土的野心有所忌惮。
tobeornot00 1 year ago 4
my last name is pronounced toong, and in pinyin is tong, like the famous chinese singer, tong tie-xin. i am a han/manchu mutt, for all nonbelievers.
lgtong81 2 years ago
@lgtong81 Tong is the Cantonese version for Tang. Were you born in Hong Kong?
WuTangtst 1 year ago
Changbaisan is Chinese Manchus territories forever ! Mao Tse Tung under North Korean flatteries and begging give out half of the Tianji Lake to North Korea only in the sixties. Before that the whole area was under Chinese control.
Don't believe Paektu is your land , only because that name appears in you folk songs. Find the facts do some research.
Thak11 2 years ago
Mt. BaekDu is KOREA's territory forever~~~!!!
백두산은 영원히 한국땅입니다.~~~!!!
pengyou1909 2 years ago
30% Koreans has genetic traces from China, but they deny that.
Thak11 2 years ago
@Thak11 true. throughout history there has been migration from china into korea. However both Japan and Korea kids are taught to be proud of their homogenous culture so it has to be how koreans and japanese are taught.
redwhitedude 8 months ago
A few Korean past presidents can trace their ancestry from China like Shangdong.
Thak11 2 years ago
You can't deny that they have got descendents from Manchus and Hans, they became Koreans now. Culturally, Korean culture are not related to Malgal , Manchus cuture and vice versa.
Thak11 2 years ago
Korean people = Manchus and Hans blood
Thak11 2 years ago
you must be crazy.....they got nothing related to Manchu and northern hans
meticulous3 2 years ago
Some of your ancesters came from China, you can't deny that , those were Sino-Koreans came from Shangdong, Inner Mongolia, Manchuria. Those are Chinese territories not Korean territores which you people like to steal from us Hans and Manchurians.
Thak11 2 years ago
You are another crazy southern ignoramus!tell u the truth, I am a Manchu from Heilongjiang,and I studied genetics and history! Pls read more before barking with your southern mouth! Koreans got nothing related us,they are closer to you southern hans and southeastAsians!the socalled dongyi/shandong/mongolia/or tungus related concepts are all from their wet dreams,all fake
meticulous3 2 years ago
@meticulous3 I agree. But we've been neighbors for quite a long time. They may have been some intermigling between koreans and manchus or rather the ancestors of Manchus.The term dongyi is a very generic term. Mongolia are even further apart from Manchu.
redwhitedude 8 months ago
The Manchu girls are so pretty, Hao Kan!!!
oseanic1980 2 years ago
Changbai belongs to the people of China, Baekdu belongs to the people of Korea. ^-^
oseanic1980 2 years ago
China will defeat Korean !
xuantzi 3 years ago
那么,《李朝肃宗实录》中所用的长白山这个名词的发明权属于谁呢?属于朝鲜(韩国)么?也不是。 金女真人定其名为长白山,传至今日,已有八百多年。据《金史·世纪》记载,长白山一词,最早是由金世宗完颜雍最早使用的。即为后世满语称果勒敏珊延阿林。
freudbird 3 years ago 7
驳长白山是韩民族发祥地,朝鲜《李朝肃宗实录》记载:长白山或白头山的发明权属于胡人(满人) 据朝鲜《李朝肃宗实录》记载:十七年十一月丙寅:长白山,胡人(满族人)或称白头山,以长白故也 。可见,白头山称谓的发明权属于中国,属于满族,朝韩是沿用了满族对长白山的称谓。
freudbird 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Remember illegal occupation of Tibet, East Turkestan & Genocide in Darfur. The rest of the world will never forget nor forgive endless disgusting crimes against humanity by PRC. Not only BBC and CNN but even AlJazeera TV strongly condemns disgusting HATE crimes against mankind by Chinese regime&its people in this century.PRC did sabotage dispatch of full UN Protection force in UN security council.PRC supplied AKs, grenades&other killing machines to African dictators for blood oil.
avanade 3 years ago
很好听的歌啊,我怎么以前没有听过呢
gaoxuef 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fuck koreans,southern korean pigs are the worst
greatwolfkingdom 3 years ago 10
The 3Miao tribes were established during the Warring States of China. Our Han brothers have acknowledge our existent for thousand of years. There was this one Miao girl, while taking her DNA blood test, she share a common root with the Korean while some Miao show great mixture of Southern genes and Northern genes. We Miao only recognized two groups; the Ancient Chinese and the Nanman as our closet relatives.
niamtxiv 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
agreed
benelliman 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What the... who said that?
Evidence?
benelliman 3 years ago
There are ethnic Manchus that still speak the language, just not in fuckin communist China...I'm both Mongol and Manchu adn Korean....We fled from the communists and most of us manchu speaking/ tibetan buddhists live in Canada, Korea, Japan, and Taiwan. The true Aisin Gioro Crown Prince lives in California.
dracokaiser 3 years ago
fuck you bitch! you are just a mongrel!so do not think you can represent the Manchus! don't misinform the world about Manchus in China!
who says we are forgotten? do you know we have many proud Manchus living happily in China?
fucking separatist wanna break China apart!
braveryofmanchu 3 years ago 4
no one does not know about Qing in China! BITCH!
we have many TV series and books regard it in China! FUCK YOU MOTHER!
braveryofmanchu 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@braveryofmanchu You don't even need to be suspicious,anything from korea related to history,origins and so on is simply fake,they are the most shameless liars in asia,there is reasons behind why koreans r hated so much by both China and Japan,China and Japan people hardly have any conflicts regarding ancient history but the koreans always have conflicts with Ch/JP when it comes to history,cultural and origin issues
GodsCommand 8 months ago
dracokaiser, if you are a real Manchu then tell me what your surname and hala is and speak to me in Manchu. The people that speak the Manchu language perfectly are confirmed that they are only in China.
ManjuSu 2 years ago
@dracokaiser It's a shame that the use of Manchu is declining. It's sad to see the Manchu identity gradually wither in mainland china.
redwhitedude 8 months ago
mongol fag. Give me a fucking break! Like I said, by ur preposterious logic, there is NO more black people in the US since they have adopted White culture and customs. Have they been identified as White-American? Get some fucking sense. U don't even fucking understand what Manchu means, yet dares to define what it is. BTW, your ethnic Mongolian brothers in China will get assimilated just matter of time. Are u going call them "chink" too? hahah... dumb ass
bigfattony007 3 years ago 2
Hey mongol fag. What the fuck are u talking about? Manchu is a name for an ethnic group. There are about 2 millions Chinese identified as ethnic Manchu in China. By ur fucking logic, then there are NO more black people in the US. Here are some of the famous Manchu Chinese: 關中(Vice President of the Nationalist party), 郎朗(world class pianist), and 郎平(US Women's national volleyball team coach). Get ur facts straight before opening ur shit mouth. -- From a proud Manchu Chinese!
bigfattony007 3 years ago 4
Sorry,sir.
Manchu dont like U Korean.
-----I am Manchu.
xiezhai 3 years ago
OK. that too bad.
klee4 3 years ago
Omg I am a manchu too! I have been searching for so long to learn more about my culture and language.... Thank you so much for posting this, this is the first time I have ever heard of my language being spoken (sing), would you have to happen to have anymore avaiable??
Cheers from a Manchu in Vancouver Canada! ^^
jimmydu444 3 years ago
I'm sorry to say that the comment that HUNDREDSSHA left is RIGHT.
"peaceintheworld463" always leaves such stupid comments every where.but I don't think that is because of the Japanese education system.
It's Just because of that He dislike Koreans too much at all,that can't be helped.
And I guess he seems to be kinda dropout.
KoshinoTami 3 years ago
BYW, I thought the Qing royalty adopted Buddhism when they allied with the Mongols, so what's with the Shamanist ritual?
milvipes 3 years ago
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
dracokaiser 4 years ago
No, We never be forgotten. my grand father is Manchu nation's vice president. we have to remember who we are.
sonofmanchu 3 years ago
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
dracokaiser 4 years ago
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
dracokaiser 4 years ago
Thank you thank you thank you! It's great to know that there are other Manchus out there! There are many of us manchus out in America, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan living in exile with the Tibetans! It's great to know that we are not forgotten!
dracokaiser 4 years ago
女真滿萬不可敵!
milvipes 4 years ago
Great! Our manchu nation will never be forgotten. We were the bravest. We were the best once!
sonofmanchu 3 years ago 3
where can I find the song?
KhonAltaic 4 years ago
太棒了,粉碎高丽棒子的野心
rieggenli 4 years ago 6
say hi to my munchu brothers.
bg24955 4 years ago
xeemlauj please keep your bloody mouth shut especially after you made anti CHINA COMMENTS ALL OVER YOUTUBE
no country pests
Chinese culture is none of A-HOLE PESTS BUSINESS
8WongYingJie8 4 years ago
btw, i like the song. ^^
xeemlauj 4 years ago
Is the song manchu tongue? Sounds altaic. It's ironic that the manchu once ruled china and tried to assimilate all ethnic groups. Today, majority of Manchu have been assimilated. Were they performing a Shamanistic ritual around the fire place?
xeemlauj 4 years ago