踢爆政府謊言，睇清暴力拆村事實（畫面修復版）

[kalok87]

條殘片竟然放咗上來?

唔好彎曲事實好嗎?

[Ocelot951]

2:02果段片

鏡頭以外工人有冇做過d咩我就唔知

就咁睇片就見唔到所謂ge推撞

同埋都希望阿豬先生明白,係工場咁樣玩真係好危險

學術性一問

如果工人果招叫浮腰

咁朱凱迪企圖使用但失敗左果招又叫咩名???

[RayTorresTang]

.......最衰係咩？係第一日播啲又cut過、又影唔到事件­正面(由側邊影）嘅片，周圍講自己無端端被工人襲擊，企圖誤導大­眾，歪曲事實！之後人地港鐵播條更清晰同角度更正嘅片，佢嘅醜行­無所循形，跟住仲要撐喎，仲好死去報案(話唔報又報），想跌落地­拿返渣沙，收皮啦！朱西迪！！咎由自取！假係自己掉架！

[RayTorresTang]

你地又搵柔道教練，又懶專業分析邊個攻擊邊個有咩用啫？又想轉移­人地視線覺得朱西迪好無辜？個問題係在於佢＂撩人者賤＂！人地政­府已收番塊地，比港鐵開始工程，嚴格嚟講係私人地方，朱西迪試圖­擅闖私人地方，土地擁有人或代表一方可使用合理武力駒趕擅進人士­，個工人真係只係用好合理嘅武力啫，無拳打腳踢吖！係朱西自己攞­嚟衰架喎........

[RayTorresTang]

.....

[blwhlee]

做得搞事者, 應該有被襲擊的覺悟吧

[chocoleg]

自己使用暴力發力推人,被人以力打力跌倒, 就話人哋使用暴力. 每個人都希望得到別人沒有的特權.

"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." George Orwell真係犀利!!

[edwincheese]

@chocoleg 不要未看內容就comment。朱凱迪不是無端端拉保安的手，影­片很清楚看見是保安先出手捉住巡­守隊員，朱凱迪見狀才介入幫巡­守隊員，請不要盲目斷章取義。即使­你不同意菜園村村民的訴求，­無論保安員是否有意，這樣的暴力也不­是文明社會所應有的。而且­，說暴力的話，政府未得村民同意下強行­拆村是更大的暴力

[chocoleg]

@edwincheese I dont really care if Mr CHU was 無端端 hold the arm of the security. When he started the physical contact with the security, then he should not complain of being physically contacted. Under your concept, Mr CHU and others protestants, without getting the tax payer's concent, they should not harrase the workers carrying out the duty. This is another kind of violence too.

[chocoleg]

@edwincheese Further, i did watch the video for a few times before making the comment. It was based on the fact shown by the video YOU provided. However, your feedback on my comment was based on your personal assumption. This shows why we are different.

[joe123lau2002]

@edwincheese

保安出手捉住巡守隊員?

家陣佢博炒呀!?

點睇都係一堆保安想拉開巡守隊員,

早D圍板早D收工,

但係條朱凱迪就走去"反拉開",

結果被保安一招KO!

[wa2000r]

@edwincheese　我最憎呢種人，行為卑鄙又要佔道德高地。

你係地盤範圍業主呀！賠償都收左，手續都做完地方就係政府的，唔­係你叫業主出來開個記者會呀笨！如果業權手續未完成，去法庭申請­禁制令呀笨。

"朱凱迪不是無端端拉保安的手"，咁黑社會都係咁，出手打人斬人­都好有理由，例如係你樣衰在先，例如係眼啤啤在先，例如係你眼甘­甘望我的女友在先。

收陀地都係咁，朱呆迪明明已經走入地盤範圍又冇平安卡同頭盔，阻­住人開工來提要求。

[sai0519]

@chocoleg 请去search朱凱迪+浮腰。入面有专业的解释，届时你就知道­到底是谁滥用暴力了。

[chocoleg]

@sai0519 I read this feature 12 hours ago on appledaily. I'm a martial art player myself but i'm not gonna argue the precise techiques here. The thing is, what if Mr CHU did not hold the arm of the security? How could he be thrown? Second, the Judo Caoch 黃柱光 is an anti-government protestant himself (you should remember him if you have good memory). Should we make our judgement just by looking at this ONE opinion then? Plus, this is a featuer written by appledaily.

[chocoleg]

@sai0519 Its good to see the passion and the positive intentions of the protestants. But there is just no absolute right or wrong in real world and you can never make everyone happy. We can discuss, debate and even argue base on objective, logical and least-bias evidences. Dont decide your stance by just looking at the superficial "facts" right in front of your eyes. Think deeper from different directions and make our city a better place.

[2kuen]

@chocoleg Think deeper from different directions and make our city a better place.

[chocoleg]

@2kuen Wot do u want to mean exactly?

[wingng112003]

食屎啦，上載嗰個！

[siuson628]

事實一再證明 朱生 企圖將職員推開 後職員出於自衛將朱生拉開 失衝落地

有片為證 誰是誰非 好明顯啦

人在做 天在看

[ff4148]

業餘水平嘅識業示威者,擺明冇料到呃錢,點出樣揾食呀!

[damyou76]

差人為一做錯就係,點解唔一早拉晒依斑刁民

[damyou76]

好明顯港鐵條片,睇住個刁民拉人在先,拉到人開始失平衡,人地當­然自然反應fing開佢啦!仲話要告人,正一刁民.

[fung81030007]

關條片叉事，朱先生等人太得閑，搞Ｄ野做！

[jaylee1127]

和平示威? 到最后又形成暴力事件，就算找出真相了又怎样，香港现在就是一直­停滞不前

[lululee3509]

momoka1206

點都唔及你咁膠啦

和平示威就唔會去衝擊人, 保安員盡忠職守, 咁都要俾人屈, 呢個係乜世界黎架

[Patrickwong1960]

多謝。看完呢段片，更清楚朱先生等人的使銅銀兼大聲的行為！

[Ocelot951]

我欣賞呢條片ge製作,十分認真及專案

不過唔好以為咁樣就可以歪曲事實

不如話後面班人衰唔飛身去接住呀豬先生好過啦

[edwincheese]

@Ocelot951 如果你認為本片有歪曲事實的地方請指出來，在這裡含沙射影有什麼­益處

[mstanley1020]

一吓KO佢

[man86man]

一方抗議, 一方執行合法行動, 繼而產生一些身體接觸, 實在無可囗非, 但問題是 --- 有人以不誠實的手法(刪去自己有問題的片段), 更公諸於世, 以圖屈鐵路公司職員打人, 此點實在過份.......

[jeffrey1228]

@man86man

你覺得係屈既，請你用例子說明，並詳細解說。

[jeffrey1228]

@jeffrey1228

而家係我問你先，請你回答！

[blushful]

@man86man

請問你所指o既「自己有問題片段」係指邊段？

巡守隊一開始發放o既片段同依段一樣，而港鐵o既所謂「真相」拍­到o既亦都係同一時段o既野。

唔好生安白造，呃o的冇留意開o既人！

[lululee3509]

個朱凱迪唔夠人大力, 又係度屈人, 正扒街

[momoka1206]

@lululee3509

睇左片先發言啦on9

[tk9124]

好明顯見到隻"豬"先生自己先拉人啦~~~~~~~~~

[theleetful]

@tk9124

片都未看便發言，同志，我們的五毛不是那麼容易掙的。

[edwincheese]

@tk9124 朱凱迪不是無端端拉保安的手，影片很清楚看見是保安先出手捉住巡­守隊員，朱凱迪見狀才介入幫巡守隊員，請不要盲目斷章取義。即使­你不同意菜園村村民的訴求，無論保安員是否有意，這樣的暴力也不­是文明社會所應有的。

[MrGaryfruit]

好明顯港鐵個工人力高馬大咁,先用武力,個村市根本一D還手之力­都無,D差佬又得個睇字,一D都唔幫下弱世市民,真係可悲.

[CTTtrain]

@MrGaryfruit 警察係都拉左朱凱迪先啦 私人範圍走入去阻人開工仲要拉住人地隻手 咁人地告你非體得唔得啊

[edwincheese]

@CTTtrain 那裡本來就是菜園村村民的私人範圍，現在是在未得村民同意下強行­清拆，還要惡人先告狀？

[wa2000r]

@edwincheese

地盤的業主賠償早已落袋，地方都平整成地盤，貨銀兩訖！

我買間屋要裝修，隔離的業主走過來話我裝修阻住佢，走入我間屋又­唔俾我開工，重想推我跌，你估我會唔會剩係順勢由佢跌落地呀，我­最少加兩腳啦，地盤工友只係走開都冇再出手啦。

0:22見到朱呆迪扳開地盤工的手然後推開人！呢班­­人只係陀­地，業主唔係佢地，但係就去阻人地開工去屈錢，不過因­為­有個­’保育’的招牌，唔係用黑幫的名，行為­就比黑幫更差，連黑幫都­知出手打人打唔贏，唔會報警屈人打自己。