Added: 4 years ago
From: mclyl
Views: 378,279
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (428)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • You probably can sing but you need to be urself. U definitely dont sound like MC at all dont fool urself this is not a nasty comment but merely the truth so im saying this with lots of love. If u love singing join a choir but dont go solo at least u would still be able to sing just not alone :)

  • she did not say she was trying to sound like her! she has an awesome voice! yo ugo girl!

  • please do send me the mp3 PLEASE...thanks in advance if you do. U have a nice voice though

  • please do send me the mp3 PLEASE...thanks in advance if you do.

  • yu dnt look likee her either .

  • You must really to improve your performance

  • Can you please give me the karaoke version of this song in mp3??

  • I don't want to sound like an evil person. But one of the comments were right. You don't need to sing exactly like Mariah Carey. She's professionally trained to sing like that. It's better if you sing sincerely as yourself and not as somebody else, I truelly believe that would sound so much better. Keep practising!!!

  • yikes...

  • merry christmas to all you tuber,s out there from holland. may god bless you

  • Congratulations Mariah! More number  1 albums and more number 1 singles for you!!!!!!

  • its okay buht u really need to stop tryin to sound like her buht ur high note sounds like hers buht everything else is okay tho i like ur voice

  • love it

  • I love it here in New Olreans !! You are doing great with your creative brains and talent. Please remember that no matter what you do many of life's losers will grab at you but you have to be strong enough to Pop A Cap on the L O S E R S and keep on walking !! I love you !

  • Please don't crush people dreams.

  • she probably isnt trying to sound like maraiah carey she is really good!!!!

  • no proper training yet i could say that you have the voice that will somehow enjoy by the listener...

  • You did pretty well, but I think you should work on strengthening your voice and training your voice more. Also, stick with a range that is comfortable- don't strain too much. With some more practice, you can become absolutely amazing, darling. :D

  • your falsetto's are pretty good but you need to work on the belts. but nice.

  • could u please tell me were u got dat karaoke xx

  • good on you for giving it a go!! You have a beautiful voice.

  • ummm u really need to work on it sorry... some notes were really flat sry... but everything else was ok and im not tht good either but i keep trying and i work hard on it soo just keep workin...

  • uhhmmmmmm.......just work on it hun.

  • hey!!! I think you did really well on here.. I hope you keep trying and keep getting better at it!!!.. I like your voice and I would love it to hear if you had any songs you wrote yourself!! don't get me wrong, it doesn't matter if you make it sound like mariah... just keep singing and enjoy music!!! =).. hugs and merry x-mas!!

  • EWL....

  • Шось не то :(

  • you did a good job

  • @lievelott i totally agree with you

  • I thought this was Mariah Carey singing because I clicked onto it and minimized it as I am at work... um sorry but I was wondering why Mariah sounded out of tune and overdoing it. It wasn't until I maximized the screen and saw that it wasn't in fact Mariah :( I still think you have a good voice but don't try to sound like Mariah because it comes off out of tune and over the top. Sorry! Still think your voice is nice, though.

  • urr gudd but just not mariah carey gud

  • no one can impersonate mariah

  • there's nothing wrong with doing a karaoke version of this song people...maybe she wanted to do that...she didn't say she was doing a cover, she said she was simply singing the song...geeesss....

  • Yeah that's true, but then she said in her information that she's not lip syncing which gives me the impression that she thinks we think she sounds like Mariah and is in fact lip syncing off her record. I still think she has a nice voice, though

  • u can sing but sing in ur own style, u'll get no where copying MC.

  • I am sorry...it is a good try but you are not close to her voice....there are several times your voice cracks.(puke) Take some voice lessons...just a couple and I bet you'll knock them dead.

  • @rustyfan022000 What???? she's great

  • wow you really sound like her...good job

  • your really good!

  • All of you guys are being very rude. I love your voice. I have tried to sing mariah and it doesnt work haha. I think you sound llike her but you need to add your own style. But your great! Keep striving at what you do!

  • where did you get the karaoke version of this??

  • well good x

  • 1.use ur own voice

    2.use ur own voice.

    3 stars

  • It seems your trying to sing like Mariah Carey and you can't !!! Thats a fact, but why don't you just sing with you own voice cause you can sing !?

  • you do not sound like mariah.. ur trying to hard and ur still way off

  • your a good singer

    but your trying too hard too

    sound like mariah

  • ur ok -D

  • gud but no one can sing like mariah!

  • Good job. :) BTW where did you get the accompaniment track for this song? :)

  • I love your voice ^_^ but be yourself...

  • hey this video is not that bad. you definitely need some voice training to get stronger and get a better ear. but you DO have a high range and you can feel the music. good job in that. it is a little hard to listen to because i'm very skeptical and strict on even myself in music. way to try tho! :) keep singing!

  • Look. I know that Mariah Carey's fans have told me that she is an inspiration to black people. But she should sing these carols properly, and not in the horrible way she does.

    Here is a young black girl singing properly:

    Kathleen Battle & Parkening Perform Ave Maria

    Note that singer Dionne Warrick, who was before Mariah Carey fans' time was in the audience too. I doubt Carey is capable of singing like this artist anyway. Carey may have a bigger "range", but this is all gimmick.

  • SHE.. CRAIZY? NO.. IS FINE :D

  • yea i'm sure u are good but make it ur own in a way its hard to copy someone else and do it right, it was.. umm bad to be brutily honest

  • i thought u were mariah carey for a secondl

  • bahaha me too! :S

  • why the heck do you need a microphone?! you are a good singer though 1:50 -2:05 was HORRIBLE

  • i know when i heard that i was klike "heh?"

  • you were good, not mariah carey good. honey you have something but work on it.

  • This is a beautiful song you picked! you have quite a talent. I must say that I am probably the one in many few guys that can immitate Mariah and hit very high notes..My personal favorite x-mas song by Mariah is: O Holy Night. but I love ALL songs by her, Maybe one day I'll get the courage and do a video like you!...thanks for sharing your talent with us. =)

  • wow u are amazing

  • that was good...im a huge mc fan so....but it was good, u held ur own

  • REALLY OFF in the beqinninq w| the "HMMMMMM" & wow. listeninq to the rest of it wass....... bleck.

  • Why not try to sing this properly like you can. Don't try to copy Mariah Carey. She is just trying to make money out of Christmas.

  • @swanningaround okay first your an idiot and second she is a wonderful singer and third your retarded.

  • CaliRose. I may be retarded, but I know that she is not the "greatest singer and greatest composer ever". I also know that she whines and groans into the microphone for money, which you people seem to want to give her.

  • @swanningaround ...mariah carey is one of the best vocalist ever...period.

  • bradley. Carey is typical of the singers coming out of American idol. She is not even a good vocalist technically.

  • you obviously don't know the first thing about technical ability...granted, her last several years have not been near the quality as her earlier years, but there has never been any doubt that mariah has an amazing set of vacal chords. her over use of her voice may have caused some damage over the years...but, in her earlier years she had the voice and the technical ability....you are confusing style with technical ability. not liking her style is fine, but the woman can sing!

  • Look bradley. Her technical ability isn't that good. Her voices labors and she has to put in various gimmicks. Her breath control is out of whack, and her voice is wobbling - and she is not even 40!!

    These black singers show how to sing technically:

    Kiri te Kanawa - Handel - Let the Bright Seraphim

    Again:

    Kathleen Battle & Parkening Perform Ave Maria

  • Comment removed

  • ummmmmm........ok?

  • goood;)

  • not bad.. . dont listen to this assholes on you tube they probably all want to be singers and are just pretending themselves that they are better than u.... u just need to work on the way u accent some of the notes u sing with vibrato.. and stuff.. just dont be a prostitute like mariah carey.. u look like your tryin to be just like her

  • HA Ha ha ha ..I had fun!

  • hey come on ppl! it wasnt bad and i bet shes wayy bttr then most of u!

  • Sorry but it wasn't that good.

  • yuck

  • she was very bad at first then i got amazed the blew me away her voice is so freaking strong ♥☻☺

  • Hmmmm.... not to be nasty but even from the humming at the begining I can tell its off. Nice effort but not quite there.

  • Not that bad... i think it sounded prettty nice! i got my song too.. check it out

  • the beginning sounded good! and she does not look like mariah!

  • my father produced this song..you did a good job..keep it up

  • did't like

  • i lv it

  • i think your good but maybe you should try and sing it in your own style n not like mariah cos its not for your voice you av a lovely voice tho.. god bless

  • good bu you need more voice:)

    and some times is..ARGH! in 1:50 to 2:00 i think..

    xoxoxoxoxoxoxox

  • ya i agree it scared me the first time!!!! :|

  • great job

  • that is not mariah i am sorry

  • its so nice.. i like it so much

  • Wtf.

  • Not that you sing badly, but i did not like this. Maybe with a little more practice, you can go far. I sing all the time + at every school concert and i have proffesional teacher in singing so i should know.

  • you can be a reat singer

  • Scusami ma questa versione fa pietà!prova a studiarl un po' di più

  • you sound like miriah carey are you lip singing because if you are that's totally cheating. BYE. still good job you sing better than my mother!

  • well if u listen carefully wen she singingz shes got an accent but mariah carey doesnt have an accent!

  • good but you need to work on your vibrato.....

  • she is NOT lip-synching and if she were se should have admitted it.......

  • wow your just as good as mimi you go gurl!

  • You look like Mariah did in the Butterfly era. Nice voice too!

  • you are so good and unique, dont try to copy mariah use your beautiful voice and be unique within your own right x

  • You look and sing like her! oMg ur fab!!

  • urheadhere no this is not mariah :D

  • no its someone else u can even tell by the voice

  • is dis mariah??

  • I am a sound man. My advice to you is to seek out a highly trained and well educated person (even someone that has a PHD in music). I bet they will gladly help you train your voice when they here you. You are really good. I can here a pro in there. Be careful though. Watch for the wolves. Sign nothing without profesional help with the details. Most important....Have fun and do the right thing at all times.

  • das ist eher heulen, als singen ... du solltest noch ein bisschen an deiner stimme arbeiten!

    ich glaube, wenn du das lied gut finden würdest, würde es sich auch besser anhören!

    denn wenn dir das lied nicht am herzen liegt, bekommst du auch die richtigen töne nicht hin !!!!! aber mutig es ins internet zu stellen !!! =) *daumen hoch*

  • ARE YOU SERIOUS???!!!

  • you are a great singer!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • You look like her. (:

  • lack of power... the voice is quite the same but it's a little out of tune sometimes. she seems mariah. but as i said before lack of power...

  • beautiful voice

  • amaizing voice....:O:O your really good....u are so good

  • Girl you really look like Mariah Carey! And got a beautiful voice like her too!!! I like it! I gave it 5 stars

  • Pretty good work! Worth watching!

  • i wish i had a voice like yours!

  • good job girl... keep doin what your doin :)

  • intonation? 1:32? 1:58?

  • This aint fake...she sing this song by herself...i listen old version of mariah..but different from what this girl sing right now. good job!

  • wow u have such a beautiful voice

  • i actually think its pretty good,u just cant try and copy mariah so much bc her way of singing is for her amazing voice...sing it in ur own way

  • I have to agree you were lip singing. Why, this version of song is older because I have it on tape & an old record that my father had in his collection. Oh yeah it shouldn't matter who sings the song unless it sucks or the singer over does it a bit like so many have done

  • read it !!!!! dw it says Mariah Carey thats a singer and she clams she is her and she's not

  • Very nice, I don't know why people don't believe it when folks can actually sing...anyway, good job!!!!

  • fake

  • not that bad x

  • u were totally lipsyncing.

  • Nice voice... but nothing compared to Mariah's tone! Don't bring Mariah in this... Mariah beats anyone! But you go girl! SING IT! :-)

  • actually christina agulera is the best because she sings way better that pink, mariah, and Kelly Clarkson combined. She just has pure talent you try to sing exactly like her and I will probably not be that enthusiastic about the difference.

  • Excuse me... check that. Mariah Carey is the number one selling female recording artist... I never mentioned Christina Aguillera in any of this... so where did you pull that from? Mariah Carey is amazing! Thanks!

  • ok if you think mariah carey fakes it you got something else coming to you! Because your wrong!! LOL Check that!! If she "faked" it she wouldnt be making the money she makes!! And doing the things she does!!

  • cool

  • omg i was speechless your the reason people want to be christian

  • tried to hard to be like mariah,

    and tried to hard period.

    specially the heavenly part.

    needs improvement, i agree with taybeezy3252 and word2you.

  • WOW u kinda loook like her!

  • You are beautiful and your voice is pretty, not to mention that you have great taste in singers! Don't let anyone take that away and sing on sister!!!!

  • a little bit work :D and dont try to be 2 much like mariah,,,work on your own voise

  • your ook i guess check out mynee [:

  • work on it a little bit

  • FINALLY, someone who sees the performance for what it is. Everyone just think it's good because she has the same TONE as Mariah and looks like her.

  • She doesn't have the same tone as mariah... her voice lacks a deeper layer to it that Mariah's has. Don't go comparing tones like that yo... This girl has a beautiful voice but doesn't have mariah's tone at all

  • alright i guess

  • Im speechless you gotta event a new word for this video becsuse fantstic ur waaaaaaaaay better than fatastic! My videos make my voice sound awful and i sing better than it shows urs is so clear and everything i loved it!

  • not very nice !! your voice is not bad, but not worked enough... to be continued

  • Yeah cuz obviously YOU could do better. -.-

    i luv it :]

  • i KiNDA AGREE

  • Wow....your singing is incredible....I love your voice....keep living outloud....I got some songs for you.....

  • you're okay. but i dont think you'll get bigger than just a youtube star. keep it up

  • ur amazing how do u make good video's like this???? the vids i make r crap my mouth dont match my words n that n ect

  • ach du scheiße xD

  • you r awesome

  • Awesome Singing On This Song, 5 Stars For Miss Lydia On This Video.

  • was fürn ......

  • coolllll!!!!!!!!!!

  • kirchenchor...hahahahahahaha

  • I think you are the next big thing darling! You really hit those top notes with perfection.... A true star!!

  • Good job Lydia!!!

  • süper.. nice voice.

  • your voice sounds really close to Mariah's voice man so lucky!

  • at least better than Britney... xD

  • haha

  • hey hunn...

    once again beautifulll....

    <33 nina

  • hey hey hey!

    its meee! n thanx for sendin me all those 15 vids ;)!

    they're great!

  • great singing.bye

    justin

  • better than the original. congratulations.

  • watch?v=shTC2mT59Go

    YOUTUBE'S ULTIMATE SUPERSTAR 2008

    OPEN AUDITIONS

  • you sing better in spanish

  • I'd hit that

  • La reléve n'est pas encore tout a fait assurée mais mais...