Added: 4 years ago
From: gabyvalla
Views: 672,300
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,192)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Tasia was trying not to outshine kelly but cudnt hlp it

  • This is beautiful by the both of them:) awesome

  • Holy Jesus, that was incredible, two powerful voices singing together, they made me cry, AMAZING!!!

  • holy shit never realized kelly was THIS good

  • They are totally different artist. and i love both of them

  • Go head Kelly

  • This reminded me of the Aretha vs Celine at Diva night... Kelly just proved that a white girl can bring southern soul into the mix as well!

  • twenty three youtube atheists need to have their ears checked.

  • I know why Tasia held back it was not that kinda party cuz you know if they ushered the spirit in the shoes would've been off and Tasia would been shoutin up a storm up in there earrrings dropping on the floor everything.

  • kelly love mariah carey she's her idol!!! and this is great singing a mariah version song... i love these two girls,,,

  • i get goose bumps listening to this collaboration

  • Beautiful!

  • its britney bitch

  • Awesomenessitical!

  • i love ittt!!

  • Y is she slaping her ARM

  • Why do I feel like they are trying to emulate Queen Mariah Carey's version?? Both versions sound very similar.

  • CLEARLY they were trying to emulate Mariah Carey's version and unfortunately, they failed miserably especially toward the end. Mariah knows what real gospel singing is. She got down and caught the Spirit in her version WITHOUT having to scream like a wild man.

  • HAHAHAHLOLOL....anyone else notice 'tasia trying to get a step in at 3:48?

    Just as country as she can be!!

  • Amen.

  • they sanging!!!!

  • Wonderful!

  • Kelly is the only other white singer who can SANG like that other than Christina Aguilera! Fantasia was def. holding back, but still amazing as usual!

  • This is my fist time hearing this. Wow! Both gals did an excellent job. Thank

    God that baby Jesus is a now the Savior of the Universe! To God be the Glory!

  • I can't stop watching 3:02 .. It's so unbelievable! :'D

  • I happened upon this video. I ABSOLUTELY LOVED IT! Kelly and Fantasia....my, my, my, my! Fabulous.....they complimented each other. I was in tears......what a fantastic collaboration. Let me listen again! I love the way Kelly got the crowded started and then introduced my girl Fantasia. Excellent, Excellent, Excellent!

  • i could have just had somebody show a little something rather then just screaming and off beat clappin then to have a praise break at then end and no one praising is just crazy. but hey if God was pleased then thats all that matters

  • Both are phenomenal belters, I can't believe their voices remain so strong with all the songs they sing being full force belted out. I sing and was a singer from age 15 to well, retired now. I know how hard it is on their voices.  God Bless them that the record companies don't burn them out!!!

  • Fantasia looked beautiful.

  • What was this on? I know Fantasia came out of the church but I didn't know about K.C. Kelly knows who Jesus is too. Listen to her call him the Lamb of God...I'll add her to my prayer list that God will draw them closer to Him and that they will sell out to Him and operate in His perfect will for thier lives.

  • @shantrellhopson This was from an American Idol Christmas special that came on during the holiday season the year that Fantasia won. It higlighted the Idol winners, Kelly, Ruben, and Fantasia. it was an hour special i believe.

  • yeah, u can tell fantasia def. was holdin back lol.. she was clapping most of the time

  • it'd have been better if either of one went alone and sung it in a solo version

  • Lol..the problem was, Kelly was singing the song the same way Mariah did on her version from 94. Meanwhile she was trying to actually sing along with Fantasia who was sort of doing her own thing. So it was kind of...interesting.

  • 1. Fantasia really held back on this big time. But still awesome nonetheless.

    2. For a white girl, Kelly did more than AMAZING on a Gospel song lol.

  • IF EVEN YOU DIDN'T BELIEVE IN GOD BEFORE...I BET YOU ALL DO NOW! WOW!

  • BOTH OF THESE WOMEN ARE AWESOME SINGERS, BUT FANTASIA HELD BACK JUST A LITTLE BIT WHE N SHE WAS SINGING. yOU KNOW SHE HELD BACK CUZ SHE DIDNT KICK HER SHOES OFF. LOL

  • @1BadBamaBelle LOL prob juss cuz she wasnt alone ! =D

  • BOTH OF THESE WOMEN ARE AWESOME SINGERS, BUT FANTASIA HELD BACK JUST A LITTLE BIT WHE N SHE WAS SINGING.

  • I can't believe this song is 4 minutes... rofl My ears... I love Kelly but man...

  • i love this song

  • fantasia is still a wonderful person of god.she is blessed sing that song

  • kelly is amazing

  • i have never seen sumbody rip asong EQUALLY widd fanny da way kelly did. dey sounded GREAT together!! Props go to Kelly cuz most ppl wld bacc dwn to a song WITH fantasia bc she always loses dem wen she goes off n her own world")

  • For me Kelly was trying WAY too hard to sound like Mariah Carey, every riff, run, and melismatic phrases Mariah did on her version of JWAWC Kelly tried 2 imitate it. Key word here is imitate, she didnt do that great of a job really, those big notes are out of Kelly's confort register and its obvious that shes trying WAY too hard. There's only one Mariah Carey

  • @dafuture93 you're an idiot who knows nothing about vocals so how bout u don't comment on stuff u dont know shit about.... just cuz ur jealous kelly can sing AMAZING (not saying she is better than mariah btw) u make up stupid crap to say bout her.... u say she is pushing her vocals too hard? ur an idiot she can hit a C6 easy and in this performance she hits G5s (which not many female singers can do with such ease) so just go watch a mariah video and shutup

  • @21ctm21 lol stfu and learn how to read other people's opinion w/o getting mad at them for it. smh grow up

  • fantasia god give us that gift continue to do his work u give chills when i listen to u u are the next mahildia jackson love u

  • my my my God, I couldnt help myself but get my praise on. thank you Jesus for being for us!!!!. I went in at at the praise break @3:12...my my my...heteshalalalalalalabababa­ha!!!! shondo!!! he is worthy!!! hey hey hey!!!!! i wsh fantasia would cut a step

  • BOTH OF THIS YOUNG LADY WAS BROUGHT UP IN THE CHURCH... THEY MUST TOTALLY SURRENDER TO GOD . THEY KNOW WHAT CAN DO FOR THEM

  • I thought both of the were great! I felt the presence of the Lord while they were singing! Amen to the King!

  • Why are yall comparing? They are two different singers, from two different Genres. Kelly obviously has a bigger rangier voice. Fantasia has a more soulful gospel voice. There was no holding back from either one of them in this performance. They were both raised in the church, and you can tell from this performance..Good job to both of them.

  • I think they equally ripped this song, I didn t know Kelly could sing like that !!!

  • @brown14suga they did both rip! Kelly showed she can hold her own wit Tasia i like that!

  • SMH @ 20 Dislikes 

  • Wonderful rendition, crowd stomping, love it.

  • Anyone know when this was filmed or what the project was?

  • Kelly probably put all the black in her that she can find to sing that song the way she did with Fantasia...lol

  • Great Performance from Both Fantasia and Kelly!!! Looks like they were both having fun and really respected each other as Professionals. Thank you for posting gabyvalla.

  • attention if your in arkansas on july 9 dont miss fantasia live in concert at the robinson center music hall in Little Rock,AR dont miss its a must see show

  • This song just sent me in!!!! PRAISE!!

  • You can tell fantasia was younger. She is much stronger now. She is the best Idol just as kelly clarkson is. The both have their own right.

  • You can tell fantasia was younger. She is much stronger now. She is the best Idol just as kelly clarkson is. The both have their own right.

  • WOW!!! Whitney and Mariah got nuthing on these 2.. amazing

  • Well, lets just have church right now!

  • It dosent matter who song the song beyyer its about whos giving god the most praise!

  • @maulroderick1201 by the sound of it, they were both puttin their all in it. lol

  • totally!

    

  • I loved these people so much they sing so go good. X

  • TASHIA took it back to CHURCH her ROOTS!

  • Fantasias high notes are nothing but screams, kelly did better.

  • @josued09 Of course U would say that, because you have No Clue what the Anointing of GOD is!

  • all i can say is two wonderfull talented ladies together is jus epic

  • no doubt fantasias better but kelly was fine as hell here

  • I think she allowed the white girl her space because we all know that Fantasia could knock her out with one blow of the voice man! Fantasia came on with a spirit and Kelly just sang from i dunno where but i felt the spirit when Fantasia Sings !! Fuh Real !!

  • Kelly's tryna out sing Fantasia even though well all know who's killin this! Fantasia was born for gospel music

  • Ya we all kno fantasia can't hit a G5 like that as well...... No need to Kelly just cuz ur a fan of fantasia.... Or the other way around

  • they both sing in church...

  • kelly clarkson did her thang.. most definatley but we all know fantasia could have and should have opened up on her ass wit this song..lmao

  • Anything sang fo th biq man uhp stairs ihs beautiful '! LOVED IHT !!!

  • Kelly sings in a baptist church. This is real easy for her.

  • Kelly Clarkson get's mad respect from the Black Community!! lol!

  • Glory to Two find ladies of Color...oops Kelly I just want u to know u r a true women of color...Smoke neck bones and fried chicken to u....and Fantasia...endless love Cinnamon...NJ

  • Kelly did good but she had to sing harder than usual to keep up w/Fantasia on this song, and Fantasia didn't even give 100 on it... Do understand both ladies are very good singers, Kelly has a voice that rocked idol its first season but if both her and Fantasia were on the first season together we would be like, "Kelly who?" lol... but on the real, if u look at some of Fanatasia's other gospel performances she really did hold back and still did a good job, JUST LIKE KELLY DID...

  • what is all this 'fantasia was holding back' nonsense - no Kelly's just far better.

  • Kelly Clarkson big respect.

  • They both did the dam thang but Fantasia was holding back, i guess so she wouldn't sing over kelly. Good job ladies!!!

  • why don't they have this kind of performance like this in IDOL anynmore

  • I love Fantaisia, but Kelly slayed this song!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Fantasia is so hard to listen to, having a " diff" voice doesn't always mean its good, such is the case w fantasia, she's horrible.

  • everybody please keep requesting fantasia new single "collard greens and cornbread" on your local radio station and buy it on itunes so lets do it

  • kelly held her on againist the beast fantasia!!!!!!!

  • @fjones90 um, she did better. belted a higher and clearer note than fantasia at the end. fantasia could barely keep up

  • @cyke12 they both performed their own way of performing, Fantasia loves to squall and so she did. they both did their thing and a loved them both in this.

  • I think Fantasia was holding back because she didn't want to sort "disrespect" THE original American Idol who made hit records by the time Tasia won. Go check out her other gospel performances. You're bound to be blown away.

  • KELLY can and will sing her ass off on every song you give her. And she is a church singer, country singer, pop singer, rock singer, opera singer "Ave Maria", And ra p isn't sing'n. This would be a million times PROVEN fact. : )

  • Kelly Clarkson is not a church singer ! She still did great :D.

  • Kelly's comfort zone is 1000 miles wide and Fantasia is in her element love them both

  • They Sang it the same way Mariah Carey does on her first christmas album. Imatation is the greatest form of flattery. Nice work ladies

  • How cn yall Say That kelly Didd better Fantasia. Fantasia Clearly did better. (:

  • i think they both did a great job

  • PEOPLE, LET'S NOT MISS OUT ON THE TRUE MESSAGE OF THE SONG WHILE FOCUSING ON WHAT THE LADIES ARE WEARING. AFTER ALL,THEY DID ALLOW GOD TO USE THEM TO MINISTER TO US IN SONG... CAN'T WE BE MORE APPRECIATIVE OF THAT ?

  • Please don't talk about peoples clothes and say you represent God...I don't believe that is what God is all about....

  • God is holy but that dress isn't. Come back to The Lord Fantasia.

  • @404momii who are you to judge stop focusing on them and see them the way God see them smh

  • You might even say, Kelly beat fantasia at her own game here...

  • Ughhh, she screams wayyyyy too much..

  • attention fantasia fans please request hard for her song "im doin me" on your local radio station cause its trying to move back up on the charts and buy her new album "back to me" this is her best album yet

  • idk how yaw can say KELLY did better than FANTASIA??? Turn your speakers up PLEASE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • 2 best diva from Idol!

  • Kelly just B*tchslaps Fantasia !

  • Even though Fantasia is a way better singer...Kelly out did her in this one..Gotta give it up for Kelly!

  • Kelly out sang Fantasia's ass on this song Big Time!!!!

  • @tubebitch12 you have lost it!

  • @tubebitch12 No cursing. It's a gospel song lol.

  • @ExplorerPersonHI Exactly!!!  Good point, love!

    Bless!!!

    - J

  • @tubebitch12 i disagree lol

  • @tubebitch12 I really would like to make this statement. I really don't think there should be cursing. Definitely when we are discussing a gospel song. But hey I guess that would just be giving respect to the Almighty Lord. IJS! Watch what you are saying when referring to a church song.

  • @tubebitch12 u may think thats the case but kelly was just singing while fantasia was giving God the praise he deserves

  • @tubebitch12 fantasia is a much better singer then kelly will ever be

  • @tubebitch12 hahaha you wish!

  • @tubebitch12 I hope u know fantasia held back just watch her vids of her tearing up gospel song, she can sing circles around kelly anyday.

  • @blackstersherron Kelly can sing circles around fantasia every day and anywhere

  • @MaryseWilsonAksana No way kelly yells both good singer but sorry she cant mess with fantasia.

  • @blackstersherron Don't you mean Fantasia screams 

  • @MaryseWilsonAksana its called growl. its a style in gospel music. technically saying

  • @tubebitch12 Are you serious ,Kelly sounds like she doesn't even belong.

  • glory hal leh lujah than kyou Lord>Fantasia you are a powerful woman of God and anointed too God bless you

  • Fantasia is truly annointed

  • watch?v=YJ2sJH6HLLk

  • when did Kelly started singin chirstian songz......?? didn't get d memo

  • Omg! Fantasia is a sweet heart and I like her but gurl!!! She was bad in this! Kelly was amazing as usual! Like how they sang the Mariah Carey version! of course!! Lol

  • they both from the ministry so

  • Fantasia held back big time on this song lol

  • we song that at church today, but we didnt tear it down like this.

  • im just wondering where I was when THIS went down WOW

  • back when they were allowed to say Jesus on American Idol >_>

  • I feel like they both are kinda screaming. It would of been really cool if they would have did a completely different arrangement than the mariah version. They are both great artists though!

  • I think Kelly rocked and was not keeping up with Fantasia..

  • DAYMN!! It went from an American Idol Christmas to a baptist church in .03 seconds LOL

    Their voices were MADE for this kind of singing. They were on FIRE!! I'm not even religious and I felt the lord in this youtube video. LMAO!

    Side Note: I do think it's funny how Kelly had a "blacker" ass than Fantasia. She has a great figure!!....Not in a gay way...Just sayin' if I were a guy and things were different....O_O

  • Stealing my culture BBOY?

  • the 18 people must of been through some things if they didnt feel that..i went SHOUTIN at 3:13!!!!!!!!! thank ya JESUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • lol...why was Kelly screaming at the end? To overpower Fantasia's strong voice? Look at her face...struggling. Ugh...do ur own thng and be confident in that.

  • @soccerbadmint its called belting the only one screaming here was fantasia hahaha

  • @KellyFan4Lyfe08 nah...tht was screaming on kelly's account.

  • @soccerbadmint lol not at all,that was tasia yellin,bout to pass out look how out of breath she is and kelly just breezed through it

  • I done got the spirit!

  • @ILuvMusic4real @2:53 fantasia was doing the , "pentecost" cool off wave hahahahahahaha you better sing kelly!!!!!!!!! praise him..!!!!! glory to the NEW BORN KING!!!!!!!

  • fantasia is really annoying, she sounds like she has a sore throat.

  • @2:31 Tasia was about to take off but out of respect for Kelly she didn't. pay close attention Kelly gave her that (please don't) look

  • @saushababetta Take off? Take off and do what?

  • @seanievortex don't do that! we both know if Tasia start shouting Kelly would be lost.

  • @saushababetta "Start shouting"? In the middle of the performance? She was shouting throughout the whole performance and was still overpowered by Kelly! No, YOU don't do that.

  • @seanievortex Kelly followed her from the time she took the stage until the end. They are different types of singers, Kelly is pop and Tasia is soul. I just happen to love soul singers. Fantasia could have easily taken over that song. Now, I am in no way saying that Kelly can not sing. I just think she was out of her element.

  • @saushababetta agree 100%. I believe that Fantasia was a little subdued and did not want to take over the song because that was not what it was about, but she easily could have. Fantasia is an attention grabber, not on purpose, but she just has that incredible stage presence. She could have taken that stage over, but as I said, that was not what she wanted to do. They were singing about Jesus. It should not be a competition, and it wasnt. Kelly did a very good job though.

  • @seanievortex shouting meaning, "dancin" its a shout with your feet and the nusic starts going fast...its done alot in black churches

  • @saunei its done in so many churches! amen! God is always looking for people to rejoice his name with out shame!

  • 1:44 kelly looks over like "ok, what you got bitch"

  • I didnt think any if them were overdoing it, they performed it like they were supposed too. This was filled with Jesus!!!! They both can sing!! Gave mariah some justice to what she did with tha song.

  • GET IT KELLY! lol I forgot she got some soul in her lol

  • Oh they rocked this fosho!!! Love both of their voices... Wait a minute yall betta praise HIM!!!

  • please vote for her new single "im doin me" on vh1 top 20 countdown to vote go to (vh1.com:vspot top 20 countdown) so please vote hard so we can get her on the countdown thanks and remember you can vote as many times as you wish

  • ... Merry Christmas!

  • I think it is really unimportant if they "sang each other out". Guys, please, this is a beautiful duet and both of them are really really fantastic. And they have fun!

    Holy fucking Jesus, this was so fucking bloody great! I have never heard such a awesome duet like this one. Thank you very much for uploading! Soul pure.

  • OH man... they rocked it!! Merry Christmas to all!!

  • It is crazy how much more powerful Kelly's voice is than Fantasia!! Particularly from 2:49-3:07. She left Fantasia in the dust!!  It's almost like Fantasia's voice got tired!! Soulful!

  • If y'all knew them at all, you would know that Kelly and Fantasia both don't take stuff too seriously. They both like to have fun. Which is what is exactly shown here. Fun. They're both fantastic singers, and I want more Fantasia and Kelly duets :]

  • OH Kelly is sooo cuute! ma Gurl really tried hard

  • What pretentious women! This SOUNDS EXACTLY LIKE THE MARIAH CAREY version from the MERRY CHRISTMAS CD from 1994!!! even fantasia seems to be copying that version, i thought fantasia would add her spin...but kelly is copying every exact note!! EVERY RUN!! god woman get ur own version going??

  • @Retrodaydream VERY TRUE... I always thought Kelly Clarkson has a hint of Mariah in her... they did a great job on the song...

  • @Retrodaydream mariah DON'T have a version she sings som1 elses version.

  • good job

  • The two best winners of that now farcical show!!! These two can sing their socks off-utterly fantastic!!

  • Love this....Kelly can sang

  • whoa!! Kelly can bring it!!

  • love that praise break at the end. thank ya' JESUS.

  • this was so much fun to watch! they did great together!

  • everybody please vote for her new hot video "im doin' me" on 106&park countdown so text fan to 79922 or go to 106&park website and vote there so we can help her on the countdown

  • THEY WENT IN FOR JESUS!!! KELLY BROUGHT IT CUZ FANTASIA WAS ALREADY THERE LOL