No. Japan killed and tortured 30 million people. The West killed and tortured maybe 1 million at the most. Japan much worse. Learn history. Japan must awake and accept guilt like we have.
The number is much lower. The japanese example was a concentrated extermination event happening during 16 years in east and southeast asia. The japanese killed for the sake of killing, raping beheading gasing, dismembering just because they liked it. There was no reason. Europeans just shot them, and mostly when there was a direct threat. The Europeans were bad, but the japanese were much worse. Maybe they censor the history books in japan.
you said what japanese killed for the sake of killing, raping beheading gasing,didnt you?
Which book did you read?Im afraid you've been had by propaganda for Chinese Nationalist Party ,and Western Journalist get the many money from agent of chinese Nationalist party at theNanjing ,Please awake,
There is no point in talking to you.Your mind is closed and living in denial. If that is what you really want to beleive then there is nothing I can do.
Japan MUST accept it's own past evil, like the West actually have and keep debating over. I hear no such debate in japan, only excuses, it is most unfortunate, and can only alienate your nabours. Internal debate is healthy, get on with it.
"Liberation" doesn't include mass murder of hundred of thousands people.But I understand that Japan did remove western dominion of east Asia, that is true. But they were not nice to the locals, so liberation isn't the right word. When Japan lost the war however, the chance of liberation from the west (and japan) was now finaly possible.Had Japan won, the the people would have remained slaves.Japan had an indirect effect on the liberation of east Asia,but that was not their intent
Please Read more of correct histrical book.....Sorry,Your knowledge is not worth talking about.Perhaps,Are you Chainese??so I can understand about your level of knowledge.
Let me explain this to you mister, you are WRONG,the attrocities commited by the japanese empire is a FACT.I dont deny the attrocities commited by the wetsern world, the western world has done MANY horrible things.Here in the west, we admit this, and talk about it all the time, but in Japan you deny it. You dont have self insight like us. This is horrible, and can only alienate you from your nabours.In Europe we would never have accepted Germany doing this.
For example. If you check out the article Nanking massacre on wikipedia. You will se that japanese wkipedia's article have no pictures and try to avoid going into detail, As well as blaming the Chinese or calling it propaganda! and minimizing the damage. They also say the pictures are false ! While ALL the other languages have pictures!! And speak of it directly and state it's truthfullness. Coincidence? No, this is a sign of all the things I have mentioned.
If you on the other hand check out an article about Americans killing the Indians, the British enslaving Africa, the Holocaust, the Vietnam war or any other event by the western world, you will see many pictures and detail. So get a little more real man.
Japan has been protected by USA all this time against it's communist nabours. Because of this, you have been living in a bubble. Germany was invaded by it's afflicted enemies and was forced admitt it's gruesome past. Now, they teach the children of this in school. Because of this, Germany is once again a trusted member of the European Union. But China and Asia never got the same justice, it was the USA who occupied, but they were not the ones who suffered the most.
USA shielded you from Korea and China. They were lenient and didnt bother seeking out all the war criminals.You therefore have never been forced to face your own past like Germany, and have been living in a state of cold indifference.
Comment removed
prodigalmind777 1 month ago
Comment removed
prodigalmind777 1 month ago
yauuna 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@tenga3wa10
They had been defeated and pushed back.
askjiir 3 months ago
昔の日本人は本当に立派だった。
今の現代人にとっては単なる歴史上での存在でしかないのか?
彼らのおかげで日本の文化は世界に誇り、美しいはずだろう。
そしてこの歴史が存在しなかったら、我々は平和を学ぶことはできなかったはず。
MegaYAHAGI 3 months ago
軍服見るとたぶん職業軍人だよね。
tawuz 3 months ago
小樽・・俺の地元だ!
sakuranbou1 4 months ago
殺されないために殺す、というのが免罪符にならない時代になってほしいね。
sheepsato 6 months ago 4
いやぁ・・戦前にカラー映画があったんだなあ。進軍の歌が使われていたんですねぇ
ramuzusu 6 months ago
これから戦争あるのかなぁ・・・
spongebob0801 7 months ago
国家総動員法が社会主義政策の思索だなんておもいもしないよねえ。大政翼賛一党独裁の挙国一致内閣って・・・レーニンスターリン体制じゃないか。これを国家社会主義という、ナチス体制とスターリン体制とニューディール体制・・・一緒だ。 世界同時社会主義の今、日本は、もうすぐ、そうなる。民主はダメ自民がダメだから・・・ 大政翼賛・・国難回避復興翼賛体制、挙国一致内閣によって復興優先原子力拡大原子爆弾開発軍備増強・・・。 一番に喜ぶのが、日本を目の仇にしてきたアメリカ合衆国軍産複合体。だって道州制で戸籍を解体撤廃て民事そして警察組織自衛他組織と、アメリカ合衆国併合準備がまもなく始まるからだ・・・・道州制国民皆兵、地方独立中央から州が独立すれば、日本政府は国家社会主義体制にして、強権を持って支配できるアメリカの一声で・・・オセロのように一夜で移行するとおもう。日本人が日本を喜んで事部の手で、解体してアメリカの懐に入っていく。アメリカの意にかなう国家主義体制の近未来、日本は万歳を叫びながら消滅する。愚かなこに見えるだろうが、私の後継のものがすることだ。 この国難できずかされたな。
pinpono843 8 months ago
戦前の日本の方が美しいな。涙がでる。
mrcrocent 8 months ago
@thinkgreen0 昭和是杀人狂魔!
xianyu3211 10 months ago
Comment removed
askjiir 10 months ago
この時代のお年寄りは貫禄あるなぁ…
江戸末期~昭和初期の激動の時代を生きてきたからかな
unabooon 1 year ago
貴重な映像には違いないのだが、なんか色々と印象操作が入ってる。ナレーションと音楽変えてもらいたいかも。
gyokusai999 1 year ago 2
女性への戦争動因への組み込み強要ですか・・・
同じような理由でアメリカでは女性が不足した労働力を補うための活発な社会進出
イギリスではバトルオブブリテンで積極的に女性が戦時体制に協力と紹介
いろいろ見てると、正直なにをいいいたいのかNHKさんはわかりませんね
hakucyanKK 1 year ago 3
生きて帰ってくるのは恥なのに、女性は彼らの無事を祈って千人針???何とわかりにくい時代だろう・・!!!
maegamikirisugi 1 year ago 4
0:33辺りに映るおじいさんは
絶対江戸時代の生まれだろうな
1919koharu2 1 year ago 2
@1919koharu2 立派な顎鬚ですよね。
meola2001 1 year ago
@meola2001 確かに
1919koharu2 1 year ago 2
01 of 15からここまで見て、
昭和10年頃までは、日本には平和な姿があったのに、
ちょっとした他国とのすれ違い、そして、
昭和12年頃の日中摩擦からガラガラとその姿は変わり、
昭和14年には、日本はすっかり軍国社会になっていた。
一度、戦争の波に乗らされると、
国家の変わり身の早さというものは、
恐ろしいものがあるなと思いました。
massu68anex 1 year ago 10
日本が、世界大戦で戦ったのは、ソ連、中国、アメリカを含め、共産主義国でした。
民主主義を守る為に 国の為に、戦った。そのご先祖さまのお陰で、今日の日本の平和があります。NHKは、そのように報道すべきです。 報道捏造ですね
obamalier 1 year ago
@obamalier アメリカが共産主義だって? 中国も蒋介石の時代だから、バリバリの反共だぜ。 東南アジアに共産主義国はなかった。 ちょっとは、勉強してからコメントせよ。 こういうのをデマゴーグという。
TheMidnightgambler 1 year ago
@TheMidnightgambler F.ルーズベルト大統領の時代、多くのコミュンツエル(共産主義者)が、何百人と入って、働いていました。これは、すでに極秘文書が公開されていてアメリカ国内では、テレビでも公開されました。お宅さんが 知らないだけです
obamalier 1 year ago 3
だが、日本は稀なんだ。国際的に見ればほとんど他国より侵略され占領されているが、日本は沖縄と元寇だけなんだ。国防意識がないのは当たり前なんだ。でもこの意識なくして日本はないと思う。ちなみにアメリカも日本同様である。
LdeathLdeathLdeath 1 year ago 4
何をもって「個人の思考と主張する能力を奪う」と言っているのか。イメージだけで語るな。
nokiwmt 1 year ago 6
今の北朝鮮みたいだ・・・
個人の思考と主張する能力を奪うと人が人らしからぬ集団になるのか
米国が主張する「自由」ってのはその事なのかのう。
cyberterro 2 years ago
出征兵士とそのご家族の気持ちに思いを馳せると非常に身につまされます。
可愛い妻や子供を残して、誰も死にたくない筈。しかし誰かが我が国を守らなくてはならない。
権利意識ばかりの昨今にあって、公共の福利を慮る日本人はどれ程いるであろう。
このような反戦番組だけでは、国の安全は保てないことも学びたいものです。
pump88berry 2 years ago 27
@pump88berry
Japan did wrong.
askjiir 10 months ago
@askjiir
no.
In the first place,,,,
Anglo-Saxson did wrong.
and Next, European Colonialism did wrong.
Japan just defend asia country against invader from Europe.
Please learn history.
pump88berry 10 months ago 4
@pump88berry
No. Japan killed and tortured 30 million people. The West killed and tortured maybe 1 million at the most. Japan much worse. Learn history. Japan must awake and accept guilt like we have.
askjiir 10 months ago
@askjiir
Can you read historical book?European killed more who african e asian,, since colonical period 15C,Learn correct history.First,open the book.
pump88berry 10 months ago 2
@pump88berry
The number is much lower. The japanese example was a concentrated extermination event happening during 16 years in east and southeast asia. The japanese killed for the sake of killing, raping beheading gasing, dismembering just because they liked it. There was no reason. Europeans just shot them, and mostly when there was a direct threat. The Europeans were bad, but the japanese were much worse. Maybe they censor the history books in japan.
askjiir 10 months ago
@askjiir
you said what japanese killed for the sake of killing, raping beheading gasing,didnt you?
Which book did you read?Im afraid you've been had by propaganda for Chinese Nationalist Party ,and Western Journalist get the many money from agent of chinese Nationalist party at theNanjing ,Please awake,
pump88berry 10 months ago 2
@pump88berry
There is no point in talking to you.Your mind is closed and living in denial. If that is what you really want to beleive then there is nothing I can do.
askjiir 10 months ago
@askjiir
Don't believe only winner's history.You must hear voice both loser and winner.
and you will be able to watch the world more wide view=).
pump88berry 10 months ago
@pump88berry
Japan MUST accept it's own past evil, like the West actually have and keep debating over. I hear no such debate in japan, only excuses, it is most unfortunate, and can only alienate your nabours. Internal debate is healthy, get on with it.
askjiir 10 months ago
@askjiir
Surely Do you think what Japan didn't accept own past quilt?
Japan have been taken Satisfaction more US and European.
and Japan liberatet of Asian pepole and African pepole from Western's domination.
pump88berry 10 months ago
@pump88berry
"Liberation" doesn't include mass murder of hundred of thousands people.But I understand that Japan did remove western dominion of east Asia, that is true. But they were not nice to the locals, so liberation isn't the right word. When Japan lost the war however, the chance of liberation from the west (and japan) was now finaly possible.Had Japan won, the the people would have remained slaves.Japan had an indirect effect on the liberation of east Asia,but that was not their intent
askjiir 10 months ago
@askjiir
Please Read more of correct histrical book.....Sorry,Your knowledge is not worth talking about.Perhaps,Are you Chainese??so I can understand about your level of knowledge.
pump88berry 10 months ago
@pump88berry
I am norwegian, and I am afraid you are living in denial. I hope this is not too common in your country.
askjiir 10 months ago
@askjiir
I hope that's not common in your country too.
pump88berry 10 months ago
@pump88berry
Let me explain this to you mister, you are WRONG,the attrocities commited by the japanese empire is a FACT.I dont deny the attrocities commited by the wetsern world, the western world has done MANY horrible things.Here in the west, we admit this, and talk about it all the time, but in Japan you deny it. You dont have self insight like us. This is horrible, and can only alienate you from your nabours.In Europe we would never have accepted Germany doing this.
askjiir 10 months ago
@pump88berry
For example. If you check out the article Nanking massacre on wikipedia. You will se that japanese wkipedia's article have no pictures and try to avoid going into detail, As well as blaming the Chinese or calling it propaganda! and minimizing the damage. They also say the pictures are false ! While ALL the other languages have pictures!! And speak of it directly and state it's truthfullness. Coincidence? No, this is a sign of all the things I have mentioned.
askjiir 10 months ago
@pump88berry
If you on the other hand check out an article about Americans killing the Indians, the British enslaving Africa, the Holocaust, the Vietnam war or any other event by the western world, you will see many pictures and detail. So get a little more real man.
askjiir 10 months ago
@pump88berry
Japan has been protected by USA all this time against it's communist nabours. Because of this, you have been living in a bubble. Germany was invaded by it's afflicted enemies and was forced admitt it's gruesome past. Now, they teach the children of this in school. Because of this, Germany is once again a trusted member of the European Union. But China and Asia never got the same justice, it was the USA who occupied, but they were not the ones who suffered the most.
askjiir 10 months ago
@pump88berry
USA shielded you from Korea and China. They were lenient and didnt bother seeking out all the war criminals.You therefore have never been forced to face your own past like Germany, and have been living in a state of cold indifference.
askjiir 10 months ago
Comment removed
askjiir 10 months ago
戦争はキチガイ
yukitopman 2 years ago 3