Added: 2 years ago
From: LutherHospital
Views: 34,593
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (20)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Comment removed

  • this is GOOD my teacher discuss this to us .. and i think there is no detrimental about this surgery..

    of course the dr. will study this first before implementing to their costumer/patient.

  • this is horrible...

  • so stomach acids go into the intestines? that can't be good

  • @Flameofsorrow..The Lap-band is NOT less effective than ROUX NY ..A landmark study of 14,000 patients shows it is more effective long term but patients will lose about 20% more weight the fist year. However the concentration of muscle and bone loss is much higher due to nutritional deficiencies, thus band patients lose more actual fat which is why they look much healthier and not as drawn out. There is no argument on DS being more, effective however with a 25% complication rate its not worth it

  • I don't get all the nit-picking debate over which is the best surgery to have in the comments. I had open RYGBS 10+ yrs ago. It saved my life. I was a kid who weighed 420lbs, lost over 250lbs. I haven't gained a single pound of it back. Bariatric Surgery has come a long way over the years. One thing has not, and will never change: Bariatric Surgery is NOT a cure, solution, or shortcut to lose weight.It's a last resort. It's a tool to help you live a healthier life. Don't take it for granted.

  • @JennNOVA1

    I think ur ryt.

  • @thepouchedpotato1 It's not a lie,the DS hasn't been performed as much as GBS yet. I'm sure it will change when more bariatric surgeons offer it as an option to their patients. My younger sister just had the same surgery this past February. We live in VA & had to go to NJ for the closest doctor who performs it. The DS is most effective for those who have already tried the lap band unsuccessfully. I had open RYGBS 10+ yrs ago. I was 420lbs, lost over 250lbs. I haven't gained a single pound back.

  • best is dietary control!

  • What a genious idea!!!!

  • Message was meant as a reply to 999MOla !!

  • gastric banding is less effective then roux en y or the switch. Duodenal The roux en Y is a safer procedure then the switch and in terms of effectiveness, it depends on your indications for having surgery in the first place. There is much more space for food in the duodenal switch compared to the Roux en Y gastric pouch that is created, though there is less uptake in the duodenal switch. You have to categorize pre0op if the problem is an intake problem or that there is a hyper uptake problem

  • LIE - please show one study demonstrating this is safer than the band

  • @PUSHMUSICNY Safety is case by case. I had RYGBS when I was still a teenager. I'm 5'11 & I weighed almost 420lbs so the safest procedure which would also be the most effective for me was open RYGBS. I lost almost 220lbs in 17 months. It's been 10 years since mine was done and I have not gained one single pound back. I've lost a total of over 250lbs.

  • thankyou

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more