Added: 1 month ago
From: TheYoungTurks
Views: 39,395
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (3,237)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i don't understand why people still don't understand what and who a transgender person is with all the information out there. If they haven't taken the time to press a button and read a little they shouldn't make so many judgements. The girl is 7 years old. And if a transgender boy wanted to join the boy scouts why shouldn't he be allowed to?

  • Girl Scouts are currently selling cookies, please support us!

  • @RachelBerryGoldStar I will be. I am so proud of the Girl Scouts!

  • When i was a little boy i was in the Girl Scouts but i got kicked out when i ate a brownie.

  • A true all girl experience?

  • clinton = first black president

    obama = first gay president

    time to elect someone new

  • Boycott Girl Scout cookies? Who the fuck is that masochistic???

  • I think its good that they started letting transgenders in girl scouts ..., because even if they are transgender they are still normal

  • The young lady on the video is not a hater. That is just the standard liberal attack when they don't have an intelligent argument (along with bigot, racist, homophobe, nazi, bla bla bla.) I commend this young woman for standing up for what is right despite the hateful and ugly attacks that the left has hurled at her. This girl could be President someday.

  • What Jayar really wants to say; "Man, this is bullshit. No dude is going to be in the Girl Scouts with my daughter, that's why they call it the mother-effing GIRL SCOUTS. And the parents of this little dude should be bitch-slapped for not getting homey some psychological help. Word up! "

  • I know plenty of lesbians who have fond memories of Girl scouts. 1 person in ten is gay. 1 person in 100,000 is transgendered. The whole thing is silly. If they are properly chaperoned it just won't matter. Way to Go GSUSA I bought two boxes of thin mints today just because it supports an LGBT friendly organization.

  • @geekyerica Why would they have to be "chaperoned" if the boy is really a girl? Last box of GS cookies I will ever buy until the degenerate flamers realize we aren't going to tolerate their attempted coup de tant of this country.

  • Oh, I just realised this is "The Young Turks". Well that explains a lot. Definition of insanity = Liberalism + Young Turks.

  • @Lightf00t1 Definition of bigotry = Conservative = Lightf00t1

  • Sick sick sick. Welcome to the twisted liberal world. They are literally insane.

  • @Lightf00t1 hahahaha you must love shoving things up your ass..am i right? hahaha

  • >Pretend to be transgender

    >Dress like a woman

    >Join Girl Scouts

    >Surrounded by hot 16 year old girls

  • @Anon371 Best plan ever. I know I would do it. I'd tell the girls i'm confused and one of them just might be able to change me. LOL

  • @ausloverxo Glad to see somebody else besides me has some sense here.

  • @83redrose83 They not only have the parts they were born with but they may also actually be attracted to the opposite sex. That means that little boy who is wearing a dress may actually like your little girl that is wearing a dress too. Anyone should understand why some parents would not want their girls exposed to that kind of weirdness. So against the Girl Scouts doing this.

  • @WebAnt, and a little girl who is not transgender may like other girls. Is this trans-girl going to rape all the girls? No. And it's not weirdness. It's normal life. Millions upon millions of transgender people in the world.

  • @Angelalynx999 I just don't believe in endlessly arguing about something neither of us will change our positions concerning. I will never believe relations between those who are genetically the same sex are okay or God's will or someone who is genetically one sex should act or dress like someone of the opposite sex. However, I don't think people who are transgender or gay or bisexual or lesbian are worse than any other sinners. I certainly don't hate or look down on them.

  • I'm a lib and I'm for transgender because I get how u can be born one way and feel like something else ie a female or male, but, Ana, I do understand why some parents would be iffy about this. Letting a transgender girl or boy in w the "opposite" sex would make some parents uncomfortable because they still have the "parts" they were born with. I assume that's why they would be uncomfortable. If it just bothrs them because it's not the "norm" then shame on them... get w the times!

  • i dont no how i feel about this dont really cear one way or anouther but i gota say it would be hard to explain to a 7 year old kid why theirs a boy dressed as a girl in their girl scout troop i can understand why pearents wouldnt want that

  • @ausloverxo, they're not going to introduce her as a boy. They're not going to say "This is a boy named X." They're going to introduce her as a girl.

  • Can we get girl scouts USA in Australia please? Maybe our girl scouts are already this good? idk...

  • @koorgen The same "biological sex" but there are other factors that make up our identity than chromosones and what our body says we are.

  • Wait just a second there's a 7 year old transgendered girl? Who made that decision, I wonder? That's pretty fucked up...

  • @Vyna80 I tend to agree. While actual transgendered people usually say that they have known their condition ever since they were children at 7 years old it seems a little premature to decide that that is what the child has and is. Should that child not get a chance to really decide for themselves when they go through puberty? Are the parents putting ideas into that kids head? I think those are valid concerns.

  • Current models describe sexual identity as comprised of 4 independent qualities; biological sex, sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression. Biological sex relates to our physical sex. Sexual orientation who we are attracted to. Gender identity, what we feel like "inside". Gender expression, how we present our gender, our style.

    Most people are not aware of their own Gender identity because they experiences no dissonance between it and their physical sex.

  • @xzanthius That was a valid point on the issue. There is also those mother hormones that have an effect on children in utero. I suspect that as science continues research on this this will find out more. We need to support little children and let them know different is normal.

  • @ddamico3 If you use the word dolt you are clearly attempting to generate the illusion of some level of intelligence although you're simply a pathetic human being.

  • @WildGamings yo' mama. lol.

  • The problem with allowing a child to dress like they choose is that they just might be confused and need a parent to help them identify with the correct gender. So, I would never allow a child of mine to dress like the opposite gender and would constantly correct any gender inapproriate behaviors. If they end up being trangender or lesbian or gay it won't be because I encouraged them to be that way. That is for sure. Nevertheless, I would love them and show them love no matter what. God Bless.

  • @WebAnt : So you would love them by forcing them to conform to your idea of what they should be rather than letting them decide what they are? Yeah, I feel the "love". And it totally fits that you would reference god at the end of your statement of child abuse. I sure hope you never have kids, for their sake.

  • @WebAnt : What a pity that you are a coward. Your actions say loud and clear that you have no confidence in your position. Poor, sad, little man.

  • lol what a biiiiiitch (the girl scout not ana)

  • why would i watch two people who obviously are in the 90-100 IQ range? how are their ideas relevant to people like me? these dolts are the kids i used to make fun of in class. if you like this "show", you are a moron. truth.

  • @ddamico3 You were a bully in your school days and apparently are just as negative as an adult, awesome! Well, at least you still have an opinion. Truth.

    (felt all smug writting this too...)

    But really what was the point of your comment? Give us a real critique cause so far it is obvious that that is where your IQ and other people "like you" lies; in the 90-100 range. If you are so smart why do you not surf news sites that actually interest you?

  • @xzanthius wow, did i know you in school? the errors is your reply are comical, my friend. nice IQ there. lol.

  • @ddamico3 I was only responding to what you said. Thanks for the compliment however.

  • Trust the butch lesbian. 

  • I wish that people understood what being transgendered is like. Imagine growing up and realizing that your face and body are not really your own, and you sensed that all your life. Everyday you look into the mirror & see a stranger. Doesn't everyone want to be comfortable in their own skin? For some people, it's not unlike ridding themselves of a cancer. It eats at them until there is nothing left.

    No one would ever choose this.

    God loves each one every of us.

    The world needs love & empathy!

  • From an biology standpoint there's no such thing as a true sex change. Just disfigured genitals and a lie you tell yourself? A surgical procedure does not change the chromosomes. even after a sex change those people will still be the Sex they were born. that being said i do feel people have the right to disfigure there genitals if they wish@AilynnStarlight

  • @theabomation AGREED! Once someone was born a boy they are always going to be a boy, and vica versa. You can't change what you were born biologically speaking. If I said I felt like I should be a girl and got a se change that is just as crazy as saying I should have been born a squirrel, so i'm gonna change species. People accept what you are and accept that if you were born with a Penis you are a boy and if not then you are a girl. END OF STORY.

  • @jpyfferroen Comparing a sex change with a species change is just....a horrible horrible fail.

  • @jpyfferroen : Only the end of the story for those who are too stupid to know what the fuck they are talking about.

  • I agree can an Male to female transsexual have a baby? NO does he have no X chromosomes NO then you not a girl ugh.... lol@jpyfferroen

  • @theabomation, first off, every male has at least one X chromosone. Some men have multiple X chromosones. Secondly, not every XX woman can have a child. And is that the defining mark of a woman? To be a childbearer? You're not a woman unless you're good for a uterus?

  • illogical argument all emotional you cant change the way you were born Period! an sexy change is basically the ultimate plastic surgery. for example If an black man bleaches his skin Pale White his children will steal be African American and not white correct? If an male were to get an "sex change" biologically speaking he is still a male just without a penis fake breast and an estrogen shot. @TheDarkSideHasTacos

  • @theabomation, What about XY males who are born with vaginas? Gender is not as clear cut as you think. Many cultures recognize third genders.

  • @theabomation While you are right that in the most BASIC sense it does not make you female or male depending on what you try to become, you can still be very close. Through the use of hormone injections and therapy it is possible to become as damn near the opposite sex as possible. Also you may want to read over things before you post in order to be sure that your grammar and syntax are in proper use.

  • You can most certainly look like a girl through hormone injections but at the end of day all just plastic surgery @talset2480

  • @theabomation : And I feel that idiots like you have a right to say the most stupid shit that comes to their tiny little minds. How fortunate for you, yes?

    What a pity that you will never be bright enough to understand what is going on. It's like watching a chimp trying to use a computer. They can type, but it's all going to be gibberish, devoid of purpose and substance.

  • @AilynnStarlight If you were born a girl, you're a girl. If you were born a boy you are A BOY. END OF STORY. This lady is stupid, I'm not ignorant. I always felt that since I was born I should have been a platypus. Then I realized I was fucking stupid so I grew the fuck up and accepted that I could never be a platypus as I am a male and of a different species.

  • @AilynnStarlight Wow you are truly speaking from your heart and taking a stand in what you believe in. Way to show power with words. That was a wonderful comment. SUBBED!

  • The hater is just clearly a lesbian and doesn't want any 'boys' around...

  • Why can't they all just be "The Scouts of America" or something gay like that?

    And get rid of all the penis and vagina controversy?

  • transgendered 7 years old? WTF

  • @missyouhoo who are you to quantify when it starts? are you a doctor? noper

  • @mona7938 No 7 year old has the capacity to make a life decision as to which gender they identify with. Should parents force their children to do certain tasks that are definite boy/girl in origin no but putting the title as transgendered on a 7 year seems like their doing more harm than good once the kid becomes a teenager/young adult

  • @missyouhoo : Take it from someone who is transgendered, it's a good thing that she is proclaiming her gender and that her parents are taking her AND the psychiatrists at their word and allowing her to be herself. I wish my parents had allowed me to be the girl that I am and that I hadn't waited so long to transition. In fact it would be MORE harmful to force her to be a boy, to suppress her personality simply to please others. Believe me, I know.

  • @Angelalynx999 I have no idea your life story and the ease of transitioning I am black female & I've always identified with that. I have a issue being a previous girl scout with boys joining dressed up as girls. They can make their own scouts or join boy scouts esp. since their acitivities are somewhat similar. Why does every scout troop have to change for 1 child? Its just way too much at 7 esp. since he has to go to school and children are cruel and whose to say those girls want him there.

  • @missyouhoo : Then allow me to educate you. She's not a he and never will be so calling her a boy dressed up as a girl is inaccurate. She wants to join the Girl Scouts because it's were she feels she belongs. Children know at that age what gender they are, and she is no different. That's how she knows that she's a she.

    I find it an encouraging thing that the Girl Scouts are inclusive of transgendered girls and I wish others were as inclusive.

  • @missyouhoo since when is joining the scouts a LIFE changing decision? get your head out of your butt. the people posting this video, the person protesting her claims, and the media are using transgender labels. that little child JUST wants to join the scouts.. get a grip

  • @mona7938 First off don't ever call me a fucking bigot I was a girl scout at that age and you know damn well wasn't talking about the scouts being a life decision. If he/she/shim wants to be a scout then be a boy scout, its enough confusion in kids lives today without explaining this to other 4-13 year olds (yes the scouts start at that age). If the child wants to wear & play with girls items then have at it. This will be my last comment on the subject so have at it.

  • @missyouhoo i dont care what or who you are. your comments present you as a hateful person, particularly the labels you toss about like shim strengthen this claim. you are completely lacking in knowledge or the origin, as well as the bio/psy/and physical issues at hand in transgender people. it is not about playing doll. it is not about dressing up like the opposite sex. thank you for reinforcing the fact you are, in fact a total and absolutely hateful, bigot.

  • @missyouhoo she never said transgender. those are adult labels. she just wants to be in the scouts.. get a grip you bigot and selfish woman.

  • Y separate boy and girl scouts then if ur gonna let each gender in the other one just combine them

  • @JCBL892 transgender people are not the sex they are given. this may go above your level of intellect or your capacity for compassion, but he feels he is a girl. whether this is a trend in development, or something deeper it is not for you to label or to decide.

  • If they teach ANY of the morals that they do in boy scouts in girl scouts this girl either wouldn't be complaining or wouldn't be considered a girl scout. Why? Because they teach us, in boy scouts, how to be polite and not tell people off or go against people because of who they are.

  • @Salien1999 except for the fact that the boy scouts don't accept gays or atheists/agnostics:

    en(dot)wikipedia(dot)org/wiki/­Boy_Scouts_of_America_membersh­ip_controversies

  • @deathreaver3356 Your source is a wikipedia page? That source could be out-dated or all out incorrect. And even if it is, I was talking about specific scouts and what they are taught. Thank you for trying to inform me, but I will believe it with a real source (I don't mean to get into an argument) ;)

  • if that isn't enough Penn & Teller:Bullshit S04E01 goes into more detail I usually don't go super deep into research the Bullshit episode is where I learned of the anti gay thing here's another article sighting some sources (the author seems biased unfortunately) wwwsnopescom/inboxer/petition/­boyscout.asp and not to be a dick but considering there's a supreme court case in which a gay man was trying to avoid being kicked out of the BSA seems to give the idea credence to me

  • @deathreaver3356 o_O Funny title LOL! And do you mean a boy? Because MEN don't join the BSA, unless they are troopmasters or something.

  • I ran out of characters to go into further detail BSA v. Dale is the name of the case and it was about a man who was a Scoutmaster until BSA officials read an interview with him in which he had stated he was gay if I remember correctly he was a Scoutmaster for quite a while before this occurred he is interviewed in the Bullshit episode as well as a boy who seemed to be the epitome of a scout except he was gay so he was either kicked out or never admitted I can't remember which

  • @deathreaver3356 Well let's see... the title is "Transgender girl scouts NOW accepted" so maybe they were just accepted or something? If so then it probably hasn't caught on to boy scouts. Either that or it's because criticism would be very high for that boy/girl and could even lead to abuse sometimes.

  • @Salien1999 girl scouts and boy scouts are two completely separate organizations with different rules the girl scouts don't have any restrictions for allowing gay/lesbian or atheist/agnostic girls from joining and if the BSA is afraid of the child being criticized/abused then they could stick up for the kid instead of barring their entry no the BSA leadership think that gays are icky they are not trying do defend them

  • @deathreaver3356 Well if they did allow them in, then this exact thing would happen. People would react, people would over-react and eventually it's a national story. If they don't allow them then the kid doesn't turn into an example. I know, it's terrible, but it's a terrible world. The Boy Scouts prepare you for the military in it's basics, and how can it do it's job when everyone is focused on this boy is technically a girl?

  • I will be buying extra cookies this year.

  • Oh wow,what a shock,republicans being bigots.

    Shit,if I was american,I'd only buy transgender scout cookies.

  • @Mazzmaker69 bigot

  • i live in Ventura County.... i don't think it's THAT Republican.... especially not Ojai....

  • This really shouldn't even be a big issue. SHES just a 7 year old Girl. What is wrong with people these days that they can't accept a transgendered girl into girl scouts.

  • @cuteabbyxo : The ones who are complaining don't understand transgenderism and people tend to fear what they don't understand. The only cure for this fear is education but the individual person has to want to learn. Those who don't want to learn (fomiz) are the most fearful.

  • Screw that girl I got cookies!!!

  • My point is this research the topic/transgender and learn it before you judge some one because of who they are. Also you're not in their shoes so you cant even imagine whats going through theire heads. I wont judge anyone i would rather spend my time learning and trying to understand it. LIVE HATE FREE :)

  • There is nothing wrong with being transgender. Im happy organizations are accepting transgirls. Also a person cant overcome being transgender its who they are. I understand haters and ignorant ppl are afraid of this because shes different. but being a bully to someone makes u seem weak, so get a life.

  • @KTevolved Why are you messaging me this shit? You get a life! Why do people like you want us to accept that sick lifestyle? Just go and have your sex change and live your life, no one is stopping you from doing that. It is my prerogative not to like or aceept transgender and consider what you do as nonsense,and if you call me ignorant,so be it.I can blissfully live with that criticism.One last thing dont mistake pity for fear, no one is scared of you nasty people.Now,fuckoff !

  • @fomiz

    I tried to remove my comment because im not a ignorant weak minded person who hates someone i dont know. I didnt want to put you down or anyone else because my views are different thats stupid. So whatever i said just forget. I understand you will never accept anything you know nothing about and is different than what society expects. Hope you have a great life :) fyi i love all around me. Everyone is intitled to different opinions.

  • @fomiz sick lifestyle? im sorry that people differ form your cookie cutter, oppressive straight while vision of the united states. you are openly segregating and globally labeling individuals with terms you have no comprehension to understand.

  • @mona7938 hurray! ^_^

  • Fuck this girl, I bought my cookies!

  • A child that young has no business being trans-gendered. His parents must be horrible!

  • This shit is retarded. What the #$%* is going on in the world. This dumb bitch is promoting this abomination. No one is scared or confused. You are the confused one here and where is the Father in all this. You are ignorant.

  • @Cee1Vee

    Hahaha u seem angry why? There is a such thing as transgender, its when the brian is the opposite gender as the body. Do your research before judging about something you know nothing about. Having love in thy heart is better than hate :)

  • @Cee1Vee That clown KTevolved & his transgenders supporters messaged me too.It's probably best to just ignore them.I'm all for debating on YT but these fools are trying to condone what is clearly nonsense.I'm with you,where are the fathers in all of this?The morality in our country has declined?Can you imagine,prostitution is illegal & so is polygamous marriage but a child at 8years old can perfectly decide to change their gender.Lord a mercy,WTF will things be like in another 100years?

  • @Cee1Vee and BTW you dont seem angry to me at all. You have asked a legitimate question. "Where are the fathers?". This is some "abnormal" shit because it is not "normal" behavior with what is consistent throughtout the world, and I just like you I can't figure out how they (trannys) have concluded that people who don't accept their nonsense are scared.There is no fear just pity & disgust in my mind for these creatures.

  • @fomiz : Because it's irrational! ;)

    There is no rational reason to hate transgendered people. So the only reason you hate us so much has to stem from an irrational fear. Somehow we threaten you. Why is that? Because it's "abnormal"? Define normal. I'm sure you are not normal to someone else so the term is completely subjective.

    Want proof that you fear us? Fear leads to hatred. You call us "creatures". First rule of hatred, demonize what you don't like so you are justified in your hate.

  • @Angelalynx999 Look asshole.Why are you messaging me?Who hates you?Did I not make myself clear?I think you're "pitiful" & "disgusting" & I'll never be convinced otherwise.Just like I'll never be convinced raw fish(sushi) is delicious.That's my prerogative not to like it.Why are you trying to force me to accept what you do?I dont want to educate myself on the matter,I'm not interested in your life.Now go forth & prosper your digusting tranny life.

  • @fomiz : Oh yeah, you made yourself perfectly clear. You hate us due to some irrational fear that your have towards us. I'm just curious why you fear us.

    True, it's your prerogative to not like us but you have no good reason for not liking us. You've already said you don't want to know anything about us which might mean that you fear what knowing about us will do to your opinion of us. Perhaps it's social pressure that keeps you from educating yourself. Fear of ridicule for accepting us?

  • @Angelalynx999 Desperate & boring. i'll allow you to have the last boring irrelevant word in my life. goodbye.

  • @fomiz : Continue to run and fear us, little man.

    You know, I wonder if it's overcompensation that makes you lash out like you do. That would be funny in a sad way, if you, yourself, were transgendered and in order to avoid ridicule you in turn ridicule us. What do you say? Do you secretly see yourself as a woman? ;)

  • @Angelalynx999 Desperate!

  • @fomiz : Oh, that sounds like overcompensation to me! ^_^

  • @Angelalynx999 Go to your parents or family members that rejected you to find the acceptance which you crave from everyone else, you desperate creature. ^_^

  • @fomiz : None of them do. Hey, you can message me to find out how you can transition and bring out the real you. I can give you all the info! ;)

  • @Angelalynx999 Lier! You know as well as I do that there are family members of yours that hate you being a tranny. Go get their acceptance & understanding first before you come asking for mine.

  • @fomiz : But I'm not a transmission. You aren't making any sense. I know the confusion you feel is clouding your mind. But don't worry, I have pills that will make you feel better and will bring out the real you. ^_^

  • @Angelalynx999 I tell you what, why dont you take those pills yourself, all at once, and before you do so, leave a suicide note for you family apologizing for the dishour & sadness you brought into their lives

  • @fomiz : Why would I do something silly like that? Besides, my pills, taken all at once, wouldn't do anything but cause me the need to get more pills and there is nothing to apologize for since I didn't bring dishonor (dishour?) and sadness into anyone's life. Again, you are making no sense. You must really be confused about your gender! :p

  • @Angelalynx999 you sound so desperate to recruit more trannys to your cause. you just cant stop messaging me and even asked me to send you private messages. you desperate confused nasty creature. must suck to be you.

  • @fomiz : We don't recruit, we infect. You see, every time you reply to me you become more feminine. Given enough time you will be just like me. In fact you might have noticed your nipples tingling by now. If not, I imagine it will be soon. ;)

  • @Angelalynx999 You know what? Your use for me is over, I've entertained myself enough with your nonsense and I've wasted enough time too. this is the last reply you'll get from me. i advise you go and get the medical psychiatric help you need.

  • @fomiz : Are you getting that tingling yet? ;P

    "i advise you go and get the medical psychiatric help you need." - You first. You need it more than I do!

  • that stuped bitch

  • Why dont they just start their's own Transgender Scout! Problem solved! Holy Eff

  • @mochaguy22 I totally agree with this. It is called the GIRL scouts, hence all of the members (hehe members) are female. Boys, transgendered or not should not be included in the GIRL scouts no matter if they identify as a girl or not. I think it's fair to not accept him in the girl scouts.

  • @afqwcx : Well, then, since you want to exclude some girls from the girl scouts what other types of girls would you exclude? What about intersexed girls or hermaphrodites? What about girls who look too much like a boy? Because once you start down the road of exclusion the list of "acceptable" members only gets smaller.

    Fortunately the Girl Scouts do not want to exclude ANY girl and so EVERY girl is allowed, regardless of their appearance. This is a good thing.

  • @Angelalynx999 A transgendered boy is not a girl. I understand what a transgendered person is but biologically they just aren't the same. There are different issues to deal with and frankly I don't think the girl scouts is the right fit for them anyway. To some point this child's parents has to explain to them that they are different and that there is nothing wrong with being different. They must also teach them that they can't do everything. A boy is not a girl and viceversa

  • @afqwcx : A transgendered girl is as much of a girl as any other girl. Unless you think that the flesh overrides the mind, which I don't think you do. After all, if we went by the flesh a man would cease being a man if he lost his penis. Do you think this is how it should be? If not then it's clear that the mind takes priority and this girl's mind says she's a girl.

    Why would the girl scouts not be a good fit for a girl?

  • @Angelalynx999 Because he isn't a girl. He is a transgendered boy just as I am not a shark no matter how much I want to be one. I'm actually glad that they did accept him. I personally would not however. A hermaphrodite and a girl that looks like a boy are different cases (both are actually girls), they should be accepted into the girl scouts. But even if this child thinks he is a girl, he is still a boy. Don't lie to the child by telling him he's a girl, tell him he's different.

  • @afqwcx : So I was wrong, you consider the flesh before the mind. That's unfortunately small minded of you. I see absolutely no difference between an intersexed girl, a hermaphrodite, a trans girl, and a cis girl. They are ALL girls because it's what's in their minds that's important, not what flesh they have.

    Umm, no one told her that she's a girl. SHE told THEM. Since she was 2 years old. The parents are not influencing this, because they can't. This is all coming from her.

  • @Angelalynx999 I'm going to take back what I said earlier, I would allow the boy into the girl scouts but I would teach him one on one that he is NOT a girl. If we go by ur logic then every kid who thinks they're batman should fight crime. There are limits to what they can do and we need to prepare them for REALITY. He is not a girl no matter how much he thinks it. Reality says he can't be something he is not and he was not born a female. To tell him anything else is a lie.

  • @afqwcx She was born in the wrong body and if you were to try to "teach him that he is NOT a girl," there is a huge chance you would cause her to develop severe depression (and possibly attempt suicide) if she was exposed to you for a long time.

    And your Batman example is dumb. No one in their right mind would let the kid fight crime because he'd most likely end up dead. Being transgender doesn't run the risk of killing you unless you're stuck in a place with people who think like you.

  • @Mingchao Saying that a transgendered child would be depressed at hearing the truth is just a generality and holds no real truth to it. All I'm really saying is that we need to stop sugar-coating things and playing pretend all the time as a culture. There is nothing wrong with this boy, he shouldn't be a victim of prejudice for what he is. But to say he is a girl is a lie, he is not. There are things a girl will go through that he will never. Raise him as what he is, transgendered.

  • @afqwcx : Transgendered is not a gender in itself. It's a classification of a person who is or will transition from one gender to another. This girls real gender is female so she should be raised as a female. True, she won't experience everything a cisgender girl will but that doesn't make her any less of a girl than say, a girl born sterile. And she shouldn't be singled out because of this. Informed, yes, but not singled out. That invites ridicule which can be deadly.

  • @Angelalynx999 That's why you educate everyone. Just from looking at this video, debating with you, and looking up "transgender" i have a better grasp on what it means to be TG and I am tolerant of that. However to say that a TG person who is physically male, is female is simply not true. You can't undermine physicality. They are not either. If I dated someone transgendered and they told me they were female they would be lying. Point blank, that is a LIE.

  • @afqwcx : Again, you are confusing the mind and the body. They are linked but separate. And it's our minds that make us who we are, not just just our bodies. Yes, my body was male, now it is less so. But my mind hasn't changed. I have and still consider myself female and I will be female no matter what I look like. So no, if I tell someone I'm female I would NOT be lying since that is what I consider myself to be.

    I'm glad that you are learning about it and that you are tolerant. :)

  • @Angelalynx999 This'll be my last opinion here. It's not bad to consider yourself something but that doesn't mean every one else will and should consider you that way. The classification of a TG person's persons is very difficult to truly comprehend but if anything is ambiguous. We are all humans but we have our differences. I am a black man. The truth is that even if I was born with a brain that told me I was white I am still black. I am black because that is my defined feature.

  • @afqwcx : You keep using false analogies. Gender identity is simply not the same as wanting to be a different race. And there is a lot of research to back up the fact that it's a serious medical condition that requires treatment in order to live a happy life.

    Why should others consider us what we are? One reason is there are still areas that are limited to one gender or the other so it is very important that others at least accept us for the gender that we are presenting.

  • @Angelalynx999 The analogy holds because to some degree this is a mental issue, not wholly one but still one. It's partly a mental issue because it deals with self perception, anyone who says no is probably a quack. I know that your brain biologically thinks ur something opposite to ur body, i get that. Thinking ur a female just because u see yourself as one is a coping mechanism or rather the easiest path. You are not really either or you are both. You should be classified thusly

  • Comment removed

  • @afqwcx gender and race are not even remotely in the same category here..

  • @Angelalynx999 yuck

  • @TheElefishJellyphant : I'm curious, what are you saying "yuck" to?

  • @Angelalynx999 dont play dumb

  • @TheElefishJellyphant : I'm not playing at all, I'm asking a question. Care to answer it or would you prefer to remain vague and useless?

  • @Angelalynx999 i rather be vauge and useless then a gross tranny. BYYYEEEE

  • @TheElefishJellyphant : In what way are we "gross"?

  • @TheElefishJellyphant You are, no worries there;0)

  • @Angelalynx999 show showing little to no comprehension of the dx. please pick up a copy of the dsm4

  • @mona7938 : Little to no comprehension? That's funny. Yeah, I'm only living it, what do I know, right? Hehe.  :)

  • @Angelalynx999 dsm4.. read it

  • @mona7938 : Again, I'm LIVING it. Unless you care to explain why it is that I need to read it again?

  • @afqwcx looking up transgender does not give you the right to make any formal comment regarding it. unless you are a doctor, psy, social worker or the like.

  • @afqwcx : And in so doing you would be emotionally scarring her. Do you really want to abuse a child? And your analogy is inaccurate. Transgenderism is a serious and valid medical condition.

    If you want to prepare her for reality then it would be better to recognize her condition. Would you tell a Down Syndrome person that they're stupid? Probably not. Then why would you tell this girl that she's not a girl?

    And I'm female and I was born male so it IS possible, in reality, to change.

  • you're being ignorant....(MJ)

  • i really doubt there would be any boys willing to go out of their way to do the whole deal of being transgender just to get to creep on girl scouts.

    if there is a transgender little girl who her and her parents have gone through all the steps of getting registry and identification changed so that that child can be officially identified as a girl, then that girl should be allowed to go to girl scouts.

  • Boycott Girl Scout cookies? Are you outta you're fuckin mind? Those things are DELICIOUS!

  • Hello everyone welcome to hell, also known as the United States of Amercia.

  • @fomiz

    ... Because Girl Scouts allow boy-girls? 

  • @JayMann620 Of course not! A 7-8 year old transexual child is perfectly normal.

  • @fomiz

    Then why is America hell?

  • @JayMann620 Was being sarcastic.Im not religious but if there is a messiah who is to return &save man from sin then that motherfucker is long overdue & America needs to be his first port of call.God forbid I reproduce in this country.The existence of any moral compass has long flown the coop. 8 year old transexuals? Lord a mercy! Why don't the parents just give him a sex change & cut off his dick then there will be no issue of him being a boy?He'll have a virgina just like the girls