Velvet Revolver - Mr. Brownstone - Rock Am Ring 2007

[WhyWouldIDoThat1]

Scott can't even get all the lyrics right... Who's he in the first place to play with those legends ? Damn, seeing this makes me realize how much Axl IS Guns n' Roses. Slash, Izzy and Duff wrote crazy instrumentals but without Axl's amazing voice it's really not the same thing.

[almaiav]

@WhyWouldIDoThat1 Myles Kennedy solves your doubt between past and present. axl WAS good, and all the Velvet Revolver and musicians selected by Slash are great together - it`s hard to understand?

[almaiav]

@WhyWouldIDoThat1 Scott tryin' to sing like Axl is strange, I agree, but find the presentation of Myles Kennedy with the solo tour's band of Slash in the Rock am Ring 2010: Axl do that in the present?

[crabby515]

Scott ROCKS!!!

[lauralikes]

slash <33

[clockoff1430]

With Slash and Duff slamming this riff into gear, Dolly Parton could sing this with these guys and it'd still rock it's ass out!! No diss intended Scott or Axl!

[velvetmike]

Scott Weiland :) !!

[incubusbuckley]

you guys do realize this is scott weiland of stone temple pilots right. he's a great performer.

[crabby515]

@incubusbuckley Thank you!!! :)

[rowse4]

Isso é muito mais Guns N' Roses q esse tal "Guns N' Roses" q não passa de um projeto do Axl.

[RockmanMKD]

Like if you like back Guns n' Roses !

[funnyboy568]

sounds much better with axl

[RockinGuitar1000]

GNR - Axl = VR

[Dgl44]

This guy can't even come close to Axl. He's trying to imitate him but in the end he just appears as the biggest gay I have ever seen, and making Axl look bad that way. :/ The song just isn't the same without Axl. You can see that even Slash is not as in the groove as he used to be... He even started the intro differently. Velvet revolver isn't a bad band. Only their singer was gay. (Now they fortunately kicked him out.)

[prod1gyxfxa]

@Dgl44 lol your still livin in the 80's and scott isnt gay, lol.. have you ever looked upon old rockstars, bowie maybe? a few others, your a ignorant little bitch is what you are, and you seem to find axl a god.. if they didnt think Weiland was a good singer, obviously they wouldnt of taken him on VelVet Revolver, you little bitch.. god there's so much more i can say to you.. keep suckin your axl rose cock buddy, ;) because your EGO MAN!

[Dgl44]

@prod1gyxfxa No I don't worship Axl because he is a bitch too. And he knows it. But he is the greatest frontman in the history of rock and that's a fact. And scott wouldn't fail so misserably if he wouldn't try to imitate Axl. And if scott was such a great singer they wouldn't kick him out of the band for talking stuff about the band that wasn't true. The rest of the band was planning to fire him for quite some time because they apparently DIDN'T like him. Get your facts straight bro. :)

[kermitdafrrog]

Sometimes I hate "german crowd" videos seriously , nothing against germans but I wonder if they don really wnjoy the music what are they doing there all sleepy.

Or at least they should bring signs or something to show their emotions.

[RockOutable02]

Have you guys ever wondered if Duff has ever been on the taffy puller like Mike Tevee in Charlie and the Chocolate factory. Why's his neck so long?!??

[mrericjackson76]

No point in comparing the singers... they're both brilliant, but both very different. I'll call this a very good cover. Nothing more, nothing less. Leave the BS at home.

[beansandwiched]

skipped to 3:47 to see if he hit the vocals. Man how I miss the original band.

[polipoli8]

Crowd of shit ...

[CrazyTulip]

@polipoli8 I agree! they are standing there like they are attending a freakin' funeral!

[mindsaber]

matt sorum, boringest drummer ever

[MotorTourerPA]

Scott knows all about Mr. Brownstone.

[Abnormalties]

Scott should have been louder. I say Scott nails covers live. This was pretty dirty, look at when he sang Break on through with the doors. Scott is an overall sick singer.

[KazAtak]

Funny how Velvet Revolver had more early Guns members than Guns now

[AndrewMcMillan1977]

@KazAtak There are no original members of Guns in Velvet revolver, I don't see Ole Beich, Rob Gardner or Tracii guns up there...

[KazAtak]

@AndrewMcMillan1977 Yeah i know I said early I meant like Appetite and Illusions

[sosforever]

can't even hear the fool

[BonJ2211]

@sosforever Not really him to blame though, is it?

[MrsBruh4]

IMITATION .l.

[gesetzlose]

sieht aus wie eine Parodie von GNR. reicht nie an das Original

[zenmonk9003]

Weiland must be my favorite modern singer. He rocks and everything he does rocks.

[beastoftheeast34]

scott fucked up the lyrics lol

[tpda1990]

Slashs Wah Wah Solo sounds the same just like in 80s & 90s . I love it. He never gets old

[polipoli8]

2:43 .... Jizz

[GunsNRosesGR]

1:32 I can see people with their back to the band??? :O!!!

[polipoli8]

WHAT A SHITTY CROWD ...

[jmfausset]

!!!

[tiagogowert]

esse scott é mto viado

[AxlTerry94]

crowd has an off night?!

[isaizaiba]

I love Axl, scott rocks but no one like him...

[snidelywhiplash]

What the hell is wrong with the audience? They all look like they ate a couple valium a piece before the show.

[polipoli8]

Why does it sound so good when Velvet Revolver plays Guns and Roses' songs ?

BECAUSE THEY HAVE THE FKNG 3/5 OF THE ORIGINAL BAND !!!

[Luxmaxnike]

@polipoli8 when matt got inside the band the formation already had 6 members (Matt, Dizzy, Izzy, Duff, Slash, Axl) so its 1/2

[polipoli8]

@Luxmaxnike I didn't count Dizzy sorry xD but I think bassist, drummer, guitarists and signer have a bigger part in an original ''rock band'' ..... so it's still 3/5 because we could also count the ''tour girls''

[ohhhhdebi]

Pathetic!!!!!!!.... AXL IS THE MAN!!!!!!

[collideoverme]

@ohhhhdebi Not really...Scott can sing, Axl lost his voice.

[RoledMandalor]

Why are you talkin bout Axl? This is fckin Velvet Revolever, not GnR! And Slash can play most of GnR songs, since he´s a composer

[bendirillos1]

for the record, izzy stradlin sang mr. brownstone, Axl has a small part at the end of this song

[darkfro]

@bendirillos1 :)...You're not serious...you should do your homework and then post. 

[collideoverme]

@bendirillos1 HAHAHA no he did not!

[eolux992]

Scott Weiland is dancing with Mr Brownstone

[jennys1903]

@eolux992 yeah unfortunately you can tell he does quite frequently....

[pato3mix]

Scott has a similar low rage notes like axl

[leozvip]

prefiro axel cantando !

[Homezlice]

He thinks he is axle rose he wishes

[ATeam192]

Scott Weiland was born to perform this song!

[gsclayton]

the best youtube.com/watch?v=U0EW2H2_lw­c

[89gerardo]

scott is a TENOR with a very thin voice

axl is a BARITONE with a darker (and powerful) voice

no one its better, its just different. end of the fuckin story

[BlanFan2O]

Guns N' Roses(current): New band with GN'R singer.

Velvet Revolver: Guns N' Roses without Axl.

I like the second one the most.

[jonsitron11]

Fucking lame crowd.

[brandonschlotfeld]

At least Scott knows how to sing live.

[MrSlashrocks13]

that crowd is dead!! If I was there i was jumping and screaming... Great song!!!

[Rehammeron]

Scott danced 1000 more times with mr Brownstone than axl so its cool if he sings the song.

[mikebecker330]

OMG...who better to sing this song than Scott W!

[95danielcosta]

@mikebecker330 who better? I know some guy named W. Axl Rose..

[mikebecker330]

@95danielcosta I was referencing to Scott's trouble with Mr. Brownstone.

[95danielcosta]

@mikebecker330 Oh, sorry my friend.. didn't think about that..

[KISSisHetero]

Its good but the appetite for destruction version with slash n axl is better

[tonicstu]

Wieland was hand picked for VR, nuff said.

[eolux992]

Only Myles Kennedy can compare to Axl

[nickj1706]

honestly VR can be pretty good, but no one can sing this song (my fav song) but axl rose, its would just be wrong!

[AxlRoselovesJulie90]

@gozerman2000

everybody has his/her opinion so for me Axl is far better than Scott. Scott dancing is very awful also :D , It's proved now that Scott is out of Velvet Revolver... peace ah... ^^

[bethaxl49]

The music is great bec of the musicians but come on only AXL can performe these songs!!!!! LOL i dont kow why anyone even attempts to try to follow in axl's shoes!!! AXL is the best!!!

[NnysVelvetRevolver]

i know that most GNR/VR fans will hate me but hey, it's my opinion, deal with it:

VRs live version of MR. Brownstone is 1000x better than GNR live

[Rehammeron]

@NnysVelvetRevolver so true

[gshdrums]

Scott Weiland is a nob...

[mccoydfm404]

I Can Relate Being that I shor it for 14 years! LOL Clean for a year but anything could trigger a relapse !!! Best to if you dont know you don't know what you're missing! but If you been there HARD Ha I like to punch every Crack Head I ever herd talking about withdrawals LOL ( No Such Thing) I shot that too 5,000.00 a weekend and stoppesd! 10 yrs ago when all the real shit keft the states! Fake ass 30% BullShit Gimma Break Aint no such thing as Coike DTs dummys!

[cactus9889]

slash , duff etc they should have kept the name GNR

[MooseTremonti]

@cactus9889 they couldn't when Axl managed to get a contract so he owned the name behind everyone's back

[compwiz878]

@cactus9889 haahah axel has gnr

[empty1388]

@cactus9889 axl is an idiot... he sang ok but was a freak... why do you think they left in the first place...

[keatsblake100]

@empty1388  What's not freakish about any good lead rock singer? Seriously.

[francoxignacio]

This is a Gn'R Song ¬¬

[arthurtrucco]

@francoxignacio Oh realy????????

[pechan97]

Velvet revolver is better than new Guns n roses because isnt guns n roses this is Axl N friends

[Moneyshotm]

Nice job by Matt Sorum playing those Steven Adler licks. Nice he didn't try and get too fancy. It's a great groove.

[TinManSixtySix]

@Moneyshotm I'm with you on that!

[Terrinorrie]

If slash had any problem with Scott pulling the axl routine, I don't think it would have gone down that way. I love GnR, but also love STP, got the best of both worlds there. And ya, the crowd looked sluggish, they really had no idea of the awesome show they were being treated to!

[GoodGuitarSolos]

I disagree with everything here: Chinese Democracy is amazing album, the band just doesn't have the magic of the original, legendary group. The musicians can definitely play but they just don't have the same charisma and legacy as guys like Slash.

Scott Weiland is awesome singer, so is Axl Rose. Talk shit about one of them: you don't know anything about vocals. Rose has incredibly wide range, whereas Weiland's voice is damn versatile and suits many different music styles.

[SzDorothy]

These songs are bringing back the old GNR powa

[TheElephant79]

Axl Rose is done, an Asshole and the new Guns n Roses is an Axl Puppet Show, it´s ridiculous.

Scott W. is a great Singer, but also completely fucked with Drugs an Shit and here he looks ridiculous. Its a Miracle that this Dude is alive.

[nic0789cle]

is the crowd sleeping ?

[Efforts1]

I'm Happy scott got fired (:

[Luxmaxnike]

@Efforts1 that is a ridiculous coment. first, he didnt got fired, he leaved the band for many reasons. second, velvet revolver had a great lead singer and now it doesnt have one at all, thats not happy. if you like the stone temple pilots ai take back everything i wrote, if you arent, then u r an homophobic moron

[Efforts1]

@Luxmaxnike ok your telling me slash lied? no dude he got fired coz of his agents. + he was gay. it doesn't matter if they have a singer or not as you can see slash still can an album duff got his other band so these guys aren't tied down to just a stupid gay singer.

[JamesKendric]

Scott Weiland is a great singer. But this song is not the same without Axl, ya know?

[Jakezeppelin1]

@thenaturalalpha for sure and yes i think he is tryin to impersonate axl

[mkim1022]

scott is nothin in front of axl shutt up...gnr without axl is nothin ..on the other hand gnr without slash and duff is nothin too...so reunite fuckers

[brosqee]

amazingly good vocals by scott..acctually kinda sounds like axl in many ways...i wish they had better recorded versions of gnr songs with scott

[MrPtrlix]

axl is talented and better than scott but scott is a great singer too. know look at chinese democrachy gnr's time has passed and @smojoe92 is right too

[donnjuansohn]

what a lame crowd 0o

[smojoe92]

Axel Rose is a great frontman, but an asshole too.

he mostly the reason the original g n r broke up.

he ether fired them or they just said fuck it and left.

to me that band is gone, its now the axel rose show.

It will never compare with the original.

Scott did pretty good, but no one can singit like axel could.

But like the other person said, there two different ppl, so what do you expect?

[MrsBruh4]

@smojoe92 It's AXL, not Axel --'

Why people never know how to wrote his name?! Fuck...

[TinManSixtySix]

@MrsBruh4 Why? For the same reason your English grammar sucks, portuga!!! Most people don't care about correction LOL

[MrsBruh4]

@TinManSixtySix excuse me?

fuck off , bitch :D I didn't even talk to ya, so keep your opinions to yourself.

[TinManSixtySix]

@MrsBruh4 LOL Yea I know, it was I that talked to you!!! LOL Keeping my opinions to myself is quite a different story, I can't!!! LOL

[MrsBruh4]

@TinManSixtySix just 'cause you're a velvet revolver's fan doesn't give you the right to bore me (;

GUNS 'N' FUCKIN' ROSES & AXL ROSE FOREVER ♥ , fag !

[TinManSixtySix]

@MrsBruh4 You cod-eating, fado-listening moron!!!

[TinManSixtySix]

@TinManSixtySix Wait... what's with that nickname?? Are you a she???? Mrs. Brufford, is that it???

[MrsBruh4]

@TinManSixtySix shut the fuck up, moron .|.

yes, I'm a girl --'

[mccoydfm404]

@smojoe92 Scott Is Better Than Axel just keep the brownstone around and he'll B oO.K. LOL

[skypjuh]

@smojoe92 you said it..

[smojoe92]

@smojoe92 get so many thumbs up (sorry)

[joaopmpgnr]

@smojoe92 Its AXL Rose not Axel. Now, I am sick of all that GNR breakup is because of Axl. Both Axl and Slash are guilty.

[AdamEarley2011]

@joaopmpgnr mostly axl he wanted SOLE ownership of guns n roses so slash signed his share and basicly said fuck it this is the Axl rose show! and he was right thats why he left. but izzy left cause he was the only clean one axl fired steven for drugs duff left to settle down as his wife became pregnant and gilby was fired cause he cant write songs matt left i think. its not all axls fault to be fair but he shouldnt have tried to take control. him and slash were like brothers! thats what pissed

[AdamEarley2011]

@joaopmpgnr slash off. it was their band all five and axl tried to take it away.

[joaopmpgnr]

@AdamEarley2011 Slash had been a bit lazy and irresponsible and Axl was starting to lose his patience. He all know that story about firing Gilby. Slash didn't like it. But Gilby wasn't even an original member, one of the five, as you say. That would be Izzy. Even Sorum replaced Adler. So, orig-members in 1994? Axl, Slash. And Mr. Dizzy Reed. They wouldn't leave forever, we know that, but they are not coming back together because of Axl AND Slash.

[dabc587]

@joaopmpgnr Well I have seen some videos around and aparently Slash has changed his mind, but al what you say is absolutely true

[mrtheghvincent]

this shows how much the 70&80 bands or so much better then the modern ones (excpet for muse ofc)

[otanalin101]

dont much like axle rose, dont much like this singer either, but fuck me this song rocks :) dont give a fuck who sung what first (kiss)

[PlayerNo22]

cut the vocal, close your eyes and tell it's worse than new gn'r, if so you're probably deaf:)

[MrXFlashX]

Slash es el ejemplo a seguir como guitarrista yo sigo sus pasos hasta la muerte Mejor en El mundooo

[joebob701]

i think myles kenedy is slash's first normal singer (i know this isnt him)

[Tiago98]

now that's just a rip off !!!!!!!! not cool at all

[AxlRoselovesJulie90]

Scott dancing is very bad, can't be compared to Axl dancing XDXDXD

It's not cool & sexy at all ;D ;D ;D Axl voice is far beyond Scott's.

[qwerty96347]

@AxlRoselovesJulie90 It's a different person, as well as a different band. What do you expect?

[gozerman2000]

@AxlRoselovesJulie90

i dont know what youre shitting dude he sings way better than that asshole of a axl like i said in one of my other comments slash makes the band axl sux balls

[ZepicTV94]

Duff is so Awesome!!!

[Luxmaxnike]

this is very good. i mean, with axl was way better, but that doesn´t mean Scott dont sig well

[GNRMetallica92]

I fucking love how Slash does the intro with the wah wah pedal. I always play that part over and over. I can't figure out how to do it.

[robrocing]

this sucks

[GinnyFrings2]

When I see Scott dancing 2:30 - 2:42.... hmmm, I miss Axl... ;)

[zetka28]

@GinnyFrings2 Oh yeah that's so true...

[goatman6767]

not a bad video at all! scott did better than i was expecting (in a sense of scott vs. axel) but i think axel has him beat

[joseleoncio1]

that crowd suckkksss!!!

[lester5192]

why didn't they just replace axl? back then? who would care if gnr made another appetite album? without him?

[luanferreiradossanto]

O slax parece uma baleia

[rendestroi95]

@luanferreiradossanto slax???

/tah sabendo legal

[MrsBruh4]

he's fuckin' ridiculous dancin' -.-

FAGOT

[MrsBruh4]

LOUDLY pleeaseeeee =D

you can't even compare Axl's voice to this shit --'

[MrsBruh4]

this is a fuckin' imitation --'

[acdcrock93]

@MrsBruh4 And DJ Ashba wearing a top hat and attempting all of slash's moves isnt an impersation? Axl can go fucki himself right now

[MrsBruh4]

@acdcrock93 I prefer the Old GNR but I love the New GNR too, ok?

And I love Slash but he is a motherfucker now :c , he doesn't even reconsider returning to Guns 'N' Roses !

You and Scott are insignificant, you could suck Axl's dick -.-

[MrsBruh4]

WARNING: This comment it's just to insult Velvet Revolver and Scott :D

Scott = fugly slut

Axl = perfect rock singer ♥

Velvet Revolver suck !

byee*

[2271608]

Its a guns n roses but without axl...

[Redrenso]

wtf his voice is almost the same as axl's. if someone would let me hear this version with sound only you'll think its guns n roses

[RedShadow27]

@2271608

Velvet Revolver - No Axl

Guns N Roses - No Slash, Duff, Izzy, and Matt. No Guns N Roses.

[2271608]

@RedShadow27 yes man... (Y) and no steven adler... :/

[GunsNRosesHardRock]

Scott = Faggot

[emoboi311]

what hat is scott wearing though i always wondered about the red one

[dgenerated]

I don't get it?? Scott is simply doing a cover..He is NOT impersonating Axl, nor is VR PRETENDING this incarnation is Guns!..Just enjoy the talent kids!! =]

[456smotpoker]

ok scot may not have the voice that axl does but i mean seriously who could sing like acl no1 but i believe he does a damn good job,of course i wish gnr would get back together but velvet revolver has more original gnr members than gnr does ....

[davecobain22]

@steamcapoeira

Very well put

[4everRock666]

fucking hell, stop bitching about scott, if you guys love axl so fucking much, watch Old GNR Videos

[shelley9000]

@4everRock666 I agree!!! But it's funny-I found a couple FANTASTIC live ones from back in the day-I go to watch them a week later and THEY'VE BEEN REMOVED! So disappointing because they were really good.  From just before G'nR made it big. For some reason I think Axl had something to do with it; and if that's true then he IS an idiot!! So many people would have seen them and became fans through that!! Oh well. I think Scott rocks!!!!!!

[Merle1987]

It's a bit ironic to see a grunge singer singing this kind of stuff. A song about heroin that isn't all whiny and gay. Whodathunkit?

[dagman9]

if i heard this without knowing its velvet revolver and without seeing the video i would say its axl singing

[crysisgamer81]

damn stupid crowd.. they just stand there and do nothing. i wonder if they even listen to the music..

[act318]

@crysisgamer81 i was thinking the same thing dude...id be going apeshit

[13StoryFall]

lol have these covered every GNR hit?? saw about 9 covers, thats kinda sad

[toxin789]

@13StoryFall it is there old stuff

[yanno661]

@13StoryFall these hits aren`t only GNR hits ... a lot of them were written by Slash an Duff so they can play them whenever they want cause they are theirs

[13StoryFall]

@yanno661 they released them as GnR songs, i just think it's wierd that they would play so many of them, it just makes them seem like a cover band, it's like james hetfield leaving metallica but still playing "enter sandman" and "sad but true" every gig. i just think it's disappointing cos Velvet Revolver have their own good songs. i'm not trying to offend GnR or Slash fans, but i'm sure you can see where i'm coming from

[yanno661]

@13StoryFall you`re right velvet revolver have great songs but there are so many GNR songs that will be number one forever such songs will never be writen so it`s normal Velvet Revolver to play them because now GnR are only a name .. they aren`t the real GnR , for me Velvet Revolver are more GnR than Axl`s caraoce band ,it`s not fair only because of the fucking name these songs to be only theirs

[WhtMike2006]

@13StoryFall I feel you but Duff and Axl wrote or co-wrote quite a few GNR songs.