Janacek - Piano sonata 1.X.1905 - The Death (Part 2)

[lavagna75]

Ohh you all people are so inteligent and studied!! music is what you feel,,, if you think wile you listen, you are the death itself!!

[kiananmal]

I think it's beautiful. I listened to Firkusny's version and this one is better, in my opinion. It's an elusive piece and she does a great job.

[bitrille]

i'm discoverin' Janacek..

sa conception de la variation et du developpement dans ses oeuvres est intéressante j'trouve, et avant-gardiste même

[George6Cavendish]

Stop criticizing this extremely accurate piano player. What a depth!

[orlandoooo]

Haha ok sorry. Yeah I can't deny that she plays it well. Just a personal opinion on interpretation!

And I didn't mean to give this comment a thumbs down, in fact I didn't know you COULD give comments thumbs up and down! No idea how to change it.

[orlandoooo]

too fast, AND out of tune :/

[pianoface1983]

For me, the essence of this piece (the silent on the first beat) which is the "death" is lost in this interpretation. It becomes banal.

[cziffra1980]

There is not meant to be silence. The pedal marks are by Janacek.

[wkzh]

cool it's a bosendorfer piano! lol... it sounds as if the guy's walking into heaven and the birds come and eat his flesh from the dead body...