Haley Scarnato Audition

[JediWitness]

I love how gorgeous she is and sexy, but not in a slutty or stuck up way, kind of a beautiful, bring home to mom, girl next door way...definitely marriage material for sure. Then add that she is pleasant and has a nice personality and beautiful smile.. great package for sure!

[WinterWonder99]

Lol Randy totally checks her out at 1:35.

[Bornthatwayy]

Uh, she reminds me of Haley Reinhart, but Haley Reinhart is so much better.

[cheryblosen]

I love her pimple :)

[UROCKMYSOX249]

@cheryblosen u mean mole

[lester5192]

i saw her last night in vegas singing and was good...but the blond girl was better.

[twirlaholic1983]

Eh. Underwhelmed.

[headinthecloudz6]

I know everyone is going to hate me for this but I don't think shes that pretty. I mean she definitely not ugly but I don't think shes super pretty either. Good audition though.

[Mwahohoho]

I saw Scarnato perform at a breast cancer race for the cure. I didn't know who she was, I'm sorry to say, I haven't watched idol in a long time. But I was taken aback, she's excellent

[IdolReady]

the first week of the top 24 I hated her but then every week after that she was amazing... she shouldhave gone farther , as well as gina

[goddamnshawtsnapin3]

she has nice legs mmmm

[Warp2567]

My sister is in this video yay! She is the blond girl that was waiting for Haley to come out of the audition room. : )

[checkoutmyprofile]

Beautil voice and song! Good job Haley!:)

[antionidept]

Allison did this so much better

[movado212]

She is a great singer but I think I she should have gotten to at least the last 4 or 5

[redsoxgirl1986]

i didnt mind her -- but i feel as tho she wouldnt have made it through this season, like he amount of talent his past season-- idk it is kinda funny to think

[inukeifer]

She was my favorite on that season,I was upset when she got voted off.

[xxdimadima]

mmm....she went downhill since this moment

[BogataColombia]

Ok...lets be realistic...I mean some of these posted reviews border on ridiculous to insane...lol. .I'm sorry but it is what it is. she sucks. Simon said it all.

[FinalStrife7]

@BogataColombia It's not that she sucks. As Simon admitted, she has great control. She CAN sing, but what most people forget is that Simon's perspective is that of marketability. He role in the show isn't to judge a singer by whether or not they can sing but whether or not he thinks he could sell their album. Plenty of people can sing amazingly but don't have the sass required for a record contract. That's where his expertise comes in.

[IdolReady]

i loved her i miss her... this season sucks.... we need some of the older season castoffs to come and make this one good

[pittdepp1963]

carrie is much better

[beachgirl7984]

Carrie Underwood did it better :)

[nwedlehi]

of course

she is winner at 4th season

but she did it well

luv her

[KKalrocks]

I met her once she came to my school i asked her if she liked simon... she said no lol she sang 2 songs I feel like a women and merry christmas she was very nice and down to earth I have her autograph hanging in my bedroom.

[sassymuzik]

i think this is the best that she did on the entire show.

[hesterdabombdabomb]

hottest chick alive oh Haley

[mcph7415]

Honestly i dont get what everyone sees in her. Her face is very average. She may have good legs but i mean she only got goegeous when she got to hollywood and had all the makeup on but she is not that naturally beautiful.

[ger7878]

she's the best!! Really sweet and beautiful from the inside out. Her and Blake and Gina!!

Rock on!

[beyonce270891]

I LOVE HER

[pokethunderdude]

Wow. Her mom can really shreik.

I pretty much agree with the judges on this audition. She was very good.

[mileyemily2310]

she got really thin on the show after she made it through. she wasn't fat before, of course, but she definitely lost weight.

[shiazacfan]

zzzzzzzzzzzzz............

[jhsyodles]

That black outfit she is wearing is so adorable!

[piratepony101]

carrie underwood can sing the song a lot better than she can. But she can still sing it good.

[bradtfd]

i meet her at my cousin inlaw's wedding shes really sexy...i like her

[IckyVicky231]

i like her

[doubleDdog09]

simon's SPOT ON with his comments to her. i agree that shes okay and a bit cabaret and that you can't really say that she can't sing cause she CAN sing. lol

[AndrewSa888]

She's very good.

[brasileiro2010]

my personal fav. off the charts gorgeous, so sweet. she could sing to me anytime. imagine being in bed and waking up to her singing softly in your ear? wow. beautiful woman.

[KCfan7706]

she was soooo good at her audition.

if she picked better songs in the top 12 she probably would have made it farther.

[dxcenaclash]

Shes hot

[pinkerchaos]

she's so pretty =)

[oklahomaweather1]

I had never heard of Haley but I like her. Good control over her voice like Paula said, but also not very original like Simon said. But she can't say she can't sing, because this girl can sing, but overall she's good and has a good attitude.

[Blisster2]

she was good in the audition but got worse as the weeks went along

[TayLovesAsh]

she actually does have a good voice though/

[sparkler123]

bashers can go away i love haley scarnato <3

[neverkilladuck]

Never compare Carrie with Haley, Haley is not worthy.

[niecy55]

i dont like the way she sang this song..i think carrie underwood did it way better..

[xSoCalBeautyx]

HALEY=WHORE.

[anjoreyes003]

dont like it dont watch

[papaypopaye]

i think haley better than sanjaya! whats that sanjaya ability? he was so weird. sanjaya You suck.

[mjdesantos]

Hmm...Haley isn't that bad, I guess. It was just really disturbing how she wore such revealing clothes to keep her in O_O

[radguy18]

carrie did it better, carrie controled her voice so much better and i have no idea how simon said she wasnt unique and they put her through the next round, the top 12?

[antionidept]

they didn't vote her into the top 12, America did.

[Boyinsane101]

haley looks like a stripper!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Boyinsane101]

well most of the time!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Imforeverone]

PRivate dancer...DANCING for money...

[MikeMunoz39]

This is definitely just as good as Carrie's, if not better

[lalalamuleaccount]

I don't think it was a good idea for her to sing the same song as Carrie. But i love her anyway

[pary813]

carrie's audition with this song was so much better!!! Carrie rocks!

[Sammeh122]

i think she got worse as the compition got further in or maybe she was just against really good people and that made her look bad

[lgvetto]

she's not the best singer in the world, but it's reasonable she got that far.. I mean she's not bad, but not so good...

[spanishspices]

00:11-00:32

integrity!! :)

[sharelsss]

ok. i dont think i can sing any better, but she wasnt that good. like randy said, it was ok. nothing special.

[warningNOTokay]

She's really confident. =) She has a really nice voice too.

[CR65]

A beatiful girl with a lovely voice. I believe that she will go far.

[funkymunky2992]

she sux! at least now she duz!!!!!!!!

[CR65]

You're just jealous because she can sing and you probably can't. It's damn hard to make it top the 8 finalists like she did. You try and audition for AI and let see how far you make it.

[funkymunky2992]

NO IM NOT!!!!!! she can't sing for her life, and she only made it that far because she's really pretty! and i dont have a bad voice, u jerk!

[CR65]

Alright my friend there is no point in getting upset over something that is not going to get you or me anywhere so let's just leave it at that. Every is entitled to their opinion you have yours and I have mine. Have a good day.

[funkymunky2992]

Yes, that is true. Let's act like civilized human beings. Yup, I have my opinion and you have yours! You too. Sorry for calling you a jerk

[angelzz4you]

Wow she's actually wearing clothes...

[babiikay03]

Oh, get over yourself. Her outfits have NEVER been that revealing. I don't think so at all.

[angelzz4you]

Hmmm...You must wear the same slutty outfits then.

[funkymunky2992]

lol yea im sure she duz..