Oh God, perfect song for the companions, you used it beautifully and the scenes you chose and the effects and the pacing...simply gorgeous!! I've been creeping in your playlist for a while and posting your vids on my blog because I have to have it in one place so I can see it over and over again. Beautiful work. Thank you so much for sharing.
I love this song from BarlowGirls!! I sing with it all the time (did i just say that O.O)... Thanks so much for pairing it with the best show on the planet!!! <3 <3 <3
This was brilliantly done. I love the concept, the song, and the direction you tried to go with this video. I know you said it's "not your best work" but it's far and above a lot that I have watched. I think you did a masterful job. The only thing I would have changed was a bit of the quick scene-to-scene jumping, and made it smoother to match the mood of the music just a bit more... Nice job. Keep them coming.
You should not apologize for this video but I know what it is like to be your own worst critic. This was very well done! I think it is a great companion video and yes there are sad bits but I think the message you tried to convey came through very strong -- their lives are better because he was a part of their experiences. Looking forward to watching more of your videos.
I do not watch Doc Who or know anything about the characters. I am watching this PURELY on the production end - how you edited it, flow, content etc... You say it's not your best work but I am very impressed with the use of space, pacing and very subtle effects. I would love to know what you use for editing and how you did some of the effects. It was definitely NOT "boring". I don't care about the show and I watched it.! As one fellow editor to another, great job!
I love it how you showed each companion as having similar emotions...the equal comparison. The song is sad, yet hopeful. Best doctor who vid i've seen!
Very good! I like the quote at the end... reminds me of a song that I'm sad has never been done for the Doctor and companions... "New Way to be Human"
wow this is simply brilliant ! it takes a lot to move me now i have seen so many fan vids, but this went straight into my doctor who playlist....excellent !!!! X
wow that video was incredible..and the bit at the end wen she says "the doctor showed me a better way of living my life" was a perfect ending welldone 5stars!!
Wow! This is beautiful. I loved this song before I watched this vid but now I think I love it a bit more. Perfect editing. I can't say enough about this vid. 5+ stars and faved. I am also going to subscribe to you so I won't miss your wonderful vids.
I freaking love the way you use such a huge amount of clips all runnign over the top of each other, it gives the video such a flowing, interesting pulsing feeling, it really works so well! :)
*Sits dumbly at computer and stares at screen* what can I say to this?? Like wow... that was amazing!! I've said this before on your vids but i'll say it again! you never cease to amaze!
i loved it! very beautiful from its soft opening and closeups to its closing flourish and worldview! :)
so - don't you go saying it's not your best. cuz i got everything you were trying to say...and then some...from it. and it was magnificent! BRAVO!!! BRAVO!!! :) ~Sharma
Absolutly brilliant! I Love all the clips you chose and I LOVE that you hardly showed any of the doctor, just his shoes or shaulder. It was very effective. Great vid! 5* and *faved*
Wow now that was wicked! I don't really like the song but Istill rated this 5 stars because you're so good at capturing the emotion of BOTH the song and the characters! And your blending/overlays of clips is like nothing I've seen- with the transitions it's soo good! Lovely work hun, I always love a new vid by you!:)
Oh, that was lovely :) I loved the acoustic version of this song, it suited the mood of the video so well :D Your editing was great too :) Brilliant job :D
Not your best work? It's beyond brilliant! I've never seen a video like this, and let me tell you I'M LOVING IT! It's outstanding, and such a wonderful, orginial, superb idea! Absolutly gorgeous, and sad. The video made perfect sense to me, I love this video. Don't doubt yourself, it's wonderful! Amazing editing and perfect clip choices. Loved it!!!!!!!
Oh my goodness! I absolutly loved it! I have heard this song so many times and was thinking about doing a vid on it...but look....I don't have to now! Hahaha. lol. I really like the plot in the video as well. Nice job....deff. =D
That was just.. amazing, AGAIN! *Puts it straight in amazing-ness playlist, AGAIN* Well Done, It's brilliant and beautiful work. Extremely well edited, and your editing is so unique and I think it's just extraordinary. You are seriously THE best out there, keep up the good work!
THAT WAS BEYOND AMAZING HUN! I know I've said it before, but I'll say it again, THAT WAS YOUR BEST VIDEO EVER!!!! You've matched everything perfectly! This song usually makes me sad, but it made me actually enjoy your video more, I dunno why :) I adore your faster pace, yet it's still slow and simple with a simple song :) PERFECT! 5* and faved, for sure!! :))
as much as I love this song, I don't typically like vids to it, but I liked yours! 5 stars! Also, I noticed you mentioned how the song was so slow and you used the acoustic version of the song (which is slower than the original version). just an observation.
I was just reading your description and it said that Donna stopped being so selfish. I don't believe that Donna was ever selfish. Donna's "flaw" or "problem" was that she was insecure, and if there was any change in her it was that the Doctor helped her see how brilliant and special she truly was.
Oh, LOVELY. I love the parallel scenes and how well they all just flow into one another. The overall exploration of the companion's emotions was wonderful. The ending felt a bit...sudden? Unfinished? I'm not sure, but I got that feeling. Though I do love Rose's voiceover at the very end.
Really well done. The emotions, the editing, all great.
teccrzy1 2 weeks ago
What do you make these epic vids with??? I must know^^
Spuffy98 5 months ago
"No I cannot see you and I can't explain whyy" seriously, I can't this alternate universe stuff is too confusing!
athena2517 9 months ago in playlist music (sad)
Oh God, perfect song for the companions, you used it beautifully and the scenes you chose and the effects and the pacing...simply gorgeous!! I've been creeping in your playlist for a while and posting your vids on my blog because I have to have it in one place so I can see it over and over again. Beautiful work. Thank you so much for sharing.
borntobewilder13 1 year ago
Wow this is very breathtaking I cried
fandomoverload2 1 year ago
Truely beautiful
firelightjen 1 year ago
I love this song from BarlowGirls!! I sing with it all the time (did i just say that O.O)... Thanks so much for pairing it with the best show on the planet!!! <3 <3 <3
technofarmkid10 1 year ago
This was brilliantly done. I love the concept, the song, and the direction you tried to go with this video. I know you said it's "not your best work" but it's far and above a lot that I have watched. I think you did a masterful job. The only thing I would have changed was a bit of the quick scene-to-scene jumping, and made it smoother to match the mood of the music just a bit more... Nice job. Keep them coming.
scubadogg 1 year ago
LOVE THIS! You just got it so right!!
You reminded me of what's great about this show. Thanks a lot!
pwt3000 1 year ago
You should not apologize for this video but I know what it is like to be your own worst critic. This was very well done! I think it is a great companion video and yes there are sad bits but I think the message you tried to convey came through very strong -- their lives are better because he was a part of their experiences. Looking forward to watching more of your videos.
hoodatwhatzit 1 year ago
Wow, this was truly amazing - and very sad. The song goes very well with the video. You did a really good job there. :D
Servena2 1 year ago
Really fantastic!
MoonDarkCat 1 year ago
Great job, that was really great. Showed their emotions very well.
carcooncreek 2 years ago
I don't cry that much on principle, but this one really brought me to tears.
themadwriter 2 years ago
This is a different version to the one have on my ipod, is an acoustic version or anything?
nellytheninkynonk 2 years ago
so good i had to watch it twice
Itunesbabe 2 years ago
I do not watch Doc Who or know anything about the characters. I am watching this PURELY on the production end - how you edited it, flow, content etc... You say it's not your best work but I am very impressed with the use of space, pacing and very subtle effects. I would love to know what you use for editing and how you did some of the effects. It was definitely NOT "boring". I don't care about the show and I watched it.! As one fellow editor to another, great job!
sherrist1 2 years ago 8
Very well done. Lovely.
Bobsyermomsuncle 2 years ago
wow this is amazing! i love the feeling of the doctor just being a ghost on their life. this is beautifully made as well! well done! 5 stars!
AmericanWholigan 2 years ago
Very, very, very, very, very, very, no really, really, really nice and fantastic and lovely! Merci!
helow98 2 years ago
Great vid! Love it :)
AnnaMarikaCole 2 years ago
5 Stars! Fantastic!
What do you use to edit your videos? They are awesome. Keep up the good work.
TheBadWolfGames 2 years ago
Great song and very nice editting, although it was a bit dark in places, but I still think it was a beautiful vid!
Queen0ftheCastle 2 years ago
woah that is so good 5 stars
DalekProductions 2 years ago
wonderfully moving vid....and the song, fantastic !
topliff12345 2 years ago
I love the version of this song you used, I've never heard it before. Barlow Girl are amazing and so is this video! Five stars.
nellytheninkynonk 2 years ago
I love it how you showed each companion as having similar emotions...the equal comparison. The song is sad, yet hopeful. Best doctor who vid i've seen!
Twilight438 2 years ago 11
Very good! I like the quote at the end... reminds me of a song that I'm sad has never been done for the Doctor and companions... "New Way to be Human"
mstiltskin 2 years ago
This is really beautiful. What a great video.
JenMalli 2 years ago
OMG !!
You gave me chills ! :D
Your editing is beyond amazing & the clip choice is heartbreaking ♥
Gah, I love ur vids so much!!
lyraGW 2 years ago 2
I love this video! It's brilliant! What's the song called and who sings it? I really like it!
AngleofAshley 2 years ago
this is brilliant. also thanks for introducing me to a really good band. i love this song.
becky31cj 2 years ago
wow this is simply brilliant ! it takes a lot to move me now i have seen so many fan vids, but this went straight into my doctor who playlist....excellent !!!! X
topliff12345 2 years ago
wow that video was incredible..and the bit at the end wen she says "the doctor showed me a better way of living my life" was a perfect ending welldone 5stars!!
s0phs196 2 years ago
Zomg!!! This is bloody fantastic!!! Whatever program you use, you used it brilliantly! Its AMAZING!!! Loved it 100%!!!! AMAZING!!
daydreamrocker 2 years ago
Are you joking??? Not your better work???
I think this video was BRILLIANT!
It actually made a tear fall down...
Great job!
NerwenElendil12 2 years ago
Wow! This is beautiful. I loved this song before I watched this vid but now I think I love it a bit more. Perfect editing. I can't say enough about this vid. 5+ stars and faved. I am also going to subscribe to you so I won't miss your wonderful vids.
heroestwdw 2 years ago
Loved this :) You got across what you wanted to - a mixture of sadness and hope. It all fitted soooo well, brilliant.
Never heard of the song, I really like it, it was perfect for this vid x
skulblaka92 2 years ago
The editing was astounding, the music matched the story, a romantic tour de force!
s00stl 2 years ago
WOW.
piratewench92 2 years ago
I freaking love the way you use such a huge amount of clips all runnign over the top of each other, it gives the video such a flowing, interesting pulsing feeling, it really works so well! :)
FairyFlossHunny 2 years ago
wow im lost for words, that was just stunning so beautiful.
mchun 2 years ago
*Sits dumbly at computer and stares at screen* what can I say to this?? Like wow... that was amazing!! I've said this before on your vids but i'll say it again! you never cease to amaze!
RainWsker 2 years ago
Beautiful! I really liked the stripped down version of that song too. :)
chasingxxstarlight 2 years ago
Get high on this:
w ww.mysp ace.c om/olivortex
humanvynil 2 years ago
Oh my god. That was so sweet, and amazing. You have to tell me how you do that haha
radicalxxrachel 2 years ago
Omg, that was so fucking brilliant!!!
Can't stop watching it... Fantastic editing!
svetatimelady 2 years ago
omg that was amazing!loved it!
withintemptationrock 2 years ago
bon boulo comme dab
marie75016 2 years ago
Awesome editing. I've never seen something like yours. Best work ever. thanks for sharing !
tenarosa 2 years ago
I love this song but I've never heard this version before. The editing is just brilliant! I love it!!!
: D
TheDoctorsRose2 2 years ago
Wow that is brilliant :D
millie33433 2 years ago
totally heartbreaking,it's beautiful. *sob*
fReAKiinRuBy 2 years ago
i love this video it so cool and sweet
kt27rule 2 years ago
i loved it! very beautiful from its soft opening and closeups to its closing flourish and worldview! :)
so - don't you go saying it's not your best. cuz i got everything you were trying to say...and then some...from it. and it was magnificent! BRAVO!!! BRAVO!!! :) ~Sharma
moookiecrisp 2 years ago
wow. ur going to make me cry...
this is great!
hoppyiscute 2 years ago
Great video! Great song and great editing!
MintyJ 2 years ago
Absolutly brilliant! I Love all the clips you chose and I LOVE that you hardly showed any of the doctor, just his shoes or shaulder. It was very effective. Great vid! 5* and *faved*
THEpowerOFme 2 years ago
This is stunning !
xXxXxcozzaxXxXx 2 years ago
Really beautiful video ! I love it ! I always thought this song would make a perfect compagnions video !
Great job !
julizumi 2 years ago
awh, I love your videos, always so great and emotional:-) awesome;-)
SparkleLightning 2 years ago
wow this is awesome
i luv it
xoxo
BloodyDeath11 2 years ago
Wow now that was wicked! I don't really like the song but Istill rated this 5 stars because you're so good at capturing the emotion of BOTH the song and the characters! And your blending/overlays of clips is like nothing I've seen- with the transitions it's soo good! Lovely work hun, I always love a new vid by you!:)
gracefulangel47 2 years ago
OMG that was beyond words !!!!
AMAZING is not strong enough ! Your best work don't deny it !
Your idea was really original and I liked the fact you used all the companions !
Perfect work (as always) !
deustchtor 2 years ago
Oh, that was lovely :) I loved the acoustic version of this song, it suited the mood of the video so well :D Your editing was great too :) Brilliant job :D
jenskii 2 years ago 2
Oh wow!! That's gorgeous. I absolutely adore this video. Beautiful editing,
EvenstarEllessar 2 years ago
Not your best work? It's beyond brilliant! I've never seen a video like this, and let me tell you I'M LOVING IT! It's outstanding, and such a wonderful, orginial, superb idea! Absolutly gorgeous, and sad. The video made perfect sense to me, I love this video. Don't doubt yourself, it's wonderful! Amazing editing and perfect clip choices. Loved it!!!!!!!
OViolentDarkKnightO 2 years ago 2
this is your best work
why did u said this isn't
don't look down at your self ;)
i like your edits
they are awesome
this video is perfect
brilliant as the doctor said
by the way
whats the name of this song?
smartiedaphne 2 years ago 2
1 more thing
this video is a bit sad
being the doc's companion is a bit sad
smartiedaphne 2 years ago
ok now i know what's the song
smartiedaphne 2 years ago
That was lovely! I adored it! Such a nice job at portraying how they felt. Beautiful! :)
ilmmira 2 years ago
Oh, I love it. Each companion brought something to the Doctor and each one took something away from being around him. Well done.
CS1723 2 years ago
Oh my goodness! I absolutly loved it! I have heard this song so many times and was thinking about doing a vid on it...but look....I don't have to now! Hahaha. lol. I really like the plot in the video as well. Nice job....deff. =D
thedoctorsdonna 2 years ago
That was just.. amazing, AGAIN! *Puts it straight in amazing-ness playlist, AGAIN* Well Done, It's brilliant and beautiful work. Extremely well edited, and your editing is so unique and I think it's just extraordinary. You are seriously THE best out there, keep up the good work!
Thanks for the video, I absolutely loved it :)
Doctorwhofan001 2 years ago 2
O.M.G.
I think I just died
Seriously
THAT WAS BEYOND AMAZING HUN! I know I've said it before, but I'll say it again, THAT WAS YOUR BEST VIDEO EVER!!!! You've matched everything perfectly! This song usually makes me sad, but it made me actually enjoy your video more, I dunno why :) I adore your faster pace, yet it's still slow and simple with a simple song :) PERFECT! 5* and faved, for sure!! :))
HarryDoesntKnow 2 years ago 3
brought tears to my eyes
how can you think this is weird. i could never of think of a storyline like that it was amazing!
5 star and favourite
tomroxxxx 2 years ago
Perfect as always, thankyou for decidng to use all the companions too [Donna's my favourite, then Martha] __---{[Favourited]} XD
AllieX7 2 years ago
Incredible! Lovely editing once again and the song choice was perfect and really fit all three companions well :D
PirateTillTheEnd 2 years ago
One Word. Brilliant.
Aussiescopper 2 years ago
Really really brilliant. Amazing fades :)
sirius136 2 years ago
I can't believe you said this wasn't your best work!!! I loved it!!! You did an amazing job and I wish I was as good as you!!
harrypotterfan0993 2 years ago
FLAWLESS
beautifull as always
xxx
xXTardisDreamerXx 2 years ago
Stunning and beautiful =) I'm in love with your videos!
SarahxRoo 2 years ago
*___*
And you said this wasn't your best work?!
That was simply FLAWLESS. I can't stress that enough. You really do inspire me and I bet so many other vidders.
I just ADORE your layers. The all transition so smoothly! Wow. Just...wow. I love love love it!
Perfect plot, perfect editing and amazing song. :D
HeartPhantom 2 years ago
as much as I love this song, I don't typically like vids to it, but I liked yours! 5 stars! Also, I noticed you mentioned how the song was so slow and you used the acoustic version of the song (which is slower than the original version). just an observation.
MattyRoh07 2 years ago
OMG Analeian !
How dare you saying that it's not one of your best work ????
That was amazing, you made me cry again (je t'enverrais la facture de mouchoirs au passage ^^)!
Thanks so much for this vid!
lott35 2 years ago
sans parole...
it`s emotional...
I must say that your editing is in my top 5 from youtube:) I adore the colors...
~Florina bisous
adearerane 2 years ago
Whoa.
That's amazing.
I love all the overlays and stuff :)
It looks sooo fantastic.
Amazing jobb :)
HogwartsHonorRoll 2 years ago
Beautiful as always!
sunnytyler001 2 years ago
I was just reading your description and it said that Donna stopped being so selfish. I don't believe that Donna was ever selfish. Donna's "flaw" or "problem" was that she was insecure, and if there was any change in her it was that the Doctor helped her see how brilliant and special she truly was.
gigo518 2 years ago
Oh, LOVELY. I love the parallel scenes and how well they all just flow into one another. The overall exploration of the companion's emotions was wonderful. The ending felt a bit...sudden? Unfinished? I'm not sure, but I got that feeling. Though I do love Rose's voiceover at the very end.
gigo518 2 years ago
Not your best work? This is incredible :D
Such a brilliant idea and great editing :)
NightTimeWish 2 years ago
Amazing
I love your videos :D
xsamanthababix 2 years ago
I think this just may be the greatest video you have made so far.
I can't tell you how immensly powerful I found it and how much I loved every second of it. :)
AsarathWitch 2 years ago
OMG Anaïs !!!!
Wow, I am completely speechless !
You always know how to use perfect clips !!!!
I just can't wait to see your new work and each time you blow me away !
misscynthia17 2 years ago
Wow Amazing !
Specialisyou 2 years ago
AMAZING !!!
KotoriMendes33 2 years ago
absolutely breathtaking
fandomoverload 2 years ago
Aaaw. What a beautiful video. (As usual.) ;-)
Nyah86 2 years ago
Thank you so much ! I'm always glad to see you like the vid (I hope you manages to see it in HD though...)
analeian 2 years ago
Amazingly beautiful
englishstudent01 2 years ago
Thank you so much !
analeian 2 years ago
Aww, no sound :(
Looks good, though!
TheNextRoseTyler 2 years ago
Fixed ! I knew it would be a problem ! Damn YouTube ! I hope you'll like it (no HD yet though)
analeian 2 years ago
What can I say? Fabulous as usual, Dahling!
TheNextRoseTyler 2 years ago