@agrilledfish. You're right. It's bar 9 of the Trio section, clearly written C# but here played C natural -- at least, according to the score in the youtube version played (correctly) by Michel Beroff. Could be a mistake, or perhaps at this point the pianist was slipping in a cheeky signal of their personal preference for natural spring water over the sharp citrus-based fruit drinks, such as Hi-C, favoured by Stravinsky. We may never know.
Stravinsky wrote this piece after consuming a can of the carbonated soft drink "Tango". Other similarly inspired works include "The Sprite of Spring" and "Dumbarton Cokes".
It's a pretty subtle difference, the C sharp just makes it a bit crunchier. I wouldn't have noticed at all except I learned the piece recently. You can see and hear the C sharp in question in this video: watch?v=isCt1YqZiY4
Around 2:06, it's the top note of the third accented chord in the bottom right measure. (The C sharp is in the key signature)
Anyway, mistake or not, I think this is a fine interpretation of the piece. I used it for reference when I was learning to play it. Thanks for uploading it! Who is the pianist? I think you should include them in the credits.
@agrilledfish since it sounds like it *could* be right - but isn't - I would guess the pianist learned the wrong note. We must always be striving to avoid such learned mistakes.
this is not a really tango,this has the essence of european tango with the view of stravinsky.this is kind a joke on european tango,but the real tango is from argentina,thanks.
I love Stravinsky. Brilliant piece. I've never heard this one. I have a feeling that Astor Piazzola heard it a long time ago. I know Astor is Argentenian but he must have listened to this anyway. Thanks for posting this and broadening my horizons.
Ha ha, Your bullshit is wasted in here. I refer you back to what you said earlier: "Without irony most of music would dissappear". That would be to say MOST of Bach's music is ironic. Do you even know what irony means?
Or you are really that ignorant and educated. Read Moliere, Racine, Voltaire, shakespeare. They all said very clever and witty things and they didn´t end up dueling because they weren´t so stupid to react that way. John, find yourself some educated friends and start reading and learning how to think.
This is all a bad bluff, without humor or unfathomable stupidity. Too many Hollywood movies I suppose.
(17 de junio 1.882 - 1.971).. :)
2005andromeda 8 months ago
@agrilledfish. You're right. It's bar 9 of the Trio section, clearly written C# but here played C natural -- at least, according to the score in the youtube version played (correctly) by Michel Beroff. Could be a mistake, or perhaps at this point the pianist was slipping in a cheeky signal of their personal preference for natural spring water over the sharp citrus-based fruit drinks, such as Hi-C, favoured by Stravinsky. We may never know.
fremsley001 8 months ago 2
@SailorVVV. Oedipus RESQ, Pepsiphone ... the list goes on.
fremsley001 8 months ago
I was gonna flag that joke as inappropriate. In poor "taste". Lol.
cindyandrob 9 months ago
Stravinsky wrote this piece after consuming a can of the carbonated soft drink "Tango". Other similarly inspired works include "The Sprite of Spring" and "Dumbarton Cokes".
fremsley001 10 months ago 11
@fremsley001 is that a joke
SailorVVV 9 months ago
@fremsley001
oh wow... that's horrid!! But you made me laugh :)
ILuvNymphadoraTonks 8 months ago
enjoyable, ecclectic, well presented. the C issue was most probably a mistake.
jb0579 11 months ago
I heard it, and I reckon the C natural is a mistake. My two cents. Overall, a most enjoyable performance though.
mrnnhnz 1 year ago
we play this in my youth orchestra..! :)
thansax 1 year ago
This sounds like the performance by Michel Beroff.
ahthramnotro 1 year ago
too fast..
0sweeterthanyou0 1 year ago
@0sweeterthanyou0 it's a tango..
WachaDrop 1 year ago
now I wanna write a tango
alex2east 1 year ago 2
Who made that picture at 0:07?
Kurtlane 1 year ago
i just saw the new Igor stravinsky and coco chanel movie and i was wondering does anyone know the names to the pieces played in the movie?
lilvl3 1 year ago
Great performance!!! Pity, you don't know the name of the pianist...Thank you for posting!
elena11d 1 year ago
my grandma plays this x)
yea, she rocks
MeeTpAradize 1 year ago 6
thank you for this music!
sesspleftocore 1 year ago
At 1:58 the pianist plays a C natural instead of a C sharp, I wonder if it's a mistake or if he had a different version of the score?
agrilledfish 1 year ago
@agrilledfish
...
I'm not sure I hear what you're talking about. It sounds in key to me, but I don't have the score, so you may be right...
MothmanCometh 1 year ago 13
@MothmanCometh
It's a pretty subtle difference, the C sharp just makes it a bit crunchier. I wouldn't have noticed at all except I learned the piece recently. You can see and hear the C sharp in question in this video: watch?v=isCt1YqZiY4
Around 2:06, it's the top note of the third accented chord in the bottom right measure. (The C sharp is in the key signature)
agrilledfish 1 year ago
@MothmanCometh
[comment continued]
Anyway, mistake or not, I think this is a fine interpretation of the piece. I used it for reference when I was learning to play it. Thanks for uploading it! Who is the pianist? I think you should include them in the credits.
agrilledfish 1 year ago
@agrilledfish hello, i have the 2 pianos score arrangment and it's c natural, just for the history
Ivorytickling 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@agrilledfish hello, i have the 2 pianos score and it's c natural, just for the history
Ivorytickling 1 year ago
@agrilledfish I used to play this and although I don't have the music anymore it sounds wrong to me!
Pierlover 1 year ago
@agrilledfish
The Mercury edition shows a c natural in both measures 39 and 40. Is this the measure you are talking about?
ahthramnotro 1 year ago
@agrilledfish since it sounds like it *could* be right - but isn't - I would guess the pianist learned the wrong note. We must always be striving to avoid such learned mistakes.
codeman2008 10 months ago
Comment removed
GabrielLett 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@agrilledfish
I have also played c :) . But now I see it should be C sharp !
GabrielLett 6 months ago
this is not a really tango,this has the essence of european tango with the view of stravinsky.this is kind a joke on european tango,but the real tango is from argentina,thanks.
kaleidoscopio2006 1 year ago
Wonderful piece
CedricKristian 1 year ago
"Bach on the wrong notes" great quote description of stravinsky
otherjoe1234 1 year ago
Please, who's the pianist? However, a magnificent tango!
Barbapippo 2 years ago
Stravinsky was a genius. My favorite instrumental composer.
SnapeKid 2 years ago
I love Stravinsky. Brilliant piece. I've never heard this one. I have a feeling that Astor Piazzola heard it a long time ago. I know Astor is Argentenian but he must have listened to this anyway. Thanks for posting this and broadening my horizons.
LewisSmith 2 years ago
Perfect! Amazing!
Asiya31 2 years ago
I could listen to this music 1000 times without being bored !
lapinot21 2 years ago 23
@lapinot21 that's why i love Stavinsky's music . Unlike many other composers you never never what's going to happen next.
RediForKing 3 months ago
Y eso que no conoció al polaco Goyeneche
joakocai 2 years ago
Amazing!
pianistpedro 2 years ago 5
1:15 Why he got arrested?
Sikisija 2 years ago 9
He was arrested for "tampering with public property." His crime? He rearranged the star-spangled banner and played it in Boston.
Gotta love that freedom of speech they're always talking about.
MothmanCometh 2 years ago 13
He also brilliantly arranged "happy birthday to you" but I can´t find it anywhere now. Does anyone know where this little gem is?
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
@mrmolinodelahoz
Wow, that's news to me.
MothmanCometh 2 years ago
@MothmanCometh i want to hear happy birthday to you, where is it?!
predoje 1 year ago
he wrote it for pierre monteux
Jafuet 1 year ago
i had it on sony cd...it has title "greeting prelude"
Jafuet 1 year ago
Comment removed
BernardProfitendieu 1 year ago
Comment removed
BernardProfitendieu 1 year ago
@MothmanCometh haha! word
aasjazz91 1 year ago
really? :-0
suratvita 1 year ago
@Sikisija He was never arrested. He just got warned by the local police in Boston.
devlin20011 11 months ago
@devlin20011
lol Yeah, it looks like all they did was give a him good talking-to.
MothmanCometh 10 months ago
As much as I hate tangos, I love this sarcastic and ironic version by Stravinski who also smelled the cheap perfume in Buens Aires danse halls.
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago 5
The question is, do you love this piece in itself or because you hate tango? I liked La plus que lent by debussy long before I knew it was ironic.
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
Not sure I agree with you that the best music is ironic. I wouldn't consider Bach as ironic.
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
Ha ha, Your bullshit is wasted in here. I refer you back to what you said earlier: "Without irony most of music would dissappear". That would be to say MOST of Bach's music is ironic. Do you even know what irony means?
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
I'll take that as a no.
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
I'm not disputing what you say. I think I can learn something from you. In what way are Bach's recitatives ironic? Mr Irony.
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
Your idea of dissonance may be different to the next person. What do you mean by "unpredictable movements"?
John27346 2 years ago
Please listen to Stravinski¨s
Happy Birthday to You.
If that doesn´t do it, nothing will.
It can be found on YT.
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
Excuse me if I'm like a dog with a bone when it comes to Bach, but I do believe you are talking through your arse.
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
You're right. I'm humble that way. Unlike you, I realise there is much to learn. I don't bluff.
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
Comment removed
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
I said bluff, not fool, grandpa. There is a subtle difference.
John27346 2 years ago
Comment removed
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
What are you talking about? I never said that word before in my life up until two hours ago.
John27346 2 years ago
Back in Bach's time, people didn't need to be ironic because everyone said what they meant and an offensive person could be challenged to a duel. :)
John27346 2 years ago
John, I wonder if you are putting me on?
Or you are really that ignorant and educated. Read Moliere, Racine, Voltaire, shakespeare. They all said very clever and witty things and they didn´t end up dueling because they weren´t so stupid to react that way. John, find yourself some educated friends and start reading and learning how to think.
This is all a bad bluff, without humor or unfathomable stupidity. Too many Hollywood movies I suppose.
I wish you well in your search.
mrmolinodelahoz 2 years ago
Does that mean you're declining my challenge of a duel?
John27346 2 years ago 2
Great performance. Who is playing?
agatr 2 years ago 4
I love this piece!
OxiDim 2 years ago 19