But this song i'm listening is really bad... this is not Nightwish since tarja's leave omg... please just change the name of the band, anette can't be nightwish's voice
I love Annette's voice. She sings with a passion and a talent that most people can't imagine. She sings this song at an octave that befits her voice. Annette is not Tarja and she is not trying to be Tarja. I think that if people realized this they would stop bickering over who is better cuz neither of them are. They are different and that's all.. if you don't like it listen to something else
Anette doesn't deserve all this hate. She tries her best and she's a really good singer. Blame Tuomas and Tarja. They irreversibly fucked everything up.
@bentenx What he said. Tarja choose some fucked up boyfriend instead of Tuomas, which obviously made Tuomas unhappy. And also that Tarja's new boyfriend took over her, made her ask for more money, skipping a concert etc. So Tuomas didnt like that and they all decided to fire her. Tbh when in a situation like that, either Tarja or Tuomas would have to go, well obviously Tarja because Tuomas is the funder of the band and they only accepted Tarja cause they needed a vocal, and she had a nice voice.
@bentenx But notheless, anette is talented, got a nice voice. Tarja went solo, and doing it still as far as I know? Why don´t you Tarja fans go there, and leave nightwish alone if you're just a wannabe nightwish fan.
@Wellkiria Volvio a ser madre, entro en crisis varias veces y te imaginas los cambios que debio tener ahora que es reconocida y criticada en NW, pobre ademas, no tiene 15 años, pero ahora no se si has visto sus fotos recientes, adelgazo demasiado con puro ejercicio, me gustaria estar como ella a su edad
@NwDevotion Si me acabo de enterar la verdad como que no le puse mucha atencion a lo que pasaba con ella pero si vi unas fotos y se ve muy bien la verdad es que lograr bajar de peso tan rapido woo y pues ser madre y estar asi no cualquiera grax por el dato :)
Well, I heard this song with Tarja, and now with Anette.
Tajra´s performance - WoW! I had chills all over the body, I was watching it like o.O , and when the refren begun, I feel...hard to describe, but it was great feeling.Tarja was so powerful :)
Anette´s perfomance - Sorry Anett :) I see just girl, who is trying to sing, no emotions, no vioce... Nothing I want to have in my mp3 and listen every day,
@patka048 she also cant reach high notes,,, she sounds very terrible when she tries to reach tarjas notes and her voice cracks and breaks when she goes to high notes... she will be much more adored if she will be in the POP industry much prefer her than Lady gaga haha...
@patka048 Funny you comment on a video that is probably recored by a CRAPPY phone. You cannot compare a shitty quality video against a high quality video with Tarja. Anette is really good live, Tarja had her special voice but anette got has a good voice too. You're either A. Ignorant or B. retarded. Ofcourse you cannot compared them, BUT tarja isnt better than anette, just 2 different styles of voice and music. Nightwish isnt what it used to be ofc but its still nightwish and it still kickass.
@patka048 well you can have your personel point of vue you can like anette or not like her but please all people stop critic her and compare her with tarja tarja has very beautiful voice i admet it and i have seen the live with her version but make some realistic point we need change she made her time and now its time for anette so stop ciritics her because he done a hudge effort
@GothicAngel00100 Simfono! Bori na mu aresun i New-Nightwish (aka Popwish, lool) alla kamia shesi me tus Old-Nightwish akoma k na sigrinis tis dio bandes ine disgrace! ^_^ Makari na stamatusan epitelus na skotonun ta palia tus kommatia!!! Maresi i fonula tis Nettie ALLA mono sta dika tis pop tragudia k ohi stis Tarja! Vevea edaksi ankapios protima tus Nnw ine dikaoma tu ftani na anagnorizi to oti i foni tis Tarja in APIROS kalliteri K to oti i Nnw ine POP k ohi Metal!
@GothicAngel00100 Retarded immature kids, tarja was no better. Just different voice style. Anette is talented and got a good voice. The question is, wtf are you doing here? Go crawl back to your cave and listen to Tarja if you're so ignorant.
@GothicAngel00100 Because most of the tards here including you have have no taste in good music. Truth hurts indeed the truth is that anette is the new vocal in Nightwish and she is not doing any worse than tarja thats the truth. You guys are just too stupid and ignorant to see that. Hating on Anette becuz tarja changed to a bitch, she just had to go and anette is not doing any worse job singing, they just have 2 different types of voice and singing style also you guys aint true Nightwish fans..
@cythixx true fans support tarja it is obiviously!! 571 negative votes are not accidentally because someone forgot keeping pressing the i don't like button!!and this is my opinion i don't care what you say .i do not like annette singing for Nightwish.if you like her keep like her but you don't listen anymore a Symphonic Metal band you listen a POP band!!
@GothicAngel00100 Pop band? Were you born mentally retarded or did you fall out of the window of 7th floor? Dam you got some heavy brain damage. First, ye if you are a true fan of tarja than stfu and get the fuck off here and search for tarja on youtube, buy her CDs, are you really that mentally fucked you have to come to a video you don't like and hate on it? Or specific person? Tarja isnt gone.. Too me you were a fake Nightwish fan, because you ONLY cared for Tarja, anyways MARCO>ALL.
@cythixx that's my problem who i will support WTF i'm living on a free country i can do whatever i want and i don't think that i must asking you!!!go and torture another poor guy and fuck you!παλιομαλακα
@GothicAngel00100 Wow you really got some mental issues. If you support tarja only than get the fuck out of here, since you dont support nightwish and aint a fan of them than go watch some tarja videos and stop being so retarded. I dont give a shit if you live in a free country or not, you're still fucked up.
@cythixx i support tarja and old-nightwish deal with that and i don't give a shit what you saying about your annette!!oh and don't forget psychiatric clinic looking for you!!bye bye fucker!!
@GothicAngel00100 So you say Tarja is old nightwish? Its still Old Nightwish, just a new singer, and old singer gone. Still nightwish and if you don't support the rest than so be it, now go away and listen to tarja.
@GothicAngel00100 So now, please just go away if you don't support this band, because a true fan wouldn't hate on any of them. A true fan would support, now if you have nothing better to say than being stupid and ignorant against Nightwish than please STFU.
Not bad, but it's not like when Tarja sings it. THAT is when this song actually has some magic to it thanks to her voice (I obviously mean Tarja here)!
dios mio no puedo creer que sus vidas sean tan buerridas que lleven 4 años escribiendo comentarios sobre anette ella canta bien y si no les gusta pues no la oigan pero por amor a dios ya consigan algo que hacer
Bue, no deberian obligarla a cantar los temas viejos ya que no estan hechos para su estilo. Te guste o no te guste esta mujer, es asi. Y respondo a la pregunta de por que aveces se sigue viendo estos videos. Por que todavia en el fondo se cree que le podemos dar una oportunidad a la banda de que vuelvan a ser geniales; ya sea con o sin Tarja. Pero tenes razon, hay que dejarce de torturar con estos videos de los temas viejos xD!
this bitch needs to be shot!! fucking people that try to take over or remake already AMAZING songs and just fuck it all up....need to be dropped like animals they are... SO to you Anette ...piss off make other songs that are your own...YOU WILL NEVER COMPARE TO TARJA.....THE METAL QUEEN
que mierdaaa es esooo 77 por favor esta cuestion no es karaoke mi amor si quiere cantar karaoke vayase a un bar de mala muerte pero no cageeee mas esta banda por el amor de Dios
Está canción la hicieron con tarja ... y la canción está hecha para ella.. nightwish no es nada sin tarja .. perdio toda su gracia cuándo entro está mujer.
Esta Version de She is my sin, esta genial, me gusta mucho... y lo mejor esque Nett no trata de copiarle la version a Tarja, Anette hace su propia version, por eso la amo **
@lacrimaangelux Otra ves tu?? Se supone que no te gusta ya Nightwish!! Por que Mierdas sigues viendo videos que no te gustan, no seria mejor que te fueras a ver videos de Tarja y dejar de joder??
@lacrimaangelux jajaja parece q algunas personas no soportan la realidad de las cosas
y si crees que voy a dejar de expresar mi opìnion solo pòr q a ti te molesta vete al carajo o puedes ir a escuchar a tu estupenda cantante con la voz mas editada q una cancion de reggeton
I think Anette is a good singer in general, I think she's pretty unsuited to a lot of the songs made for Tarja because she doesn't have the kind of voice that can handle such range and the like. With this particular song, she had it, mostly, it was within her own range even though it wasn't from DPP. I don't know why she deviated from the normal notes during the refrain when she could've stuck to them. It didn't spice it up. >.>
the only thing i hate about anette is the fact that she changes some notes which doesn't really sound good for some of the songs, oh god, nightwish do sound so pop...but i still like them though and i like anette too..anyway, it's the band's ideologies that's keeping me following them..
Amigo realmente ja era , esse vocal naum tem nada a ver com a banda . Ja fazia algum tempo que eu naum ouvia Nightwish e agora topei com a vocal nova e posso dizer que naum tem nada a ver com a banda , concordo com o amigo de baixo R.I.P !!!
HAHAHA sure honey...Thats the EXCUSE more POPULAR for people who try to defend that stupid girl with no voice. but guess what? facts are facts and SHE SUCKS... NO ONE CAN SING THIS SONG ++ -BETTER - ++ THAN +++ TARJA +++.. Thats all!
@UltravioletSlave "she sucks, Stupid girl with no voice" ? seriously? that im afraid, is A BIASED opinion. NW is doing much better with Anette then with Tarja. Thousands of ppl still go to their concerts, and thats a fact.
DPP sold twice as much copies than the album "once" if she couldnt sing, then do you think Tuomas and the other band members would have chosen her? No they wouldnt.
@nunavutkid13 haha, I can sing so much better than Anette. she is just a GIRLY voice like Alicia Moore (pink), Avril Lavigne.. and that is all...absolutely nothing special... Nightwish lost the magic, and that magic was Tarja. you talking about sales? ok. if you use alot of new marketing.. even putting a BOAT on the concert stage thats so commercial, I don't care DDP, I like the instrumentals a little bit ( I accept the toumas talent).. and thats all cause I cant write more characters on YT XDD
@UltravioletSlave lol well can you sing better than her? You have to remember she has to sing like everyday at concerts. She may sing awesome one night, and bad the other night. Yes I agree, Tuomas has talent!! YOu know...you can listen to the whole DPP album without listening to Anette? Poet and the pendulum, for the heart I once had and the Islander are awesome instrumental. NW can still have the magic, just not the way your use too...
DAMN!!! on every fucking video!!!! shit shit shit! everyone saying the same shit ''tarja was better'' ''anette was not made for nightwish''... cmon... is there anything else to talk about? all i see is some obsessed fans saying they want tarja back...
@XaddictedXtoXmetalX maybe people say those things because they're true. You don't have to be an obsessed fan to feel that way. I'm just now discovering this group and I agree. This girl is not very good.
@lasktguy hey i totally agree with it... tarja WAS better... and i mean.... much better than anette... but if you check other nightwish videos we just see people mentioning that... it kinda sucks
@XaddictedXtoXmetalX, that's one of the annoying things about places like this. Thousands of people on it and lots of them voicing their opinion even though it may have allready been stated ...over and over and over.
@YouAreLost2 hey, I was just agreeing with the person. I never said I wasn't guilty of doing it. Of course I assume you're also guilty of the same thing. So Mr. Pot..here's the kettle.
@lasktguy I don't consider myself guilty of anything... lol! Of course people complain, it's normal to do so. I only find stupid that you complain about what you also do... that's all. :)
@lasktguy Lol... you may even find it stupid but still you don't let go of it! If it's so stupid, why don't you just ignore it?! As for the "over and over"... having in mind that I comented only twice you're really just over reacting and making it more then it really is... again, your complaining for no reason! LOL! You don't want to be criticized, you have a good way to stop it: stop posting! :)
@61n4L33 yo pienso que en la audicion, todas las chicas imitaban el estilo de tarja, y anette fue la unica que no se la daba de tarja y por eso la eligio xD
She really do not know how to sing, i mean what it means all that ajjjajjj??
And she try to look like pippi longstocking....I am very disappointed choice of singer.
They could have been much better to find.I do not understand how the general got a place. At least Toumas could do is to find singer with a stronger voice, thank god there is a lot of them.
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD! Don't kill my favorite song!! I'm begging you!! Anette really shouldn't sing Tarja's songs. For one they are way out of her reach because they were made thinking of Tarjas amazing voice power. She's doing her best (Anette), I give her that but why is it that they murder beautiful songs?!!
I don't understand this many dislikes. This is awesome :)
lflaviorochan 1 week ago
she is a kitten. tarja is a tiger!
kampia 2 weeks ago
q asco
VampiraSatanica 3 weeks ago
She is my sin is my favorite song from Nightwish.
But this song i'm listening is really bad... this is not Nightwish since tarja's leave omg... please just change the name of the band, anette can't be nightwish's voice
Dante785 3 weeks ago
anette sucks in this song ... its a tarja song ....
DarkCamelotTheBest 1 month ago 2
Shocking difference.
cnh2132 1 month ago
It's better this way. That's all I have to say.
mistermatt1986 1 month ago
Whatever you say.Anette's a great singer,and I adore her version.
NeuronMasturbation 1 month ago
barf...sorry but this is slaughter
tachius11 2 months ago
I love Annette's voice. She sings with a passion and a talent that most people can't imagine. She sings this song at an octave that befits her voice. Annette is not Tarja and she is not trying to be Tarja. I think that if people realized this they would stop bickering over who is better cuz neither of them are. They are different and that's all.. if you don't like it listen to something else
angelofmusic232 2 months ago 2
the better version is with tarja i thing
KimiWebmiss 2 months ago
îhhh
SimonaLady92 2 months ago
q daño me gusta anette pero esta cancionnnnnnnnnnn no vaaaaaaaaaaaaa la malograaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa :'( es una ofensa para tarjaaaaaaaaaaaa
NWTar 3 months ago
@NWTar Aver... ¿Quien escribió la cancion? ¿Tarja?
ThePriestessSymphony 1 month ago
que alguien tenga la caridad de enseñarle a cantar... suenas más rítmicas sus tripas con hambre..
manikmorta 3 months ago
que pesar esta bobita!!!!... nooo deje así.. mejor escucho evanecense.. sueña más poderoso!..jajajaja
manikmorta 3 months ago
Tarja / Anette discussion is senseless already years ago.
True Nightwish fans will support Anette until the end. Holopainen & the guys chose her, then we have to support their choice and value her.
Tarja always-complaining fans are just jealous cause Tarja was fired due her attitude. And that's all.
I Love Nightwish, I like Tarja, and obviously I like Anette.
metalartema 3 months ago
Give Her A break you guys , She's new and she's Trying , she might not be tarja
But She is as good as well
SchyteOFBODOM 3 months ago
WTF!? THIS IS HAPPY METAL!! >.<
aquillaSrb 3 months ago
eh
1malakian 3 months ago
I would like if the audience do the same like in this video!!! /watch?v=_hnxies4Wtk
Cracknigga99 3 months ago
@Cracknigga99 You got mental problems irl. Go fuck off and gtfo, you wannabe nightwish fan.
cythixx 3 months ago
Anette doesn't deserve all this hate. She tries her best and she's a really good singer. Blame Tuomas and Tarja. They irreversibly fucked everything up.
bentenx 4 months ago
@bentenx What he said. Tarja choose some fucked up boyfriend instead of Tuomas, which obviously made Tuomas unhappy. And also that Tarja's new boyfriend took over her, made her ask for more money, skipping a concert etc. So Tuomas didnt like that and they all decided to fire her. Tbh when in a situation like that, either Tarja or Tuomas would have to go, well obviously Tarja because Tuomas is the funder of the band and they only accepted Tarja cause they needed a vocal, and she had a nice voice.
cythixx 3 months ago
@bentenx But notheless, anette is talented, got a nice voice. Tarja went solo, and doing it still as far as I know? Why don´t you Tarja fans go there, and leave nightwish alone if you're just a wannabe nightwish fan.
cythixx 3 months ago
@cythixx How am I related to what you have said?
bentenx 3 months ago
@cythixx Oops, sorry, I didn't see your first comment.
bentenx 3 months ago
PHEJJJJ
extramentall 4 months ago
wow that's amaizing!! anette is soo good! =)
elwaen 4 months ago
Many songs she does much better than she's given credit. Not this one, however, sad thing :(
TheWatchtower24 4 months ago
patetic -.-
Pabloarriegui 4 months ago
I love how she is changing melody !
majomanak 4 months ago
And patetic.
Gaermanicus 4 months ago
Horrible.
Gaermanicus 4 months ago 4
Creo que es lo mejor ue he visto de anette , estaba super delgadita que le paso ??
Wellkiria 4 months ago
@Wellkiria Volvio a ser madre, entro en crisis varias veces y te imaginas los cambios que debio tener ahora que es reconocida y criticada en NW, pobre ademas, no tiene 15 años, pero ahora no se si has visto sus fotos recientes, adelgazo demasiado con puro ejercicio, me gustaria estar como ella a su edad
NwDevotion 4 months ago
@NwDevotion Si me acabo de enterar la verdad como que no le puse mucha atencion a lo que pasaba con ella pero si vi unas fotos y se ve muy bien la verdad es que lograr bajar de peso tan rapido woo y pues ser madre y estar asi no cualquiera grax por el dato :)
Wellkiria 4 months ago
hahahaha this si so bad it hurts.
sad thing is : she doesn't sing it any better in 2009 hahahah
they became so shitty now.
ISeeAnIdiot 4 months ago
Удалите это дерьмо, это жалкая пародия на Tarja Turunen
GreyChakal 4 months ago
D:
:°(
Yulivea 4 months ago
Agora em português claro, Ela é muito ruim!!!!!!
cezio137 4 months ago
es tan tan pero tan dulce esta version hhahahaha bien me gustabas mas en ALYSON AVENUE HEHE
ANDOUTLOVE 4 months ago
i'm guessing the rest isn't worth seeing...maybe she died...let's hope so :D
lilacinsd 4 months ago
Tarja, where are you?
crujesono 5 months ago
Жуть!!! Без Тарьи исполнить She is My Sin лутше бы и не пытались.
GrazhdaninMilion 5 months ago
Anette killed such a beautifull song with her poooooor voice. How can she shit on one of theyr best song ?
Kacicka999 5 months ago
Jesus!!!! She murdered the song completely!!!!
crizial 5 months ago 5
Well, I heard this song with Tarja, and now with Anette.
Tajra´s performance - WoW! I had chills all over the body, I was watching it like o.O , and when the refren begun, I feel...hard to describe, but it was great feeling.Tarja was so powerful :)
Anette´s perfomance - Sorry Anett :) I see just girl, who is trying to sing, no emotions, no vioce... Nothing I want to have in my mp3 and listen every day,
thinking how is Anette awesome live
Nightwish just isn´t what it used to be.How pitty
patka048 5 months ago 31
Comment removed
angelsdoweep 4 months ago
@patka048 she also cant reach high notes,,, she sounds very terrible when she tries to reach tarjas notes and her voice cracks and breaks when she goes to high notes... she will be much more adored if she will be in the POP industry much prefer her than Lady gaga haha...
angelsdoweep 4 months ago
@patka048 hope she burns out and totally never come back... it will so nice w/o her.
angelsdoweep 4 months ago
@patka048 Funny you comment on a video that is probably recored by a CRAPPY phone. You cannot compare a shitty quality video against a high quality video with Tarja. Anette is really good live, Tarja had her special voice but anette got has a good voice too. You're either A. Ignorant or B. retarded. Ofcourse you cannot compared them, BUT tarja isnt better than anette, just 2 different styles of voice and music. Nightwish isnt what it used to be ofc but its still nightwish and it still kickass.
cythixx 3 months ago
@patka048 well you can have your personel point of vue you can like anette or not like her but please all people stop critic her and compare her with tarja tarja has very beautiful voice i admet it and i have seen the live with her version but make some realistic point we need change she made her time and now its time for anette so stop ciritics her because he done a hudge effort
KimiWebmiss 1 month ago
τι ηχορυπανση ειναι αυτη??????
what the hell is going on!!!!
why she is still here???!!
someone must stop her!!!
GothicAngel00100 6 months ago 14
@GothicAngel00100 Hahahha dikio exeis!
MrNightwishFun 6 months ago
@MrNightwishFun Παντως σοβαρα καποιος πρεπει να την πυροβολησει!!
Βεβηλωνει το ονομα του συγκροτηματος και κυριως της Tarja...
GothicAngel00100 6 months ago 2
@GothicAngel00100 Entelws eidika thn tarja -.-
MrNightwishFun 6 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 Akoma kai egw thn exw :-p
MrNightwishFun 6 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 Ellinas e?? Sibasho!
TheFullmoonTraveller 4 months ago
@TheFullmoonTraveller ευχαριστω!!!!!!το ελεεινο ειναι οτι καποιοι προτειμουν το συγκροτημα ετσι οπως ειναι...στην ουσια προτειμουν ενα pop συγκροτημα...
GothicAngel00100 4 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 Simfono! Bori na mu aresun i New-Nightwish (aka Popwish, lool) alla kamia shesi me tus Old-Nightwish akoma k na sigrinis tis dio bandes ine disgrace! ^_^ Makari na stamatusan epitelus na skotonun ta palia tus kommatia!!! Maresi i fonula tis Nettie ALLA mono sta dika tis pop tragudia k ohi stis Tarja! Vevea edaksi ankapios protima tus Nnw ine dikaoma tu ftani na anagnorizi to oti i foni tis Tarja in APIROS kalliteri K to oti i Nnw ine POP k ohi Metal!
TheFullmoonTraveller 4 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 Retarded immature kids, tarja was no better. Just different voice style. Anette is talented and got a good voice. The question is, wtf are you doing here? Go crawl back to your cave and listen to Tarja if you're so ignorant.
cythixx 3 months ago
@cythixx The truth hurts very much i see!!Well if you check better I am not the only one with these comments!!And I think I everyone agree with me!!
GothicAngel00100 3 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 Because most of the tards here including you have have no taste in good music. Truth hurts indeed the truth is that anette is the new vocal in Nightwish and she is not doing any worse than tarja thats the truth. You guys are just too stupid and ignorant to see that. Hating on Anette becuz tarja changed to a bitch, she just had to go and anette is not doing any worse job singing, they just have 2 different types of voice and singing style also you guys aint true Nightwish fans..
cythixx 3 months ago
@cythixx true fans support tarja it is obiviously!! 571 negative votes are not accidentally because someone forgot keeping pressing the i don't like button!!and this is my opinion i don't care what you say .i do not like annette singing for Nightwish.if you like her keep like her but you don't listen anymore a Symphonic Metal band you listen a POP band!!
GothicAngel00100 3 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 Pop band? Were you born mentally retarded or did you fall out of the window of 7th floor? Dam you got some heavy brain damage. First, ye if you are a true fan of tarja than stfu and get the fuck off here and search for tarja on youtube, buy her CDs, are you really that mentally fucked you have to come to a video you don't like and hate on it? Or specific person? Tarja isnt gone.. Too me you were a fake Nightwish fan, because you ONLY cared for Tarja, anyways MARCO>ALL.
cythixx 3 months ago
@cythixx that's my problem who i will support WTF i'm living on a free country i can do whatever i want and i don't think that i must asking you!!!go and torture another poor guy and fuck you!παλιομαλακα
GothicAngel00100 3 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 Wow you really got some mental issues. If you support tarja only than get the fuck out of here, since you dont support nightwish and aint a fan of them than go watch some tarja videos and stop being so retarded. I dont give a shit if you live in a free country or not, you're still fucked up.
cythixx 3 months ago
@cythixx i support tarja and old-nightwish deal with that and i don't give a shit what you saying about your annette!!oh and don't forget psychiatric clinic looking for you!!bye bye fucker!!
GothicAngel00100 3 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 So you say Tarja is old nightwish? Its still Old Nightwish, just a new singer, and old singer gone. Still nightwish and if you don't support the rest than so be it, now go away and listen to tarja.
cythixx 3 months ago
@GothicAngel00100 So now, please just go away if you don't support this band, because a true fan wouldn't hate on any of them. A true fan would support, now if you have nothing better to say than being stupid and ignorant against Nightwish than please STFU.
cythixx 3 months ago
we all miss Tarja...
jeanlucasluc 6 months ago 5
Not bad, but it's not like when Tarja sings it. THAT is when this song actually has some magic to it thanks to her voice (I obviously mean Tarja here)!
zeldagirl1234 7 months ago
i m just wondering how is her voice after a concert!!!!!!!
evitahate 7 months ago
@evitahate I was wondering if she ever sucked a cock on occasion after a show..
astrolifter 6 months ago
dios mio no puedo creer que sus vidas sean tan buerridas que lleven 4 años escribiendo comentarios sobre anette ella canta bien y si no les gusta pues no la oigan pero por amor a dios ya consigan algo que hacer
Eddiehunter05 7 months ago
Bue, no deberian obligarla a cantar los temas viejos ya que no estan hechos para su estilo. Te guste o no te guste esta mujer, es asi. Y respondo a la pregunta de por que aveces se sigue viendo estos videos. Por que todavia en el fondo se cree que le podemos dar una oportunidad a la banda de que vuelvan a ser geniales; ya sea con o sin Tarja. Pero tenes razon, hay que dejarce de torturar con estos videos de los temas viejos xD!
FerchuTurka 7 months ago
this bitch needs to be shot!! fucking people that try to take over or remake already AMAZING songs and just fuck it all up....need to be dropped like animals they are... SO to you Anette ...piss off make other songs that are your own...YOU WILL NEVER COMPARE TO TARJA.....THE METAL QUEEN
aja44b 7 months ago
pop
andunusblick 7 months ago 3
que mierdaaa es esooo 77 por favor esta cuestion no es karaoke mi amor si quiere cantar karaoke vayase a un bar de mala muerte pero no cageeee mas esta banda por el amor de Dios
lacrimaangelux 7 months ago
O.o WTF?? OMG!
TheSgnarf 7 months ago
wtf???
alcosboys 7 months ago
sounds like a pop song hehehe
guidoangel 7 months ago
love tarja!!...
danielmetalsp 8 months ago
Está canción la hicieron con tarja ... y la canción está hecha para ella.. nightwish no es nada sin tarja .. perdio toda su gracia cuándo entro está mujer.
KATYATHRASH 8 months ago
This song completely lost its class with her. It sounds CHEAP.
Wistielyn 8 months ago
this song is only for Tarja!
Vinovnik01 8 months ago
Tarja forever......
popas7 8 months ago
Esta Version de She is my sin, esta genial, me gusta mucho... y lo mejor esque Nett no trata de copiarle la version a Tarja, Anette hace su propia version, por eso la amo **
NwDevotion 8 months ago
@NwDevotion que estupido tu comentario 77
lacrimaangelux 7 months ago
@lacrimaangelux Otra ves tu?? Se supone que no te gusta ya Nightwish!! Por que Mierdas sigues viendo videos que no te gustan, no seria mejor que te fueras a ver videos de Tarja y dejar de joder??
NwDevotion 7 months ago
@lacrimaangelux jajaja parece q algunas personas no soportan la realidad de las cosas
y si crees que voy a dejar de expresar mi opìnion solo pòr q a ti te molesta vete al carajo o puedes ir a escuchar a tu estupenda cantante con la voz mas editada q una cancion de reggeton
lacrimaangelux 7 months ago
she's looking like a hooker in this video. and sings like one.
thiago7000 8 months ago
estoy contigo cosmosyluna, ahora es una completa porqueria, es vieja ni canta solo ahulla
Valek666 8 months ago
Aqui es donde extrañas al viejo Nightwish ...
cosmosyluna 8 months ago
Just perfect...
Caos0828 9 months ago
Between 2007 and 2011 there was a BIG difference in her voice... Think that her voice is the same than 4 years ago is stupid... :B
reveprofond 9 months ago
Comment removed
xkinslayer 9 months ago
Comment removed
GrissyPink7y9 10 months ago
not as good as tarja shes better of singing her own songs then tarja's
darkDMCangel 11 months ago
Anette is really good singer and she has very good sound. but in my opinion it'd be better if she sing songs, that the band wright for her.
maribeetle 11 months ago
really.. she sucks.. Nightwish is not what used to be. :(
galayoona 11 months ago
I LOVE ANETTE ♥
NwDevotion 11 months ago
she has a really good voice but NOT for nightwish.. at least the ones i loved ONCE
wiltzer1 11 months ago
you gotta be fucking kiddin me.... this is NOT she is my sin..THIS IS ANOTHER SONG ;(
wiltzer1 11 months ago
ржака
TheTercel 1 year ago
I like Anette, in DPP is really good and she can sing song of others albums really well too.... but THIS ONE NO!, she destroy the song!
Dathir 1 year ago
I think Anette is a good singer in general, I think she's pretty unsuited to a lot of the songs made for Tarja because she doesn't have the kind of voice that can handle such range and the like. With this particular song, she had it, mostly, it was within her own range even though it wasn't from DPP. I don't know why she deviated from the normal notes during the refrain when she could've stuck to them. It didn't spice it up. >.>
OJtheModerator 1 year ago
LOL
Steelhead1986 1 year ago
and once more an epic song is dead.
ISeeAnIdiot 1 year ago
Parece un cover tocado en un bar. CHau,
AzUaChan 1 year ago
the only thing i hate about anette is the fact that she changes some notes which doesn't really sound good for some of the songs, oh god, nightwish do sound so pop...but i still like them though and i like anette too..anyway, it's the band's ideologies that's keeping me following them..
iamfoxynicole 1 year ago
Amigo realmente ja era , esse vocal naum tem nada a ver com a banda . Ja fazia algum tempo que eu naum ouvia Nightwish e agora topei com a vocal nova e posso dizer que naum tem nada a ver com a banda , concordo com o amigo de baixo R.I.P !!!
Tresenhorn 1 year ago
que malllllll
meruru82 1 year ago
Sounds pretty good, but not with Nightwish is Symphonic Power Metal, not pop rock sound sing pop rock at all. Let change the singer.
She Really is the SIN... R.I.P.
zamurai81 1 year ago
This is by FAR the best performance I have seen of Anette...I'm impressed o.o Wish she sounded like this all the time
mayohs06 1 year ago
At the end she looked like she wanted to...nevermind.
crush1st 1 year ago
Wonderful! Cant wait for the new album, and songs actually written for Anette's voice! Yum yum!
IKEAFTW 1 year ago
@IKEAFTW This comment is a sin.
belladarling222 1 year ago
Que fea version por diossssssssss
estebquilmes1 1 year ago
@estebquilmes1 Ya se!!!! No se que estaban pensando cuando la dejaron que la cantara. No mames.
belladarling222 1 year ago
@belladarling222 YA no es lo mismo sin Tarja....
estebquilmes1 1 year ago
@estebquilmes1 La neta no, ella era Nightwish.
belladarling222 1 year ago
Not bad...I've heard her sing old songs worse but I have to ask....why is she dressed like Avril Lavinge? I thought this was a symphonic metal band?
thevisualkeiguru 1 year ago
@thevisualkeiguru LMFAO SERIOUSLY. A million times seriously.
belladarling222 1 year ago
don't ruin it anette u just can't sing it .
OrionNebula101 1 year ago
To kurwa żart ??!??!? Jak tak to niesmaczny.
olecki75 1 year ago
She is not Tarja but...
Is she a bad singer?
NO! She is not
larsson1414 1 year ago
HAHAHAHAHA
my ears are crying, and my eyes bleed !!! ...
Abedilen 1 year ago
WHY????
God, WHY!?
Aaga223 1 year ago
calling her stupid is not fair... she is worse than tarja yes, but people, she was chosen to be the new lead
onenew34te 1 year ago
@onenew34te Yeps, you're right. Tuomas is the only stupid here!
YouAreLost2 1 year ago
"She just sing different than tarja"...
HAHAHA sure honey...Thats the EXCUSE more POPULAR for people who try to defend that stupid girl with no voice. but guess what? facts are facts and SHE SUCKS... NO ONE CAN SING THIS SONG ++ -BETTER - ++ THAN +++ TARJA +++.. Thats all!
UltravioletSlave 1 year ago
@UltravioletSlave "she sucks, Stupid girl with no voice" ? seriously? that im afraid, is A BIASED opinion. NW is doing much better with Anette then with Tarja. Thousands of ppl still go to their concerts, and thats a fact.
DPP sold twice as much copies than the album "once" if she couldnt sing, then do you think Tuomas and the other band members would have chosen her? No they wouldnt.
nunavutkid13 1 year ago
@nunavutkid13 haha, I can sing so much better than Anette. she is just a GIRLY voice like Alicia Moore (pink), Avril Lavigne.. and that is all...absolutely nothing special... Nightwish lost the magic, and that magic was Tarja. you talking about sales? ok. if you use alot of new marketing.. even putting a BOAT on the concert stage thats so commercial, I don't care DDP, I like the instrumentals a little bit ( I accept the toumas talent).. and thats all cause I cant write more characters on YT XDD
UltravioletSlave 1 year ago
@UltravioletSlave lol well can you sing better than her? You have to remember she has to sing like everyday at concerts. She may sing awesome one night, and bad the other night. Yes I agree, Tuomas has talent!! YOu know...you can listen to the whole DPP album without listening to Anette? Poet and the pendulum, for the heart I once had and the Islander are awesome instrumental. NW can still have the magic, just not the way your use too...
Well Idk what else to say..bye!
nunavutkid13 1 year ago
Está a 10000000000000 años luz de Tarja.
monsterarturoramone 1 year ago
it just sounds like a pop cover of "she is my sin"
Tarja is unbeatable
Lasdosconzeta 1 year ago
someone has a tomato?
edsilmac9 1 year ago
Wtf is the brunette from Tatu doing in Nightwish? Send the bitch back.
belladarling222 1 year ago
kurwa co to ma być!?
kijukiju123 1 year ago
*** sorry for my english
DafniNik 1 year ago
not bad... of course she is not as good as Tarja and i hate when she sings Tarja's songs but it's not very bad.. until 0:51 :P
DafniNik 1 year ago
DAMN!!! on every fucking video!!!! shit shit shit! everyone saying the same shit ''tarja was better'' ''anette was not made for nightwish''... cmon... is there anything else to talk about? all i see is some obsessed fans saying they want tarja back...
XaddictedXtoXmetalX 1 year ago 2
@XaddictedXtoXmetalX maybe people say those things because they're true. You don't have to be an obsessed fan to feel that way. I'm just now discovering this group and I agree. This girl is not very good.
lasktguy 1 year ago
@lasktguy hey i totally agree with it... tarja WAS better... and i mean.... much better than anette... but if you check other nightwish videos we just see people mentioning that... it kinda sucks
XaddictedXtoXmetalX 1 year ago
@XaddictedXtoXmetalX, that's one of the annoying things about places like this. Thousands of people on it and lots of them voicing their opinion even though it may have allready been stated ...over and over and over.
lasktguy 1 year ago 7
@lasktguy Well... funny for you to say that since you do the same... otherwise you wouldn't know this happens!
YouAreLost2 1 year ago
@YouAreLost2 hey, I was just agreeing with the person. I never said I wasn't guilty of doing it. Of course I assume you're also guilty of the same thing. So Mr. Pot..here's the kettle.
lasktguy 1 year ago
@lasktguy I don't consider myself guilty of anything... lol! Of course people complain, it's normal to do so. I only find stupid that you complain about what you also do... that's all. :)
YouAreLost2 1 year ago
@YouAreLost2 well I find it stupid that you keep going on over and over about what I'm doing so maybe you could just knock it of.
lasktguy 1 year ago
@lasktguy Lol... you may even find it stupid but still you don't let go of it! If it's so stupid, why don't you just ignore it?! As for the "over and over"... having in mind that I comented only twice you're really just over reacting and making it more then it really is... again, your complaining for no reason! LOL! You don't want to be criticized, you have a good way to stop it: stop posting! :)
YouAreLost2 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@YouAreLost2 would you just shut the fuck up already.
lasktguy 1 year ago
only one word-SUCKS
chopantura 1 year ago
Tarja is hotter.. lol
Fawx90 1 year ago
Tarja forever, anette sucks >_<
Lucasuhi 1 year ago
@Lucasuhi OHHH YEAHHH!!!
herinfernalmajesty27 1 year ago
she's hotter than tarja xD
AaronHolopainen 1 year ago
WTF???.... Anette is killing NIGHTWISH...what happen? why?... bah. Tarja is THE SINGER.
carlostheone2007 1 year ago
Anette's voice... hurts me. REALLY bad. It's like the song of an evil Siren who wants to drive you insane, who ALSO happens to have throat cancer.
TheMarg0r 1 year ago 2
she doesn't sing different than tarja, she just CAN'T sing. these are very different things.
livesontrial 1 year ago 15
tarja sings it a lot better... well... to compare of course...
tarchee26 1 year ago 2
-.-
xZauXx 1 year ago
Que horror , quien sera el bastardo que le dijo a esta mujer que podia cantar, que manera de perder la dignidad.
61n4L33 1 year ago
@61n4L33 yo pienso que en la audicion, todas las chicas imitaban el estilo de tarja, y anette fue la unica que no se la daba de tarja y por eso la eligio xD
AaronHolopainen 1 year ago 2
omg.... what is that ?;/
RevolutionGirl17 1 year ago
no no no please u suck anette tarja ur the best come back
MrSarkastiko 1 year ago
I'm crying now! ;( horrible! Tarja come back pleaseee
Madzia34882 1 year ago
Anette shouldn't sing Tarja's songs. It's really bad idea...
GwiazdaWieczorna 1 year ago
Her voice is terrible :(
syl3984 1 year ago
She really do not know how to sing, i mean what it means all that ajjjajjj??
And she try to look like pippi longstocking....I am very disappointed choice of singer.
They could have been much better to find.I do not understand how the general got a place. At least Toumas could do is to find singer with a stronger voice, thank god there is a lot of them.
Roxannda 1 year ago
jajajajajajajajajajaja look at the rating
chopantura 1 year ago
what a shit, this reminds me a college band
nieowlolsurf 1 year ago 2
dejate de joder... ahora nightwish es como evanecence ?
Symphox85 1 year ago
EPIC FAIL XD
MajinLao 1 year ago
This is the one Tarja song that Anette sounds okay singing IMO...comparec to most of the tohers, she's actually okay here...
MadameChristie 1 year ago
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD! Don't kill my favorite song!! I'm begging you!! Anette really shouldn't sing Tarja's songs. For one they are way out of her reach because they were made thinking of Tarjas amazing voice power. She's doing her best (Anette), I give her that but why is it that they murder beautiful songs?!!
tora15 1 year ago
For God's sake do not sing this song, you're destroying this som.Tarja back the love of God
ValentinaKowaslki 1 year ago
I really love Anette, but I prefer Tarja about singing this song.
turkey9494 1 year ago
I have to agree with most of the people here. This girl shouldn't sing this song. I'm sure she's a good singer but she sounds really bad doing this.