Added: 4 years ago
From: rockduo
Views: 115,493
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (323)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The first power balad.

  • Amazing... no lip sinking!! pure, WOW!!!

  • Love the hair, Karen.

  • I love you Karen. This was your greatest moment. Beautiful.

  • Well ... first pop vocal ballad to use rock guitar ;-)

  • Pure unadultered talent without all the bullcrap that is around today!!

  • Beautiful voice!

  • I LOVE KAREN CARPENTER, GOOD MUSIC FIRST AND GOOD TIMES... A DIFFERENT WORLD... LOVE KAREN!!

  • SHE WAS SO NICE AND NORMAL so SO SO TALENTED. I miss you Karen. Thank you RIchard for keeping her voice with us for nearly 30 years since she passed. And to see her singing this live, even though she is nervous about public performances, well it's just wonderful to see it really turn out so well. I was very young back then so I didn't know what i was watching. Thanks to who ever posted this clip . WOnderful

  • Nixon music

  • Wow! Richard had an ARP Odyssey? That's a new one on me!

  • Goodbye to Love = 1st ever rock ballad

  • @roscoegino Yesterday--By The Beatles/1965........and.....As Tears Go Bye-The Rolling Stones/1966 were the first real rock ballads,check 'em out......

  • @frankty67 those were regular ballads in the genre of rock n roll. i meant rock ballads as in ones with rock guitar.

  • @roscoegino

    Its confusing i guess---Would 'Dream On' 1973 be considered one of the first real ballads?

  • @frankty67 but Goodbye came out a yr. before Dream On. No one had ever introduced hard rock guitar to a ballad before Goodbye to Love. And then years later, groups like Journey made a fortune off of them! LOL!!

  • @roscoegino

    I never knew there was a difference between like Early Beatles rock ballads and the later 'rock GUITAR ballads'. But I think you're right. Because Im 55 yrs old I always thought those early Beatles songs were rock ballads.So the real rock guitar ballads really took off in the early 80s with the REO-Hi Infidelity singles, and like Journey hits? And then every other 'Hair Band" had to have they're own personal little rock ballad.... Isn't rock and roll great!!??!!

  • @roscoegino The solos and structure of Goodbye to Love have always reminded me of McCartney's Maybe I'm Amazed (1970).

  • 5:54 Karen even point out Tony at his solo part. I love Karen, she was and still is the best singer ever!!!

  • I'll bet she was pissed that she didn't get to drum and they had that awful looking drummer.

  • @christo930 that's Cubbie from the Mickey Mouse Club all grown up on drums. Check out Part 3 of this where Karen drums

  • @tubiebrother The Mickey Mouse show was pretty much over during my youth. I was very happy to see her on the drums in part 3. Karen was a pretty good drummer, but is far more known for her beautiful voice.

  • @christo930 It was over during mine too but i saw some reruns for a little while. Karen was a great singer and a great drummer. Very very talented person. One of my all time favorite voices, if not the favorite. I'm glad I could direct you to the number with her on drums.

  • @tubiebrother I had already seen it by the time you replied, but I still appreciate that you did it, thanks!

  • @christo930 You're welcome!

  • Such a rich and pure voice, unmatched.

  • Absolutely pure golden voice and talent that we so rarely see in a lifetime, she could sing anything! Truly one of the greatest voices of the twentieth century!

  • Karen has the most beautiful voice I have ever heard, bar none. It is such a shame that she had to die of anorexia. She ranks right up there with all of the true greats. Better by far than any performer today. She had grace, style, and talent.... F T REST.

  • Goodbye to Love -- what a jam!!

  • Is she so polite and sweet she vows everytime the audience applauded her song to begin with...great entertainer GOD must be glad to be her among his angels...

  • they wanted to put out a "squeeky clean" and wholesome image in contrast to

    other artists of the day ... i agree with everyone her voice has a beautiful quality.

    but with the appealing to middle america combined with a bit of tendency to lounge music tastes... they come of a bit saccharine and cheesy.

    one wonders if karen had subscribed a bit more to the ideals of that era (authenticity, feminism, revolution) perhaps she might not have killed herself in pursuit of conservative ideas of beauty

  • @PlaneEater funny comment .......it's simple ,they were ahead of their time

  • @PlaneEater Too many bong hits dude? Fuck your hippie idealism. Hendrix, Morrison and Joplin were great examples, eh?

  • @sqweezel now now why can't we appreciate both? Does one type of music have to be an enemy of the other? LOL with the dead examples you cited tho.....

  • @sqweezel now now why can't we appreciate both? Does one type of music have to be an enemy of the other? LOL with the dead examples you cited tho.....uh but then Karen died too so not philosphically sure what to think.

  • her way of singing should be studied by today's music "divas".they all oversung, sustaining notes and doing unjustified, un-called for and un-necessary vocal runs every time a line's sung.

  • I don't think she had her 23rd birthday yet that year, and her voice was so full and mature even by then; always astounds me.

  • Probably the best act ever on Johnny Carson...

  • What a shame - she had a one in a billion voice and was pretty but they were packaged so wrong. But then again this was the early 70s, which was an odd time.

  • This is a good song,they sure do not play music like this any more

  • @SandyInOhio1000 so true, but kids today would call it oldies or disco and so on. music like this doesn't exists anymore (except on CD's or Youtube) unless someone decides to try it again and see what happens.

    I have every record they made. I loved the Carpenters and still do.

  • the purest voice. brings a calm to my heart when i hear her voice. Gone too soon

  • AMAZING !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!

    

  • Always fun to watch Cubby O'Brien on the drums too... Little bit hyper on the kick drum here, but a treat nevertheless... Insert as many Karen superlatives here as you wish, she was a timeless and incredible talent. Wish we still had her...

  • Great voice, Great band, Great medley !!!

  • Quite a rockin' group!

  • get a load of the Kustom amps on the back! hahaha!

  • check out that vinyl LP

  • 23 years old and every square inch of her is GORGEOUS!

  • I OBJECT!!!

    The cameraman totally blew this one!

    When it came time for Tony Peluso's famous guitar solo, Karen purposely stepped out of the camera's range so the focus would go to Tony. The cameraman didn't know what to do and zoomed in to Richard!!

    He finally gave us a small glimpse of the solo being played.

    RIP Karen.

    RIP Tony.

  • @philipcarol - It was probably the director in the booth that didn't get it right. The director sees all the camera inputs on various screens in the booth and directs the switch operator as to which shot to put on the air or on tape.The director is also responsible for telling the camera operators what shot to take for future selection. Most likely there was a camera on Tony at the time and another one on Richard. The director chose Richard's camera instead of Tony's. I hate that too.

  • @philipcarol Good catch lol. She knew to slide off to the side. Good job Karen, too bad the camera man was asleep at the wheel. Guy was a good guitarist, a little slice of the Carpenters Rockin Out.

  • @philipcarol actually, the director of the show calls the shots. 3 studio cameras cover all angles and the director relays his choice of shots to the technical director controlling the switcher board. If it's anyone's responsibility, it's the director's.

  • @philipcarol That was a great solo too!

  • @philipcarol It wasn't the cameraman who blew it -- it was the director who called the wrong shot. Or at least didn't have a camera directed at Tony. ...Rowby

  • so sad I am crying as I watch this

  • I dont think i ever heard her miss a beat or a note. Greatness.

  • One of the prettiest and most natural singing voices I've ever heard. She is sorely missed, today's music is garbage.

  • WOW!!! how can something I've heard many times still leave me speechless?? Man I miss her!

  • Jesus.. She's singing live here.. Karen makes it look so effortless.. Amazing talent... Can't believe 28 years ago the world was preparing to say its final goodbye to her and her voice... I want to go to Karen's tomb on the 30th's annerversary if nothing else to finally pay my respects to her..."

  • Freedom of choice, baby. It's our own self-destructive behaviors, towards ourselves or others, that causes world-wide pain. We can chose to do it, or chose not to.

  • wow i love watching this

  • Thanks for posting this piece of history. Karen's pristine voice is a gift from God to be sure, but I think few people give due credit to Richard Carpenter for his writing and arrangement skills, and the lush, complex background vocals he composed and sang.

  • @davefarrar, If this is a gift from God and God decided to take it away, then God's an asshole.

    I think these are artists who worked long & hard to create beautiful music. This is the result of hard work. Why do people give credit to an invisible man when it suits them and don't give credit to the invisible man when he allows genocide, starvation and terrible atrocities happening now & historically.

  • @casyatbat God has His reasons for all He does, and all those terrible things will be made right...but only in His timing. Meantime, He did let me know that Karen is alive in Heaven, and she knows shes loved. :) Wait for the Resurrection, she may sing for us again!

  • @MasterAceman123456, Maybe, what about the other things that God allows like genocide, starvation and terrible atrocities.

    You seem well meaning & respectful so I'll say I am one of those who had was religious as a child. But as I see the world today it appears to be that there is no God or he doesn't mind seeing man suffering.

  • @MasterAceman123456 Keep telling yourself that....

  • You just can't beat that awesome medley. Oh, for what might have been...

  • You can count on one hand the number of American singers who have such a distinctive voice you know them immediately when you hear them. Karen Carpenter is one of them.

  • I love seeing Karen & Richard with their band as you really see their pure joy of singing, performing and playing their instruments - like a rock group! It's like a jam sesssion, instead of just KC & RC, themselves, as we mostly see in most of their music videos.  They rock!

  • As you can tell from my username............. I am a HUGE fan of CHARICE from the Philippines. She is an unbelievable talent...I mean beyond anything EVER for her or the generation before her.

    However, there has NEVER..............nor shall there EVER be a voice like Karen Carpenter's. She was "one of a kind".

    I had a crush on her.. I was just a boy in the 70's when I watched her on TV.

    NOW I know why!!!

    Karen....................my GOD what a voice, U will always be my angel.

    I LOVE YOU.

  • My older brother was a huge fan back in the 70's (he's 10 years older than me) but I never appreciated them. Looking back, I missed out. Her voice is pristine.. Beautiful.. And the songs so heartbreaking.. Miss you Karen..

  • I'm 66, been a musician all my life... I sing gritty to bel canto, and play a few instruments. I never appreciated her at the time when she was with us. She sings so beautifully... interpretation and all that. When she hits those low contralto notes out of nowhere... aren't we grateful we still have some of her.

  • @checagou1340 ditto that - I'm 63 - so hip back then! No time for pop sugary group like the Carpenters. How great they were.

  • Miss her

    

  • Karen live in our memory,for ever.

  • Karen live in our memory,for ever

  • Another one of Gods one time only gifts to us, what can you say about that voice, its milky smooth.  God Bless you karen, we miss you very much, heaven must have needed a voice in their choir.

  • 12 days later they were in Nashville, Tennessee in concert and I had 3rd row center tickets! Was 13 years old and will never forget the anticipation of that evening.... or the depression afterwards that ot was over... I always had looked forward to the next time I would see them live - an event that sadly, would never occur....

  • Confession: When I was a teenager, and these two were becoming famous, I thought they were NOT cool. Typical teenage arrogance-what an idiot.

    Now I'm weeping at the beauty of their talent. I wish I could see what she would have been doing if still alive. What a crime! She would have been 60 by now.

    Gosh! Have I changed?

  • @M0ofi32012 Yes, you've become smarter and wiser. But you could see it in another way. They weren't cool--they were extremely talented, legendary musicians. The term "cool" is simply beneath The Carpenters, and youth can't often grasp such concepts because the young tend to live just for the moment. "Youth is wasted on the young." It takes some level of maturity to appreciate the unadulterated beauty of The Carpenters' music.

  • This was back in the days when you could either do it or you couldnt'. No technology like Pro Tools and Auto-tune to fabricate mediocre talent into superstars, like there is today. Karen was the real deal. Richard, too.

    This is a live performance. How many of today's 'talent' would risk their manufactured image on national TV???

  • The first time I heard this song was in 1972 I was stationed on Guam it was the theme of a prom dance I was invited to.. man it was heaven beautiful ladies and listening to music like this... what happened to the world.....they say everything goes in a circle...can't wait till it gets back to this music.....thanks for posting this treasure..

    Barry

  • Fucking blinding performance and great lead guitar at the end too.

  • If it's a consolation to anybody (as it was to me), there was never and has never been any article written anywhere which described Karen as "fat," "chubby," or any thing else of the sort. No manager, critic, agent, etc. ever called her that either. It's become an urban myth which has become the "truth." Her disorder primarily was the result of her removal from behind the drums.

  • rRichard was so young and cute!

    : )

    He orchestrated it all! He's so talented.

  • Karen doesn't just sing these songs: the expression in her voice seems to perfectly interpret them, as well. Don't you feel like she is feeling every word she sings?

    Sometimes I feel like she had heartache deep in her soul and that's why she sings them so well. Kind of sad....

  • @karenaperville She died from anorexia, so I have no doubt that she had some skeletons in her closet and was able to put that in her singing.

  • This is one of the most haunting songs ever written. I can't imagine anyone but Karen Carpenter singing it, either.

  • God - what a voice!!!!

  • I love how Karen leaves the scene to let the band play. I noticed that nowadays there's no solos in songs. In "Masquerade" there was a flute and piano solo and saxophone solo. Nowadays I don't hear a small guitar break in any song or a piano break, sad.

  • omg what a voice!

  • Comment removed

  • @catholicpriest1 , you are fucked up, your the one that needs to go on a diet, hope it kills you.

  • Great session. They were a fantastic group who worked so hard for perfection. They achieved it on so many levels. Karen's singing was always spot on. Thanks for the memories.

  • Really, just superb...I don't know what else to say.

  • Karen's voice never gets old..it's perfection in its purest form

  • And Richard's genius made all this possible. More #1 hits in a row than Elvis and the Beatles. Can you imagine Michael Jackson and Carpenters collaborating?

  • @georgemcclurelive It was Karen, not Richard, who was the star of the group. And Richard and their mom resented it.

  • [Karen Carpenter] She was a bright star who graced our shores for a short time. Now she has returned to the stars from whence she came.

    Her voice was so perfect that I never thought there was a real person who created it. Now I see her fragile frame failed her and I'm heartbroken. - gm

  • Karen YOU are that SUPERSTAR you talked about when you were on the radio and I am that helpless fan!!

  • Cubby was a real hotdog on the drums. He added too many extra snare shots on the upbeats and extra cymbal crashes. I guess Richard and Karen approved of his style. I much rather have Karen's jazzy style on drums.

  • The great thing about KC is that her "live" voice improved as she got older.

  • Can't help it. Every time I hear Karen sing I get choked up.

  • What amazing talent, a voice you can listen to forever. Who didn't love Karen

  • RIP Tony Peluso.

  • Never had seen that before...love her so much. Goodbye to Love, indeed.

  • richard doesn't get enough credit for guiding karen's voice. he really sheparded her talent.

  • @roscoegino - Sorry I don't agree. Take the first song here, "Superstar" - the recording is the first take, and the first time, Karen sang it, from a lead sheet. That kind of talent doesn't need a hand....(and she was a musician herself, playing the drums, so she had her own instincts and relationship with music aside from singing...) What' you are hearing, is a gift....and those kind don't come often enough.

  • @Alvin4NY Of course it'sundeniably KC's rich alto. But it was Richard who told her she could sing. She did not know until age 16 or thereabouts. She just started off playing drums, didn't sing until Richard asked her. Then he and co-writer John Bettis would fit songs to her vocal range. It might be KC singing but both needed each other 100% per cent.

  • Nothing but beauty .... A treasure

  • Contrary to what many people think, The Carpenters were perhaps one of the coolest bands back in those days. Their music was never contrived, it was timeless, in a class by itself. Musically they were so gifted. Quality is everything. Quality is always cool, and The Carpenters were the epitome of quality music.

  • @mrshinyshoes I am a fan of the carpenters, but to call them "cool" in any sense is silly. They were adult contemporary and not popular at all with the youth of the time.

  • @christo930 Yes, but they were definitely "cool" with the adult crowd! ;)

  • @mrshinyshoes To the extent that any adult can be cool:)

  • @christo930 Hey, you're talking to one! 

  • @christo930 They didn't bother to cater to the youth of the era. They did their own music on their own terms. To me, that's what "cool" is.

  • @Rudy61287 Fair enough. I lost my ability to be cool a long time ago. Once you pass 30, it's all over.

  • @christo930 after all of these years, if my friends would look at my albums and see a carpenters album in my collection, I would say it was my sister's but now I'll admit they were mine. I loved them then and I love them now!

  • RIP the excellent Tony Peluso -- Karen now has some of her old musical company up there to jam with. They really rocked the Tonight Show together.

  • @Iwakuni8 they sure did.

  • @Iwakuni8 What? When did Tony die?

  • @bsbncandey Two or three months ago. Great loss to music world, superb lead guitar, and, as far as I could tell, a very nice man as well.

  • @Iwakuni8 I know Richard must have been really sad about that.

  • I had this album! I was in 7th grade and 13 yrs old!

  • tony peluso  you rock!!!!!!!

  • Great performance. Really builds at the end. How often do you see that kind of spontaneity in seasoned pros like they were?

  • check it out at 4.26-4.40, the players were changing instruments. Besides Karen & Richard, the other players are also very talented musicians. Impressive.

  • Camel Toe at 1:44!

  • @jupitermoon10011 Idiot!

  • The Carpenters' music will last because of the pathos in Karen's voice and in her life, like Judy Garland. Richard's amazing musicianship are the perfect frame for it. And the weird Young Republican/Wedding Singer look they presented adds a surreal eerieness.

  • "It's nice to know somebody loves me" - who couldn't? What a sweetheart! I can't imagine being the happenstance audience on the Tonight Show that night, when, "oh, by the way, musical guests tonight are The Carpenters!"

  • The timbre in her voice is astounding...really, when i was a teenager i secretly loved the Carpenters, but couldn't tell anyone cause Zeppelin and Sabbath were top of my list back then. But her voice always sent shivers up my spine in a beautiful sort of way...

  • Funny, I actually have the album, Johnny was holding in his hand--it was the first viynl record I ever bought.  I became an immediate fan of The Carpenters after listening to their "greatest hits."

  • Ok I have to admit it. Love her performance. love, really love her voice... but hate her hair style.

  • Love her hairstyle. And yes, she was a real lady. R.I.P. KC!

  • I love her modest bow to acknowledge the applause. No showing off, no grandstanding. Lovely, lovely lady. And she was a lady.

  • ...and Karen all but disappears from the stage for Tony's guitar playing. What a beautiful class act she was.

  • @earcandy2008 true. not many would notice that. what's great is that toward the end of tony's playing, still off to the side, k grabs a tambourine and at 7:55 hits that little syncopated percussive accent on the upbeat along with mr. plaid jacket who adds a leg kick for emphasis. if they had just let her do her thing behind the drums she'd still be w/ us today.

  • nobody has anything close in her sound...it's timeless and totally original (too bad that's not happening much today)

  • ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!

  • great songwriting, arranging, and great vocals made the Carpenters unbeatable.

  • I love the growl in her voice when she hits lower notes. She is the best alto singer in the world. Karen marry me in heaven. I love you.

  • Karen's voice was amazing! That was back in the day when singer's actually sang LIVE! It's ashame she's gone.

  • This is a ridiculously good live performance. The change-ups are so slick and Richard's backing vocals blend perfectly.

  • Ann and Nancy Wilson of Heart. Both have great voices and always put so much feeling into whatever they are singing whether it's one of their songs or somebody elses. Ann reminds me a lot of Karen especially when singing something soft with a harmony from Nancy. I would have loved to see Karen try her hand at a good rock song like Quarterflashs Harden My Heart or Melissa Etheridges I'm The Only One or a good Pat Benatar song that would have been awesome.

  • Karen had a beautiful and elegant alto voice. The Carpenters was excellent 70s pop!

  • They had a kick-ass lead guitarist too.

  • @Ahzdiosh your rite

  • anybody recognize the drummer on this video? Give up? Why its little "cubby" from the original Mickey Mouse club. I think his real name was Carl O'brien. I'm glad these 70's videos can still be seen--they bring back sweet memories.

  • Actually, it was around now that someone made a comment like (his chubby little sister...) that set her on her way to the weightloss and tragic loss of life. And NO she doesnt look chubby at all here. she looks very normal. She doesnt even have a waist when she turns to her side. She is a women with hips! But not cubby at all!!!

  • It's amazing such great female singers are no longer around and that we are saddled with these Hacks that people are calling superstars. Esp when they Gypt the audiences with their lip synching. PPL Pay for concerts to see these fools Lipsync and they cannot even do that. Karen was a gem

  • she nailed to the wall every time what a beautiful voice !!! the voice of an angel !!!

  • there will never be another Karen...her voice is so distinctive and beautiful...brings bk so many memories! My favorite Christmas song is "Merry Christmas Darling" I still have all my Carpenter albums

  • Right!

  • J Coleman I am so with you.

    It made me feel better listening to Close To You and Johnny was a wonderful and brilliant host. Simplicity is greatness.

    I could just listen to Karen forever.

  • a funny moment w/the drummer @ 5:53, hard to tell but I think he loses hold of a stick. Then in the next shot you can kind of hear the drums fade out and then back in as Richard looks over w/a confused look for a sec. But in no time the music is back to sounding good. What pros!

  • her figure was so good her...

  • Agreed, Karen had the finest voice ever recorded.

    Anyone else here think she wanted to let loose a bit? Can you imagine her in a Dio type of band...just sayin lol.

  • Hands down my favorite female singer. Karen put so much into it. I'll never forget how "Close to you"

    made me feel better when I was a little kid.

    I love Johnny Carson what a great host!

  • I wonder how many people in that studio audience realized that they were in the presence of the greatest female vocalist in history?

  • @JP5466 amen to that! THE GREATEST.

  • @JP5466 Exactly. None of us really knew how good we had it back then. What a time!

  • Wow, Karen was totally hot here. I think it was the next year that her weight really started to drop. But she was 5'4 and I would estimate her weight here at 115. Perfect.

  • What a WONDERFUL and natural talent they both had! I miss her so.  I was first awakened to their music in the era of "Top Of The World"...remember it vividly. "A Star On Earth - A Star In Heaven"

  • Oh my goodness, how majestic a performer...gone way too soon. RIP KC...we miss u.

  • I get a little emotional hearing her sing these songs. They may be melancholy but they are great songs. She was such a great talent. I don't think she ever was ever comfortable in her own skin and with her talent; of course had anorexia nervosa. My high school girlfriend, late 1970's, had a sister who was like this. I remember how deathly skinny her sister was. Makes me sad. RIP Karen Carpenter.

  • I had such a crush on this lady. Her, Olivia NJ, and Linda Ronstadt!

    She was so flawless in my eyes.

  • Saw Karen and Richard with my aunt back in 75 at the Sahara hotel here in Las Vegas... flawless voice, sounded just like her records. Standing ovation at the end of the show!

  • One for the ages.

  • 12 days later, I saw them in concert.... Nashville Tennessee.

    A highlight oi my then 13 years....

  • what's wrong with her dress. She's beautiful.

  • Dress? What does dress have to do with anything when you have a crystal voice like her's? She worried too much about how she looked and ended up losing her life over it. Society is crazy when it comes to how performers "should" look. There are plenty of great looking females making millions "singing" that can't hold a candle to that voice. It's a dirty rotten shame.