Added: 1 year ago
From: WhereIsTruth
Views: 3,975
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (58)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The Quran does not say how to pray. It only speaks of varies positions, not how they all work together. How to pray is in the Hadith, as well as how the Quran is to be implemented in a myriad of areas.

  • @atwaterkent911

    peace to you,

    actually, the Islamic style of praying is not in the Hadiths. rather, it is the traditions of your fathers.

    if you took all the Hadiths about prayer and put them together, at best you'd come up with a very vague outline of the Islamic Salat...explained in Part 10 of this series called "Does the Hadiths Teach Salat"

    the reason the Islamic prayers are not in the Quran...is because they are not from Allah

  • @WhereIsTruth salam alikom, so then how are we supposed to pray? are the majority of muslims doing it wrong?

  • @mujahedeen1987

    wa'aleykum salaam,

    Allah doesn't consider anyone's sincere worship as a waste.

    if you like, i invite you to see Part 57 of my videos. it's called:

    "Prayers that are pleasing to God"

  • so what point are you exactly making about the hadith ?

  • @FM43ful

    peace to you,

    the point is: the hadiths are not from God, and in fact are condemned by God in the Quran.

    if you like, see Part 50 of my videos called: "What does the Quran say about the Hadiths?"

    that video is a compilation of Scriptures from the Quran

  • Research about Hadith follower IQ  /watch?v=rc2hzWIReic

  • Christians believe that Jesus is the Son of God.

    Muslims believe that Hadith is the Word of God.

    And when Allah is mentioned alone, the hearts of those who do not believe in the Hereafter shrink with aversion, but when those other than Him are mentioned, immediately they rejoice} [Al-Zumur 39:45]

  • @@-"Kulthum ibne Amral Attabi once collected a crowd round himself in a mosque & related to them - with full Isnad (chain of narrations) a hadith saying that he who touched the tip of his nose with his tongue might rest assured that he would never go to Hell. The audience showed their readiness to accept this forgery as a genuine (shaih) hadith - by trying to acertain their fate in this way"

    Ref: (Hadith Literature by: Dr. Professor Muhammad Zubayr Siddiqi)

  • @Factszz

    peace to you,

    yes, four parts in this series are devoted to quoting the ridiculous nonsense in these books. how anyone could try to defend such rubbish, and base their beliefs on this, is beyond comprehension.

    the sad things is...not only do Muslims look foolish for following such obvious fabrications...but these books slander Muhammad and repel people from the Quran.

  • @WhereIsTruth

    Sister: Mushrik [who seek a partner with ONE GOD] Hadithers are being brain washed from pat 1200 yrs. Their mind are not the minds of SICK-People. That sickness has made them stubborn. Only a revolution can correct that sickness of Hadithers. May Allah guide us and these Mushrik hadithers

  • @@"During the first century of Islam & also thereafter the various political parties, the heretics, THE PROFESSIONAL PREACHERS, and even a number of sincere Muslims, all made their contributions to the growing rubbish-heap of false traditions (Hadiths)".

    "They made deliberate changes to the text or the Isnad of certian Hadiths & fabricated others from scratch for the sake of sectarian gain"

    Ref: (Hadith Literature by: Dr. Professor Muhammad Zubayr Siddiqi)

  • Hadith books are the biggest conspiracy of Persian Zoroastrain against Quran and Islam. as per Quranic law, Who follow these books are Kaafirs

  • The fact of the matter is, those who say we dont need the messenger to make decisions or follow his teachings are simply liars and Allah replies to this in the Quran. Allah in the Quran doesnt just say follow the Quran and thats it. He also says that UNTIL they make you (the Prophet (saw)) the final decision maker, they dont have an atom of faith in their hearts, those who say we dont need the messenger when we have the word of Allah are lying to themselves.

  • @TheKap1an

    note how many times Muslims have to add (Muhammad or Prophet) in brackets when quoting Scriptures. why? because the Quran doesn't actually say Muhammad or Prophet. most of the time it just says Messenger. this is because most of those Scriptures did apply to Muhammad, but Allah presented the Scriptures in generic form, because they would apply to future Messengers in your midst. see Parts 56 and 71

    "You hurry to Allah! I am from Him, a Warner to you clear and open."

    Surah 51:50

  • @TheKap1an

    U are a brainwahsed ignorant idot. Hadith buks were invented by Zoroastrian Persian Hadith Imams 300 yr aft Prophet. So how Muslim followed Islam in those 300 yrs?. Hadith buk were invented by Parsi Imams to deface Islam & to do conspiracy against the teachings of Quran. In the final battle of Qadsia, Arab Generals crushed Persian Parsi Empire & Persian took revenge from Arabs by fabricating 4 millions hadiths that are heap of Lies tht Insult Prophet & Allah. U r a brainless donkey

  • And how the hell do the Hadiths slander him? Of course theres fabricated Hadiths, but theres a way to know if a Hadith is Sahih or not, just tell me this, have you studied usool-u Hadith?

  • @TheKap1an

    how do the Hadiths slander him? are you kidding me?

    have you watched Part 87 or the rest of this series?

    i have many people to speak to. i am not going to re-explain everything to you personally. watch the videos if you want the answer because this debate is over.

    peace to you

  • We are told that in the Prophet(saw) is the best example to follow, and we have direct chains of narration going down to him.

  • @TheKap1an

    the Quran also tells us that Abraham set the best example. also, that we are not to make distinction among the Prophets.

    in regards to just how reliable the chain of narration was, this is addressed in further episodes in this video series.

  • @WhereIsTruth

    The Quran explicitly states that in Muhammad(saw) is the best of examples for you.

    Can you show me where it says this for Abraham?

    Of course all the Prophets were noble men, but the difference is we have direct ''access'' to our Prophet.

  • @TheKap1an

    the Quran says that the Messenger sets a good example. this is what God says about Abraham too:

    "A good example has been set for you by Abraham.." Surah 60:4

    you do not have access to Muhammad. your fabricated Hadiths are condemned by Allah in the Quran, explained in Part 50.

    they are the source of the wicked slander against Muhammad, peace upon him, explained in Part 87.

    the Hadiths are a product of the jinn and wicked, lying men such as Buhkari, explained later in this series.

  • @WhereIsTruth

    ''they are the source of the wicked slander against Muhammad, peace upon him, ''

    What are you talking about? The Hadiths tell us all the details of our Prophet(saw), like how to pray, how to make Hajj, the details of heaven and hell, what will happen on Judgement day etc. etc. there is nothing wicked about this, we dont take the Hadiths as 'sacred text', as anything that contradicts the Quran is not adhered to. We have direct chains of narration going to the Prophet himself.

  • @TheKap1an

    you claim i know nothing about the Hadiths, then explain how i am able to put up so many videos about the subject.

    the Hadiths actually do not teach Salat, explained in Part 10.

    another Part in this series examines your so-called Science of the Hadiths...and four other Parts exposed the ridiculous lies in the Hadiths.

    i'm not going to go on in endless argument with you. you can watch the videos or not...i am not your guardian.

    peace

  • @WhereIsTruth

    Im not going on in an endless argument, and this is the last thing Id like you to answer:

    Pretend that there was no Hadiths AT ALL. Then how would we know the sort of man the Prophet(saw) was? How would we have an example to follow when we dont actually have anything?

  • @TheKap1an

    you have the Quran. if you follow it...then you are following the example of the Messenger who brought it.

    how many times it says "your only duty is to deliver the Message"..."you are not their guardian"

    if his only duty was to deliver the Quran, and he is not anyone's guardian...then there is not need for the Hadiths, which slander him.

    again, if you like, see Parts 50,70 and 87...or any of the four parts in this series that shows how much ridiculous nonsense is in the Hadiths.

  • @WhereIsTruth

    The worst thing is when people go around talking about subject like these when they havent even studied science of Hadith.

    The difference between Muslims and other religions is that we know exactly what were doing and why because we have exact narration.

    The source for Sharia law is 1. Quraan 2nd Hadith, as there can be cases that are not in the Quran, so it is reffered to the Prophet himself.

  • Maulana Aslam Jairajpuri (1882-1955) professor of Arabic and Persian said:

    "When Allah showed me the facts of Qur'an at that point I came to know the position of hadith in Qur'an, which is history of Islam. To consider the hadith as Islam is not correct. If they were in Islam, then Muhammad would also have left a written manuscript of these, like he did in case of Qur'an. For Islam, Qur'an is enough which is a complete book and in which Islam has been finalized."

  • now if what u are saying is truth...post all of my comments and let me give you so many other refrences as well...in which Allah said "follow the Prophet Muhammad PBUH"......

  • @pakdhartii

    i'm sorry...but i do not let people go on and on in endless debate on my channel.

    preach whatever you want on your own channel.

    peace

  • Indeed in the Messenger of Allah (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) you have a good example to follow for him who hopes for (the Meeting with) Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah much.

    ( سورة الأحزاب , Al-Ahzab, Chapter #33, Verse #21)

  • @pakdhartii

    God also says in the Quran that Abraham was a good example.

    we are to follow all of the Messengers, not just Muhammad.

    we follow the Messengers by following the Message from God they received...not by following books full of nonsense that were written hundreds of years after Muhammad's death after these rumors had been passed orally through many people.

    note: you had to put (Prophet) in brackets...that's because it is added.

    God is telling all who understand to "Say" this or that.

  • yeah God said to follow the Prophet (may peace be upon him). Meaning follow the Quran and Muhammad's sunnah. Yes, this is true. Hadiths HAVE been fabricated. But the prophet (may peace be upon him) said that his way of life, his hadiths will be fabricated but the Quran will always be the same. He said if one of you hears a hadith, know that if it contradicts to the Quran then it is not from me. But if it goes with the Quran and Islamic teachings it is from him .

  • @Adelown

    peace to you,

    where in the Quran does Muhammad tell you to follow his Hadiths that do not contradict the Quran?

    Allah says in the Quran that if Muhammad taught anything other than the Quran he would have stopped the Revelation to him and punished him.

    Surah 69:43-46

  • Asalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi , i understand where this brother is coming from in relation to some hadith but the consensus is in the book of ALLah where he gives many places to be obedient to the prophet just one verse is enough to clear this up. 4:59 those things that are in accordance with allah that come from his messenger R the true hadith

  • peace YUSEF976CM,

    you obey the Messenger by obeying the Message...the Quran.

    there are plenty of Scritpures that show we are not to follow fabrication, which is what the Hadiths are...fabrication and rumors.

    please see Part 50 of my videos called:

    "What does the Quran say about the Hadiths?"

    within these own books there are recorded commands from the Prophet to not write them.

  • Tirmidhi and Ibn Hibban quote Abdullah ibn Mughaffal that Gods Messenger warned: Oh God, Oh God! Refrain from using bad language about my Companions! Oh God, Oh God! Refrain from using bad language about my Companions! Do not make them the target of your attacks after me! Whoever loves them, loves them on account of his love of me; whoever hates them, hates them on account of his hatred of me. He who hurts them, has hurt m and he who hurtsme, has hurt Godhe who hurtsGod will punish him.

  • first of all ibrhim,

    those are not Scriptures.

    they are one person claiming what other people said. and most Hadith are someone saying what someone said someone said they heard the Prophet or his companions say. that is called a rumor, which will be addressed in an upcoming issue, God willing.

    also, of course the fabricators of the Hadiths would put statements in to make people think they were rejecting God if they rejected their fabrications.

  • @WhereIsTruth I BEAR WITNESS THAT THERE IS NO GOD BUT GOD!!! I love love love this video...all your videos...May Allah Bless your efforts and continue to use you to shine the light of truth into the vicious darkness of falsehood that is the so called "hadith." PRAISE ALLAH!!!!

  • peace grownupnaynay,

    yes...Praise Allah!

    Most Gracious, there is no god but GOD!

  • Autho billah, I have never seen a mor distorted translation of an Ayat.

    Do you actually understand arabic at All.

    May Allah guide you to the truth. I will react to this distortion of the text.

  • peace again Super,

    i am a Believer. Surah 49:14 10:103-106

    i pray many times a day, through out the day. i do not limit myself to 5 times.

    please see Part 57 called:

    "Prayers that are pleasing to God"

  • also I did learn that the prophet warned himself of hypocrites, those who will wish to fabricate the good word of god and the prophet. hence the science of hadith came as to verify the chain of narration, but unfortunately it did not bother to criticize or work on the body (matn) of the hadith itself. hence we have the main reference being the quran toward the hadiths we have today.

  • again brother,

    God's Words are to be our only source of spritual guidance.

    please see Part 50 of my videos:

    "What does the Quran say about the Hadiths?"

  • @WhereIsTruth how did the Quran reached us. Exlain that to the Crowd.

  • "This is a Scripture whose verses have been perfected, then made perfectly clear. It comes from a Most Wise, Most Cognizant."

    Surah 11:1

    "Praise GOD, who revealed to His servant this Scripture, and made it flawless."

    Surah 18:1

    "This Revelation of Scripture is from GOD,

    the Almighty, Most Wise."

    Surah 45:2

    "Those who strive, strive for their own good.

    GOD is in NO NEED of ANYONE."

    Surah 29:6

  • Salam alaykum.

    Most of the verses you seem to quote refer to speech in general not specifically to the sayings of the prophet beyond the noble quran. but answer me. How without the prophets life and his character and action could we not know how to pray, how to do zakat. how to behave morally since the quran mentions matters very broadly for its universal purpose, surely needed a guide of this scripture? and who better than its prophet?

  • wa'aleykum salaam almulla,

    Allah quite clearly says that the Quran is complete and fully detailed.

    Surah 6:114,115

    are you saying that it is not?

    God has told us how much to give...neither extravegantly, nor are we to be stingy. that amount is different for each person.

    as regards to prayer...the reason why your ritualistic, memorized prayers are not in the Quran...is because they are not from God.

    there are many examples of prayers in the Quran, please see Part 57 of my videos.

  • peace SuperSkiiLz,

    yes, and Allah also says in the Quran that Abraham was a good example, but we do not follow fabricated stories about him.

    the Hadith is very intelligently and carefully collected??

    well, as this series progresses the so-called authenticity of the fabricated nonsense called the hadiths, and the "science" of collecting them, will be exposed.

  • Dear Sister Becca ,

    peace be upon you and your family, i agree with what you had stated in this video. For we are to follow God's holy scriptures and that God alone is all powerful and all knowing of what we , humans never knew.

    For many have invented lies , from the Era of Moses , David , Jesus ( Yeshua ) and now Mohamed.

    Moses era = People worshipped calf

    David = People worshipped bull and fire

    Jesus = Romans worshipped him

    Mohamed = Venerated by so-called muslims

  • and peace upon you as well brother MDIS,

    may Allah bless you and your family with happiness and all that is good.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more