David Gilmour and Kate Bush - Comfortably Numb (Live)

[snidelywhiplash]

Wow. Kate is (not surprisingly) very very good for this song.

[patrycjabond]

love it

[10CPhil]

Wish I was there!

[copitosilva]

bella musica...tengo 39 AÑOS Y ME REMONTA A MIS 16 CUANDO ERA TODO ERA SOLO FUMAR

[TheBantamka]

that's absolutely fantastic! THANK YOU!

[leel66]

Awsome ..... love it

[flo15jo]

Oh boy, that was good.

[sroysr]

i like how you smothered the guitar solo with the drums and piano

[drdoutrina]

SHE IS WONDERFUL.

[brucep216]

been comfortable numb

[brucep216]

thats awesome

[FireGoddess08]

I Love Comfortably Numb, One of my Fav Pink Floyd Songs Ever! But with Kate Bush No, Her Style is so much different,

[MrDiamonds01]

vocal is a bit low but aside from that really nice job

[paulo70412]

nice



[yeswab57]

Excellent. My hat is off to the folks who recorded this, and to the poster for taking the care and having the fan-community-mindedness to make the mixing effort. People look at me funny when I take on a labor of love like this...

[drbas81]

kate is really much under tone :(

[provincianesca]

Tengo 48 años y escuchaba a kate bush con sus cumbres borrascosas y babushka y por el otro a Pink Floyd haciendo confortablemente insensible, y nunca hubiese imaginado que ambos caminos se juntarian alguna vez...

Los destinos de la musica son inescrutables.Esto suena bien pero algunos mamarrachos como Coverlade y Page ya lo hacen a uno poner desconfiado el oido.

Aun asi esto suena bien Gilmour nunca hizo boludeces.

[johnlen53]

słaba jakoś dżwięku

[MikeSargentOnline]

Wasn't holding your hand to David in the bible?

[abdounnour]

very interesting version, beautiful duo!

[KbcBerlin]

Sounds like somebody in the audience with a decent recording device , to me.. A lot of room sound, and a back of the hall .

[laggie24]

Outstanding melody, lyrics and not to mention Kate and David, the artists that shines like diamonds even when the sun doesn't shine!

A song that makes ya stop for a while and makes ya wonder about your own life!

p.s. the 4 individuals aren't only comfortably numb but also deaf millioners who flew away with themselves,ain't no emotions!

[liverpoolsammy]

A new twist to a classic song. Good to hear man :)

[fatoldsun76]

IT HAS BEEN RECORDED IN PARIS ON 2002. I WAS THERE AND IN THE END OF THE SHOW I WENT ON THE STAGE HOLDING THE HAND TO DAVID!! IT HAS BEEN MY MOMENT OF GLORY

[neagaritrance]

@fatoldsun76 How i envy you

[mollysangelique]

@fatoldsun76 i never adore stars you know they not better higher than me the only i adore will be ,my belovrd one man him i adore from loving him not david gilmoure i wouln,t need a hand talk about dance and music he needs to piss as you do

[WillShakespeare2007]

@fatoldsun76 - Yes I remember he told me some cunt got no stage and ruined the end of the show for everyone.

[celticpride67]

@WillShakespeare2007 he fucked it all up for everyone that night,i remember gilmore saying let go of my fucking hand im trying to play here,but thats the french for ya

[urbino08]

@fatoldsun76 lucky!!!!!!!!!!!

[Smashinz2002]

I've always thought that the versions of Comfortably Numb with a female lead singer were the most moving. . This is no exception. But my favorite version of all was sung by an african-american woman, name unknown to me. Her interpretation of this classic was brilliant and unbelievably moving.

[DavidHill333]

Poor mix.

[luxiniv320]

Love how the audience starts clapping and whistling when Gilmour starts singing..then shuts up in time for the second block. Sounds like floyd fans would rather hear the song than their clapping and whistling :D

[eb8931]

I found another couple of versions of the Kate Bush version of this song recorded from camera's or camera phones. The quality of this recording is a lot clearer, although the levels are very strange, I'm curious where it was recorded from.

[uplifter1000]

@eb8931

There are several here, seem to all have been recorded around the same time? One version was blocked (?!) but the others made it - go figure.

At any rate - very cool to hear all these unexpected duets :) xx

[shadowhunt86]

Gilmour not wearing a black shirt? I'm shocked.

[fntime]

This is NOT Kate Bush's song! I really like her, but this song

doesn't do it.

[TheEpicMusicChannel]

Ooh how lovely it is to click on a video and not see any comments about Lady Gaga or Justin Bieber! I love this version, I can't think of two better people to sing this song as a duet. Breathtaking.

[whillop]

@TheEpicMusicChannel You JUST fucked it up .

[Eragon9393]

@TheEpicMusicChannel

You sir, are an idiot.

[RobbJMcToo]

@TheEpicMusicChannel Well....now there's one.

[GameTableOnline]

@TheEpicMusicChannel Why did you have to go an ruin it by mentioning them? :)

[MatheusOliveiraRckr]

='D beautiful!!!

[VoiceOfGood]

If you love this music, you will probably like this guitar player I heard here on youtube ... just go to double you, double you, double you dot sound cloud dot com forward slash jeff underscore paxton ... and also at double you, double you, double you dot reverb nation dot com forward slash jeffpaxton ... check him out ... he sounds like Pink Floyd ... Peace :-)

[larryfrayne52]

Tilyaud is duality smellied backward, i like her hair.

[fedtho]

First and foremost: thanks fur uploading this!

I really don't see what is supposed to be wrong with Kate here... I just wish her voice was a little less drowned (Gilmour's is much clearer).

And guys, STOP using youtube as your pissing contest forum, PLEASE.

[MrGilteacher]

Kate you as goo as wine!!!

love you.

[MangledBizarre]

That one dislike is by Roger Waters.

[PHILRAWS]

@MangledBizarre good comment mate - from a Rog fan!

who wudda beleived it with kate bush though! - DECENT VERSION(ONLY DECENT - WE BOTH KNOW HUNDREDS BETTER) - but alright, ive always found kate bush strange(check out video for wurthering heights) - but gotta admit i'm warming to the woman!!!(not just because i admit i would!!)

[Dazzler59]

@PHILRAWS its not about the videos its about the music

[sonicgsxr750]

@MangledBizarre he has been back a couple more times.lol

[architecturalabdabs]

@MangledBizarre Non that was actually me, lol.

So 44 of you were wrong, as much as I love Kate, this can't be done by anyone other than Roger. :)

[grimbattalion]

yaeh! im viewer# 21000

[FunWithFungus666]

Roger Waters, is a countryside alliance, fox hunt surporting scumbag.

[aloneintheshadow450]

@fucktube74 I have Amused to death, it's a good album. I have the first album of Gilmour, David Gilmour, and Wright, Wet Dream. I prefers Wet Dream it's more musical and experimantal.

I'm just more open minded than you. I like all faces of pink floyd 'cause each era have his sound. And next Echoes was written by Pink Floyd and compose by gilmour and wright. Shine on too. I better know pink floyd than you. I listen more thant 150 bootlegs and my two favorites era are 70-71 and 94-95

[romber58]

@aloneintheshadow450

You are like any facist or small minded person who thinks that his opinion is more worth than anyone elses .

[aloneintheshadow450]

@romber58 I defends my point of view, if you do not like it it's your right but do not say stupidity

[fuckutube74]

Roger Waters was Pink Floyd

[aloneintheshadow450]

@fuckutube74 Wrong! Pink Floyd is Rick Wright David Gilmour Nick Mason and Roger Waters!

[fuckutube74]

@aloneintheshadow450 Roger Waters wrote most of the songs and lyrics for PF

without him they aint shit

[aloneintheshadow450]

@fuckutube74 David Gilmour and Rick Wright made the MUSIC of Pink Floyd, and Mason made the groove. Waters is not as good musician as Gilmour and Wright. Without them, Darkside will never be an The Wall will be a Crap

[fuckutube74]

@aloneintheshadow450 bullshit

Waters wrote most of the songs and lyrics

All the band memebers were essential and without waters Pink Floyd is crap

Amused to Death by Roger Waters was one of the best albumns ever made

but im sure a shallow guy like you would never understand what it meant

[irondaddymac]

huge kate fan.. this is not very good.. nice to hear her sing live nonetheless.. i don't blame her for not wanting to release this..

[7byseven]

I love how she sings it just like Waters how it should be.

[MazterGuitarz]

@7byseven

Yeah,almost even greater...

she'll fit but everyone (origin) is the orignal..

Maybe not..

still the same old song!

[mariosapm]

what were the original audience recordings made with? and where was each person located? did you do the mixing?

nice job

[einhov]

I've got no specific information about the recordings, I merely found them on the internet. I did the mixing.

[mimosf]

@mariosapm Kate Bush was David Gilmour's guest during a performance of Pink Floyd's "Comfortably Numb" at his Royal Festival Hall show on January 18, 2002. Kate sang the part of the Evil Doctor.

[shayanrafizadeh]

Wow