@potterati101 i was not comparing them i dont think you know what compare means. I was saying how in American mj brought a change in music similarly hemeash brought a change in india and atif brought it in pakistan. if i was comparing the two this what it would sound something likes this. MJ is a better dancer than hemeash that is called comparing. I am talking about how one person can bring a change to something.
@drinkyman2007 u r rite abt MJ bringing a change in pop music!
he has the most beautiful voice i've heard & also the music he made always had so many feelings. atif also is a gr8 singer & is 1 of my fav . but himesh is not 1 of dem so may b i didn't lyk the fact dat u gave his xample with MJ who i consider as the best!
@potterati101 Respond to this video... I am a big fan of micheal jackson so big that i learned how to dance like him but his voice was not has amazing as singer that lived in his life time. the reason he was king of pop is he had different vocal and style. which is what a real singer needs to have.farhan is a good singer but he is not the life of jal he is not the one that comes with all the ideas it gohar watch some of jal interview farhan admitted too that gohar plays a big role in band
@drinkyman2007 abt farhan & goher i wanna say dat i kno how important goher is 4 jal actually wat r v even talking goher ne hi jal band banaya hai. he is the 1 who produces such soul string music & in live performances he always plays with so much passion dat is y i said ki woh Jal ki jaan hai! & farhan's voice simply touches hearts!
u all watchers PLS STAND FOR ME as i am student of this school and i was there live during this show......!!!!!!!!!!! it was my carnival when i was in 9th...did u understand or contact me
who composed addat is as yet a matter of debate ....same can b said fr songs ..lik dil harey zindagi bheegi yaadeinand all .....ne ways both of moved on...and the magic tht atif and goher were able to create once in addat remains unconquered
well.. this song is originally sung and prepared by JAL the band.. and That Cheap ATIF aslam sung it after they have a clash in the band.. 50-60% songs which are sung by ATIF Aslam and based on STOLEN LYRICS.. and he Sung those songs for indian Movies with some stupid editing.. Besides.. this guy JAL.. got a lot of better nice and encouraging voice than that Commercial ATIF.
Jal ka her eik song Bakwas hai sale phatooo bhanchood Gando. Atif aslam ki copy and Atif Made a well desicion by quitting the jackass band Jal is bullshit
huh? oh wa' abt when atif stole all ov Jal's songs! huh? lamhe, Aadat, dil haare, rangoun main & the list goes on....... & letah he sells them for indian movies without carring that those songs were done ba jal!!! Atif is a LOOOOOOOOOOSSSSSSEEEEEERRRRRRR!!!!!!! NEXT THING U KNOE HE'S GONNA SELL HIMSELF TO AN OUT SIDER TOO.......
hellz yea!!!!!! did u hear atif's new songs? they suck big time!!!!! when on the oda hand, jal's new album is a hit!!!!! i love their new songs & especially Chup Chup!!! & also hamein itna pyaar & oooooohhhhhh Sajni!! guys, check these songs out!!!
lesitan jal makes better music and atif is a better singer farhan can never be as good as atif and atif when it comes to music can never make better music that gohar lets leave it a that i like atif and jal and when they split up it was sad day but they both are doing good without each other stop hating and comparing and live to like them both
@drinkyman2007 dats ur opinion! atif ki awaaz me woh sweetness nahi hai jao farhan me hai. but i agree ki he's gr8 2! but i'm happy dat dey split up cuz aisa nahi hota toh faran jaisa singer nahi milta humein!
Atif voice brings a different sound in music and great singer always bring something different. Great singers like Micheal jackson and,Himesh reshammiya. Mj and Himesh reshammiya both voice was not spectacular. But it was different and new. Farhan is a great singer and yes he is really good i love his voice too. but hes style is not anything new he has nothing different about him and its Gohar although is different in his music. And so far the majority agrees with my opinion
@drinkyman2007 i respect ur opinion but PLEASE don't compare MJ with himesh!
MJ is the king of pop aur himesh infront of him is seriously nothing. kisne bola ki MJ ki awaaz spectacular nahi hai! he hhas the most spectacular voice i've heard aur plz compare karna hai to kisi aur se karo. still i respect wat u actually wanna say. aur goher jal ki jaan hai aur farhan jal ki soul hai!
@potterati101 i meant to say gohar in his music is very diff and gohar is the reason why farhan is good without his expertise farhan would not be able to survive alone
listen to the part between 4.29-4.33 and then listen to that same part when atif sings aadat. plz dont say its the same coz its not. once uve heard them both, try singin them urself and i bet u'll find atif's version harder to sing to. for me atif is a more gifted singer.
i dont know who came up with aadat and lamhay but whoeva says that this guy has a betta voice than atif shud know that there was a reason y atif was originally chosen to be the lead singer of jal.
atif can definitely get the crowd behind him during live performances. if u dont believe me just watch his performance of aadat in london on youtube. its just incredible.
i really dont leave comments but think about where atif stands and where jal is... jal is good but if you compare both of them then there is no comparison whatsoever... jal is a band with good music as Goher got mature with time... if you go back, the song AADAT voice was atifs and guitaring and drumming was done by our very known musicians Salman Albert and Mekaal Hassan... Goher could not do it... so original music of AADAT was done by them... atif has voice of the millenium...
i love atif's songs. he is a really good singer and i am so proud that he is not Indian his songs are touching the soul.ant there are sooo many yaadain with his songs. He is my fav singer
emeralds123 is wrong all of the songs that atif lays claim to were all composed by gohar and the band was formed by gohar. if you notice in atifs new album none of the songs are composed by him and that is why he is a cheap sellout and loser who ripped of gohars songs
what atif has given in new album nothing just lols songs , hum kis gali ja rahe hain , mahiya ve, suya ve, what was new, g chord, d chord. c chord,, u can play all atif songs on 1 chord og g ,, hah hah aha what a great musician aatif is.. lols... first and last thing is goher is the best and true man ,, baqi sub bakwas hai ,, we have learned so many things in jal album aadat, but nothing from doorie,,,
i really got hurt when i used to hear that atif is the best, the mind behind atif was goher, all the composiotins were given by goher , and what is aatif, a screaming voice.. my little sister can cry like him, im also a guitarist, so i can use my sister as a atif , but beleive me i cant make music like goher, u will feel the difference when jal's next album will come to market,, it will be dhoodh ka dhoodh aur pani..
He helped in composition... As an artist, Atif should have had enough integrity to give credit where it was due. And he pulled all of this off when he was in Jal. Talk about stabbin someone in the back.
Actually, if u look at atifs florida performances, and a few at from pakistan he is not playin the guitar....dont get me wrong, I think atif is an awesome singer but a poor live performer...
FARHAN IS MUCH MUCH MUCH BETTER THAN FAKE ATIF...
ayandipdatta 2 months ago
Cool.The bad part is- I wasn't in Senior Modern School till 2006.
But Jal is great!
sagarverma024 10 months ago
DOOR JITNA BHI TUM MUJHSE, PAAS TERE MAIN
I want to meet Jal and go to their concert
devilkanan 1 year ago
yaar jal was gr8 but the sounds of ppl in the end was disturbing!
potterati101 1 year ago
@potterati101 i was not comparing them i dont think you know what compare means. I was saying how in American mj brought a change in music similarly hemeash brought a change in india and atif brought it in pakistan. if i was comparing the two this what it would sound something likes this. MJ is a better dancer than hemeash that is called comparing. I am talking about how one person can bring a change to something.
drinkyman2007 1 year ago
@drinkyman2007 u r rite abt MJ bringing a change in pop music!
he has the most beautiful voice i've heard & also the music he made always had so many feelings. atif also is a gr8 singer & is 1 of my fav . but himesh is not 1 of dem so may b i didn't lyk the fact dat u gave his xample with MJ who i consider as the best!
potterati101 1 year ago
@potterati101 Respond to this video... I am a big fan of micheal jackson so big that i learned how to dance like him but his voice was not has amazing as singer that lived in his life time. the reason he was king of pop is he had different vocal and style. which is what a real singer needs to have.farhan is a good singer but he is not the life of jal he is not the one that comes with all the ideas it gohar watch some of jal interview farhan admitted too that gohar plays a big role in band
drinkyman2007 1 year ago
@drinkyman2007 abt farhan & goher i wanna say dat i kno how important goher is 4 jal actually wat r v even talking goher ne hi jal band banaya hai. he is the 1 who produces such soul string music & in live performances he always plays with so much passion dat is y i said ki woh Jal ki jaan hai! & farhan's voice simply touches hearts!
potterati101 1 year ago
they SUCK big time
ijaw619 1 year ago
Big difference wen atif and jal sings...atif makes u fly dude...im sry but jal have no effect!!..:S:S:S
555discovery 1 year ago
aby kia baat he farhan bhai ki.......wah wah.nazar na lag jaye...wsy farhan bilkul mry par gya he...heheheheh
farhanruler 2 years ago
Comment removed
farhanruler 2 years ago
atif is the best jal is the 2nd no atif is number one
decentamir007 2 years ago
awsum guitarist! playz it really well...afta oll in a gud and famous band lol...btw if sum1 or himelf(lol) could sort out and give me the chords!
hehehegode 2 years ago
Its Gohar he made the song tho I still say that it suits atifs voice now but Gohar made it.
Peace
barhaich 2 years ago
JAl and Atif bOth Ov dem Rawkxz.......\m/
z4zain77s 3 years ago
awesome performance..>!!! dude
dakshcb 3 years ago 3
hey u sandip its hard to believe but atif sux big tym
navycraze0071 3 years ago
heyyy u navycraze shut ur fuckin mouth..........Both Jal & Atif roxxxx.........
sandipanmimo 3 years ago 3
banday ke sur chek ker zara :P
AbdulrehmanSajid 3 years ago
jal rox...........atif suxx big tym........
navycraze 3 years ago
really man jal rocks no one can do like them and roxen also rocks
gowtham008 3 years ago
u all watchers PLS STAND FOR ME as i am student of this school and i was there live during this show......!!!!!!!!!!! it was my carnival when i was in 9th...did u understand or contact me
ravanrajtogaya 3 years ago
try n hum da way he hums inda begining..its damn tough....
ubrulz1 3 years ago
I sing as well...itz a vry hard art to learn....jal iz good in itz place nd atif iz gd in his place..both r dey best...
GautamV16 3 years ago
lots of love to jal from india
aquamrinal 3 years ago 2
who composed addat is as yet a matter of debate ....same can b said fr songs ..lik dil harey zindagi bheegi yaadeinand all .....ne ways both of moved on...and the magic tht atif and goher were able to create once in addat remains unconquered
siddhantbhardwaj 3 years ago
well.. this song is originally sung and prepared by JAL the band.. and That Cheap ATIF aslam sung it after they have a clash in the band.. 50-60% songs which are sung by ATIF Aslam and based on STOLEN LYRICS.. and he Sung those songs for indian Movies with some stupid editing.. Besides.. this guy JAL.. got a lot of better nice and encouraging voice than that Commercial ATIF.
Untilolango 3 years ago
agreed. atif is a kuri chod.
spinnersdomain 3 years ago
lol at kuri chode hahahahh well said
t4tharki 3 years ago
LOL, you've got to be kidding or else you know nothing about vocals
Thamin 3 years ago
Atif cannot sing, i kno vocals.... Jal is wayy better
evanescence87 3 years ago
LOL, now I know what your standard on vocals is :P
Thamin 3 years ago
LAUGHING OUT LOUD? haha at what?
I've seen your video dude, you sound just like Atif Aslam (CRAP)......
evanescence87 3 years ago
Well for once I wish you were speaking the truth :P, LOLLL
Thamin 3 years ago
hey any pakis wanna help me here? u guys know any good songs from jal and atif aslam?
Arjun1234 3 years ago
atif: pehli nazar.. tere bin.. kuc is tarah.. doorie..
jal: Sajni.. payal
samz316 3 years ago 2
atif sang this song better.
truth.
johnnywisdom 3 years ago
JAl ka koi song bakwaas nahi ho sakta.
dev0071988 4 years ago
Jal ka her eik song Bakwas hai sale phatooo bhanchood Gando. Atif aslam ki copy and Atif Made a well desicion by quitting the jackass band Jal is bullshit
SAM20060 3 years ago
from 4:20-4:35 is the best thing I have heard, so beautiful
1nev1tab1e 4 years ago
huh? oh wa' abt when atif stole all ov Jal's songs! huh? lamhe, Aadat, dil haare, rangoun main & the list goes on....... & letah he sells them for indian movies without carring that those songs were done ba jal!!! Atif is a LOOOOOOOOOOSSSSSSEEEEEERRRRRRR!!!!!!! NEXT THING U KNOE HE'S GONNA SELL HIMSELF TO AN OUT SIDER TOO.......
zikimora 4 years ago
critsizing is easy .. art is dificult .. bro .
zob1122 3 years ago
atif is best he really matches emraan hashmi
lilaries2000 4 years ago
well, Atif's not betta then Jal!!!!! his voice pinches meh in ma ears, well, most ov the time it does!!! anywayz....... jal's the best!!!
zikimora 4 years ago
is that Farhan singing? It sounds so beautiful.
sakina2007 4 years ago
yes it'z farhan!!! i knoe he has a gr8 voice!!!
zikimora 4 years ago
Fine music...was this at the Modern School, New Delhi?
Who are these people?
Pkr 4 years ago
yeah d concert was in modern school ..
hellofabest45 4 years ago
why do Atif Aslam and Jal keep playing each other's songs?
i mean isn't Lamhey definetely Jal's song?
hazardasd 4 years ago
yeh it was gohars composition, but then atif stole it and brought out his album "aadat" first so everyone thinks that jal copied atif.
abacado1 4 years ago
hellz yea!!!!!! did u hear atif's new songs? they suck big time!!!!! when on the oda hand, jal's new album is a hit!!!!! i love their new songs & especially Chup Chup!!! & also hamein itna pyaar & oooooohhhhhh Sajni!! guys, check these songs out!!!
zikimora 4 years ago
lesitan jal makes better music and atif is a better singer farhan can never be as good as atif and atif when it comes to music can never make better music that gohar lets leave it a that i like atif and jal and when they split up it was sad day but they both are doing good without each other stop hating and comparing and live to like them both
drinkyman2007 4 years ago 8
@drinkyman2007 dats ur opinion! atif ki awaaz me woh sweetness nahi hai jao farhan me hai. but i agree ki he's gr8 2! but i'm happy dat dey split up cuz aisa nahi hota toh faran jaisa singer nahi milta humein!
potterati101 1 year ago
@potterati101
Atif voice brings a different sound in music and great singer always bring something different. Great singers like Micheal jackson and,Himesh reshammiya. Mj and Himesh reshammiya both voice was not spectacular. But it was different and new. Farhan is a great singer and yes he is really good i love his voice too. but hes style is not anything new he has nothing different about him and its Gohar although is different in his music. And so far the majority agrees with my opinion
drinkyman2007 1 year ago
@drinkyman2007 i respect ur opinion but PLEASE don't compare MJ with himesh!
MJ is the king of pop aur himesh infront of him is seriously nothing. kisne bola ki MJ ki awaaz spectacular nahi hai! he hhas the most spectacular voice i've heard aur plz compare karna hai to kisi aur se karo. still i respect wat u actually wanna say. aur goher jal ki jaan hai aur farhan jal ki soul hai!
potterati101 1 year ago
@potterati101 i meant to say gohar in his music is very diff and gohar is the reason why farhan is good without his expertise farhan would not be able to survive alone
drinkyman2007 1 year ago
yes it is!!!!!!
zikimora 4 years ago
listen to the part between 4.29-4.33 and then listen to that same part when atif sings aadat. plz dont say its the same coz its not. once uve heard them both, try singin them urself and i bet u'll find atif's version harder to sing to. for me atif is a more gifted singer.
pervaiz123 4 years ago
i dont know who came up with aadat and lamhay but whoeva says that this guy has a betta voice than atif shud know that there was a reason y atif was originally chosen to be the lead singer of jal.
pervaiz123 4 years ago
wow im in love :PP CiaoZzZz
cuteladycute 4 years ago
atif can definitely get the crowd behind him during live performances. if u dont believe me just watch his performance of aadat in london on youtube. its just incredible.
pervaiz123 4 years ago
fact: guy from jal has a better voice than atif, he knows how to get the crowd goin, atif sux at that, and atif is really flat compared to this guy!
donnav786 4 years ago 2
truth..
digitulpunk 4 years ago
TO ALL HATERS...
this is ATIF ASLAMS song, JAL is a stealer! They were going to steal "Rabba Sacheya" from Atif after he wrote it! ATIF IS BETTER NO MATTER WHAT!
ztph555 4 years ago
fear God
bravouk666 4 years ago
atif is dumb acc...... ONLY JAL RULZ....atif is so fuckin proud dono why...
humaisshinwari 4 years ago 3
i really dont leave comments but think about where atif stands and where jal is... jal is good but if you compare both of them then there is no comparison whatsoever... jal is a band with good music as Goher got mature with time... if you go back, the song AADAT voice was atifs and guitaring and drumming was done by our very known musicians Salman Albert and Mekaal Hassan... Goher could not do it... so original music of AADAT was done by them... atif has voice of the millenium...
pakipacs 4 years ago 2
i love atif's songs. he is a really good singer and i am so proud that he is not Indian his songs are touching the soul.ant there are sooo many yaadain with his songs. He is my fav singer
aksika 4 years ago
atif sing frm his nose...he is just chor sala ...jal is wow...gr8
ckkapoor 4 years ago
emeralds123 is wrong all of the songs that atif lays claim to were all composed by gohar and the band was formed by gohar. if you notice in atifs new album none of the songs are composed by him and that is why he is a cheap sellout and loser who ripped of gohars songs
MOSTBOX 4 years ago
hi guys i am from india - like jal anyday better than atif - altho atif's pretty good too, but jal packs the punch!!!!!
hukkao 4 years ago
jal r better den atif live
bilal786123 4 years ago
what atif has given in new album nothing just lols songs , hum kis gali ja rahe hain , mahiya ve, suya ve, what was new, g chord, d chord. c chord,, u can play all atif songs on 1 chord og g ,, hah hah aha what a great musician aatif is.. lols... first and last thing is goher is the best and true man ,, baqi sub bakwas hai ,, we have learned so many things in jal album aadat, but nothing from doorie,,,
kashifpaki900 4 years ago
i really got hurt when i used to hear that atif is the best, the mind behind atif was goher, all the composiotins were given by goher , and what is aatif, a screaming voice.. my little sister can cry like him, im also a guitarist, so i can use my sister as a atif , but beleive me i cant make music like goher, u will feel the difference when jal's next album will come to market,, it will be dhoodh ka dhoodh aur pani..
kashifpaki900 4 years ago
stupiddd goher composes ALL of the songs in JAL.. Atif is the 1 who stole em!
an313 4 years ago
no he didnt!seriously...its atifs song and thts it.
emeralds123 4 years ago
jal stole this song from atif! jal cant even sing it right...its sounds so much better wen atif sings it!
emeralds123 4 years ago
..sorry, but this is Atif's song. even if he didn't compose it, he makes it sound amazing.
1goodstuff2 4 years ago
atif did compose this song.
emeralds123 4 years ago
He helped in composition... As an artist, Atif should have had enough integrity to give credit where it was due. And he pulled all of this off when he was in Jal. Talk about stabbin someone in the back.
digitulpunk 4 years ago
well atif created jal with gohar so its like his song.
emeralds123 4 years ago
that's a plus! I was saying it sarcastically for the jal fans..lol.
1goodstuff2 4 years ago
lol, ok..we all hve our opinions
i heard this compilation thing by jal the other day on tv..it was pretty gd. but ohwell..
RaRaMus 4 years ago
man he ruined that, atif does it much better. Jal shoudl stick 2 their owns songs! They r much better at them!
RaRaMus 5 years ago
heyyyyy raramus aadat is not of atif its if jal n goher composed tht n by the way atif ruined it
199338 4 years ago
Great song
bluesapphirerose 5 years ago
yuksss
zalinababar 5 years ago
Wait farhaan, sorry i meant gohar...isnt that the leads name?
TheeeDoctor 5 years ago
thats coz aatif plays guitar while singing
bearztagger 5 years ago
Actually, if u look at atifs florida performances, and a few at from pakistan he is not playin the guitar....dont get me wrong, I think atif is an awesome singer but a poor live performer...
TheeeDoctor 5 years ago
Farhans voice is obviously not as good as atifs, but atif sounds too choppy live...farhaan is more fluid...seems better in front of a crowd.
TheeeDoctor 5 years ago
the alaaps of farhan suck ...
aouatif 5 years ago
wow they sound awesome live....
TheeeDoctor 5 years ago
JAL IS AWESOME!! You are so lucky you got to see them live!
Suki2 5 years ago