I enjoyed your rendition very much. Scott Joplin would have smiled. Rag Time certainly is a big part of Harlem....forgotten by generations of pop-culture androids.
I love this! Very pleasant! Do you have a better recording with less background noise? I'd love to put this on my iPod! :D I think the saxophone versions of this song are a bit heavy; this is fun and light.
This is original and light hearted, I think it to be enjoyable simply because it is different from the original. And it is jazz unlike what SOME people had previously stated, by the way I have a Master's in Jazz studies.
I've never heard the original before, but when my friend sent this to me, I loved it almost instantly. Great job <3
For those who are whining about an interpretation losing the feel of the original--music is an art, and just like how Shakespeare can be brought to a 20th century setting, music can be turned from gloomy to gleeful without losing its ingenuity. Losing sight of that is losing sight of what an interpretation is.
An excellent point my friend. And besides, even though you may not enjoy this interpretation, you can still appreciate the effort and originally that this guy has shown.
Let me tell you a thing or two about Jazz. It's all about interpretation and improvisation. But you have to learn and know the tune and the chord changes as they are written. Otherwise you need to write your own songs. Indeed the reference to Shakespere is apt, but even so the text is never changed, otherwise it's not Shakespere. So it is with Jazz standards and any professional player will tell you that. This is not whining, it's about the music and staying true to the composer's aim.
I agree with your assessment, and that you were not rude, just honest. The lush 'B' section deserves four-note chords in the rh, with the right thumb hitting the dominant 7th, and some lush harmony for the descending 5ths. Plus, the lh habanera rhythm is totally out of character for this piece. This is a long way from jazz.
Finally, someone who understands structure and, probably just as importantly, 'intention'...composers build into pieces an 'emotional intent' that should convey a mood. Here the piece conveys a sense of the late night streets of Harlem in the golden years, of the sensuality associated with night, etc. And, indeed, the piece is a Jazz masterwork from the pre-bop era. We don't mess around with Shakespere or Beethoven, so why do people think we should veer way off course with something like this?
I enjoyed the piece, i think you displayed control and fluency throughout and had an interesting spin on the original. Jimmie, this is an interpretation which whether you like it or not, was clever. Express your opinion sure, but don't abuse someone if you don't like it. Clearly a talented pianist here, keep up the good work!
Tell me how I've been abusive. If you're going to put yourself out for hire it's part of the deal. Music is a tough business for tough people and you have to be able to hang. All I am saying is that you have to know the tune and the changes, which is not happening here. Also Swing means this in a nutshell- one, TWO, three, FOUR, behind the beat a bit. It's not rocket science, but you have to play in the pocket.
Eugene, thanks for your comment. I have no problem with Jimmie giving his opinion about my interpretation, I am up for listening and I agree that my version is fast and maybe inappropriate. However, I am not used to the amount of hateful rude comments that YouTube is filled with and if he wanted to add constructive criticism then why note at least be civil about it rather than bashful, blunt and offensive.
It's not a matter of "manners", I was not being rude, just truthful. You do not play the melody. Your chord voicings are not good. Rhythmically, nothing about your playing really swings. Harlem Nocturne is not about being on a carousel...it's about late night...sex...longing. There's nothing wrong with your ability to play, but it's always a matter of taste, the sublime. Listen to the masters who made this tune what it is and learn from them.
Hi there! This is great! I really enjoyed listening to this, and I smiled every time it started to swing. Bravo! By the way is this difficult to play, I mean I'm still a student but I have quite a bit of experience, though mainly in classical piano. (I just finished a few of Chopin's preludes to give you an idea of my level). Anyway I'd love to play this is it hard?
this is a really nice version, very clear, alot of versions of this alot of people fail to keep the LH clear, hiding it with pedal which sounds terrible but youve done a great job :)
楽しい。
junfsinatra 8 months ago
If Bela Bartok performed this piece, this is what it would sound like. Love your interpretation!
hate13breeder 10 months ago
make sheet music!!!!!!
mugglebornbratt 11 months ago
Love your mellow sound. All on the same page musically. Love it when it all comes together like this.
MrAtlantajazz 1 year ago
Remarkable music, and you would not prompt where it is possible to find notes
you can throw down them on mail
Elyarahmanova@mail.ru
Elya122 1 year ago
fantastic
flip1877 1 year ago
@flip1877 Thanks Flip! Glad you're diggin it ;)
joolsscott 1 year ago
I enjoyed your rendition very much. Scott Joplin would have smiled. Rag Time certainly is a big part of Harlem....forgotten by generations of pop-culture androids.
schniggitty1 1 year ago
Nocturnes are supposed to be about night and sleeping.
You play this as if you're moving uptown.
f3989 1 year ago
LMAO! this makes my sides laugh. the sound is liike some one hiding and abouts to strike hahahha(:
eddycocotechno 1 year ago
I love this! Very pleasant! Do you have a better recording with less background noise? I'd love to put this on my iPod! :D I think the saxophone versions of this song are a bit heavy; this is fun and light.
mishoven 1 year ago
i wish i could play the piano like you.
CotymoG 1 year ago
Superb!
gstarrrr 1 year ago
hey i like this song can you send me the music for it
sridg9 2 years ago
AWESOME! Mad about this album, every song is perfect.. Just downloaded this album for free at DownloadMusic/./im , remove the slashes..
Qwerty521458 2 years ago
Good job very cool
nuguns 2 years ago
Such a fantastic point of view on this classic jazz number
jazz is unchained
Thill1116 2 years ago
This is original and light hearted, I think it to be enjoyable simply because it is different from the original. And it is jazz unlike what SOME people had previously stated, by the way I have a Master's in Jazz studies.
123jelms 2 years ago
very original interpretation! i really enjoyed it!
operabird9 2 years ago
GREAT!!!
arminnetwork 2 years ago
Hey JimmieBluffdweller, where can i hear an example of you playing?
catface1965 2 years ago
great interpretation! I like the bouncy feel of this one.
PinkTorpedo11 2 years ago
inspiring
Thill1116 2 years ago
very nice!!!
Kelidachi 2 years ago
Great piece!
doelman 2 years ago
I've never heard the original before, but when my friend sent this to me, I loved it almost instantly. Great job <3
For those who are whining about an interpretation losing the feel of the original--music is an art, and just like how Shakespeare can be brought to a 20th century setting, music can be turned from gloomy to gleeful without losing its ingenuity. Losing sight of that is losing sight of what an interpretation is.
Litening17 2 years ago
An excellent point my friend. And besides, even though you may not enjoy this interpretation, you can still appreciate the effort and originally that this guy has shown.
MrLJensen 2 years ago
Let me tell you a thing or two about Jazz. It's all about interpretation and improvisation. But you have to learn and know the tune and the chord changes as they are written. Otherwise you need to write your own songs. Indeed the reference to Shakespere is apt, but even so the text is never changed, otherwise it's not Shakespere. So it is with Jazz standards and any professional player will tell you that. This is not whining, it's about the music and staying true to the composer's aim.
JimmieBluffdweller 2 years ago 2
I agree with your assessment, and that you were not rude, just honest. The lush 'B' section deserves four-note chords in the rh, with the right thumb hitting the dominant 7th, and some lush harmony for the descending 5ths. Plus, the lh habanera rhythm is totally out of character for this piece. This is a long way from jazz.
bbrannddX 2 years ago
Finally, someone who understands structure and, probably just as importantly, 'intention'...composers build into pieces an 'emotional intent' that should convey a mood. Here the piece conveys a sense of the late night streets of Harlem in the golden years, of the sensuality associated with night, etc. And, indeed, the piece is a Jazz masterwork from the pre-bop era. We don't mess around with Shakespere or Beethoven, so why do people think we should veer way off course with something like this?
JimmieBluffdweller 2 years ago
I enjoyed the piece, i think you displayed control and fluency throughout and had an interesting spin on the original. Jimmie, this is an interpretation which whether you like it or not, was clever. Express your opinion sure, but don't abuse someone if you don't like it. Clearly a talented pianist here, keep up the good work!
HiggaLovesHarvs 2 years ago
oh and by the way jools do you have the music for this? or do you know where i could find a good arrangement of this piece
HiggaLovesHarvs 2 years ago
Tell me how I've been abusive. If you're going to put yourself out for hire it's part of the deal. Music is a tough business for tough people and you have to be able to hang. All I am saying is that you have to know the tune and the changes, which is not happening here. Also Swing means this in a nutshell- one, TWO, three, FOUR, behind the beat a bit. It's not rocket science, but you have to play in the pocket.
JimmieBluffdweller 2 years ago
Sorry jools, your version is way corny/smaltzy . Jimmie's comments were right on.
eugeneherman 2 years ago 3
Eugene, thanks for your comment. I have no problem with Jimmie giving his opinion about my interpretation, I am up for listening and I agree that my version is fast and maybe inappropriate. However, I am not used to the amount of hateful rude comments that YouTube is filled with and if he wanted to add constructive criticism then why note at least be civil about it rather than bashful, blunt and offensive.
joolsscott 2 years ago
I will do some listening and have another go.
joolsscott 2 years ago
It's not a matter of "manners", I was not being rude, just truthful. You do not play the melody. Your chord voicings are not good. Rhythmically, nothing about your playing really swings. Harlem Nocturne is not about being on a carousel...it's about late night...sex...longing. There's nothing wrong with your ability to play, but it's always a matter of taste, the sublime. Listen to the masters who made this tune what it is and learn from them.
JimmieBluffdweller 2 years ago
Learn the tune. Then learn to swing. Then actually listen to others playing it the way it was intended....
JimmieBluffdweller 2 years ago
LOVE IT!
WhipItIntoShape 2 years ago
Great job!!!
wdkelper 2 years ago
My jazz band just played this,
I love playing the bass line in this.
:]
yaaay.
CHOKETRENDKILL 2 years ago
great, im using this to help set the setting in my story im writing, i wanted something excatly like this, thank you!!!
NightmareNumber100 2 years ago
Hi there! This is great! I really enjoyed listening to this, and I smiled every time it started to swing. Bravo! By the way is this difficult to play, I mean I'm still a student but I have quite a bit of experience, though mainly in classical piano. (I just finished a few of Chopin's preludes to give you an idea of my level). Anyway I'd love to play this is it hard?
jazzkingrt 2 years ago
not really its actually pretty easy once you get past the syncopation problems.
babybanannie 2 years ago
Where you can download notes, tell me please!?!=)
Lavthao 2 years ago
good man....great to listen,
all the best from austria
eugen
uigen 2 years ago
Very good indeed. yrs ago a young man played this on a sax at our teen club and I've loved the tune since in any variation. Agin well done
rchance643 2 years ago
I listen to this like every night! It made my 'Greatest Hits' playlist. Really stands up exceptionally well!
Turtlegoyim 3 years ago
this is a really nice version, very clear, alot of versions of this alot of people fail to keep the LH clear, hiding it with pedal which sounds terrible but youve done a great job :)
eyeballnick 3 years ago
Is there standardized sheet music for this?
iChrisDiversified 3 years ago
yes... The sheets for "harlem nocturne" are actually quite simple.. The music is smooth!
Laban54 3 years ago
Brilliant. Makes me wish I played like that. More!
Zorrothar 3 years ago
This stuff is awesome! Great stuff man! Keep playing Jazz Pianno!
LightningtheValliant 3 years ago 3
really great stuff. i really enjoy to play along on guitar.
antihax91 3 years ago 3
whoever invented the nocturnes
(possibly Chopin) should be praised
rolandvanleeuwen88 3 years ago 6
@rolandvanleeuwen88 John Field invented the nocturne
ragtimesamtime 1 year ago
Jools, you good!
JamKar1 3 years ago 2
sweetness XD
artimis101 3 years ago 2
pure beauty... Hope your career is taking off well in England
Eccentric0Enigma 3 years ago 2
I'm jealous, your technique is so smooth. Excellent video man, five stars.
Formetheus 3 years ago 6
yo, dis wuz AwEsOmE! i play dis song 2 but on an alto sax. U should give me the notes 2 dis version on piano so i can learn dis song 2. PLZZZZ!!
Chicanobrownpride25 3 years ago 2