Any musician knows that there are two types of musicians: those who can play other people's song, and those that can create.
Obviously Joaquin Phoenix can play and sing Johnny Cash pretty damn good. But can Joaquin actually COME UP WITH the shit that Johnny Cash did? The image? The sound (as far as creating it)?, THE LYRICS?
Nah - there is indeed only one Johnny Cash. But Joaquin does indeed walk the walk and talk the talk in the movie. Very talented dude IMO.
@impreprex1979 if you can say that musicians actually write their own songs most of them BUY their songs, some cases marry talented song writers. Still like Cash though. and Reese and Phoenix actually sound better although it maybe better recording technology.
@mar4cus johnny cash loved joaquin. he saw him in gladiator and felt honored and humble that joaquin wanted to portray him. johnny cash said before his death that he will only allow this movie to be done if joaquin portrayed him.
this isnt as good as the original Johnny Cash but then again no can be as good as he was, but this is a damn good impression of Mr. Cash. Phoenix is a great actor without a doubt and Cash was a great singer and performer from what ive seen of him
the only thing that Joaquin Phoenix has better than Johhny Cash is that Joaquin's versions of the songs have better production values which some confuse with a better voice
did u know the first time i seen this movie i did not know that is was not johnny cash singing i felt so stupid. he does sound alot like the man in black though huh?
If you were paid 10 Mil and had 5-6 months to practice a ton, you'd get it right eventually. Actors bust their ass to do it right and most try to completely become the character they play. Even if they pick up bad habits and get addicted sometimes.
Honestly I liked the covers on the soundtrack, and I thought that the similarities between Cash and Phoenix were errily similar, but I felt that Phoenix sounded a little... dead. Nothing against the guy, but just an observation.
i've been listening to the original versions too...and this is pretty good and it's believable. there's a slight slapback echo on the vocals; it deepens the voice for more depth. cash had this great, big-sounding voice. all hats off to the guy for doing it...pretty big shoes to try to fill.
u can tell this is modern, drummers back then never played this powerful. This is still no Johnny, but i was suprised at how well Pheonix imitated johnnys singing
Yeah. But. You do realize that acting and singing are 2 skills that can be possessed by a single person right? Phoenix can do both in my opinion. I'm not comparing him to Cash, I'm just saying. He can do both.
@GamerJamer Cash never tried to play Joaquin Phoenix in a movie. Making comparison's between the two is natural after Phoenix gave the kind of performance he did in that movie.
@xKEVIN505 Yes Cash did not try to play Phoenix but consider the fact that Phoenix have made many movies which have been, more or less, commercial successes and he really goes into the character he is playing and therefore both he and his movies is/are fantastic. Phoenix is a very talented actor, who obviously has talent for BOTH singing and acting very well. His performance as Johnny Cash is outstanding. Cash lived a hard life with drugs and abuse. He could sing but his acting was worse.
when joaquin sang this song in the movie..it was the most awkward situation in this film...very emotional. and he acted the role so well....so this song reminds me of the awesome abilities of joaquin in acting!
I loved the movie, and I loved "ray", but I hate how the actors always think that they are hot shit and decide to start signing, like we want to hear them belt out a tune
I'm sorry that i cant agree with you because even though this is not Joaquin's song i like it more than johnny's version i guess because i herd this song with Joaquin's version first but I'm glad that johnny came up with this lyrics.
me no hable mucho espanol senor/senora but i was replying to someone who said Johnny cash was stupid and for some reason my comment ended up here instead of the guys comment
Joaquin did a damn good job doing johnny hands down!!!
hjwionarang 2 months ago
I think the only reason I prefer his voice over Mr Cashes himself in this song is because his voice is deeper.
JasonCHILLpepper 6 months ago
singed? sung man, sung*
TheHatethegame 6 months ago
believe this is the closest any person could get to sounding like johny cash
bigpoppagful 6 months ago 2
Slappys
MrSouthphillyitalian 7 months ago
phoenix aint cash but hes pretty fuckkin good
REDDRAKON 7 months ago 2
he did such an amazing job with his role. i had no idea reese could sing that well either!
USMCthedevildog 7 months ago 2
I love cash and pheonix both!!!
cpkungzhu2 7 months ago 2
good job !!! phoenix...
charger1311 7 months ago
he sounds alot better then the real johnny cash lol
commyyyyy 9 months ago
BUT HE SINGS VERY WELL
CecySHeredia 11 months ago
@CecySHeredia LOL- I got that reference!!! Long Live Will Smith!!!
Chr1st1ne1972 9 months ago
Whats with all the Butthurt in these youtube comments? Just sit back and enjoy a great cover of a great Johnny Cash song.
IDBTitanosaurus 11 months ago 3
i just raped the replay button
havenochannelname 1 year ago 2
for you 4 who disliked this fuck everything you stand for!!!!!
enwrockskansas 1 year ago
@enwrockskansas
Maybe they just don't like Joaquin's version of it? You need to chill.
AslansButterfly 10 months ago
Any musician knows that there are two types of musicians: those who can play other people's song, and those that can create.
Obviously Joaquin Phoenix can play and sing Johnny Cash pretty damn good. But can Joaquin actually COME UP WITH the shit that Johnny Cash did? The image? The sound (as far as creating it)?, THE LYRICS?
Nah - there is indeed only one Johnny Cash. But Joaquin does indeed walk the walk and talk the talk in the movie. Very talented dude IMO.
impreprex1979 1 year ago 2
@impreprex1979 if you can say that musicians actually write their own songs most of them BUY their songs, some cases marry talented song writers. Still like Cash though. and Reese and Phoenix actually sound better although it maybe better recording technology.
icoreyphone 9 months ago
@icoreyphone I concur!
impreprex1979 9 months ago
@icoreyphone is that y
MrPhsychedelea 6 months ago
he sounds really nice,the rest of you can suck any dick u want..
mitsmitsouni 1 year ago
actually cash coached phoenix idiot, so he's pretty dang close...
MrsMarshall2U 1 year ago
@MrsMarshall2U cash died before this movie started production idiot
SuperCriticguy 1 year ago
@SuperCriticguy Yes, but Cash met with Joaquin before he died. He approved him for the movie pretty much
TransformerslNC 11 months ago
wtf is this shit? actors, act.
shaq tried to act, EXACTLY.
serverthetilted 1 year ago
He really did a great job I had respet for Joaquin before he started letting guys shit on him
StevenTaylorJones 1 year ago
to be honest i think hes a better singer that mr cash
MCIJosY1 1 year ago
for an actor phoenix sing very well
jonycash911 1 year ago
@spade8050 ya but you can get in loads of trouble for putting it on youtube.
JennelleBelle 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
"When I was arrested I was DRESSED IN BLACK"!
the13D 1 year ago
"When I was arrested I was DRESSED IN BLACK"!
the13D 1 year ago
this song is awesome, shame you dont hear stuff like this in the charts, its really sad
saffron91 1 year ago
class
jazzaste123 1 year ago
Better then Johny
PsychoMikeRants 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@PsychoMikeRants are you fucked?
TheDaleDenton 1 year ago
Joaquin did a great job... but... the thing is, you believe every word that johnny cash is singing and these are not joaquins songs.
tingeljan 1 year ago
I don't give a fuck what anyone says, Johnny Cash would've been proud of Joaquin's performance!!
mar4cus 1 year ago 22
@mar4cus johnny cash loved joaquin. he saw him in gladiator and felt honored and humble that joaquin wanted to portray him. johnny cash said before his death that he will only allow this movie to be done if joaquin portrayed him.
JennelleBelle 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JennelleBelle he definitely didn't say that, your just making shit up
MrGinge1000 1 year ago
this isnt as good as the original Johnny Cash but then again no can be as good as he was, but this is a damn good impression of Mr. Cash. Phoenix is a great actor without a doubt and Cash was a great singer and performer from what ive seen of him
brusselsprout22 1 year ago
phoenix is outstanding
munnytome 1 year ago
i love johnny cash, but i think this version is better than johnnies... sorry john lol
cranedave 1 year ago
Phoenix did a great job here.
He's not a singer but this sounds pretty good.
LaloRallyExpert 1 year ago 4
@ johnnyjaramone....yeah kudos to Joaquin, but bite your fucking tongue better than Johnny? you smoking the crack pipe dude????
47jenken 1 year ago 2
hang on to those coat tails joquin what a weird name
acesandeights65 1 year ago
i like it man its like johnny cash mixed with elvis and a pinch of the killer jerry lee lewis keep up the good work dude . shoot that bad bitch down
acesandeights65 1 year ago 2
phoenix is even better than cash...
johnnyjaramone 1 year ago
he did a great job.
ShoeiBoy 1 year ago
the only thing that Joaquin Phoenix has better than Johhny Cash is that Joaquin's versions of the songs have better production values which some confuse with a better voice
willcad 1 year ago 3
I love Johhny Cash !!!! Joaquin Phoenix did very well playin em but the singing i much perfer John
daysoftheweek1 1 year ago
I really think Joaquin's a better singer than Johnny Cash
sports23player 1 year ago
@sports23player u have got to be kidding me? owell we all have our own tastes i suppose, good or bad.
LitaWWF 1 year ago
@sports23player ...
JohnLennonMemorial 1 year ago
Joaquin Phoenix did an awesome job portraying Johnny Cash
blutocampbell 1 year ago 4
I like how he's singing about a sad subject as if it's funny or something.
OrangeOceanOctopus 1 year ago 3
johnnys alot better whole better
lillie721 1 year ago
Ohhhhhh you are good .. Will E. Lee!!!
OilGusher 2 years ago
dat lovin' 44 hell ya. and duh way i run
Krypticflask 2 years ago
there is a rock star in milwaukee with a full back tattoo of that photo. it helps him rock harder................check out- the cocksmiths
djbensyl 2 years ago
Yes, Joaquin, lay off that whisky and cocaine and all that other stuff. Do not let history to repeat itself.
HotelDesHorlogers 2 years ago 3
I got the shirt that has the picture on it.
Ihateyouall1243 2 years ago 5
Great picture! Wish I had a poster like this.
jfhburr123 2 years ago
singed? thats a weird way to spell sang
hepatitis123 2 years ago
to be fair Johnny Cash covered it too
KOOLGUYHUGO 2 years ago 2
yes, I believe the original Number was sang by Roy Hogsed! But I'm not so sure!
35hotford 2 years ago
Nice :D
That middlefinger is huge by the way
Christiannck 2 years ago
They took him down in Juárez, México.
lgamborimbo 2 years ago
little judge.....eh eh eh aren't most of 'em like that??
redwing46901 2 years ago
der
Phoenix
...
der darf das.
the phoenix can that make.
Harry83CANE 2 years ago
someone posted this graphic with johnny cash's original song. it's not here anymore. can somone re-post it?
deemilieu 2 years ago
Joaquin did a great job on this song,Not johnny but still good
isaach211 2 years ago 2
his acting was excellent but his sining voice is a little too low
sandythebear 2 years ago
yea, just a bit too low
he kinda sounds like he mixed a touch of elvis in his version
Fitzcard 2 years ago
@Fitzcard
agreed
stringsx 2 years ago
Phoenix sings really good in this tribute film,it reminds me of Johnny at some points but still not Johnny Cash
nickoloukos 2 years ago
very very very nice....still not Johnny Cash..but it's very good ^^
MrDericktroia 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
does not sound good, sounds like
A+ crap!!!
jessedowns 2 years ago
Joaquin...sounds good....good luck in his music career!!
VBW061211 2 years ago 4
i can't forget the day i shot that bad bitch down...
genius!
freddysouth 2 years ago 5
did u know the first time i seen this movie i did not know that is was not johnny cash singing i felt so stupid. he does sound alot like the man in black though huh?
brandyjones1980 2 years ago
If you were paid 10 Mil and had 5-6 months to practice a ton, you'd get it right eventually. Actors bust their ass to do it right and most try to completely become the character they play. Even if they pick up bad habits and get addicted sometimes.
Harbaugh95MVP 2 years ago
i agree, best example is heath ledger.
heath ledger is the joker.
btt: like this version but like the version of johnny better.
great song!
MugD4 2 years ago 3
Very imperessive for an actor who has little or no training before this role!
fullthrottlemf 2 years ago
Honestly I liked the covers on the soundtrack, and I thought that the similarities between Cash and Phoenix were errily similar, but I felt that Phoenix sounded a little... dead. Nothing against the guy, but just an observation.
AnathemaBlack 2 years ago 6
i've been listening to the original versions too...and this is pretty good and it's believable. there's a slight slapback echo on the vocals; it deepens the voice for more depth. cash had this great, big-sounding voice. all hats off to the guy for doing it...pretty big shoes to try to fill.
deemilieu 2 years ago 9
i don't think this is as good as the folsom prison blues cover he did. now that, that was an epic cover.
gerardarthurway56 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Check this young lady Patsy Cline 101
ToddGustafson 2 years ago
u can tell this is modern, drummers back then never played this powerful. This is still no Johnny, but i was suprised at how well Pheonix imitated johnnys singing
taylor775n 2 years ago 5
This was a great movie!
Tommigril 2 years ago 4
He's not Mr. Cash but it was a pretty good cover.
rckr24 2 years ago 50
this blows, I like Cashs' version.
Bskiz1978 2 years ago
Phoenix is an actor, Cash is a singer. You wouldn't compare Cash's acting skills with Phoenix's would you. If you do your an idiot.
GamerJamer 2 years ago 48
@GamerJamer I think he has a better voice and overall singing ability than Johnny Cash although he is not a singer.
sports23player 1 year ago
@GamerJamer Go and eat your M&Ms...
johnnyjaramone 1 year ago
@GamerJamer
Yeah. But. You do realize that acting and singing are 2 skills that can be possessed by a single person right? Phoenix can do both in my opinion. I'm not comparing him to Cash, I'm just saying. He can do both.
AslansButterfly 1 year ago 7
Cash was also an actor Genius
@GamerJamer
cirishpimp 7 months ago
@cirishpimp Yep.
GamerJamer 7 months ago
@GamerJamer Cash never tried to play Joaquin Phoenix in a movie. Making comparison's between the two is natural after Phoenix gave the kind of performance he did in that movie.
xKEVIN505 5 months ago
@xKEVIN505 Yes Cash did not try to play Phoenix but consider the fact that Phoenix have made many movies which have been, more or less, commercial successes and he really goes into the character he is playing and therefore both he and his movies is/are fantastic. Phoenix is a very talented actor, who obviously has talent for BOTH singing and acting very well. His performance as Johnny Cash is outstanding. Cash lived a hard life with drugs and abuse. He could sing but his acting was worse.
Spyflugan91 4 months ago
Took a shot of cocaine and away I run Made a good run but I ran too slow They overtook me down in Juarez, Mexico
thaskyguy 2 years ago
joaquin is not better than johnny cash lol thats funny. my favorite tune in that movie , was "get a rhythm".
dredayak18 2 years ago 2
when joaquin sang this song in the movie..it was the most awkward situation in this film...very emotional. and he acted the role so well....so this song reminds me of the awesome abilities of joaquin in acting!
maximiwax 2 years ago 5
I think this version made me a really fan of johnny cash.Walk the line is an amazing film.
JM1988 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
i hate to say this but joaquin is better than johnny. it killz me to say that
royroy52 3 years ago
Idiot
Erlendwz 2 years ago
probably the best song Joaquin did of all JCs songs he sang
jimi8787 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Este vídeo é engraçado!!!!!!!!!
THIES VIDEO IS FUNNY!!!!!!!!!
Este video es engarzado!!!!!!!!
jevanbatistasantos 3 years ago
I'm so glad I watched this movie. I am a new Johnny Cash fan.
brennaboo 3 years ago 13
AWESOME!
seanacker21 3 years ago 7
Phoenix is fucking skilled!!!!!!
MrMatto91 3 years ago 12
I loved the movie, and I loved "ray", but I hate how the actors always think that they are hot shit and decide to start signing, like we want to hear them belt out a tune
danoftherepublic 3 years ago
couldnt agree more
uaintgothebollocks 3 years ago
the original is much better cuz it was sung by Mr.Cash
and i actually like the original version more than this
but i think this is great too
i watched the movie '' Walk The Line ''
and i think it's really an amazing drama
mrgenius4 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I thought the movie was called ;Snort The Line;..........
wgoco 3 years ago
coke wasn't big back then.
fanuvgod1 3 years ago
I'm sorry that i cant agree with you because even though this is not Joaquin's song i like it more than johnny's version i guess because i herd this song with Joaquin's version first but I'm glad that johnny came up with this lyrics.
12522310 3 years ago
very good performance by Joaquin Phoenix... I like it better than the original
AlexRmF 3 years ago
I second that.
jsalas89 3 years ago
Fucking LEGEND!!!!!!!! Yeah!!
choppaholic26 3 years ago 3
Awesome song by the great Man In Black!
Good performance from Phoenix. Too bad he is quiting acting.
R.I.P Cash, genius!
JL6162 3 years ago 4
he is quiting acting? what?
Jobana 3 years ago
he said hes gonna quit acting to persue music i think
TheChin2010 3 years ago 2
Does no one read the video titles?! It clearly says that its joaquin phoenix singing
liberal0irony 3 years ago 3
no no one reads the titles
mann5711 3 years ago
wait a minute that isnt johnny cash that is from "walk the line"
mastercheef12345 3 years ago
hey fellow... name your videos for what they are...
big john was a friend of mine, sing his songs but label them as you.. not John!!!!!!
Argedionx 3 years ago
this is DEFINITELY NOT Johnny Cash
themosmitsos 3 years ago
its joaquin pheonix btw. brilliant anyway
whatwillgetushigh 3 years ago
Look at him. fuck you fuckers, got to love Johnny Cash
FireSide31 3 years ago
i loveth this songggggg.
and cash of course.
psychobillykiddo 3 years ago
respect the man in black
terrycourt1 3 years ago
top tune by a great and honest man rip cash
terrycourt1 3 years ago
that's a cover version, that's not original Johny Cash
rumplin 3 years ago 2
that guy is actually right, JOaquin has a deep voice, he's really good.
haguen26 3 years ago
a really nice song, but this isn't cash singing, it's joaquin phoenix... anyway i like it
JuIinho 3 years ago
yeah...and phoenix's voice is better
amazing performance...both singing and acting!
Barbraossa85 3 years ago
go away cracka;your comments are abusive and rude...grow up;you cant touch this man...UNDERSTOOD?..great song
tuktukskagal 3 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
this song is retarted as shit
cracka2447 3 years ago
are you deaf
loggydooo 3 years ago
are you becoming retarded?!
mastercheef12345 3 years ago
va vill du mig??
smultronvodka 3 years ago
Helt säker kan man ju aldrig va, men jag tror inte att han förstår svenska.
aducimeH 3 years ago
me no hable mucho espanol senor/senora but i was replying to someone who said Johnny cash was stupid and for some reason my comment ended up here instead of the guys comment
mastercheef12345 3 years ago
If Cash was alive he should of ran for President, seriously!!! Johnny Cash for President!!!
jaypacalypz 3 years ago 3
bästa låten !
candymountn 3 years ago