Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (492)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I think that Haley's fans should really get off of James's videos

  • OMG....i wish he could come back to this season...i miss him sooo much and his album is amazing!!! friggin BADDASS! hes my metal/rock god!!! :))

  • Haley sang it better.

  • I LOVE him SO much!!!

  • i love this dude but i think haleys version is better

  • Mimzy - "Stay"

  • great awsomely done...but haley did this better hands down

  • GASH. ok James...I love you, I REALLLLY love you but leave this one to HALEY pleaseeeeee?!?!?

  • wait, he's 21 and is married and has a 2 year old kid??  WOW

  • this guy is a huge fan of the beatles and that's why i luv him :D

  • haley

  • Holy shit how did I miss this...

  • Can someone please explain to me how he was eliminated?! His voice is flawless!

  • james did an AMAZING JOB here and in milwaukee last night!! his version od "sweet child o mine" was CRAZY!!

  • JAMES DURBIN IS THE BEST PERFORMER EVER ! 

  • i love james!:D

  • James Durbin was GREAT in concert on tour. Loved his performances!

  • James rocked the house in OKC tonight. Go James!

  • haley sings this song way better, but it should have been the two of them in the finale!!! <333

  • @CarolinaQueen518 no, The Beatles sing it WAAAY better, haley sucks!

  • I liked James---Until I seen him in concert!! He sucks!!! Seriously.

  • @woodward516 he got a flu over sacramento and portland

  • @woodward516 He's been sick for most of the tour, so that's probably why.

  • If you LOOOVE JAMES DURBIN Follow me on twitter @Durbinator814 my account is dedicated to JAMES!!!

  • James Durbin is super awesome!!!!!!!!

  • We love you James Durbin - rock on - reach for the stars!!

  • Haley sang circles around him!

  • @DaGavinX -_-

  • James Durbin is a phenomenon - did I spell that right - he will rock his way right to the top!!

  • damm this was just beautiful

  • American Idol is based too much on performance and not the singing

  • New channel for America's Got Talent - AmericasGotTalent11 - Go subscribe!

  • Comment removed

  • @stargazerlilys he probably would hate you to if you were worth knowing.

  • Comment removed

  • @stargazerlilys Nope.  But you kind of had it coming saying that you hate people you don´t even know. Thats just sad.

  • Comment removed

  • @stargazerlilys It sounds like you have poo in your ears. He was the only real contestant in this season. Not some false popsinger without any meanings of his own like many of the others. Go clean your ears please.

  • Comment removed

  • @stargazerlilys why? Why? WHY?? this is true talend!!!!! I'm sorry for you.....

  • @marii387 WTF????? WHY ARE YOU SORRY FOR ME!!!!?????? IT IS MY OPINION DUH

  • WY ARE ALL YOU GUYS HATING ON ME?????? IT'S MY OPINION THAT I HATE JAMES DURBIN YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE SO STUPID AND SAY YOU ARE SORRY FOR ME

  • probably felt more in these 30 seconds than i felt in all 20 performances Lauren Alaina did on idol ..........

  • wow man.. he is the real american idol

  • scotty McCreery is a terd nugget that should NOT have won!

  • James had Idol wrapped up from the beginning. It was the Fox network that dissed him from the Pepsi comment during one of his performances (Coke is the sponsor which Ryan made a point to correct him). How many times has this show truly had the BEST singer/performer win the entire thing - maybe once or twice. He has been discovered and he will be untouchable!

  • @windrivermarketing LOL you're fucking delusional. James was a good performer, but there were so many who were better than him vocally. Besides, the voters are southern moms and 14 year old girls, so of course Scotty and Lauren beat him.

    And in the end, Haley was by far the best when considering vocal ability, uniqueness, star power, versatility, and actual on stage performance.

  • I love that he dall all that Beatles music. I'm a huge Beatles/McCartney fan & it was good to see someone do something other than 80's pop crap

  • Amazing Voice! I can listen to him all night!!!!

  • I feel so bad, angry and disappointed that the real star James Durbin was voted off!!! He has a great voice with super show, he has a soul and heart! Why did Jennifer Lopez cry? She understood what we just lost...but we will hear about James soon! I hope and I believe he will come a famous singer! WE LOVE YOU JAMES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!

  • I would love to hear a full version of this.

  • he should have one, he brought an amazing performance every week, he never had a bad week. he could sing any genre of music! i really hope he gets a record deal, id listen to his music all the time!!!

  • Sooooo disappointed that James was voted off .he should be the next idol. I lost interest in Idol after that. Grandma in Canada.

  • I'm addicted to his voice! I have an important Math and English test tomorrow, but I can't study because I can't stop listening to James Durbin!!!

  • @SLASHdaROCKER

    Lol.. same here :D I have a job interview tomorrow but I just keep watching James' videos all night

  • Pure unadulterated raw talent brewing up from his soul. Brings shivers when he sings. Forget about American Idol. This kid has outgrown American Idol. There's no stopping him now. Probably better off not winning. He'll be less confined by contracts, regulations, restrictions. He'll wind up with a better contract better suited to him. You can't keep this kind of talent hidden. Thank you, James, for sharing it with us.

  • Uh......Not to stray from the subject of the awesome singing I have just experienced....But did anyone else hear someone say "autism" at the beginning?

  • @ThyPunkRockKitty He was probably mentioning the fact that he has Asperger's Syndrome, which is a form of high-functioning autism. My son has Asperger's, and he just graduated from college five days ago.  James (as well as my son) is living proof that you don't have to be defined by your "disabilities", that you can transcend them and go on to great heights of achievement!!!

  • @lightacandle5 Oh, thank you for clearing that up. ^-^

  • America got it all wrong. James should have won the whole thing. He's amazing.

  • WOW! it shoulda been JAMES VS SCOTTY IN THE TOP 2.

  • simply the best

  • this 30 second performance shows more talent than every single song sang by lauren alaina and scotty mccreery combined.

  • dude he sounds like a whiney bitch

  • James Durbin has been my favorite since he auditoined. I voted for him so many times! This guy moves me so much! Hes talent and passion for singing is beyond belief!! KEEP ROCKING JAMES DURBIN!!

  • Fucking America, dumbasses.

  • i like haley's version!

  • this twitchey ticky goof should not be allowed to have access to guns and knives.

    People who know him admit that he once held a knife to the throat of an innocent 8 year old kid.

  • @brilliantWISEgenius your dumb who fucking cares what you say

  • @brilliantWISEgenius you stuped ass that was one of though fake ass magizing if he did that he would be in jail

  • @brilliantWISEgenius You're a fucking idiot -_- do you believe EVERYTHING you see/read in the media? Well go follow your herd of sheep that will believe anything they're told.

  • I loved this young man since day one. American Idol fans got it wrong again!

  • they missed a an early Elvis Presley like sexy beast . Got a voice loves singing and performing .you know people will listen and love it. Mistake D-U-M-B idol show.

  • Well why the fuck shouldn't he be cocky? Do you have something against being entertained? Jesus, you people are fucking stupid.

  • awful and annoying + COCKY

  • I LOVE YOU JAMES, YOU ARE THE BEST & WILL SUCCEED MORE THAN ANYONE ELSE ON AI. I AM A HUGE FAN!!

  • you are the best singer i love you you will always have my vote

  • James - don't you dare give up on your dreams. you are the best and we all know it. You WILL be succesful, and you WILL be famous!! YOU ARE AMAZING!! keep on rockin' James!! <3 <3

  • his full of himself and that screaming is very annoying.. cocky people never get anywhere... now i hope Scotty is next.. his song " Where were you the world stop turning" was a evil calculated move to get votes, hoping to use 911 and bin laden to get votes... thats just twisted

  • @dpfan74 You don't know what full of oneself even is, and you've obviously never heard of classic heavy metal and 80s rock...the vocalists back then did PLENTY of high notes/screams like James does. James is awesome, period.

  • James & Pia who had the best voices on AI should have been on the finale. AI turned into a Nashville star type of show keeping Lauren & Scotty who in my opinion are no where close to James in talent. James we will miss you and sure hope you get signed b/c u are worth it. Hope to see u soon.

  • @jjwalkerggt I agree, all Durbin fans should vote for Haley & get rid of the country kids!! not a bad idea...

  • You are absolutely awesome James - we cried when you were eliminated from American Idol - just like Jennifer Lopez - as she can - we can recognise amazing talent - keep hold of your dreams and keep going - I believe the world is your oyster now and we will definitely be buying your first release! God Bless you!

  • James, You did what you needed to do on American Idol. You introduced yourself to America and the World....See you on the BIG Stage...I'll be in the front row!!!! You are awesome!!!! Kiss that ol show farewell, thank them for the free advertisement and Kick ass!!!!

  • Hi. I'm portuguese, and I wonder how in the hell was this guy eliminated? It's the best voice ever on the show. I only saw the show to hear this kid sing, and man, I tell you, he's one of the best voices I've ever heard.

  • James is incredible! He will definitely go far with his career! See you this summer on the Idol tour! :)

  • James Durbin is awesome!!! :O)

  • He is amazing! i was so upset to see him voted off, he is by far the most tallented on that was in the bottom 4!! he already is the winner in my eyes! my girls loved him we voted like crazy for him, and it was so nice to watch him on Jay Lenno lastnight (friday the 13).. he is just an amazing singer and he needs to be on the radio now so we can enjoy his voice there is no one out like him!!

  • HIS VOICE IS SO GREAT! THE PEOPLE OF AMERICAN IDOL SHOULD DO SOMETHING WITH THE WAY PEOPLE VOTE BECAUSE THIS IS NOT FAIR! AMERICAN IDOL PRODUCER SHOULD CHANGE THE SYSTEM OF VOTING AND SHOULD DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT, SO PEOPLE LIKE THIS YOUNG MAN AND OTHER GOOD CONTESTANTS DON'T LOOSE THE COMPETITION. THIS IS NOT FAIR!!!!!! I AM SOOOOO MAAAADDDD!!!!

  • James, You won the whole thing in my book!!! The final two should have been you and Pia, and you should have prevailed. The current remaining three just don't compare!!!! American Idol should do something different in terms of judging next year. Meanwhile, I'm sure you have a terrific career in front of you. Good luck, and can't wait for you first album!

  • I was really PISSED OFF last night and I am still pissed off he was voted off . BUT , I can say I know we will hear from him . He'll get signed on by someone . Maybe Steven Tyler ! Good Job and Good Luck J.D. Much love , your fan in Columbus Ohio ~ Lisa.

  • Finally, the overrated James Durbin is out. Did you noticed the bitchy smile of Lauren? If Americans are smart that fattie bitch will go home next week.

  • I really don't know how the people let it go some good talent like James from the American Idol?

  • James' fans," James' Concert is ON for Saturday in Santa Cruz". He still will be performing in Santa Cuz this week, Fox's "American Idol" has made an exception to the rule. Just google "James Durbin Concert is ON for Saturday in Santa Cruz"

  • James, you inspired us. Thanks. Best of luck to you and your adorable family. You've really accomplished a lot and have a lot ahead of you. I hope Americans learned from you, saw your strength as both an artist and person. Those of us who struggle will keep you in mind when we think our difficulties are a challenge. I"m sure people don't have any idea what it took for you to allow that gift you have to blossom. Never let people stand in your way... in peace, Dori

  • Not the best voice, but a great entertainer. Made for performing and the stage. He can sing, and if he goes into the hard rock arena you don't need a great voice anyway. But he was great fun to watch and he performed the shit out if it every weak. It is disappointing he got voted off. Should have been Haley

  • Fuck this he shouldve won, i really just dont get why the fuck hayley reinhold or whatever is still on there, she sucks ASS

  • @Mochashake27

    Hayley rocks!!!!!

    Its scotty who should be voted off!!

  • @TheLeonftw Totally agree, James was the best. America got it wrong once again!!

  • HOW IN THE WORLD DOES JAMES DURBIN GET VOTED OF AND LEAVE HALEY, WHO SHOULD HAVE BEEN VOTED OF AFTER THE FIRST ROUND. WE LOVE YOU JAMES!!

    HALEY = NAILS ON CHALKBOARD

  • @Transfmrsrulz

    hayley rocks!!!!!

    its scotty who should be voted off!!!

  • @MsKGB1 I say everyone vote Haley. Scotty & Lauren took Pia & Jame's place on AI. Not fail!!

  • @jjwalkerggt I agree. James n Pia should have been in finales, fair fight. Now it;s between the Country. We gotta unite forces to vote the country off. GO HALEY, Durbinators! Kick damn country to the curb!!!

  • seriously he is what is wrong with this show, people if you think he is good or has a good voice you must not be musically because it sucks, and of all contestants his voice runs sharp as can be. fact

  • James is an unbelievable talent and was robbed. I wonder who did he piss off amongst the big brass anyway? The remaining three should hang their heads in shame because they are not anywhere close to being in his league. This one was stolen right out from under you James! Ahhhhhhhh but you are in good company, Adam Lambert was robbed too!

  • Well, I never liked American Idol, and I just found out they voted James Durbin off just cuz he sang rock and metal. Fuck those faggity ass pussy shit likin bitch fukin cuntbag country singers. You think the Navy Seals that killed Osama listened to country to get them stoked before that mission? HELL FUCKING NO. They were prolly blasting "Seek and Destroy" till their ears were bleeding. America is about going balls deep, and thats what this guy did. Damn shame he got voted off.

  • he was the only reason i watched this stupid show. but i like to think of it in this way...the people who win american idol sometimes arent as sucessful as the amazingly god gifted singers are like James Durbin. This isnt the end for him. ill always be his fan:) btw Maybe Im Amazed is the best:P

  • @vintagegreentea I couldnt agree more.

  • @vintagegreentea You are right! The one who wins is not always the one that succeeds. Daughtry is a great example.

  • What the F*** is wrong with Americans!!!

    Y dont the frickin rednecks that vote for Scotty and Lauren go back OUTSIDE AND BBQ and leave the voting to ppl with a brain to vote!!

    I love you James and I literally cried when they said you were going home!

  • James, you will continue to go far, keep singing your heart out! My 9 year old daughter was diagnosed with Asperger's almost a year ago. You have truly inspired her and to not feel ashamed. She actually started crying when you were voted off. (She does not display a lot of sorrow or empathy for others). Right before bedtime, she said, "James is like my Autism cousin". Then mommy cried! God bless you and all the advertises that you have endured!!!!!! ROCK ON!!!!! Joy in Austin, TX

  • America fucked it up tonight! Period. American Idol can kiss my ass! In the words of Eminem, "Fuck it, and feed it beans!"

  • James goes home & those 2 girls are still there???????? American Idol just lost the best singer they have ver had on that show....ROCK ON JAMES DURBIN!!!

  • this is bullshit i thought one of the girls would be gone

  • WTF HOW THE FUCK IS HE OUT!

  • I was from the start Haley's fan but when I saw Durbin eliminated, I started crying like crazy! He should have been in the top 2, not Scotty or Lauren. People are just stupid.

  • It's a shame James got eliminated before Lauren or Scotty ... All you James fans should vote for Haley now !!! Team Haley FTW

  • @bigandbuilt20m James Fans should vote for Haley & send Lauren or Scotty packing to Nashville Stars, they are not american idol material.

  • How can they eliminate this talent and leave someone like Lauren Alaina on the show?

    I've lost all faith in democracy

  • @rh83cp WE NEED TO DO JUSTICE PEOPLE! AT&T HAD PROBLEMS THAT NIGHT! NOT TO MENTION THE CONFUSING NUMBERS! PLEASE WATCH AND SPREAD MY VIDEO! WE NEEEEEE TO FIGHT FOR WHAT IS RIGHT PEOPLE! WE NEED JUSTICE! JAMES SHOULDN'T HAVE LEFT!

  • @rh83cp Exactly.... They threw Casey Abrams away, now James Durbin. In my opinion , the best entertainers ever to be on idol..

  • @rh83cp I love James Durbin's way of singing. He has an amazing voice. I am waiting to hear a lot from him in the future. He will make it BIG!

  • @rh83cp  Oh well.. america voted>

    But James kicked fukin ass

  • @rh83cp

    are yu crazy ? laurens amazing . her vocal range is undoubtebly incredible . not that james isnt great , but lauren is deffinatly just as talented .

  • James - what an amazing gift you have been given to share with the world. There is no doubt that your future is going to be phenomenal!!! You are an amazing inspiration for all those with tourettes & those aspy's out there - both of my nephews have it. Keep true to yourself and your beliefs. You've won a family of fans here in Mississippi.

  • you look like yoda dfbighair

  • Well it tell me if I have asperger and this guy can get on stage so can I thanks

  • ....he looks like YODA...

  • I hope he quits crying - it could cost him the title. It is getting out of control. If you can't handle it - it will go to someone who can

  • @flyingrickch he was diagnosed with Tourettes....show some compassion...he controls it through emotions

  • @purplechic29 my bad - but it just seemed it is getting to him - he is my favorite...

  • @flyingrickch he is very talented...and something as minor as Tourettes shouldn't get in the way of his dreams:-)

  • @flyingrickch

    People who suffer from Aspergers can't control their emotions.

  • very nice song indeed!

  • James, I love hearing you sing, and can't wait to buy your first release! You are amazing and gifted! thank you for bringing awareness to Aspergers and Tourettes! My granddaughter who is 10 was just dx'd with Aspergers and she also suffers from Tourettes and is Bipolar! Thank you for showing the world that you can overcome any obstacles if you follow your dream and believe!

  • @Harleymum2 I have Tourette's too and James is a great inspiration! He brings a good sense of awareness. I sometimes control my TS by my emotions as well. He has a really good voice.

  • No offence but Adam Lambert can carry the high notes a lot better. James sounds like he is shouting.

  • @controledinsanity Adam is seven years older, and has been professionally trained. James is just raw talent. I would love it if James had some vocal coaching before he put out an album, because I agree he can be rough in some areas. That being said-he has great talent, and amazing stage presence. Also-to get up and perform with Tourettes and Aspergers is impressive. I do NOT vote for James because of his disabilities-but I do give him props that he is perfoming through all those obstacles.

  • @Lisa4174 Good for you.

  • @controledinsanity Thank you. I hope I made it clear that I DO vote for James-I vote for his talent, not because of his disabilities. And it's offenSe.

  • JAMES WILL FREAKIN WIN. HES THE BEST EVER!

  • so good, so good

  • he has come so far and made so much improvement, and while the high notes may be his trademark, there is really a whole other level to his voice which is the reason i love him so much!

  • i cringe every time, he just plays for his high notes instead of just singing and then going high when you need too, just sounds awful and makes me cringe.

  • James Durbin is the GREATEST!!!

  • ~Please VOTE for JAMES DURBIN! He deserves to win in the finale! Such an amazing singer, performer, musician and is a joy to this world. Gawd I love this man :)

  • I have to admit during the auditions and hollywood week he was pretty terrible, because he always used his high pitched singing. Now he has matured to the point where he's one of the best on the show, and now he's my favorite :)

  • James Durbin is just soooo good - please be sure to continue to support him with your Votes - he gives 200% to every performance - let's show him our love and support!!!

  • Truly a very special talent - hopefully he'll keep the "realness" as his career volcanos after he wins American Idol.

  • Never miss it! I tape it to watch over. James Durbin is gifted and MUST WIN!!!!!

    Make you vote win! Vote for James! :)

  • what?? people think his amazing singer? OMG his awful.. this peroformance was kinda horribly its over the place... my god are u guys deaf??? and some people compared him to adam wew lol thats kinda funny.. his nothing.! adam definitely a millionx better..

  • james durbin makes my ears bleed! i want him to leave! and for all you people saying he's better that adam lambert?...clean ur ears cause u obviosly don't know music! all he does is try to immitate adam! like cmo'n...bring something new to the competition! like haley her voice is UNIQUE

  • My wife and I have only missed one winner since the beginning and that was Adam Lambert. I'm sure many others have as well. This one is not a miss, James is the winner!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Hey James' I just love to hear you sing & I think that you have an 'Incredible voice' thank you so much for sharring your gift to the world, wishing you & yours 'ALL THE BEST' ALWAYS~

  • James Durbin MUST win American Idol.

    He's the best. Everybody, vote for him like crazy the whole 2 hours on Wednesday. Please. James is the next American Idol.

  • James better win but if he doesn't he will still get a contract and he is going to be one of the biggest stars American Idol" has ever brought to us, the fans. But its up to us to keep him on top. With a good manager and good songs, he'll have nothing to worry about for the rest of his life when it comes to Heidi and the baby. They will be taken care of by an awesome young man.

  • This young man is a briiliant performer, he was born to perform on the big stage? James, you are simply breathtaking, such a nice, polite young man too! YOU, James Durbin will be the next American Idol. Enjoy!!!!