Added: 3 years ago
From: edialfaro
Views: 46,843
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (473)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • me quedo con satriani

  • It's not even a competition, Petrucci wins.

  • @ShredWithMe1

    Petrucci has nothing to do with these guys..

  • Não tem comparação. Satriani vence Slash em todos os sentidos ( apesar de curtir o som dos 2). Principalmente pela agilidade e técnicas utilizadas.

    Satriani até ensinou Steve Vai!

  • honestamente eu nao sei como podem preferir satriani... sim, ele é mais rapido em seus solos, mais os solos do slash tem alma cara... SLASH com crtz

  • To even compare Slash to Satriani is sacrilege.

    I like Slash ... he's a great guitarist but Satch is a completely different realm.

    Satch is a MASTER!!!

  • satriani e so que eu tenho a dizr

  • Satriani

    

  • ¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡SLASHHHH!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Technique wise- Satriani

    Pure emotion- Slash

    Both have their own fortes

  • Comment removed

  • joe is god !

    master of masters

  • xd Mil veces Satriani

  • joe tem velocidade mais isso nao o faz melhor slash tem melodia e sabe oq faz

  • slash!

  • Petrucci all the way

  • Satriani owns.

    Slash blows.

    enough said.

  • satriani is the shit! fuck yeah!

    satriani rules!

  • This calls for a try-out between the 2 of them

  • Slash!!!!!!!!!!

  • joe is the best in my opinion!!!!

  • how can you compare a guitar god to a famous on guitar. Its like comparing a Ferarri (satriani) to a Mustang (slash ) idiots

  • slash best of de world

  • JOE SATRIANI !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • did your known that Eddi Van Halen's Eruption introduced the Two-handed tapping .. and still "Eruption" has been named the 2nd greatest guitar solo by Guitar World magazine.

  • Slash still beats all alive guitarists.. i mean november rain solo can beat any solo, by any guitarist..

  • slash é o melhor, só perde pra jimi hendrix !!!!!!!!!!

  • man, i belive slash is great, but every comparing slash, u guys (slash fans) has only /always 'sweet child of mine' to be compared,,,, u shoud know that guitarist like joe has many thing to compare.. i see many other discussion about slash is only talking about 'sweet child of mine' again and again'.. i dont like to compare actualy because in every comparing,i hv to say words like those above..

  • slash is the best

  • Watch the solo of Eddie Van Halen --- Eruption ... Rock n' Roll !!

    

  • ok when it comes to technique Satch wins no competition but when it comes to making killer riffs and solos that just want to make you cry slash hands down,and i like both these artists,also Satch isn't all about speed just listen to starry night and you'll know what i mean

  • I'm sorry, but it's plain impossible to compare Sweet Child O' Mine to Surfin With The Alien. Surfin' With The Alien is the absolute coolest song ever written, it makes epic fast driving music, and it actually tells a story, and isn't just some unoriginal love song.

  • Why does everyone just say that Satch plays with speed?!?!?!?!?!?!?!? That isn't true!?!?!?!?!?! Listen to Tears In the Rain, Why, Day At The Beach, Always With Me Always with You, Echo, Saying Goodbye, Flying in A Blue Dream, Searching, If I could Fly, Musterion, Out of the Sunrise, God is Crying, just off the top of my head!!!

    Seriously, why do people think all he does is "super fast solos"???? Open your eyes.

  • @PowerMetalEuphonist I guess it's because his most popular songs are like that. Or they just mistake him for Malmsteen or Vai. XD

  • @mrjedidja People shouldn't be mistaking him for Vai either. I mean, just look up Liberty, Feathers, Whispering A Prayer, Christmastime Is Here, Tender Surrender, The Riddle, etc. I must admit, though, Vai does focus on solos more than Satriani, but he has some really beauty songs. Entire albums of it...

    Malmsteen, however, does just focus on speed. He may have one or two beautiful songs, but almost all of it is just 5 minutes of random solos.

  • I think Eddie Van Halen is much better

  • @grabber691 I agree! Satch and VH are pretty much tied for me.

  • Joe is the greatest

  • Joe's music is way much better, if you ask me.

  • Tough one. Satriani might be technically better than Slash, but then again, who is better at writing the riffs that become hits that the whole world and his brother knows and loves, and has a knack how to hit the right spot with the people - that would be Slash and that is the talent right there. know what i mean? Dam it is a tough one, there's two sides to it. but Slash is just Pure Rock n' fuckin Roll \m/. I'll have to go with Slash, I like his music more.

  • Santriani obvio!!!!

  • @themachete97 a so pra ti idiota

  • @themachete97 Es Satriani si "N" pendejoooo

    (error de dedo ¬¬)

  • (Continued)

    ...his own solo and not trying to be fancy by playing fast. I have to go with Slash, but Joe is pretty good at speed picking. Happy Soloing.

    -Jacob

  • @bob3063v If you think Joe ever just tries to be flashy by playing fast you're pretty clueless. Also if you think the only purpose of playing fast is to be cool then you're sorely mistaken.

  • @MrXorHomer If you happened to read my other comment that said, ''Not Hating''(On Joe) then you probally shouldn't have replied. But anyways, his style is speed playing so understand that, and I don't want to reply to someone who has a PedoBear as his profile picture... Or a guy with a teddy bear as a picture.

  • @bob3063v Whatever I have as a display picture is irrelevant. His style is not speed playing either, also I know you're not hating on Joe, but you're just providing false information.

  • @bob3063v Satriani's style is not speed playing. Listen to more than just Surfin With The Alien and Satch Boogie and you'll find a world of beautiful otherworldly melodies, hard rockin' riffs, emotional solos and cool, laid-back blues.

  • (Continued)

    Gibson Les Paul Standard. He doesn't try to be ''cool'' with a guitar that's big and 'pointy' but same with Joe and his guitar choice. But you guys' really have to focus on Slash's guitar solo's rather to Joe's. Slash just play's in between mellow and fast. So it's pretty cool in my opinion. My point is that Slash is better soloing and with his style. Joe just try's to play fast and wants to get the crowds attention with his 'fast playing' while Saul(Slash) Does his own thing doing

  • I'm sorry but I have to go with Slash, or both... Mostly Slash, because you guys have to realise that Slash was a guitarist for the longest of times and he plays 'Real' Solo's. He doesn't try to be all fast and fancy. He can be all fast and fancy but he likes to stick with the original. Joe is good, but he try's to be fancy and good by playing fast (Not Hating) I like his song Satch Boogie it's really nice and all but Slash's style of guitar playing and dress style is awesome. Also with his.....

  • SLASH!

  • @HONOR THE BIGGEST AT THE EARTH VIDEO. IF WE HAVE SOME MORE PROFESSIONAL SKILL VIDEOS TO PROMOTE THE GREATIEST KIND OF MUSIC WITH CLASSIC .,BECAUSE J.SATRIANIS ACADEMIC OR - PRO TRASH SPEED HEAVY METAL HAS SO MUCH ROOTS OF JAZZ AND BASICS FROM BLUES ., SLASH IS GENIUS WHITE/HEAVY METAL GUITARIST WITH SUCH STRONG BLUES ROOTS-BASICS ...,UNITE THEM WHIT DR.Y.J.MALMSTEEN.,DR.JOHN MACGLAUGHLIN., SER STEVE HARRIS., DOCTOR OF WHITE/GLAM METAL D.COWERDALE AND WER GOT ALL UNIVERSE AT ONE STAGE 8888

  • @HELLAS STOP PLEASE MY NOBLE FRIENDS TO ARGUE. THEY ARE PLAYING THE MUSIC SO ADORN,SPLENDID,MAGNIFICENCE,TH­AT WE ALL LOVE. SO LETS UNITE ALL OF US .,AND GIVE SOME PROFESSIONAL COMMENTS. +SAUL HUDSON-*SLASH IS HEAVY METAL GENIUS GUITAR PLAYER WITH BASICS IN VERY STRONG ROOTS OF BLUES..... /////PROFESSOR .DOCTOR +++JOE SATRIANI - FATHER OF PRO-ACADEMIC STYLE OF TRASH/CLASSIC/GLAM/SPEED/WHITE­/HEAVY METAL GUITAR IS TORCH OF ALL TODAYS TOP ELITE GUITAR PLAYERS THEY ARE ALL LEGENDS @ATHENS

  • @HELLAS STOP PLEASE MY NOBLE FRIENDS TO ARGUE. THEY ARE PLAYING THE MUSIC SO ADORN,SPLENDID,MAGNIFICENCE,TH­AT WE ALL LOVE. SO LETS UNITE ALL OF US .,AND GIVE SOME PROFESSIONAL COMMENTS. +SAUL HUDSON-*SLASH IS HEAVY METAL GENIUS GUITAR PLAYER WITH BASICS IN VERY STRONG ROOTS OF BLUES..... /////PROFESSOR .DOCTOR AND FATHER OF PRO-ACADEMIC STYLE OF TRASH/CLASSIC/GLAM/SPEED/WHITE­/HEAVY METAL GUITAR IS TORCH OF ALL TODAYS TOP ELITE GUITAR PLAYERS WITH SER +PAUL GILBERT., THEY ALL LEGENDS @ATHENS

  • what's with all these people comparing guitar virtuoso's to slash? i actually saw a shawn lane vs slash video. so stupid.

  • Let Slash make a solo album first

  • @riopato2009

    he did. well, he called it a solo album, but i think it's stupid to call it that because of all the GUESTS!!!

  • there can be no arguement like "best, better.. etc"...

    their styles are so different. slash generelly don't use high speed. satriani goes on high speed generally. slash plays with feeling, satriani plays with high technique.

    so who is better question changes from person to person according to their music preferences.

  • Slash all the way!

  • Joe Satriani just plays with speed and sometimes this is too much, look at G3 lives the solos look like a competition with Steve Vai or Eric Johnson

    There is soul in each Slash's solo, just listen to Double Talkin Jive or Locomotive. According to me you can't ask the question, Slash is the best

  • Satch all the way!

  • slash is the best

    he is funny he have felings when he plays and he is jumping and dancing when he plays guitar

    slash is the best

  • @MsGuitarman1 ignorante de mierdaaaaaaaaaaaaaa! no mereces ni respirar

  • @pecav10 sorrrrrry i dont understand u

  • slash um pouco melhor

  • es best satriani

    

  • che pero si van a hacer un slash vs joe satriani aganlo bien

    con los buenos solos de slash y los buenos solos de joe satriani!!!

    pero igual toca mejor joe satriani!

  • No one can beat the satch

  • joe in habiltie and guitar and music and all

    JOE 100%

  • you know nothing about music because you are a noob. do you play the guitar or not?

  • @MrJuicypineapple Hahahahahaha well you have no videos and skwizzgar has 152 videos. And his video e minor improv is insane. better than what slash can do, and i have been a big slash fan for 1 and a half years, i have recently realised how bad he is. skwizzgar probably knows more about guitar than you and probably plays 5000000 times better than you aswell, so i would just shut up.

  • @GuitarCrazy12100 you just suck..... XD

  • joe is better

  • santriani is much better

  • I say the same to Ms Juicy pineapple slash plays with heart and feel what it touches but joe is good but only puts effects like buckethead and dislikes :(

  • @bryanmjj slash is dunk satriani so much better... satriani is the god of guitar players

  • satriani is god!

  • @alborecargado teu rabo fdp

  • There is but one GOD, Satch. Slash is a pile of debris.

  • only kids go for slash..i mean slash is good..But, if you're looking for a great guitar player..The other guy, He's the one

  • No matter his soul?? no matter how passionately he play?? just matter of how quickly satriani, and his crazy techniques ???!!??? Slash is much better, Slash plays with his heart! he conveys the emotions for the guitar! He is unique! Nobody plays like him! Satriani is fast and knows a lot of technique, nothing more!! SLASH ALWAYS

  • @Slash10able bullshit you fuck nut, if ANYBODY plays from the heart, its fucking SATCH...slash is good, but goddammn you people dont know anything...

  • @Slash10able mediocre de mierda estas hablando de un guitarrista que se caracteriza por combinar justamente virtuosismo, conocimiento, tecnica con sentimiento y exelente gusto, anda a escuchar a rick asley pedazo de mierda mediocre

  • jajaja slash is good but satriani is great his technique and speed is much better . slash is overrated. slash always plays the same.

  • como puedes comparar a satriani con slash ..... es como comparar un ferrari con un fiat jajajaaja satriani es infinitamente mejor en todo .... tecnica,velocidad,composicion,­feeling,armonia,etc...........­.........

    es una ofensa el video q hiciste ...para mi slash es el guitarrista mas sobrevalorado q existe ....existen miles o talvez millones mejores q el ...los q dicen q es el mejor o q es bueno no tienen idea de guitarristas jaajajjaja

    ponganse a buscar mas y veran q es cierto.

  • SLASH there is no other

  • @MrJuicypineapple Joe Satriani eats slashes in his cereal...slash is nothing compared to satch..NOTHING

  • @skwizzgar joe satriani is bald because he is afraid of slash

  • @MrJuicypineapple hes afraid slash is gonna bore his ears with the wah pedal..

  • @skwizzgar Slash has always struck joe when he was a kid was so joe has an error-BRAIN

  • @MrJuicypineapple that comment made no sense...proof that hardcore slash elitist fans are fucking stupid

  • @MrJuicypineapple

    do you know what slash plays with his heart and his balls and satriani plays with lots of effects usw slash is the best there is no other!!!!!

  • @MrJuicypineapple how does he play with his heart and joe satriani doesnt? fuckin dumb

  • @skwizzgar noooooooooooob

    

  • @MrJuicypineapple hey everyone!! juicypinneapple says slash plays with his balls so he MUST bet better since this guy said it!! fucko..

  • slash

  • joe is the most versitile and inovative of them all and capable of playin any kind of genre. joe will have my regards and votes until he cant play anymore. such a terriffic composer.

    joe yr the one.

  • read this boy , put the guitar hero beside ,ok , mmmmmm easy , satriani is like a lamborghini ok and slash , mmm like a vw, understand , now you can go to enjoy you game

    lee esto chico , pon tu guitar hero de lado , te lo pongo facil , satrian es como un lamborghini y slash , es como un vw , estamos , ya puedes regresar a jugar

  • JOE IS THE BEST

  • everyone Knows Satch is Kings Of Kings With The Guitar and Thats fact. Satriani has taught Steve Vai and kirk Hammett. Vai and hammett are way better Than Slash. slash is a Good band guitar Player there is a Difference. Hammett is in Metallica but would Kill it if he went solo. slash Could not make it solo because he is not as good as a solo guitar player. fact. Satriani wins this one Big. Plus i Love Satch way more than Slash.

  • Don't get me wrong, Slash is a fine guitarist, but to even put him in the same sentence as Satriani is ridiculous.

  • Satriani, really putted the guitar into a new level, slash didn't.

    I'm sorry slash's fans but the sounds, the legatos and the technic satriani invented made an impact on guitar. We can see that satriani really worked on finding cool sounds and new licks while slash just took some likes from hendrix vaughan clapton, added more distortion and abused the wah pedal.

  • How could Slash be even mentioned in the same breath as Satch.

    Slash = fine guitarist, and yes soulful but to compare him with Satch is just unfair. I have a suspicion that even Slash would agree.

    Satriani = Master musician with absolute command of every aspect of music. A genius with an encyclopedic knowledge of music.

    Just look at the list of musician that had at on point or another studied with him:

    Vai, Andy Timmons, Larry Lalonde, Charlie Hunter to name but a few.

  • HAHA, é a comparação mais absurda q já vii, é claro q o Satriani é infinitamente superior ao Slash, só quem não entende porra nenhuma de guitarra faz

  • SLASH MOTHERFUCKERS!!!!

  • joe satriani = 100% soul and love for guitar

  • @shamacuervo that's what in my mind..soul = Satch

  • The Best Guitarrist Here Is Joe Satriani!!!! No More!

  • Slash = 100 % Feeling

  • Joe is the best.

  • Comment removed

  • how can u compare? they're both guitar gods but they play totally different kinda music y'know.

  • speed has nothing to do with it , its the sound and skill of what you play , which obv slash has

  • Joe satch for just an interview played a Em9 to a Fmaj7(#11) then played a Quick Lydian 2nd octive to dorian (Subdomiant) Then ran a melodic minor down the fret board with a sus2 addition. Then Ended it with a Pitch Harmonic but flattend it just enough to where he could bring his whammy up to turn it into a natrual key with perfect Alternate/Lagato picking. Just an interview. Slashs songs such as paridise city. Open G D C then with a sloppy lagato picking pentatonic solo. Joe wins obviously.

  • @TheBeatlesCom So what? I prefer Paradise City way better than your lydian, mixolydian, dorian, and aeolian shit. It´s about the music, not the technique, in that case you should listen jazz instead rock. Yes, Joe, which I admire a lot, is better musician, but Slash wrote better songs using just his pentatonic shit

  • @Xehen The chorus of paradise city is in the Mixolydian mode. The G (technically G flat) chord is obviously the one chord and it makes a I IV VII IV I chord progression in Mixolydian mode

    The verses (just an urchin etc.) are in dorian mode. The G chord is still the one chord and the B flat 5 can only makes sense if he modulated to the dorian mode.

  • @Xehen he wrote better songs? in your opinion maybe...

  • satriani is not better because he,s faster why it,s get,s on the music

    it,s everyone his own choice

  • Slash is part of the group of the best guitarrists ever. The group is composed by that kind of blues guitarrists(not totally blues, but with highly influencied by it) like Jimmy Page, Jimi Hendrix, Eric Clapton, Keith Richards. Slash's diference is that he reached success in the 80's and had more hard rock influences. PS: That's my opinion.

  • all guitarists are the same......inferior to joe satriani

  • Slash should not even be compared to Mr. Satriani. Clearly not any competion. Slash is good but, not Great. To follow the path: look to the master, follow the master, walk with the master, see through the master, become the master.

  • KH is better than slash ,and satch is better than the two of them to nobody can out play ,satch hes the king ,

  • each has the talent and uniqueness

  • slash

    

  • satch > slash

  • lol how can you compare them

    satriani was the master of hammett..... and vai......

  • sastch will eat slash for breakfast.slash is just a guy who can play guitar.but joe is GOD.

  • jajaja slash vs satriani jajajaja WTF slash is shit ..... slash vs satriani jajajajajajajajajajajajajajaja­jajajajajajajajajajajajajajaja­jajajajajaj no way

  • If you don't know why slash why slash is best

    Slash does what nobody else does

    He can play the most fast and beautifull solo's

    and okay satriani is faster, but slash put's soul and feeling in every note that comes out of his guitar, while satriani just shows of

  • @jerommeke340 but satriani's music is happier - sounding

  • @jerommeke340 how the fuck can you say slash puts "feeling" in every note? thats bullshit..you know nothing lmao

  • @skwizzgar i completely agree

  • Sure, Satriani have very fakking great skills. But. Slash's sund is way better, and the feling you get when you lissen to Slash's solos is amazing. He's just a classic oldschool RockN'Roll guitar player. Prablably the last as i see it now. This video is just a matter of taste.

  • Satch plays better.But Slash`s guitar sounds better...

  • la velocidad no importa seguro hay muchos mas que tocan igual que satriani. pero como slash es dificil igualar sus mejores solos y sino vean a jimi hendrix y jimmy page que no necesitaban velocidad para estar donde estan.

  • @jlfsdx18 tas loco? satriani no toca solo rapido, domina todas las tecnicas incluido el floyd, y tiene muchisimas canciones lentas y con muchisimo feeling. otro ejemplo es petrucci, los que no conocen bien van a decir que hace puro ruidito (un monton de nepes dicen eso) pero tiene 15 años de discografia y decenas de canciones con solos muchos mas significativos y con mas sentimineto, y ademas tecnica, que los que va a hacer slash. no digo que slash sea una mierda, solo no se compara con satch:D

  • @jlfsdx18 satriani no hace solo velocidad, tiene muchisimo feeling y ademas domina todas las tecnicas hasta el floyd lo usa perfecto. otro ejemplo es petrucci que con 25 años de discografia hay giles que dicen que hace solo ruidito rapido. y en todos sus discos hay decenas de temas que te hacen volar. no digo que slash sea una mierda(en particular no me gusta) solo digo q no podes decir que encontras un satriani a la vuelta de tu casa porque es una estupidez. tocar como slash es menos dificil.

  • No competition Satriani wins out of the 2 of them

  • any one know Slash was student of Satriani -_-

  • @geda1212 Aww man shut the hell up

  • satch owns slash

  • Comment removed

  • goooooooooo striani

  • slash is a blues based guitarist so he is better than any meaningless shredder

  • omg what the hell ahahahahahahaha this some kind of joke of course joe is better than slash

  • slash is better then joe.

    slash solos make sense joe dont so there

  • i rather listen to always wiht me,always with you by joe than just listening to sweet child o mine by g&r.

  • they are my 2 favourite guitarist

    BUT

    Vai is the best BY FAR

  • joe satriani et slash sont les dieu de la guitare et les autre guitariste vaux un pet de cochon

  • omfg! how can u compare slash to joe WTF! dont get me wrong i like slash but joe pwns his ass all day long!

  • you can't compare a virtuous guitar player like Joe Satriani to a fucking overrated begginer.

  • I read the title and all i could do was laugh hahaha Satch hands down.

  • hahahahahahahahahahaha slash aaohaohaohaohaoohahoa mercy come on guys slash is trend ikon!!!joe is god........ solos of slash resemble chromatic exercises!!!i like slash but ...............ahahhaha

  • umm slash is legendary if you know any thing about music joe is the best forever thats a fact not an opinion

  • umm slash is legendary if you know any thing about music joe is the best forever thats a fact not an opinion

  • c'mon, cant be compared at all. both genius, both amazing players

  • 2 common songs by the artist shows no proof of there abilities,

    Listen to Searching, Chords of Life, or just any song offa, Crystal Planet, Strange Beautiful Music or Is there Love in Space? And you'll understand, Slash=overrated

  • slash is totally overated hes good but not legendary

  • Satriani Kicks Slashes Ass All Over The Park,

    hes more melodic, faster, better technically, over all just so much better.

    but, slash shows us you dont have to play fast to have a great solo

  • joe satriani ;)

  • jajajajajajajajaja, satriani kicks everybody's ass he's just the 2 best ,slash is an overrated bitch, satch you are awesome!!!

  • Both amazing my two fav guitarist!!!

  • SATCH!!! definetley!

  • slash is amazing. i love his music far more than satriani's...but satriani is just so freaking talented its not even funny. but yeah theres my take on it.

  • oh shit i cant believe it...

  • MY OPINION, Slash!

  • @BlueVoiceMusic jajajajajajajajajajajajajajaja­ja ok its your opinion, but you gotta learn something about good guitar players

  • @hayabus111a Slash is a very good one, don't know wat you're talking about