His live performances are transcendent...as where his recordings are on the cerebral side...kind of lacking the 'human element' of his live spontaneous read of the acoustics of the place/people etc.
Not a fan of Andrew Bird, but this is a great performance.
I love the way you can hear the chaotic hum of the other artists playing at the festival around him, and when he starts playing there is an illusionary fall of silence.
Hard to describe, but this performance has something that the rest of his music (so far as I have seen) seems to lack.
OMG ANDREW!!!! I don't believe, you sounds great!! OMG!! So long time without seeing each other, do you remember all those wild days at university (with all your very naughty press hidden under your bed :) Great you're doing good. I tell you that, you gotta type in youtube ANDREW'S WELL KNOWN BARBECUES and listen to the song, I thing it talks about you my good and loyal (and never forgotten) friend!!! Cheers mate, hope to pop down to your flat sometimes!!!!!
Sometimes, when I don't feel like getting up in the morning, I hum Andrew Bird to myself and find the strength to rise. He plays with the most sincere passion that is absent in most popular music of this era.
nothing else like him... he has really made his own form of music and that is why he is so amazing. glad to see there is still real music coming out of the US
Anyone else find it funny when you get on any Youtube video with a live performance in it, there's always someone who says "Duuude, this guy is stoned out of his minnnnnd"
Do you just like to think that creativity is only possible with psychedelics?
Not that I really care if you'd prefer all your favorite artists to be stoners, I just think it's funny.
I think its sexual excitement is a natural result of music that causes an emotional response in people. Good music is a very personal expression. A lot of people are attracted to his aura.
Same thing happened with elvis, led zepplin, the beatles... Ella Fitzgerald gets me hot and shes a beast. It's about good music.
Same with Britney Spears, and various other hacks who were made icons of a shallow generation, not because of their artistic credibility, but rather on the veracious hormonal impulses of a soulless horde of consumers, who have grown up and out of those teenage scenes, and have invaded this world of music bringing the shallow lessons of that time.
Yeah, I just saw him Sunday, and I've got to say... though the Decemberists are wonderful and were awesome live, I was slightly underwhelmed by them because Andrew Bird is so cool. I almost wish a worse act came first so I could appreciate the Decemberists more, haha.
He is amazing. Just....beyond words. You can tell that his whole body and mind are in the music. THAT...RIGHT THERE.....is called pure, unadulterated PASSION.
I went to see him while in Boston a month ago - had no idea about him before then. And was completely mesmerized and astounded. What a concert - strike that - event!
Fuck, I wish this guy was going to Rothbury. Does anyone know anything about this festival? I usually go to Bonnaroo but am unable to this year,,Is Rothbury a decent substitute?
yeah... its pretty sick... If You stick with your instrument long enough at some point you don't even have to think about it.. It just comes out.. music is the language of the spirit .. You just have to let it sing. L.j P.s the force is strong with this one. keep RoCkIn Andrew bird !
Merging your own voice with your violin like Andrew Bird does takes some serious tonation skills. Gotta give him all the credit in the world for that.
I was pondering the same thing. It's almost as if he's not playing the notes, he's simply "thinking" them. He sings a note and he plays the exact same one without a passing thought.
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actully wrks ths really wrks
Fuck is that hotttttt........wowza .............god i love this man....im seeing him in three days bitchez....and so proud to be from the same state as this wonderful man...
God I love this man. He actually sounds better live which is so rare to see now a days. A lot of artists sound good in album because of all the sound editing they do and totally suck live. It feels fake, but no, not andrew he's REAL. That is what makes him such a respectable artist. He's creative, different, and wonderful.
I like this version more than the one in the album. :)
Yeah, I prefer this version to. With that said, none of his studio versions are BAD at all. They are very, very good. But this version of Why? is just INSANE.
i think i might have been here. not sure though because i had been up for 40 hours driving to tennessee and i'm sure of it that he was the first one I saw could have been 2005 though. no, definitely 2006. it was a strange weekend.
All superlatives fail to describe Bird's talent; trying to describe it only leaves you wishing the English language had the words. An amazing performance, at the least.
I want to scream, I want to cry, I want to smile 'til my face breaks and my heart explodes! ANDREW BIRD!!! AHHHHHH!!!
walawalawombat 6 days ago
His live performances are transcendent...as where his recordings are on the cerebral side...kind of lacking the 'human element' of his live spontaneous read of the acoustics of the place/people etc.
torchytaboo 3 weeks ago
Not a fan of Andrew Bird, but this is a great performance.
I love the way you can hear the chaotic hum of the other artists playing at the festival around him, and when he starts playing there is an illusionary fall of silence.
Hard to describe, but this performance has something that the rest of his music (so far as I have seen) seems to lack.
halcyonab 1 month ago
DAT THUMBNAIL LOL
cockroachbalogna 1 month ago 2
13 people have no soul
isitall2fimilar757 3 months ago
needs more cowbell
Jayhawks6 4 months ago
this guy plays his violin like a guitar better than most guitar players play their guitar
zrouth 4 months ago
i wish whoever recorded this would have caught his hands too. i wanna see what he's doing! so amazing.
adinebean 4 months ago
pure. fucking. genius.
loykianos 4 months ago
there are better versions
lcd19777 5 months ago
bad quality. Andrew Bird deserves better.
justa16thnote 5 months ago in playlist andrew bird
wow... mesmerizing
paleguyalden 6 months ago
OMG ANDREW!!!! I don't believe, you sounds great!! OMG!! So long time without seeing each other, do you remember all those wild days at university (with all your very naughty press hidden under your bed :) Great you're doing good. I tell you that, you gotta type in youtube ANDREW'S WELL KNOWN BARBECUES and listen to the song, I thing it talks about you my good and loyal (and never forgotten) friend!!! Cheers mate, hope to pop down to your flat sometimes!!!!!
russellroom 7 months ago
I'm salivating...
kevinluvtortugas 7 months ago
this guy needs to by an oud or lout
trackerbignose 7 months ago
@trackerbignose
And you, need to buy a vowel! Sorry I couldn't resist.
randolphz 6 months ago
Celebrate Brooklyn! Opening Night Concert with Andrew Bird
free 8 pm June 10
Rosales79Diego 8 months ago
Celebrate Brooklyn! Opening Night Concert with Andrew Bird
free 8 pm june 10
Rosales79Diego 8 months ago
His face at 3:59 is forever burned into my mind, soooo funny.
KdizzleFOshizzle27 8 months ago
I love the way he moves when he preforms.
LivyBear95 8 months ago
I almost cried..lol he is so unbelievably talented and this song is so true!
carleto22 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I've been modeling most of my music around the sounds Andrew Bird masterfully creates. What he does is amazing.
If any of you have a moment, I'd be interested to hear what others think of my music. I have a music video on my channel. Let me know what you think!
clemdarlingmusic 8 months ago
best performance ever!
syde007 10 months ago
unequivocally amazing <3 <3 <3
mamacans26 10 months ago
Comment removed
Kittiri 11 months ago
Andrew Bird.. is A-MA-ZING! I love his music.
Kittiri 11 months ago
beautiful teeth.
crogerscp 11 months ago
SING IT DADDY OHHHHH!!!
mexico712 1 year ago 2
HAWT!!!!!!!!
nuts4orly 1 year ago
Musical genius.
KdizzleFOshizzle27 1 year ago
which swimming styles if done regularly will make you grow taller?
TheLeilisa 1 year ago
11 people did that.
BAMeynig 1 year ago
saw this guy on nick jr. and had to check him out!
russellwayneguarisco 1 year ago 3
I'm not a particular fan of his studio work, but this performance always leaves me speechless.
It's perfect, plain and simple.
halcyonab 1 year ago 2
he is the man, check out my videos, not as good, but I would really appreciate it :) much love
TallerThanTreesMusic 1 year ago
Who clicks "dislike" for this video? What a bunch of dicks.
elizarickmanmusic 1 year ago
I am madly obsessed with Andrew Bird and can't go a day without talking about him and listening to him.
spooncastro 1 year ago 25
me too!
simonjsadler 1 year ago
@spooncastro So are we all, brother. So are we all.
McGurkerRULZ 5 months ago
holy f*** ~ shades of mr. buckley there... fun!
rubysunshine7 1 year ago
0.0 ITS A GOD DAMN VIOLIN!
lgedmiston 1 year ago
high off life :P
roxtar55 1 year ago
just orgasmic. hes so into it
sugarbugj 1 year ago
this song and his voice gives me goosebumps
gateway804 1 year ago 2
his voice reminds me of Tim Buckley
BrownCow25 1 year ago
even in low quality, the man mystifies and inspires!
AnnaRose5225 1 year ago 2
utterly enchanting
marcreevesmusic 1 year ago
Genius....so unique....so easy going...
leoramospinto 1 year ago
uffff!
FabulosaFama 1 year ago
Wow, just awesome. Was at Bonnaroo this summer, would have loved to see this there!
codym83 1 year ago
So, so sexy.
misstina88 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if you think this is good, then check out his cemetary gates performance!!
Zebztheshit2 1 year ago
who were the 8 assfucks who disliked this video?
Man, I wish I could play this.
BurntByTheMoon44 1 year ago
-goes changes his panties
GregThaVeg 1 year ago 2
Makes me think of a violin-playing Rufus Wainwright :)
assassin3004 1 year ago
DAMN YOU FOR BEING SO...EA...SY....GOING!
McGurkerRULZ 1 year ago
He's so sexy.....
r92cab 1 year ago 4
Creo que me alegro de no entender la letra xD
Sasustrike 1 year ago
This is the best live performance I've never been to. Damn him for being so sexy.
missmargey 1 year ago
Sometimes, when I don't feel like getting up in the morning, I hum Andrew Bird to myself and find the strength to rise. He plays with the most sincere passion that is absent in most popular music of this era.
thepoopygirl 1 year ago 4
@thepoopygirl wow!! I should try that one morning. Seems like a good idea
TheJonah13 1 year ago
this song is just far too good for words
Hurtdeer 1 year ago
YES ANDREW BIRD. YESSSS
thatspud 1 year ago 3
He is so freaking amazing.
Everything about him.
I'm in musical love
ComicHoagies 1 year ago
I normally don't like Andrew Bird, but my god.
This is fucking...
just fucking...
UGH...
JUST FUCKING AWESOME.
ArsEstAevum 1 year ago 3
this must had been a second stage or something, there's a lot of music noise in the background
brunobliss 2 years ago
read the info. it says sonic stage. its one of the smaller stages at roo.
uncleruckus516 2 years ago
agreed
seeemorechick 2 years ago
Andrew Bird is a f*cking ROCKSTAR.
rational777 2 years ago 9
HELL YES
swatsch 2 years ago
nothing else like him... he has really made his own form of music and that is why he is so amazing. glad to see there is still real music coming out of the US
ARoq69 2 years ago 3
ah the bliss of a person who has achieved their full potential. so cool.
posypusher 2 years ago 2
Anyone else find it funny when you get on any Youtube video with a live performance in it, there's always someone who says "Duuude, this guy is stoned out of his minnnnnd"
Do you just like to think that creativity is only possible with psychedelics?
Not that I really care if you'd prefer all your favorite artists to be stoners, I just think it's funny.
ChanceCooper125 2 years ago 5
He sounds like jeff buckley with a violin here...
trivialproblems 2 years ago
Ecstasy < This.
Who agrees?
icanmakeaname 2 years ago 23
Absolutely.
Niemeyer2007 2 years ago
Jesus. I had never heard this.
nonesuchone 2 years ago
this song makes me want to cry because i feel like there's notother expression appropriate enough for this
kaylashalaylaaaaa 2 years ago
I get that.
nonesuchone 2 years ago
andrew bird apparently has listened to a lot of south indian classical music
ginhousebluesify 2 years ago
Absolutely awesome...
musicshapedhole 2 years ago
what an awesome performer
halimski 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm not a fan of anything else this guy has done, but goddamn this version of 'Why?' is genius.
Phabulouso 2 years ago
Comment removed
Phabulouso 2 years ago
the intro kinda reminded me of the darjeeling limited
artistsandbox 2 years ago
ça c'est bien vrai.
JolieShoulamite 2 years ago
Yes.
RandyBurman1 2 years ago
mmmmm... =D
BridgieBL 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Oh I get it all you people want his dick, That means he plays good music right?
All new "indie" music = boy bands for grown girls.
uglyluke12 2 years ago
Why did you put indie in quotes? He hasn't signed onto a major record label, which is practically the definition of indie.
Also, generalizing across an entire genre of music that isn't really defined by anything other than the fact mentioned above is stupid.
1969AbbeyRoad 2 years ago 2
I think its sexual excitement is a natural result of music that causes an emotional response in people. Good music is a very personal expression. A lot of people are attracted to his aura.
Same thing happened with elvis, led zepplin, the beatles... Ella Fitzgerald gets me hot and shes a beast. It's about good music.
judenschnitzel 2 years ago 7
it certainly is !!
cashmonkey9 2 years ago
Comment removed
uglyluke12 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Same with Britney Spears, and various other hacks who were made icons of a shallow generation, not because of their artistic credibility, but rather on the veracious hormonal impulses of a soulless horde of consumers, who have grown up and out of those teenage scenes, and have invaded this world of music bringing the shallow lessons of that time.
uglyluke12 2 years ago
Are you comparing Andrew Bird to Britney Spears?
TCAWhat 2 years ago
Fuckin, well said.
nonesuchone 2 years ago
man you are SOOO cool!
monsterstinker 2 years ago
... Moron.
ChaoThing 2 years ago
Stoned out of his mind.
bluesmaster14701 2 years ago
he doesn't do drugs at all haha
OutletEntertainment 2 years ago
Yes I'll take two of whatever he's having, thank you.
nonesuchone 2 years ago 6
His voice is amazing! I think him and beast should get together and do a song!
KnightOfBlood 2 years ago
Uhm...why don't I want to call my girlfriend anymore?
What...whats happening...
ProfessorCrow 2 years ago 5
this man is turning the sexual world upside down
shpanky028 2 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
love love love!!!
TheBirgirl 2 years ago
Amazing.
isitall2fimilar757 2 years ago
this video is amazing but the best part is when he goes crazy at 2:33-3:00.
so effing hot.
musicinducedeuphoria 2 years ago 4
Sexy.
csandman07 2 years ago 5
i want his glasses sooooooooooooooo bad does anyone know where he got them from?
rythebrain 2 years ago
pshh prolly a gas station! it's the swagger, not the object-- (but they are pretty sweet ^_^)
loujunk92 2 years ago
i know lol but i want them soooooo bad he makes them look cool
rythebrain 2 years ago
He's so sexy what the hell.
shrinkedinks 2 years ago 13
Orgasm.
Googolagahummike 2 years ago 10
Multiple orgasms.
LeahWanderlust 2 years ago 49
Infinite orgasms.
billyvau 2 years ago 94
@billyvau hahaha 69 likes for infinite orgasms. no one touch that comment!
GlenviewLane 11 months ago
I was at that boston show too, it was amazing
immatureidiot911 2 years ago
I second like all the former comments...
and I'm pretty much ruined for all future musicians...
b/c there is no way they can be this darn AndrewBird.
fashionandmusic921 2 years ago
I just saw him tonight, opening for the Decemberists. I was very impressed
apophis77 2 years ago
Yeah, I just saw him Sunday, and I've got to say... though the Decemberists are wonderful and were awesome live, I was slightly underwhelmed by them because Andrew Bird is so cool. I almost wish a worse act came first so I could appreciate the Decemberists more, haha.
sk8rkid135 2 years ago 2
freaking talented genius
bigcyhutch 2 years ago 4
He is amazing. Just....beyond words. You can tell that his whole body and mind are in the music. THAT...RIGHT THERE.....is called pure, unadulterated PASSION.
willsing4fun 2 years ago 4
I went to see him while in Boston a month ago - had no idea about him before then. And was completely mesmerized and astounded. What a concert - strike that - event!
bigcyhutch 2 years ago
i love seeing a violinist being recognized. i love andrew bird he is my favorite musician :)
sirhenry1234 2 years ago 2
this guys is the man
tpritchas14 2 years ago 2
truth ...sing it bird
ACMarley422 2 years ago 2
he is so wasted
likeOMGitsUNLTD 2 years ago
no, i don't think he could play that wasted..
anaapocalypse 2 years ago 3
fine fine not wasted, just really baked
likeOMGitsUNLTD 2 years ago
this isn't Bonnaroo, I was there..
yvecolby 2 years ago
yeah, it is.
onyema11 2 years ago
I love his music, his look, his humour. One of the greatest and underrated musicians in the industry today. Thanks for posting.
honeypulse 2 years ago 4
wooojooww¡¡¡¡¡ no podria ser mas perfecto,este sujeto que grandioso ...
puro talento...
sociopatainofensiva 2 years ago 3
Fuck, I wish this guy was going to Rothbury. Does anyone know anything about this festival? I usually go to Bonnaroo but am unable to this year,,Is Rothbury a decent substitute?
TheJonah13 2 years ago
Hey man, its better than bonnaroo. Idk thats my opinion but the environment at rothbury is unlike any. the lineup is not too shabby either
sDtAeNw 2 years ago
he will be at lollapalooza this year
karri08 2 years ago
Rothbury is phenominal.
Nothing else needed to say other than that.
ibanezvampire70 2 years ago 3
damn you for being so easy goin
skyofsoundjohnny 2 years ago
This is so effing HOT. The violin, the melody, the voice, the lyrics. Fantastic.
BarbaraGVE 2 years ago 3
im a dude and im fucking turned on jesus hahaa
lkman4 2 years ago 9
THIS is how you make the violin sexy. Can't wait to see him this year!
christinapeacock 2 years ago 6
AMEN!!!! Andrew knows how to use that violin. =)
UjustTHINKiAMaRETARD 2 years ago 3
yeah... its pretty sick... If You stick with your instrument long enough at some point you don't even have to think about it.. It just comes out.. music is the language of the spirit .. You just have to let it sing. L.j P.s the force is strong with this one. keep RoCkIn Andrew bird !
LylesJoseph 2 years ago
phenomenal
soybeanJosie 2 years ago
Merging your own voice with your violin like Andrew Bird does takes some serious tonation skills. Gotta give him all the credit in the world for that.
ChillpointNews 2 years ago 4
I was pondering the same thing. It's almost as if he's not playing the notes, he's simply "thinking" them. He sings a note and he plays the exact same one without a passing thought.
ahkoostick 2 years ago 4
i wanna have his babies
rionassetnoc 2 years ago 8
This guy has got the Jimi Hendrix strain.
rentoz 2 years ago 7
He's simply awesome. I never get sick of watching this.
mdesoleil 2 years ago
Comment removed
mdesoleil 2 years ago
I was heterosexual Before I saw this video.
AsoulDivided 2 years ago 62
HA HA! I definetly know what you mean!
ChillpointNews 2 years ago
@asouldivided - and i was a lesbian!
brandywinevalentine 2 years ago 4
See there... his talent and good looks are turning the sexual world upside down.
AsoulDivided 2 years ago 11
LOL excellent comment!
sucramnormark 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actully wrks ths really wrks
NatalieStan 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Sounds like someone shooting at stray cats in an alley. Very odd and mostly un-listenable.
souleater0815 2 years ago
Fuck is that hotttttt........wowza .............god i love this man....im seeing him in three days bitchez....and so proud to be from the same state as this wonderful man...
OEDIOUS 2 years ago 2
2:37 awesome
Silverismine 2 years ago
He's so frigging amazing at violin
killar55 2 years ago
i want him. that is all.
pollykingywingy 2 years ago 9
oh god, who doesn't? hahah he's amazingly hottt and talented.
LaLaLiciaaa 2 years ago 2
God I love this man. He actually sounds better live which is so rare to see now a days. A lot of artists sound good in album because of all the sound editing they do and totally suck live. It feels fake, but no, not andrew he's REAL. That is what makes him such a respectable artist. He's creative, different, and wonderful.
I like this version more than the one in the album. :)
todamushroom 2 years ago 6
Yeah, I prefer this version to. With that said, none of his studio versions are BAD at all. They are very, very good. But this version of Why? is just INSANE.
ChillpointNews 2 years ago
WHAT CD IS THIS ON?
PLEASE?!
DelousedMind 2 years ago
its on "the swimming hour", but the studio version sounds a lot different.
macegrace 2 years ago
I saw him play this song live at the orpheum theatre in LA, CA lastnight...it was incredible
iainlbc 2 years ago
i think i might have been here. not sure though because i had been up for 40 hours driving to tennessee and i'm sure of it that he was the first one I saw could have been 2005 though. no, definitely 2006. it was a strange weekend.
mdkruse2 2 years ago
How i wish we'd had a better sound quality on this particular performance...
francfortois 2 years ago
This song makes me want to just throw him down and eat him with honey. Damn Andrew is sexy.....that raw talent makes me want to scream!
PoliticalRocker 2 years ago 12
That is a really odd, but interesting fantasy.
jamygabb 2 years ago 5
Eccentric perhaps lol
PoliticalRocker 2 years ago
Comment removed
jfay11 3 years ago
Everyday i dream of having sex to this song.
Or-gas-mic.
tofucheeze 3 years ago 6
I feel ya. He did this song as his encore at his Philadelphia show a week or so ago. It was awesome and damn sexy.
DawnCandace 3 years ago
Why d'you do that?
Mashypotato 3 years ago
One of his best songs.
jamygabb 3 years ago 2
If it wasn't for youtube I wouldn't right now be experiencing this chest pain like pleasure from the amazingly talented, Mr. Bird. Thanks OtterFreak.
WaitsWeights 3 years ago 2
All superlatives fail to describe Bird's talent; trying to describe it only leaves you wishing the English language had the words. An amazing performance, at the least.
JasonBunting 3 years ago 5
Spanish language do have the words: "cabronamente chingon"
controlzen 3 years ago