Added: 4 years ago
From: yanglintw
Views: 3,197,111
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (5,536)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Love Tuomas!!!

  • i wish i wasn't so shy so i could just sing Nightwish songs and post em on youtube...it sucks i'm so stage fright.... instead i just come and listen to these songs....

  • 0:00NLY 0:00NE M0:00RE TIME!!!!

  • Tarja is Tarja, Anette is Anette. Each is unique and have their own style and own fan base. So let this years long argument die? Please?

  • Kinda sad, that it's really an end of an era ...

  • Wait what, there are still people crying over this??? Wow.

  • All these die hard Tarja fans need to stop complaining, we've been over this. I love Tarja's voice, it really is beautiful and unique, but that is not what made Nightwish. Nightwish is the combined efforts of Marco, Emppu, Jukka, and Tuomas w a vocalist, and great music and lyrics written by Tuomas. Nightwish said they wouldn't have been able to continue with her, I prefer Nightwish w no Tarja than no Nightwish at all. And they didn't lose their fanbase, they just played their biggest US show.

  • @jandrodavid

    Who cares "what Nightwish is" really.

    NW with Tarja was great, NW without Tarja is not. Mostly but not only because of Anette.

    Old NW had millions of fans, if they would still love NW they would crush the so-called 'Anette haters" on YT. Thing is, that most of those people are exactly those old fans.

    About the new fans.. they are many, but let me refrain talking about people enjoying Anette's horrid voice and her missing note after note even in her own songs

  • How could anyone pick someone else's voice over Tarja's???? 

  • Anette will never match Tarja ... :|

  • @MaciejCVR As Tarja would never match Anette. They different type of singers. Anette of course can not sing what Tarja sinsa and she should never try as it wil be like a hamster trying to lift an elephant.But tarja as well cannot sing what Anette is singing and should never try as it will be like a bolldoze competing in cock roach race.Everyone has its place.

  • @musicResistances I'm afraid I have to disagree a bit with you. In essence you have a point, but Tarja's voice is one that has come with training Anette is... she has a nice voice, but she needs to mould it more to suit the music that Nightwish do.

  • @MaciejCVR

    I just attended one of Tarja's concerts.. my friend, each time I wonder WHO can ever match her.

  • SHe was Nightwish, they kicked her, they died

  • @karagz she kicked herself :'(

  • i love the new songs and anette is a really good singer, but this is pure magic just come back together

  • Comment removed

  • There are two sorts of bands: the ones which sound awfull at live concerts and the ones that sound better than the studio version. Nightwish belongs to the second sort.

  • <3

    

  • aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa satan, que este con todos vosotros jaja sois unos putos taraos

  • Fuckin epic!!

  • I feel like a hedgehog, my spine is tingling everything I hear that majestic chorus.

  • Tarja is Nightwish, no more, no less ...

  • @SpectrumVoodoo You kidding me? How about giving some cred to the guy who wrote 90% of the music? No, please, give all cred to a woman who took no part in the creative process of songwriting! I mean, having a classically trained singer is much more defining of a band than ALL OF THEIR SONGS! Clearly.

  • @wr4tchild HEY HEY, I told it cuz in my oppinion about the band has changed a bit with the new singer ok?

  • @SpectrumVoodoo No, Nightwish is Nightwish, their music will be the best... for ever.

  • @SpectrumVoodoo That explains why Tarja is complete crap on her own and Nightwish just released probably their best album yet. Nightwish made Tarja.

  • @Nemexixx- song from new album are NOTHING compared to "end of all Hope",Planet Hell",Dead to the World", etc....new nightwish is nothing without Tarja

    Thumbs Up for Tarja \m/ >_< \m/

  • The best of the best

  • she is the best

  • PERFECT

  • for some reason everytime i look at tarja i see an angel....or maybe she is an angel....hmm

  • she is heavenly but I am not going to say she is irreplacable they could have gotten someone nearly as good as her like simone ,floor , sharon or scabbia but annette just cannot sing metal

  • hahaha marco on 4.12, epic!

  • Che spettacolo!

  • they sound best when they sing together

  • ES PERFECTO, QUE BELLA VOZ, LAS LETRAS, UN GRUPO QUE SIN DUDA PASARA A LA HISTORIA PARA MUCHOS,,, ,,

  • Nightwish without Tarja is shit!!!

  • Not going to put all the blame on Tarja's husband. A great deal of blame to pass around.

  • Tarja must come back !!

  • 88 people have never dreamed

  • I know the Finnish are reserved, but I wish Tarja would write a tell all book.

  • @whitegxp

    you certainly wouldn't like its content^^

  • @whitegxp You should read 'Once Upon A Nightwish' I think it gives a pretty even-handed account of the escalating problems that eventually led to the split.

    In the end it's Tarja's manager/husband who comes off the worst. Tarja and the band just seem to be almost cripplingly reserved and incapable of properly communicating their needs to each other. It was her husband who created all the conflicts and she just went along with it.

  • i used to listen Nightwish, after Tarja leaving the band has simply faded, too bad they dont put Marco as a lead singer or something, he really has a great voice (Northern Kings anyone?)

  • @m3talkid It would be an excellent choice to put Marco as lead singer, cuz when Annette sing's the only thing that u hear is the piano or otherwise the guitar and the drums would just shut her voice down --

    I miss Tarja so much :(

  • Tää on parasta jumalaut tää on parasta..ever dream of me..khyl

  • TARJIA IS NIGHTWISH SORRY ANNETTE SHE KICKS YOUR ARSE XX

  • Nightwish was the most perfect band with Tarja. I miss that time :/

  • 4:50

  • Heal the scars and change the stars..

  • MILLIONS OF THUMBS UP!!!

  • <3<3<3<3<3<3

  • Sure Tuomas loved Tarja. She brought his songs to life.

  • great song

  • "Would you do it with me?" Yes...... :)

  • i litterally cried at 4:00 on.

  • Some people are gullible enough to believe anything they read or are told without question.

  • It would had been okay if Toumas had sent HER the letter, he could had called her bith or what ever but privately! he did what a kid uses to do and also betrayed 9 years of fellowship, what a gentleman! doing things in a lady's back (I cant beleve thet she never rehearsed because she does it good with the music and synchronizes perfectly in the duo songs).

    Tarja seems to be a beautiful person by he self and What Lies Beneath rocks!

  • @YawarLiawar Dude, he did. After the concert you just listened to, he gave her the letter. I guess he put it on their website, or wherever, a couple of days after that.

  • @IkTheNew Yes, I know he gave the letter to her after the concert and after they gave her a Judas's goodbye hug. I mean if the letter was delivered only to Tarja and then they announced that the band would keep going on without her, respectfully and without taking advantage of the situation to taint Tarja´s name and get some freee publicity.

  • @YawarLiawar I don't agree, I think the fans must know why she left, like now. What would you think, if your favorite band told after a show or on their website that one of their most important members left, without giving the reason with that news?

  • @IkTheNew What about the clasical mismatches between the members of the group or different interests of the main vocalist or announce the last tour with Tarja so that she could say goodbye to the Nightwish fans instead of betray her and look like a herd of gossips.

    I wouldn't like my partners to do what the guys of NW did to Tarja but nevermind, what's done is done. Happy new year and keep listening to nice music and spread the good musical taste everywhere.

  • Ok Tarja stop fooling around, and get your ass back to NIGHTWISH now!!!!! I said now

  • @dangizg1

    Just listen to her solo project and let nightwish be nightwish ;)

  • @dangizg1 after the way that there treat to her there is no way to have Tarja back....so there is no Nightwish for me after Tarja was kicked out by the band..we enjoy the solo carier of our metal queen <3 <3

  • @dangizg1

    туда ей и дорога

  • Ok Tarja, did you hear the guy? He said NOW and NOW means NOW!

  • @dangizg1 That's one reunion tour I can't fucking wait to see.

  • Comment removed

  • Undoubtedly Tarja is a more powerful singer (and IMHO better) than the new girl. I read the termination letter they sent to Tarja after this show, and I would have done the same thing if I were Toumas. He is the main composer of all their material, and if the "voice" of your band was distant through all the creative process, demanding more money for shows, traveling separately, threatening to quit at any moment, and just being an all-around diva, I'd get rid of her too. Despite her talent

  • Agree.

  • hermosa tarja

  • I damn love it!!! This is THE SONG OF MY LIFE!!!!

  • Fleetwood Mac had more personal problems than Nightwish, and they were able to keep it together.

  • @whitegxp

    I found it funny how people think that band must be like family. Ofc its nice if band get along but generally bands are to make music and they did top class music back then with Tarja.

    Some people are implaying that Tarja is bad person .. and ? She is charming,beautiful and has voice of angel and whats most important she is singer and this is what singer is about. I really dont care if she loves kittens as along as she performs so amazing!

  • @whitegxp Nightwish just sent a letter to Tarja telling her she had been cut off for silly reasons. Sincerely, judging by her voice, she could even be Elizabeth Bathory or Adolf Hitler, but i would have fought with the nails to keep her in.

  • @Jesterfox Did you read the letter? Do you know the things she did? Yeah, nice voice. But not talking to your band-mates for 1 year, cancel concerts for shopping with some friends, is that the good way for a band?

  • @IkTheNew at least, according to Marcelo's response letter, the concerts did go through. Instead of trusting blindly in Toumas's letter, you should try to seek out the other's party regard in the same matter.

  • Comment removed

  • @Jesterfox comparing new live nightwish songs with older one... I start to think - that letter was sent because Tarja force them to work harder.... nowadays they even playing worse

  • @Jesterfox Just? what you mean by just?

  • @karagz i was meant to say that they didn't do anything more than sending a letter

  • @Jesterfox It was quite rude, you dont letter these things, that letter made her even cry you know

  • @karagz And I guess the multiple shows she canceled because she did not wanted to sing this night did not made any fans cry.

  • @Doum92 Fans can cry over many things.

    Shows can be rearranged, kicking someone out with a letter cant

  • @karagz You obviously are very close to every members of the band to know the entire story, I'm so jealous, I wish I could. Too bad only them really know what really happened. Now you can keep whining over it for eternity or just accept the fact that she was leaving the band after the tour or next album anyway.

  • @Doum92 Did i ever whine, i didnt whine, i just hate Anette and i dont listen them anymore

  • @karagz Plz, next time just say that you don't love her voice instead of hating a person you never met

  • @Jesterfox I totally, agree, her voice made the band, after Annet joined the band I totally lost interest, we already had a band that sounded like that. Just better, Lacuna Coil. Epic fail nightwish for firing your fan base -_-

  • Comment removed

  • Nothing beats the REAL one!

  • Wow! 0:09 Tarja's look kills me...

  • @Gorick77

    I was just planned to say the same thing, until I see your comment.

  • Comment removed

  • ♥TARJAAAAA♥

  • Can I get banned for hitting the replay button too much?

  • watch?v=QsytQUum5pU&feature=re­­lated you have to listen this *_____*

  • Damn!!! if only my girlfriend has voice like tarja, i would let her talk whole days long, and i would enjoyed

  • Rakastan sinua :D yeeeeaahh... I know two word <3 first of all I want to learn: 1. english 2. franch and 3. finnish....( my national lenguage is georgian )

  • Give Marco another 10 years, and his voice will end up like Art Garfunkel's voice (smoker) of Simon and Garfunkel. Google "The Boxer" or " Bridge Over Troubled Water".

  • Marco drinks, and smokes and i will always fucking be confused how does he have sooo much range in he's voice?!

  • @Mihatkd Well, he's Marco. What'd you expect?

  • @Indera9537 Nothin' more. Marco for life.

  • @Mihatkd It's those incredible Viking beard-powers he possesses. =)

  • @Mihatkd he stopped drinking actually.

  • i love Nightwish!

  • Magic!

  • are we sure that tarja isnt rly a angel?

  • 4:26 great harmony....

  • So wonderful I must cry :D

  • FUCK YEAH!! I can't see the dislike balken^^

  • Tuomas (L) Tarja (LL) ains... los viejos tiempos que bonitos fueron...

  • @yugster78 hey, nothing wrong with styling your hair! :p

  • @Misamassacre96 it is if its fucking emo hair cutts then they say whats metal or not!

  • Great band! I've left her several voice mails but haven't heard nothing back, wonder why...well someday i guess, lmao.

  • Someone help me, please.

    Erm.

    My penis is kinda stuck in the speaker.

    Awkward. :P

  • ouuuu noooooo!!! I'm fucking crying man.....I love both of them, Tarja and Tuomas, but it's sad to see it... what a song for the beloved person inside of every one of us :( (sorry for my english)

  • Tuomas is so amazing..

  • Tarja is best.

  • tarja is very nice queen.

  • :D

  • The advertising is REALLY getting on my fucking nerves! You can't even set a playlist to role, because it'd get interrupted every 5 minutes with those crappy adds!

  • Comment removed

  • @Porte87 if you can get Ad block+ for you're browser, problem solved ^_^

  • @unholygeneration You are my hero. THANK YOU!

  • @Porte87 download a free adblock program, I haven't seen an ad on youtube for about a year

  • Just shut the hell up about genre! And listen to the music and do something interesting.

  • Fuck noobs who come in here saying this isunt metal, go back to styleing your hair!

  • If you are looking for " heavy" metal style, listen to The Kinslayer-Nightwish End of an Era.

  • Nightwish is Symphonic metal...

  • i'm loivin in 

  • Waoo 

  • I love her coat <3

  • Grande Tarja!!

  • i don't give a crap if this is heavy metal, power metal or gospel..i just enjoy this masterpiece

  • @shogomurata It`s symphonic metal (Heavy metal with a female fronted singer) ;)

  • I think Anette's an amazing singer, and like her being part of nightwish, but this is absolutely Tarja's song. :)

  • merveilleux

  • all u got to do is just look at tarja and she makes u feel like all your troubles have just vanished..but then when u listen to her voice..she makes you feel like ur world is a heaven and nothing can go wrong..

  • nightwish é foda

  • She's so majestic, all hail the Queen!

  • I would pay thousands of pounds to see this line-up again. I'm sure I'm not alone! haha. Someone invent a time machine already! I have to say though, whilst I don't like watching this - the whole Tarja giving it her all completely oblivious to the fate that waits her, when the band knows already - what a way to go out with her performance at this gig. Absolutely amazing!

  • @TealOctober we can split the bill

  • @axxz03 Sounds like a plan! ;-)

  • He wasn't crying but he was obviously sad and with some mixed feelings because he knew that this was going to be his last gig with Tarja.

  • i don't even understand why everyone tries to find an explanation to the fact that tuomas was crying,when i don't think he was,i mean seriously,that is only a gesture,he wasn't wiping his tears or blowing his nose

  • If Tarja and Nightwish will not reunite then how about Marco and Tarja together again??

  • Capt. Jack Sparrow!

  • @DeMitreN Thank you.

  • What's that action figure on 0:52?

  • @Porte87 he`s crying

  • @DDKPDK I meant the doll he has on his piano. It's Jack Sparrow, aparently.

  • que hermosa canción.....that beatifull is this song :D

  • Nightwish was and is an incredible band, regardless of who the lead vocalist is.

    Tarja was awesome. I have, and enjoy, her solo material. And it is true that Nightwish isn't the same band today that it was in this video. But not being the same doesn't make them less than they were then. Some of the stuff they've done on Imaginaerum, they never could have done with Tarja.

    One more comment, though: There are also some NW songs that Anette just can't do. This is one of them.

  • Jukka Nevalainen...awesome

  • if you must say 'nightwish= [here a name]' it should be nightwish=tuomas. he write lyrics, music, etc. for THIS band. i always thought Tarja was his muse, but now she's gone and nightwish is still a wonderful band with new amazing vocalist. i don't get it - it's been so long since Tarja left, but people still can't get over it, even if both of them - Nightwish and Tarja - are doing incredible good.

  • @wujekeustachy I totally agree : Tarja did great things with Nightwish, and Nightwish is still doing amazing things without Tarja : that means Tarja doesn't make Nightwish, but Nightwish is a whole thing, improved by her.

  • aw the little bitch is crying(tuomas ofc)

    great performance btw.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot i didnt know jackasses could talk or type

  • @XxvaultlegendxX

    aw an anime fan is insulting me. oh no what am i gonna do.

    guess what: not everybody loves tuomas.

  • @ISeeAnIdiot who the hell said im a anime fan?

  • @XxvaultlegendxX

    your videos honey.

  • gooooooose bumps one m00:00re time

  • tarjas face on 0:03 isnt really lucky i think

  • ¿Por qué ya no es lo mismo NIGHTWISH sin Tarja? Aquellas épocas...

  • @mariafer93cb Muy sencillo. Pese a que Tuomas es el líder, Nightwish siempre fue Tarja + 4.

  • all those likes ...<3

  • This put me to tears...

  • Ich muss sagen, dass ich versucht habe mich an Nightwish mit Anette zu gewöhnen ... sie ist sicherlich eine echt gute Sängerin! Aber wenn ich mir die Videos von "End of an Era" anschaue ... dann kommen mir die Tränen ...

  • Tuomas ftw and always will as long as Nightwish will exist <3

  • I'd like to declare the minute 4:25-5:25 as one of the best minutes in the history of music!

  • the moment in the drummer's life... when Every cymbal is moving while u're playing... THATS when u know you are legit

  • @matyviola I say NEVER underestimate the role of the drummer in music like this. Without Jukka this song goes nowhere. I watch him every chance I get but the cameras rarely stay on him for more than a second or two. Very frustrating.

  • D+ Todo dia vejo todos clipe dese SHow Foverer Ow YEs Bay PirRalhoO

  • This is one of those songs that you never pay attention to, until you actually LISTEN TO IT, and then you simple can't stop replaying it...