Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (162)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • thanx a lot :)

  • That intro always makes me well up and shiver. it's so beautiful

  • this is coming in mighty handy - thank you sooo much :) by the way, the pick up switch on my cheap Mexican strat is silent also - i never considered myself lucky in that department, but if you insist most of them clunk from pick up to pick up.. then i'll count my blessings :)

  • "I'm sure Gilmour did 15 takes"

    No, I'm sure Gilmour got it in 1 take.

  • hi ,where did you get the backin track from

  • I'm sure didn't do 15 takes! Sorry but thats a major insult to the master string bender.

  • you, sir are a genius. Thank you!

  • can i buy you a beer? thanks for uploading a great lesson.

  • yo take three, just completed that solo i been working on for months lol, is my first solo to play on electric tho, hey anyways thanks for the tutorial , mine is a different version with a lil improv, but your tutorial helped out alot , keep it up tony dude :) great job

  • dude, are you kg? seriously, i think you are

  • you play this so well that i almost can tell no difference at all, and i have remarkable memory for musical phrasing, thank you so much

    you kinda sound like rage cage

  • you play this so well that i almost can tell no difference at all, and i have remarkable memory for musical phrasing, thank you so much

  • Very nice tony...great lessons man

  • thanks man,very nice...  ;)

  • Tony, you play it so soulfull, great play man!

    What effects are you using?

  • that tone is like, heaven on earth! ^_^

  • Man... Your Really good, This is note for note perfection. If I only had an Electric guitar rather than acoustic, Id study this song, until I could play it this good. ITs my All Time Favorite Song!

  • what pickups do you have, guitar model etc..thanks

  • Dear Threetake! you have the best best!!!!!!!!! cover of pink floyd, I know cause I know..and dont worry about thomas or etc they are saying, I have seen al of you tube and I know..this is the most melodious and played with feeling and deapth...AS I have asked before also, would you care to answer what gear you are using? will a POD XT help..I want to learn and play this..Thanks!! is the most beautiful cover..why dont you play sorrow and other covers also and teach!!!LOL

  • friend... how your set of pedal.. u use in this song? my email... yankelss@yahoo.com.br

  • friend... how your set of pedal.. u use in this song?

  • @xorgevaldivia..... No man you took me wrong. I am not showing off I am just asking whether that guitar is good for playing or not as I don't even know that. So that is why seeking some help.

    Thanks !!!

  • great song - great lesson - thanks for taking the time to post...

  • I am totally new to all this and just bought Fender Squire, Affinity, Stratocaster Electric Guitar.

    Can anyone help me why I can't managed to produce even a little bit of same tone as he's producing. Is it something to do with guitar's tuning or what??

  • @omermansur dude trying to show off saying u just bought a squire aint gonna get u anywhere, squires are shitty ass guitars anyways. just keep playing and if you practice enough everything will fall into place on its own.

  • @omermansur buy an emg dg 20 set its around 300 its the pickup configuration installed in a pickguard that he uses in the pulse era in his red stratocaster and use ghs David Gilmour signature set or fender custom shop pickups 54's,69's or texas specials or semour duncans ssl 1 sets for 170 on average just changing your pickups can really help with the sound quality and buy a sound modulator like a pod xt from line six you have all the basic distortions modulations and delays inside.Hope it helps

  • Comment removed

  • Thanks Tony, that was very helpful. Well, the reason you have more hits is because you make the effort to teach, and most of the visitors are looking for lessons. If i just had to watch someone play , i'd much rather watch Gilmour play than some freaking Thomas Crane.

  • @Tony, its also the fact that you make an effort to teach , and the hits are often people trying to learn how to play. If i had to just watch somebody play, i wouldn't go to some freaking Thomas Crane's video, i'd much rather watch Gilmour himself play.

  • I am going to be a bit of a hypocrite here. I can not stand how much people bash each other on Youtube. We all have an opinion and sadly some people don't know when it is or is not an appropriate time to say something. That being said I mean this in the friendliest of recommendations. I think you are a very good player and teach very organized yet casual. My only advice to you is that I feel your attack (bite) is too much. Possibly the pickups are set too high. Just friendly advice. Cheers!

  • Hi

    I love the way you teach on this video. Not patronising (e.g. first finger on 5th fret on 4th string and second finger on 3rd fret on 3rd strings, etc.) nor overly complex. It's like having a real teacher. You start off with the regular speed, then slowed it down to show how each note is picked and then repeat each phrase several times until the student can play along with you in real time. Fantastic. Wish other tutors were more like you.

    Cheers

  • Goedemorgen, vind het heel fijn dat je hier goed kunt zien en leren hoe je dit moet spelen! Ook het liedje vind ik echt heel mooi!

    Liefs

    Mieke

    miekefreedom bloggen.be

  • great vid!

    love the tone you get comes across really well

    any tips to replicate it?

  • What pickups and amp effects do you need for this sound???? Please!! Anyone!!

  • is that a pacific guitar?

  • Flawless playing man,, Awesome tune. Just breath taking shit

  • Grazie!

  • About Thomas Crane. He does a fine job at playing. I'd even say he's better than me. So why do I get more page hits?

    I learned this when I was making webpages a long time ago. Using keywords to help people find your site is very important.

    The difference in keywords between Thomas's and my pages are I offer lessons, backing tracks and guitar tabs for free.

  • @ThreeTakeTony

    excellent work tony,first rate job and i looked at thomas cranes version and would still rather yours, any chance of you doin the same with the 2nd and 3rd solo's.tanx again..

  • @ThreeTakeTony where can i get the tab book mate? been looking everywhere for it

  • thats because cranes a lefty LOL I just like to see anyone who can play it at all heck I can't so thanks guys maybe one day I'll figure it out thanks Tony

  • thats because cranes a lefty LOL I just like to see anyone who can play it at all heck I can't so thanks guys maybe one day I'll figure it out thanks Tony

  • hey man that was excelent! thank you

  • awesome! thank you:)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • tell us about your gear

  • Thank you for the video!

    I learned it! very helpful

  • Excelent and very helpfully!!! Do you have the solo 2 & 3? If not, please make the videos for us!!! Adios!!

  • Hi Im not wonting to sound stupid its just how the fuckn hell do you get 49000 hits and the likes of Thomas Crane gets only hundreds go look if Im wrong I will apologies.

  • Is that you Thomas???

  • @ThreeTakeTony lol that's funny. i went and checked this thomas crane out and though i think you did a much better job on the coming back to life intro i have to ask you to check out his comfortably numb cover. I think you might have to give credit where credit is due as far as that cover goes anyway. but you're still my fav lol. take care tony, we'll see ya again brother.

  • 10:49 let´s throw it away !

  • thankx man reli helpful and great tabs....awesome

  • great lesson

  • The Best cover i have ever listened to....great work ..!!

  • Man I have recently rediscovered this song and as bmxs5 just wrote, man, you made my day... not only you have the skills to pull it off in Gilmour fashion but you had the patience to teach us how to play like yourself, hence like Dave. Kudos and all my respect, thanks!

  • Dude thank you so much...you made my day bro. Now i can play my favorite song

  • where I download the file into mp3?

  • Very nice. I love this solo and there are some really tricky parts that I need to push myself to get into it. By the way I couldn't download the files, if there's somewhere else you can put them or send me through e-mail, will be much appreciated.

  • I have decided Rapid Share suxs! I am looking for a new pload site, maybe mediashare. I'll get it going soon.

  • wich guitar & ampli are you going to use for this song?thanks,

    Mario

  • can you send me the backing track or tell me where to get it? Thanks

  • very nice sound. great job.

  • Amazing :)

  • Excellent!

  • Damm your good ,nice job, how long have been doing this?

  • there's a diference between "your" and "you're"

    I sure know it, do you?

  • my english is not so good... srry ;D

  • Fuck off c0no you grammar bully

  • @kw1ksh0t It's good to know there's people who appreciate what i try to do: teach some fucking english to the people, FUCK

  • since I was 15....

  • how long have you been playing for am a beginner and just wanted to know how long it would take to get that good thank you !!

  • Sweet dude,that guitar sounds exactly like Davids. I didn't even know you could get Gilmour pickups.Your'e right about other Strats,mine pops all over the place when switching pups.

  • Great video!!

    played it very well!

    helped a lot, and i learned it, thanks!

    sorry for the english, i'm brazilian

  • wonderful !!!!!!

  • Very nice, your string are 0,9 or 0,10.... Thanks!

  • 100/100...its flawless....!!.

  • 99/100

  • 70/100

  • What kind of equipment are you rocking?

  • Equipment: Guitars: 1. Fender MiM Strat with David Gilmour pickups. I switched the Pearl pickguard with a Black one. 2. Epiphone SG with Tony Iommi pickup. 3. Cheapo Bass 4. Yamaha Acoustic Misc: 1. PodXT Amps: 1. Fender Blues JR. The one with only a Volume and Tone control. 2. Fender Blues JR Tweed. This one has 3 tone controls and a reverb. 3. Fender 15G, great practice amps. I have 2 of them for a stereo sound.
  • I used the Fender for this vid. It has the best sound.

  • some folk make it look so easy..you are one of them ....you make it look easy because you are excellent at it !! keep posting im trying to keep up

  • yeahhhh,  perfecta tu tuleccion Tony, gracias.

  • Oye me puedes ayudar ya q no le entiendo mucho

  • que es lo que no entiende smi hermano?

  • Fantastic!! and Thank you so much

  • Awesome job. Great bends and great precision.

  • amazing pal can you do shine on. ynwa

  • Priceless

  • Thanks!

  • your bends are so precise !

  • Thanks to you now I can play my favorite song. You don't know how much you helped.

    Gracias

  • Dito on that.

  • oye ayudame es que no le entiendo

  • i'm also learning this on acoustic and it just sounds amazing!

    thanks Mr. David Gilmour for the song and thanks Tony for the lesson

  • brill,lovely guitar tone and well played..

  • nice tony...Gilmour king of bends!!!!!!!!1 Ya some people need their little naps or they're cranky....classy response Tony....can't please all all the time eh Tony!!!

  • you are just beautiful..beautiful..!!! one of pink floyds cult song..and how much you would love to be able to play like that...:)..I am trying out these days...I have an acoustic..and hmnn..it does not come out as in the electric versions...absolutely love it ..thanks..:) beautiful... !!!

  • 494878200 .... and wut the hell kind of name is that dude suck my cock and like ur mommy said if u dont have anything nice to say keep ur cock sucker closed =) have a nice day fag

  • great lesson.thanks..

  • please can you tell me what time do you come in on the backing track.

  • I come in at about a count of 2 playing on 3.

    I remember this was hard for me at the beginning too. It took some time to practice along with this backing track.

    Just know that when you find a keyboard player to play with you won't have to count at all.

  • Hahahaha...sounds like somebody needs a nap!

  • if you cant learn this by this brilliant well explaind lesson then you you mite as well give up trying to play this intro.

  • Comment removed

  • hey dude for future refence you should say what frets but still great lesson I used online tab so yeah :D

  • Amazing! Nice cover and great guitar.

  • Hey how does the timing go for the intro.. is it free style ?

  • Kinda freestyle. You make the song your own when U play from the heart.

  • merci merci beaucoup tres bonne idee tres bon son

  • thank you really good teaching

  • Thanks so much. Really nice teaching. And I must say I love how you go "nuts" about the switch!

  • thanks a lot

  • Very very Good!!!

    And great sound!!!

    Thank you very much!!!

  • What effect do you use?

  • Sir we love you for doing this!!!!

  • Excellent video man, thanks a lot

  • So far the best Coming to life instruction video I seen on the internet.

    T H A N K Y O U ! I am just learning and I LOVE Pink Floyd ...

  • These EMG's pickups sounds just perfect.

    I just love that music, and i learned to play it with your video lesson. thaks a lot.

    Please, keep up with the good work. teach the other solos of that music so i can learn with you again.

  • very good

  • AMAZING!!!!!!

    Are those EMGs?

  • Yes. They are the David Gilmour Pickups, EMG DG-20. I just replaced the Pearl White pickguard with a black one.

  • dude, I love you

    one of my favorite solos and I am really new to guitar, this could be a perfect first solo for me to be able to play. thanks again sir!

  • Well played and very good tuition thank you. I am having a problem working out the run down from 23 sec to 28 secs. Even watching you i can,t figure it out. I have tried to download the tabs from rapid share but it won,t let me. Any help appreciated. thanks

  • beautiful tone...

  • u r wonderful dude

  • Really beautiful playing performed in a very educational way! Thanks for offering your time to improve my own playing.

    I hope you will add some new solos soon.

    Best regards from Norway.

    PS: Nice guitar. What model do you play on?

  • Thanks! It is a Fender MiM Strat with David Gilmour pickups. I switched the Pearl pickguard with a Black one.

  • superb playing!

    now I can learn it so much easily, thanks to you sir.

    keep it coming!

  • PERFECT

    the best

  • simply beautiful.....

  • Comment removed

  • I've watched all you have so far but I just keep being drawn back to this one. excellent job tony. if i had a cam and a mic i'd ask ya to teach me via messenger, lol.

  • great work..loved just listening. I will pass on to my daughter.

  • thanks a bunch! please do more stuff like this, you are an excelent teacher!

  • I thought it's just a cover but you really found time to share your knowledge with us. Thanks a milltion, I always wanted to learn this as my first intro solo after wish you were here, but was too lazy to study all the notes from guitar pro. I really feel like I owe you one. Thanks a bunch!!!

    Cheers, Paul.

  • good video good sound. some parts a bit too slow and some a bit too fast - by just a bit. At around 45 seconds i think its a bit too slow for instance. All in all, great video, very nice sound achieved on that guitar. Thanks for the vid!

  • Oh and I forgot - great bends - very exact.

  • Tony, is there any way you can email me the tabs for this? I can download them, but the print is very small and I cannot read it. I love the way you break it out. I've having a hard time with section E. I cannot follow what notes your playing, because it blends into section A. Any help is appreciated.

    Chris

  • Tony, the tab link isn't there. Can you take a look?

  • Nevermind, I found it. Doh!

  • non capisco un cazzo

  • I've been playing for 4 months know. And my my forced my to do that song, 'cause se absolutely loves it. It's seemed so hard, but it's not that hard :)

  • Fantastic.

  • great vid..thanks alot man

    i know david uses a DD-2 for ther delay on this album but would you know which specific settings he uses for this song

  • I'm bloody determined to learn this!

    Guna jst keep tryin till i do!:D

    Maybe meaning a all nighter!

    woop

  • Awesome tone, awesome bending and playing. You are very good as teacher.

  • I love this song. Please help us with what effects you have. :)

  • Also, 1:40 is just too fast :(

    Even looking at your tabs I can't figure out how to do it.

  • Nice lesson!

    If i buy my pod xt, I'll post the result!

    Thanks a lot man,

    Hugs.

  • Tony you're something else. Would love to see more Pink Floyd tutorials if you wouldn't mind doing so. Bravo, guy!

  • This is fantastic you have helped tremendously , any time in the future you will be teaching the second solo ( great stuff) you are a great teacher

  • this is so cool i appreciate this, i have a gipson. how do you get that clean sound? any affects u recomend? i really wana play this =]

  • I can't get the links to work for the downloads. Keeps giving me an "error" and trying to get me to pay. Anyone else having this problem?

  • very good teaching tony thankyou for your help keep up the good work.Looking for more help.

  • This has made me feel like anything is possible with my guitar. As a newbie to this lead solo world could anyone tell me the effects set up on this track. Thanks happy lickin

  • got to be the closest ive ever heard to gilmore, which is quite a feat!! very well done

  • Great video, as usual :D

    But I miss the section markup on the sheet, like you did on the iron man solo sheet. It made it alot easier to see exactly wich notes was in that section (im a newbie :) ), and so on. But I think I'll manage anyway, thanks for a great lesson once again!

  • I'm glad you caught that. I fixed it so you can download the tab with sections A through G. Check for the link on the right.

    And Thanks for checking out my videos. I'm always learning songs and I will share them with you.

  • Nice! Thanks!

  • Luv this song! Excellent lesson! 5*****

  • Great cover. Good job.

    So uh, when is the Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath tutorial video coming??? I cant wait :)

  • very nice work :)

  • first view/comment/post.

    your biggest fan.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more