Added: 3 years ago
From: peachfuzz877
Views: 10,876
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (102)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Honestly, both amazing, i would say evenly amazing. Brodeur has better record than roi but he also had a better defensive team to back him up. I'd say that makes it even.

  • Comment removed

  • i'm not anti roy but i feel that the amount of time given to brodeur is much less and thats y i disagree with you mr turnupthevolume.

  • They're both great goalies, but Brodeur was on a team with amazing defence (Niedermayer, Stevens, Rafakski, & Daneyko holy crap!) that trapped the crap out of every game.

    Not that the Avs or Habs had bad D (Blake, Foote, Bourque on the Avs; Robinson & Chelios on the Habs) but they weren't on the same page.

    No coincidence that after Niedermayer & Stevens left after '04 the Devils never got out of the 2nd round.

    Plus, in their head-to-head match-up, Roy won. Gotta give it to Patrick Roy.

  • martin brodeur

  • i think the sad part is that brodeur is gonna retire either this year or next year, and hockey will lose both the greatest goalies, I would pick Brodeur because of all the accolades he has, he holds more records than Roy, but Roy is still the 2nd best, and extremely close behind Brodeur, and to everyone saying Roy revolutionized the butterfly stance, just so you all know Brodeur revolutionized the HYBRID stance, its a very close call, but devils fans say it the best, MARTY'S BETTER! MB30 FTW

  • Man Roi was the best in Montreal...what a dumpass compilation!

  • Brodeur easy! Patrick always had a beast of a team to play in front of him. Brodeur did not always have one. New Jersey has only been dominant for the last 15 years ish. Although Roy would still have the wins record if his career didn't get cut short, Marty has done a lot more

  • Roy= Best of all time and will always be! martin broduer=Pussy

  • @MrFlyersFreak no broduer is 2nd best .... no doubt roy is best though

  • Patrick Roy

  • bs wrong mrturnupthevolume

  • Roy definently he had more heart

  • Roy all the way

  • JONATHAN QUICK

  • both are good, but i have to give the gold to roy. if you think about, it roy made brodeur better. the reason brodeur is so good is that roy brought butterfly to the nhl. so goalies tried doing butterfly but brodeur never uses it, so people were being trained against butterfly goalies, so playing against brodeur was like playing against a new style, so nobody knew how to play it, but if roy hadnt brought butterfly, every goalie would have been playing like brodeur, and he would be just a goalie.

  • roy got 5 more minutes then brodeur. and brodeurs better

  • @rfmapleleafs he got 5 more mins because he made 5 mins more worth of good saves. why? because roy is that much better than brodeur..... and he always will be.

  • @MrTurnupthevolume no... cuz whoever made this is a Roy fan... anyone else notice that Roy, for whatever reason whether on purpose or his style, gave up enormous rebounds and had to keep saving himself? the detroit one is a prime example... 2 big rebounds... He was still one of the best, as is Brodeur....much better? no Brodeur had an amazing arsenal of skills, Roy was just Butterfly king

  • @silfocus84 then tell me this, whats he king of? why did he lose the stanley cup finals the one time he was against Roy? tell me good answers to these questions then ill think about saying brodeur isnt so much worse than Roy.

  • Roy 

  • this song defines goaltending

  • tim thomas is the great goalie of the now, right now he can go toe to toe with broduer and ruy, BUT I WANT TO GET THIS ACROSS, he is not a hall of famer as of NOW he is playing better than them

  • @patsfan4life99 Okay you know what?... FUCK you tim thomas is a fucking dwarf.

  • @backuganhelper that maybe so but cough cough * stanley cup and con smyth* cough cough

  • THOMAS IS A BEAST SO YA !!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Patrick Roy evolved the Goaler's impact for the Ice Hockey game. Patrick Roy made possible for goalie to worth and earn money like a superstar scorer. Patrick Roy made this with a weak team. Brodeur followed his track with an ultra-defensive team. See who you think the beast goalie is!

  • Ryan Miller, btw the first "save" for brodeur went wide :)

  • It's Brodeur. Roy is definely somewhere on the top 5 but of course Roy is more popular, his team didn't block anyone from the cup :) ($20 says I'm going to get a hurtful reply) :(

  • roy is way better

  • any way you look at this there is a argument for both about why they are the best, with all there achievements i don't think anyone can say that one goalie is better. they were both amazing at doing what they do though and that is stopping the puck and winning games

  • Roy: 3 Conn Smythes nuff said

  • Hasek :D

  • Brodeur is speed

  • Marty, just look at the numbers. Also he's so much less of a d-bag than Roy was about his team. He had a rough game with the habs and that was it. Marty's had his rough spots with the devils and he's not going anywhere. He's a team player and that's what I respect about him.

  • Patrick Roy hands down. Martin Broduer is easily the 2nd best of all time but lets look at the facts here. Roy is an 11 time all star, he has 5 Jennings trophies, 3 Vezinas and 3 Conn Smythes and he is the youngest player to win the Conn Smythe as well as the only 3 time winner in history. He is also considered by many to be the father of modern goaltending and the guy who brought the butterfly to the limelight (not the first to use it but the first to use it so well)

  • MartIN

  • Comment removed

  • roy would be better if he still played but now its brodeur

  • Okay, my dad told me once that there was an actual fight between these two....i really wana see it, can somone give me a link?

  • martin brodeur all the way

  • Roy

  • patrick roy, martin is a crybaby

  • @kanyehatersrox your a duish bag martin brodeur is way better.

  • its Martin not Martain

  • Brodeur is good, but not as good as Roy.

  • The best: Roy!

  • wmg sucks balls

  • We can only see when Brodeur is retiered.

    I believe he can Win 1 or 2 more Veznias and 2 more Stanley Cups.

    The Conn Smythe Trophy is a great Honor,

    but seiously...

    Brodeur couldnt have has one.

    I believe he was over shadowed by great players in the PlayOffs.

    As for Patrick Roy of course he will have a few.

    No one else was as good as him the the PlayOffs except Joe Sakic and mabe Froseburg....

  • can't we just end the debate by saying that they're 2 of the greatest goalies to ever play the game?

    imo, Roy is the ultimate in focus and reaction speed

    Hasek the ultimate in acrobatic saves

    Brodeur is a combination of the 2 with a 5% decrease in each of their individual strengths.

  • lol rettaaard

    martAin Brodeur

    MARTIN

    WTF

  • Roy was very good but I think brodeur is the best.

  • roy for sure

  • roy > brodeur

  • I would pick brodeur over Roy any day, especially since Brodeur doesn't have catastrophic meltdowns that affect his team and he is gonna hvae the most career SO's by the time he retires. But you could win a cup with either guy in your net.

  • roy is soo much better

  • Brodeur's clearly better, I mean his 4 Stanley Cups, his 3 Conn Smythes (which is a record) and the fact that he virtually invented the butterfly and changed the game of hockey altogether. Oh wait... Roy did all that.

    And that's how you know Roy is better.

  • Roy didn't invent the butterfly he just popuralized it.

  • Note that I said "virtually". As in he helped promote it and perfect it to what it is today, which is what you see people like Marc-Andre Fleury using. And for all it matters, Roy did invent it. He's the one that started to flare his legs out, not just drop to his knees, which is what Glenn Hall (the actual "inventor") did.

  • He perfected it.

  • Brodeur is better. Roy has had multiple meltdowns where he's allowed 6 or 7 or even more goals. Brodeur has never had that happen. Brodeur has the most wins in a season, is about to have the most wins ever and either is or does have the most shutouts and has played less seasons than all other goalies whos records he's broken. He's also tied Roy for playoff shutouts and will break that too. Oh, and his all time GAA is better than Roy's too. And that's how you know Brodeur is better.

  • Comment removed

  • You're forgetting the fact that Roy played on the mediocre Montreal Canadians for over half his career, while Brodeur plated on the best defensive team in the league. If it's about numbers,Patrick never had a fair chance. Roy was never called the best because of his accomplisments, but because of his drive and ferocity. That was what made him unstoppable in the playoffs.

    Regular season=broduer is better

    Playoffs=Roy is just full of confidence

  • Sure but he had the likes of Foote, Blake and other good defenseman plus tremendous offensive talent on his team. Brodeur had barely any offensive support. The best defense is a good offense.

  • Ok, let's talk about Roy's stats. 161 playoff wins. Brodeur needs more than 50 to tie that, and he won't do that. If you try and say that most shutouts means he's the best, think of how much harder it was for Sawchuck to get the 103 he had. Roy will always be better than Brodeur, give it up. 3 Conn Smythes. How many does Brodeur have?

  • Umm no more SO's doesnt mean hes the best, it's the whole list of records that he's broken that makes him the best. And the only one that Roy has him on is Playoff wins.

  • *And Conn Smythes. Give up.

  • You keep telling me to give up as if my point is completely wrong and invalid. I guess a better career GAA and SV% and the fact that he has MORE SO's and wins and LESS losses in LESS seasons means nothing when comparing goalies. Look I'm not trying to down Roy, I'm just saying that when you look at the facts, Brodeur is better. Thus I think YOU should give up. 3 Stanley Cups, 4 Vezinas (Roy had 3), 4 Jennings speaks for itself. Keep in mind that Brodeur has a good 3-5 years left to win more.

  • "Best" means in terms of numbers, so Brodeur is the best goalie.

    However, if you were tied 0-0 in game 7 of the stanely cup finals in double overtime, which goalie would you rather have in net? One who is known to fall down under pressure or the goalie who thinks the very idea of "pressure" is exciting?

  • Pressure? Roy let up 7 goals to Detroit in the Western Confrence Finals in 2002. 9 in 1994 or '95 during his last game with the Habs. When Roy gets rattled he's useless. Not to mention his temper and attitude. I'd take Brodeur over Roy every time. Call me thickheaded if you want but Roy was too cocky for his own good and he crumbled from it multiple times.

  • I guess the fact that Roy is 4-1 in finals and Brodeur is 3-2 would make me comfortable with either one of them but if I had the choice I'd take Marty.

  • Isn't Brodeur 3-1 in finals?

    he has only lost to the Avalanche in 01, the rest he won right?

  • You can't act like Brodeur deserved the Vezina last year, no way. He didn't lead in any categories like GAA, Save Percentage, Wins, Shutouts (Nabokov was better in every category). And yeah, Roy let in 9 in his last game in Montreal, because he didn't want to play at all, but the coach wouldn't let him come out. And without Roy, there wouldn't be goaltending today, there wouldn't be a butterfly. Roy had 10 overtime wins in the playoffs his rookie season. He had no offense, he was the whole team.

  • "He had no offense, he was the whole team." I can say the same exact thing for Brodeur. And once Stevens left he continued to put up consistently good numbers. Like I said before, more wins, shutouts, and playoff shutouts all in less seasons.

  • Esposito first used the butterfly, if it wasn't for him, there would be no butterfly style, without Roy, it wouldn't have been popular, Also Roy had 10 overtime victories in 93, not his rookie year.

  • Good catch, i was drunk when I left that. But it wasn't Esposito, they say it was Glenn Hall. I'm too young to have seen either play, but that's what the book "Without Fear" says. It's a pretty sweet book, written by the staff of The Hockey News. Check it out sometime.

  • Truthfully, I had just watched a video on Tony Esposito at that time and they were talking about his style and how he was like a father to the butterfly style or something, so yeah, I am subscribed to THN, but I doubt I will get it through that, so maybe i will

  • Both are quebecois so.. i dont care

  • @caca98019 Haha 2 years later and I still laugh at that comment.

  • luongo- haha thats funny. roy's my favorite player of all time, but it really doesnt matter which one you have your gonna win anyway.

  • brodeur..roy sucks

  • agreed brodeur is best but roy is still good

  • Comment removed

  • @powwerranger not at all. roy has done WAY better than brodeur. roy almost singlehandedly led the habs to 2 stanley cups and led the avs two cups. he has 3 conn smythes which is more than anyone including gretzky (who he has deked before) so roy is just better.

  • @MrTurnupthevolume your giving him credit for deking gretzky? what was gretzky donna do? slam into him?

  • @zomgaskill its a joke, but, yes.

  • actually the answer wuld be Roberto Luongo ..

  • he is hurt so i dont think he his the answer

  • well that a good question because

    brodeur-968 games 538 wins 290 losses

    but,still playing

    roy-1029 games 551 wins 315 losses

    but,is retired

  • there both great goalies! but any true hockey fan knows that has at least watched hockey for 10 years that roy is better. dont get me wrong broduer is great in his own way but roy is the best goalie of all time.

  • Roy is the best goalie of all time and the best fighter ;)

  • @loppar3 Best "goalie" yes, without a doubt. Fighter, no. Hextall would take him in a curb stomp

  • a 1:26 of brodeur , 5 minutes of Roy...Also second song blows.

  • this is good video i like it

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more