paul is dead - the rotten apple 18 L

[boobah1067]

This backmask doesn't convince. Others do. Why put this in your series?

[BEATLES4EVER57]

I got an Ipod and yesterday at midnight he turn on all alone and the song how was playing was Revolution 9 and believe me...I DON'T HAVE THIS SONG ON MY IPOD ! I didn't sleep of all night

[VonFisch1]

0:55 "Ah blup"

1:06 "Em dee dep di dep" 

Try again.

[raymaster56]

"Really dead?" I hear "ABIDA BED"

[Msemospongebob]

i think the people who do these video's just hate the Beatles and want to ruin their songs by saying they say "paul is blody" or "he's really dead" in the backround or if you play it backwards.

[lrkel]

More like i know it than i know you.

[bluesrock2008]

please, enough with "turn me on dead man"!

[anime0wnz1423]

at 1:13 he is saying my knee hurts a lot

[lansfordjames]

im getting preety freekin pissed off about hearing"turn me on dead man"

[YouDonteverhavetodie]

well, not that this isn't interesting but i really have to go and watch some wallpaint dry

[OddlyRandomPro]

0:41 it sounds like he said, "better me than you." haha. for some reason.

[byemynameishi]

ok, seriously, if you tried saying 'you better believe it' backwards, it would probably sound something like 'i'm really dead'. plus you can hear the ammount of syllables. it's not supposed to sound like that. stop screwing around with beautiful music :(

[DCAreaguy2001]

faul looks like a trainee

[L0K3]

you see how george touched his face? well that's an ancient tibetan gesture commonly given at funeral processions to the relatives of the deceased

[frikinjoe]

@L0K3 And believe it or not, Paul does it many times, if you watch several DVDs of Paul McCartney´s concert he makes this several times. I went to Paul´s concert in Mexico last year, he touched his face like George does it here so many times. :S

[squmak]

a guitar can sound like that if u put the tone on the guitar to 0 or 1 and on the guitar amp,high bass on the equalizer. i would like 2 learn what george was playing in this vid. cud b fun 2 play.

[elitet0kr]

it gets more ridiculous as time goes on...

[calvero75]

(1:07) Los niños de Cerati... los niños de Cerati...

mmm...

Ah!! Soda Stereo está muerta!!!!

[UNSCArcher]

It sounded like Im a cookie.

[Flasoo8]

jrrcor...Paul at the time was already an accomplished musician, and could play many instruments. He simply chose to play the accoustic guitar for that song for the camera. Apart from the vocals, the accoustic guitar is the prominent driving force of this song...the 'bed' if you will.

[jrrcor]

Why is such a wonderful... so-called bass player.... not playing bass... why is George playing???

[ShanBruceLee]

jrrcor - there are pictures from the early beatles years showing Paul playing drums too. Of all the beatles, he was the most skilled player.

[canbekalakay]

George is playing electric guitar.

[jrrcor]

Sorry to disappoint, but it's a bass guitar,,,,may not look like it,,,, but watch the way he's playing...who do you think is playing the bass line.... it would be George who admitted it in later clips...

[canbekalakay]

George is playing the bass line, but he is still playing an electric guitar. It's the one he used in the other videos in Let it Be and at the rooftop concert.

[canbekalakay]

George is playing the "bass line", but he is still playing it on an electric guitar. It's the same Fender Telecaster that he used throughout the Let it Be film and at the rooftop concert :)

[Alfonxdk]

Narh its a guitar, if you look close and look on the tuning screws(sorry for bad english there) you can see it strings up in 6, and if you listen to it it sounds like when i play my fender and i turn down the tone on one of my single coils. So my guess is that its a Guitar he is playing here...

[zolf1988]

no, it's a 6 strings Fender bass :)

[LizardPlay]

all who belive in this shit are idiots

[Redstar226]

Its more plausible than Christianity.

[gubnud]

not a single one of those lines reversed says anything near what you claim they say....paul is alive and anyone who even comtemplates thinkin otherwise is a complete fucking idiot...ive watched quite a few of thesse 'rotten apple' things and theyre all shite

[ProSkateNate90]

Correct me if i wrong but

the guy in the red is Paul Right playing bass

and Paul played lefty so why is he playing right handed

[thedayitriedtodie]

are u for real?????

that's George, and that's a guitar....

paul is singing and playing an acoustic... with a left,,...

u thing.....

what an idiot!

[thedayitriedtodie]

ok, ur young...

but still... jesus...

[wemily101]

thats george

[tellyxx]

What's this song called ?

[JJJKK6699]

two of us

[pajamysamy]

im not being rude im just curious why do u referr to people as sheep?

[The5thBeatle92]

at 1:00 I can't hear "I'm dead" but latin word "ab est"

[survivorguy91]

Spending someone else's hard earned pay?

[josiesezlol]

Ok I'm tired of hearing "turn me on dead man."

[daddypriam]

@josiesezlol Don't watch, then. Simple for someone with a brain.

[josiesezlol]

@daddypriam jeez whats your damage faggot

[ladybuglove4all]

@josiesezlol to me it sounds more like nomnomnom, and it makes me hungry -_-'

[lavacalechera9]

@josiesezlol agg... me too :@

[kartr123]

Spanish!!

[BeckiiBubbles]

what the hell i just looked at the related vids and it had a "paul is dead-rotten apple 64" you can sod that off.

i really dont have time to sit here and watch these 20 second videos about a rumor.

if paul was replaced then maybe that was the best thing for the fans and for the group. they might have lost a lot of love through that accident. but if its not true then these videos are just filling peoples heads with lies and making them suspicious about someone, why? he's got too much talent?

[jqfs]

Utter and total BULLSHIT!!!!!! Paul is NOT dead. Goddamn get a life people.

[orbandsceptre27]

First you say it`s backmasking, then you say it`s not - what exactly are you trying to say...?

[edmatper]

bullshit !

[wicatar1]

for the record, i heard "im good","lets see u listen up" and thats just whet i heard.

[Tuberman67]

Ok, I think I got it all figured out now. Paul was in an accident. He survived, but became a vegetable. William Campbell replaced Paul, which is why there was such a long break between "Revolver" and "Strawberry Fields." There, I solved it, now can we put this to rest?

[onlywas]

I think if paul was dead,that william campbell was a lucky bastard to marry whith that good piece of pussy was linda.

[plstrom]

yu need a really good imagination and even than a big strech to ear those things you write...

[blabadiblabla]

The first one you say sounds like "i'm dead" really sounds like "Alll puttin, al putting.." and your so called "really dead" really sounds like "good fee fix it up, good fee fix it up.." Really off on those two. :P

[THOSANDJosh]

I HATE SHIT LIKE THIS that makes you think that a crock of shit is true!!! 1. The words you're hearing are your imagination. Have you heard of it?! Just because one guy starts a rumor that Paul died, everyone believes him!! 2. One kind of fag with no life would be willing to make over 60 videos about a myth that isn't even true!!! FAGGOT!!!(& I don't mean a bundle of twigs either)

[skidoofus]

He does make a convincing arguement though, i know that all this is a crock but no need for name calling though. I agree with you in some sence but he spent time in makeing a rumour true and he has done a good job with it

[keys4ever2]

I cant understand the reasoning behind why the creator of this film wants to add this song as a clue. It again is a very clever use of back masking but, how can you back mask a live recording.  If you listen to other takes of this song, Paul says different things at different times, totally improvising on every take. When you play music or any recording backwards, often times there will be phrases that sound like audible familiar words but to use this technic on a live recording is ridiculous.

[pickimmymouth]

bull shit

[Doppelganger9000]

and who the fuck cares if it sais i know you

[Doppelganger9000]

its what you want it to be

instead of "really dead" it sounds more like "is jesus dead." its just noises

[neozos]

we are all dead when we are born.unbelievable but true.

[georgeharrisonislove]

FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAKE paul is still alive

[fluggencheimen]

You are only hearing what you want to hear.

[blabadiblabla]

You said it in a nutshell.

[GoBrowns26]

maybe assdoooouuutttt has a point i think i hear him sayin number 9 to before turn me on deadman which could be pointing to revolution 9 where alot of stuff in reverse is saying paul is dead

[paul43mccartney43]

finally we see paul playing guitar

[lsdarcy]

Fuckin GARBAGE!

[lsdarcy]

RUBBISH

[assdoooouuutttt]

am I the only one who hears "number 9" before I hear "turn me on deadman" when the video starts?

[seanman11111]

i did too! so wierd rite?

[amen1994]

Dudes,turn me on dead man and number 9 are playing at the same time ;)

[CryHepZero]

whatever you freak. stupid . it did not say that

[lennon1412]

I really want to show you my experience but it's all in my mind.... lol

[Katsnjammer]

The smart thing is to reverse the Beatles songs and make them sounds like something they want them to be and that's why some beatlemaniacs believed in it

[Caesaro]

How could Paul be saying "I'm Dead"!?

[lennon1412]

I just heard Penny Lane forewards and the same time Strawberry Fields Forever backwards. At 1,18 Paul said: I'm alive you silly people and at 2,06 John said: No, you're dead.

[rog944]

Wow, man, that's a freakout! But did Paul say he was alive, or was it Billy Campbell?

[lennon1412]

I think it was paul himself from heaven. In 1971 john imagined there's no heaven, and paul came back. then he did this one interview where he said: I wasn't really dead. This is cool, isn't it?

[rog944]

Paul wasn't really did... just genetically mutated.... his soul lived on in the DNA trasnplanted into Billy Campbell.

[wongseewhy]

*William cambell*

[deepvoodoo]

William Eugene Campbell

[grobanbuble]

Yeah lol I heard "I'm really Paul" but i did hear "I know you" very clearly. but I think the Beatles were just doing this for fun b.c too many people were trying to find hidden meanings in their songs. I think john said this somewhere in an interview.

It's really fun trying to find clues tho. Real of not.

BEATLES FOREVER!

[quantum52]

man, stupid people....

if people want to know, theres a thing

if people FORCE THINGS TRYING TO KNOW, theres another thing......

[beatleslovee]

I hear "Im really Paul" "He lives it up" and "I know it good"

[Marlowann]

It doesn't sound like "I'm dead," it sounds like "I'm willing."

[beatleslovee]

HAHA You wont even believe it, I heard "Im really Paul"

[Weirfan69]

i got "theres been an incident" and "i know it goob"

[RpKingman]

I think we need to remember the very primitive technology that the average person had back then. I do believe in this conspiracy but sometimes I think it goes too far. Its easy for us to reverse video and network all these clues, but in the '60s this would have been a monumental effort for the average person. Fans in the U.S. didn't even have access to most of the media & recordings which were available in the UK.

[VoteLynnSwan]

In this video, Paul is playing bass right handed, Paul was a left handed player...

Also, George Harrison is playing left handed when he was traditionally a right handed player.

[zitface42]

that is ridiculously untrue!!! Paul is playing left-handed in the video and George is playing right handed! Look again!!

[VoteLynnSwan]

it was my mistake... Paul's beard threw me off... I mistook Harrison for Paul haha.

[MCRmauricionvp]

i know you too..

iamaphoney rocks

[iejmem]

"relieve the debt"?

[madaboutmika75]

sounds like: 'i am smitten' and 'ive been bittener' and 'i know you'

xx mavvy xx

[bettysaidulied]

How does a "dead guy" say he is dead? this rumor is sooooooo stupid and funny

[oxodunk]

He's not Paul he's William Campbell a Fake PAul cos the other is dead

[Kilerchuk]

The power of suggestion is so strong in something like this.

Not only are people looking for those words...but you actually put them in text on the screen so that you are reading them while "hearing them".

Even closing your eyes to watch it the first time will make you come up with something different.

[Kilerchuk]

All I am hearing is:

Is Meal Deb.

[morninggloryseed]

After seeing all of these, I'm convinced whoever made this is simply spoofing the whole 'paul is dead' thing, and those who believe it.

[jesusranch34]

you have way too much time on your hands man, the myth can only go so far, and notice I said "myth". all you're doing is ruining these great song for everyone.

[magazinekitchen]

is there any song you wont try to claim has a message?

[bgumbyguitar]

Iamaphony takes it up the butt with no lube while listening to Michael Jackson plead his innocenece of child molestation backwards.

[beatlegal4eva]

woteva loser

just coz u dream of michael jackson u sicko!!

haha

LMAO

theres a clue from all my comments iv left u

STOP WATCHING twat

[bgumbyguitar]

your the fuckin loser bozo. Keep dreaming that you have something with this dead shit

[bdown4l1]

it's me again bgumbyguitar SEE YOU NEXT ROTTEN APPLE VID

[beatlegal4eva]

init

if u dont like it wanker ful off

[MCRmauricionvp]

ROFL i loved John whistling backwards

[beatlegal4eva]

me 2

[MCRmauricionvp]

it rocked right?!

[HaHaHaPaulIsDead]

Stoopa stoopa YOU.

See Rotten Apple #36 ("Hello, Dad").

[lordmitchwood]

This theory is the biggest load of crap EVER

[bgumbyguitar]

If you play Flying from Magical Mystery Tour backwards at half speed it says "Paul is going to bumfuck your mum and show you all he's alive"

[HaHaHaPaulIsDead]

He'd refuse your mum, that's for sure. His belief system doesn't allow him to consume animal flesh.

[bgumbyguitar]

What belief system? I thought he was dead you arsehole. Not a bad comeback though but if you really believe that crap you are definitly a shit for brains retarded misguided fool who needs to let the sixties press propaganda lie in its past.

[HaHaHaPaulIsDead]

The dude who today calls himself PJM that you think is PJM is a vegetarian and an "animal rights activist" so he is the one who would refuse your mother. It was the Beatles who said that Paul was dead (and then denied that they'd said it), not "sixties press propaganda".

[bgumbyguitar]

Well I think that there is enough said by you to determine you are craked like I said earlier. Just think of what great music we would have not had if the real(I'm just kidding folks) Paul would not have turned himself into a dead person. Anyway I refuse to argue about this mountain of bullshit implanted in the minds of the skeptical nuts.

[bgumbyguitar]

Aslo I am starting a "Paul is Red" rumor. 1st clue is the song Back in the USSR. This played at regular speed in the stereo and mono versions tell us that he is not dead but he is a communist hence the term Paul is Red. Hows that for laugh.

[bgumbyguitar]

Clue number two. They painted him RED in the movie. HELP. Paul is not dead but RED!!!!

[bgumbyguitar]

Paul is Ringo in Help. Ringo was painted RED and is not dead yet. Paul also is not dead but RED. Hence the album RED ROSE SPEEDWAY. lol

[bgumbyguitar]

Clue number 4 is in the song Yes it IS. John sings the word Red is the color that my baby wore. RED Paul is RED.

[bgumbyguitar]

Clue number 5 is Strawberry Fields Forever. what color is a Strawberry? You guessed it right RED, Paul is not dead but Red as in communist. Sounds stupid doesn't it? just like the Paul is DEAD crap.

Number six John mudders Cranberry sauce at the end of this track.

[bgumbyguitar]

your all fuckin cracked

[applemaca07]

I know you too!.....Yah rocket!

[Maxdtf]

LoL...

Instead of I'm Dead I hear "I burried Paul"... Did Faul burried Paul ? OMG...

And yes, Paul played on accoustic, on piano, on bass, and on many more instruments...

[jrouly]

beatle backmasking = just a hoax

for those who belive paul is not dead check out "paul is NOt dead - belive it or not series" on youtube,

not as good as the rotten apple seris but tells the truth

[iLikeCookies6607]

it sounded like he said look at me im dead

[Beatle1989]

To all you people that believe he is dead, anwser these.

1. What happened to the car.

2. How did the Beatles so quickly find an imposter that looks, sounds, as talented and as good song writer as paul.

3. How did 'Faul' get pauls bank account and house etc.

4. Why would pauls family let an imposter into there lives?

5. Why didnt jane leave 'Faul' 'straight away' after the 'supposed death'?

6. So linda was tricked into thinking he was the real paul?

[Tdani81]

Here are your answers:

1.The car was totaled.

2.The imposter was a talented musician named Billy Sheppard from Billy Pepper and the Pepperpots that disappeared around 66.

3.Brian let 'Faul' have Paul's bank account b/c he had access to it in order to desposit his money.

4.Paul's family were probably threatened by a mafia to keep quiet.

5.Jane Asher DID leave Faul after she saw the relationship wasn't going to work.

6.Yes, Linda was either tricked or fell in love with Faul.

[FidoForce42]

Paul is playing an acoustic???

[Shlumpledink]

It sounds like he said im blue. OMG PAUL IS AN ALIEN

[Tdani81]

Ok, this video was a very weak "clue".

[Salhavika]

Ok, that was just stupid... nothing sounded like it was supposed to sound like.

[Clanocelle77]

Eh beh !! Vous avez de l'imagination pour entendre I'm dead !!

Well !! You've got imagination to hear "I'm dead" !!!

[Earthlinked]

All I hear is "That bitch Heather Mills is NOT going to take all my money - I'll beat the shit out of her again!!" but maybe I am wrong -- not sure if it says "bitch" or "stumped legged whore"

[Earthlinked]

YOU ARE COMPLETELY WRONG!!!!

It is Koo-Koo-Ka-jube!!!!

[Matrixproductions]

I did not hear really dead but I did hear 'I know you'

[jetflock]

just enjoy the video.

[beatlekrista]

LOL wtf??? All I hear is "I know a go".

Um...yah...reeeaaall scary knowing goo's and such.

Nice try though.

[TwoHourBreaks]

O I get it. Back masking is done by first making your song and then you play it backwards and superimposed a message whereever it will fit. Sounds very mysterious but actually it's pretty easy.

[paulonthepiano]

lame

[stefichjo]

Nonsense. These reverse sounds could mean _anything_. And they do _not_ even sound like "I'm dead" and stuff.

[paulisadeadman5]

pauls dead, its a joke, i dont believe hes dead but im fascinated with all of the clues, believe it or dont believe it but this shit is brilliant so is the guys whos making these

[Uploadmorevids]

wow that sounds nothing like hes reallu dead

[flowerzandbeads]

george is too hot for words....

[guitarlicksinc]

well my aunt and i were watching let it be and she pointed out his cheeks got a little puffy

[TheNaturalWoman]

I guess it was a gimick, because right now Paul is fighting in a nasty divorce battle with his ex-wife, Heather Mills McCartney.

[julian234]

Sounds like "Visa debt" to me!!

[beatlekrista]

Lol. hey! It actually does sound like "Visa Debt" more then anything. :D

[JamesPaul66]

Geez, you need to stop shopping.

[shyface52]

yaaa where you said 'i know you' (well does that make sense) i hear 'i know he is'

[johnpaulolivier]

If you can read this, you´re lucky,so you can say: I´m alive. If you can´t read this you propably passed away in a car crash like our poor Paul. So RIP and go on wasting your time. Living on borrowd time without a thought of tomorrow! Lebe Deinen Traum und denke über das Leben und nicht über den Tod nach. I think your dead rumor folks are really dead in your mind!

[JamesPaul66]

Maybe you should get a life. Because you don't believe this and your still posting. The evidence is overwhelming that Paul died. This means there are some criminals committing fraud and criminals should be in jail. So you see, this really does have a purpose.

[Kainlarsen]

Says the pot to the kettle.

Evidence? WHAT evidence?! All you have are a string of vague hidden things in music and artwork. That is proof of NOTHING! If Paul was really dead, there would be no way in hell 3 guys from Liverpool could cover it up. Frankly, I find you faintly ridiculous in your refusal to look at logic. You are merely an over-zealous fan.

[iamaphoney]

dont worry

the truth is on its way

the 9 november 2007

[JamesPaul66]

Can u elaborate?

[floydian709]

What happens on november 9th??????????

[JamesPaul66]

Kain - UR an over-zealous ignoramous. Your "evidence" proves nothing. Just because something seems difficult, doesn't make it impossible. Are you so naive that you can't figure out what a little money and muscle can do?

You must be connected to The Beatle organization to be so sure of your position with such lame argumentation. MI6? You don't have to listen to the music to know. Just look at the facial forensic analysis, the height difference, etc. Guess that's "illogical" as well.

[twoperfect]

I don't know much about paul mccartney and i don't even know the whole conspiracy thing. All I know is that the Beatles were famous

But already I'm thinking it's a load of BS =/ Why don't they just say it straight up? Wouldn't his family say something if he was actually dead?

[renownpete]

get a life!!

[roisincasey]

what a load of crap. Anything can be made to seem real, especially with so many people in the world with so little to do

[dalehutchinson]

ARE THE BEATLES DEAD IS WHAT I HEARD

[Truthseeker47]

Where you said " I know you", I hear "I know I do". I did hear " really dead".

[Vime]

or...have bee for sid....