Added: 2 years ago
From: CurzonRoad
Views: 1,435
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (21)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • MOLTO BELLO!!! Thank you my friend for sharing this Wonderful and Rare Performance of Great Australian Operatic Soprano DAME NELLIE MELBA (1861 – 1931).

  • I believe it IS Melba. It sounds exactly like her. Adams was an excellent singer but with a lighter voice, and I don't think she had any reason that very day to imitate (so perfectly!) Melba's spirit and "maniere de chanter" in everything - tone production, trill, scales etc - Melba three years later still had an excellent high D in the recording of Se saran rose. I really believe it is her.

  • According to the Met database, Melba sang Marguerite de Valois only 4 times in 1901 and then never again.

    Adams sang Queen Margot 8 times in 1901, and 3 times in 1902.

    I am the most fanatical Melba fan who ever lived, but I've always believed this to be an Adams performance, based on the Rogers & Hammerstein Library transfer of 1985.

    Now, listening to this, I'm no longer so sure.

  • But two of Melba's 1901 performances were on tour.

  • At 1:10, you can hear that high note (even through this cylinder), ringed throughout the operahouse. This soprano must have had a big voice.

  • The earlier file (see "video responses"), minus filtering thus even noisier, actually gives an even stronger "live" presence. Thank you by stopping by! Cheers, etc. Doug --

  • Great performance

    If this is not Melba which it seem to be- it [must ?] be another Marchesi student. The vocal product - pure silvery voices and precise attacks are like fingerprints.

    Thanks-JOHN

  • There is a new Melba biography (by Ann Blainey) worth seeking out.

  • "Nellie Melba, a Contemporary Review" by William R. Moran (Greenwood Press, 1985) is very, very good.... but I'll be looking for the Blainey book here momentarily. THANK YOU!

  • Doug, it gives me chills to think this was captured so many years ago. This transfer has quite an amazing quality and whoever the wonderful operatic soprano was had an awesome voice.

  • Hi Ginny: Thanks! For many it is clearly Melba.... and for others, well, it clearly isn't, thus fun & games. In any case, and no matter, quite an amazing document. Perhaps we could get the CIA & FBI to help in identifying our singer! ALL BEST. Cheers, etc. Doug --

  • Caro Douglasio,

    This is a very intersting post. I have no idea which Soprano it is, however, I am awed by the device that captured the voice so long ago. The soprano singing had a beautiful clear voice and the two ladies in your video were very beautiful. Grazie mio caro.

  • There is a silvery quality that is definitely Melba's. Also, we hear a very penetrating voice, of rather large volume, a lyric coloratura, not a leggiero stuff.

    Ponselle one day said and repeted that Melba's voice was " a great, large voice, not a light soprano at all".

  • As I've stated before, I for one am convinced this is Melba, not Adams or some other soprano. The tone is difficult to judge by on these Mapleson cylinders, but the technique, including the Melba scales, is unmistakable. Thanks so much for posting.

  • It's really very, very interesting (and perhaps like a Rorschach inkblot test?). There are so many who agree, while many others will beg to differ. As I've said before... no matter... amazing document. Thank you very much !

  • Thanks for posting!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more