The X Factor USA - Melanie Amaro Live SHOWS- WEEK 1

[lhiz646]

charice..................

[kayitangan]

oww shes good! but definitely not better than charice^_^

[milleyloveful]

@kayitangan

yes she is

[kayitangan]

@milleyloveful huhhhmm..u can visit my channel & watch charice version of this song..& see also charice singing some lung busting songs live^_^

[78applemac]

Very far from Charice's version...now who says that Melanie is better than Charice? Listen carefulyy LOL

[666theevilthatmendo]

I LOVE YOU !!! MELANIE!!!!! .............

[fufurriify]

She is realy amazing... I hope that she gonna win!!!! Yeeeeeaahhh Mel!!!

[bondwr]

Melanie will win, as she should because she has it all, the voice, the talent. Drew also has a unique voice and is also a favorite of mine, however I still think it should go to Melanie. For the "guys" I think Josh should win. This is just my opinion.

[smmerchick11]

@FLguyCB It wasn't the prettiest note... Lol. But she's a  human she makes mistakes, besides that she sounded amazing and usually always is so good.

[parrafito]

@smmerchick11 If we are talking about her notes then we should talk about Eric René who did not hit a note ever!

[missRichmondvirginia]

she always makes me cry

[Pardyhard1]

They should redo the Witney Tour and have Mel sing instead. Yahhhh

[DRnatz16]

uhm.. i think her voice is just okay,,,, not good, juz sayin' :)

[Hawanlaydee]

could hear the nerves! cracked a bit (well, don't make me "CLOSE" one more door)

but, I love Melanie but going for JOSH! rooting for you though!

[babyjrocs10]

I LOVE THAT SONG ESPEACIL SHE SONGED

[shannonsmithmusic]

that gave me chills like 100 times

[westfaner]

Horrible song choice... why ... why does anyone want to her this song ??, she is amazing.. good job on a very tough song to sing.

[chyeamooya]

how the hell could simon be so blind to send her home

[FLguyGB]

@chyeamooya He did that for ratings, lol. You really think something as expensive as flying an entire camera crew to Florida, not to mention Simon taking time out of his ever-important life to go, was done on a whim? The show underperformed in its first week, and they've been pulling every stop to get the ratings back up.

[FLguyGB]

@FLguyGB And then they had to eliminate *two* girls to make up for it *GASP*...the public like twists and drama, and Cowell likes his bank account to grow.

[TheMichael95s]

That was AMAZING!

[bezko17]

i was so happy that melanie made it to top 3, i know she can make it till finals, actually i like them all drew, rachel and melanie

[edinburghboy75]

melanie she no 1

[benjaax]

she's fantastic but She sang out of tune in the beggining of the first chorus .. but it's a little mistake.. she's amazing she will win.. or drew or josh

[TheKingLotus]

@vkendriv...you're a clown for that comment. She only doesn't connect with IDIOTS like yourself...lmao

[benjaax]

@TheKingLotus you're wrong asshole.. u will see her in the final 2 and YOU will be the idiot in that moment.

fuck you

[TheKingLotus]

@benjaax wtf!!?? Aren't you the same hypocrite that just stated "... but it's a little mistake.. she's amazing she will win..."??

GTFOH.....you just want attention. Make up your mind and hop off my d!ck!! LMAO

[benjaax]

@TheKingLotus shut up piece of shit, wait the finals and shut up little shit

[thehappykadaw]

She didn't do good, she did AMAZING!

[serasjustin]

she sing good but i'll go for drew she have an amazing voice..i lab both of u

[FLguyGB]

Are you kidding? That first "close" on the chorus sounded terrible.

[kushi8410]

@FLguyGB SHE IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING BUT I AGREE WITH YOU

[ukeinfused]

@FLguyGB: give this young woman a chance (look at the first two and the 2nd live show!!). Melanie admitted being very emotional here and that it affected her song. The producers really messed with her - they sent her home after two stunningly brilliant auditions, and she had to sit there in that rejection for 3 weeks before Simon came back for her.

[cersus]

@ukeinfused Agree!...

[maiiraaXD]

@FLguyGB Hahahah, i think you are a pathetic loser that's jealous. Oh, since you thought that way, why dont you STAND THERE ON THE STAGE (like it would ever happen) and sing ... LIKE THAT. Eveyone would already boo-ed you before you even started.

[FLguyGB]

@maiiraaXD Awww, don't get all butthurt. Everyone has an opinion.

[cersus]

@FLguyGB she did mess up the first 'close', okay, and the second 'close' was ALMOST there, it fell flat at the end... but she nailed every other single part of the song!

[flgarrett]

@FLguyGB Yes, there was a hiccup of sorts on that first "close", but there is no denying that this young lady is a young Whitney/Maria/Celine type of talent. Don't know if she will win, but don't hate on her...

[missyjaneflo]

@FLguyGB How did this get top comment? Why don't you go up there and sing this song in front of a million people...

[infashionsense]

She is an absolute natural, LOVE HER!!

[cheecomania]

she is awesome!

[vkendriv]

She only sings well thats all, there´s no connection with audience

[benjaax]

@vkendriv haha you're wrong, it's all the opposite. And she didn't sing "well", she sings amazing her record it's similar to beyonce, she will be a big singer