also taiwan is so lucky to have such many great singers!and joanna was is gonna be ma favourite asian singer!without you taiwan,aisa would become soundless...
Normally during a performance, everyone's eyes are on the performer.. but I noticed that the majority of the audience were looking upwards. Her singing was so moving that everyone was trying not to cry.
this is since a-Mei, the most beautiful voice that i had ever heard. such emotion in that voice! can't wait for her albam! wish that she can carry on Taiwan's vocie like Tsai Qing and a-Mei and many other great voices did.
太感人了
s098002600 1 year ago
Joanna的表演真的很棒,有一種從一開始,大家都因為失去了這樣一個好朋友好家人而難過得不得了,然後慢慢的,輕輕柔柔的撫慰現場大家的憂傷的氛圍。
anleena0110 1 year ago 2
wow...the song itself is marvelous...what more combine with Joanna's voice. superb
stemilyn 1 year ago
真的好好聽
acoboylikeyou 2 years ago
what happened? who died?
winkiiV 2 years ago
Its Joanna's mentor
totskyg 2 years ago
so he died??
winkiiV 2 years ago
such an amazing voice.
such a precious gift.
such a talent girl.
keeping singing, we cherish u, support u, and love you forever.
today211314 2 years ago 4
太煽情了,人家只会更伤心~
laoshapigou 2 years ago
who died ? is this her dad ? the one that recently help her with her debut album ? what just happend here ?
alcs82 2 years ago
這首歌真的很棒
qwert780407 2 years ago 3
写给你的歌,最能打动人心
colorblue88 3 years ago 2
著名的作曲家張弘毅(1950-2006),去年過世,迄今整整 一年,這位在台灣電影 音樂界、流行音樂界、舞劇、輕歌劇有多元貢獻的作者,極少人知道 他的名字,除非你說「 玫瑰人生」、「隨風而逝」的作曲家。 這一年許多朋友的共同協力下,張弘毅紀念音樂會-「張弘毅音樂人 生」,將以台灣首見的 型式登場,橫跨流行經典音樂、電影配樂、電視主題曲、舞台...
YourJovi 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
有需要攪到那麼煽情嗎?你看他太太多悲多傷...有想過她的感受嗎...歌是很好聽,也太殘酷了吧
gordonleung226 3 years ago
it might seem "cruel", but sometimes tears are what you need to heal the pain.
You should admire how she's able to pull the song through without breaking. That's her teacher as well after all.
terting 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
也没有到残酷那么严重拉...
又关那太太感受什么事
不过那献辞的也太长气了
罗里巴索的
他还以为现在是董事长长致词咩...
meemeewawa 3 years ago
哭可以有很多種情緒:悲痛、感傷、幽怨、不捨,也可以是激動、欣慰。舉例來說,有些奧運選手得獎升旗的時候哭,就不是一種悲傷的哭。但願張太太的哭,帶有一些溫柔、甜蜜的回憶。
teresateng1 3 years ago 3
難不成 她老公死了 還要很開心喔= =?
orz0430 3 years ago
我不是那個意思,我只是希望他們也顧及一下他太太的感受,她不一定想要常常悼念他,無奈他丈夫是個公眾人物,是不能避免,但不是一定煽情的悼念才叫真的悼念,像我的話,我會希望每一年開個party大家開開心心玩來悼念他,或者搞個基金會做慈善等等,或Joanna唱誰不哭呢,懷念如果是痛的,不快樂的,幹嘛讓自己不快樂呢
gordonleung226 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
就这么几句话还要看稿吗?
opooice 3 years ago
看看沒甚麼嘛,你到他那年紀會說話已經很不錯了
gordonleung226 3 years ago 4
深深感受到詞裡所說的... 那種淡淡的憂愁與悲哀的感覺... 太感動了...
lingcei 3 years ago 6
goodness this girl
is a genius
so talented
taiwan is lucky to have
her
Ginne86 3 years ago 12
also taiwan is so lucky to have such many great singers!and joanna was is gonna be ma favourite asian singer!without you taiwan,aisa would become soundless...
liuwenjie6678 3 years ago 4
aww thanks for supporting Taiwanese singers!
please keep supporting them! :)
Ginne86 3 years ago 2
好感人的歌聲!
沒有刻意的哭腔,卻更能讓人感動
tomkoo1229 3 years ago 7
She did great on this,a voice so soft yet so deep and in control.
gottarockman 3 years ago 3
before she sang, i thinked she cried.
beibeiXD 3 years ago
stop reading.........
count500 3 years ago
who die?
carinequah14 3 years ago
Normally during a performance, everyone's eyes are on the performer.. but I noticed that the majority of the audience were looking upwards. Her singing was so moving that everyone was trying not to cry.
王若琳的聲音好感動! 我也快哭了. ;w;
BeiShen 3 years ago 4
woah... she sings so effortlessly! amazing~
rachel9010 3 years ago 3
年度最touch的影片
yinghih 3 years ago 4
很美
OliverTW 3 years ago 6
i cant help crying...
so touchable!!!
motherwithmcr 3 years ago 5
this is the voice we need, soooooooo soulful
sbho 3 years ago 3
這首歌寫得真好聽,Joanna唱得真是沒話說...不知道這首歌將來有沒有機會收錄在下一張專輯呢?很期待~~Joanna加油!!
juichung0720 3 years ago 3
my heart melted
blissfulme1119 4 years ago 2
She sings like Joni Mitchell
ginakagil 3 years ago
請問說話的男主持人是誰?
michaeljou 4 years ago
應該是導演/演員陳耀圻
liangyp1031 4 years ago
催淚呀
男人都禁不住了
fliege2u 4 years ago
JOANNA,
It has been weeks since I accidentally found your page,I love your music,the way you sing,
you sing from deep of your heart,and tis is one of your song,that I love love the MOST!
THNX, ~ CIAHUI FROM SYDNEY ~
Ciahui118 4 years ago 2
she is in YouTube as festouverture, Joanna and her guitar and originals/covers.
guest63 4 years ago
THe most powerful voice that drive into your heart INSTANTLY
aomoon81 4 years ago 2
It is so beautiful.
swingliting 4 years ago 2
好美的聲音....
感動到哭了....
wu9632000 4 years ago 9
très touchant
avec la mémoire
dimitrihsu2 4 years ago 5
this is since a-Mei, the most beautiful voice that i had ever heard. such emotion in that voice! can't wait for her albam! wish that she can carry on Taiwan's vocie like Tsai Qing and a-Mei and many other great voices did.
evacoustic 4 years ago 14
I totally agree! The Taiwan music industry should be extremely proud to have someone like Joanna
vc1188 4 years ago 6