Added: 6 years ago
From: SungJin
Views: 157,526
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (420)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • the only problem in dream theater is their vocalist

  • @xXMeTalZXx

    No taste of music.

  • @DeadSteal really? if i have no taste in music maybe i'm listening to justin beiber and spreading things like 84iloverock :P dumb fuck

  • man the vocalist sucks!! very irritating!

  • amazing riff :O

  • I swayed from side to side.

  • Agree. LaBrie = Panadol

  • Ment for bfmv99m3a1

    

  • @LampusGilak- You should try learning some Dream Theater any instrument. Maybe then you'll appreciate the music instead of being some prick who sounds like he's jealous because he wishes he could get down like them.

  • This is one my favourite DT songs. Love just about everything about it!

  • Singer is horrible.

  • LaBrie is an amazing vocalist, but I don't think his vocals fit this song at all. It may be due to this being a live performance, or do to the fact that Charlie Dominici's voice just fits the track better (not note wise, but the sound of his voice).

  • @Intelligentia100 I think it's because LaBrie just isn't as good as he used to be. He would have sang this better back in the day. Someone on Youtube uploaded the "I Remember When" documentary. There were live clips of all the songs (I think) from their 1st album and Dominici did not sound good live. He sounded like he was straining to sing the higher parts. Now, I'm not saying he's a bad vocalist. I think he sounds good on his Dominici albums.

  • @Intelligentia100 labrie is a less than mediocre vocalist who mistakenly gets a lot of credit by people who assume that because the rest of the band is at a very high level of musicianship, labrie is too. labrie consistently has basic musicianship problems and thats been going on for over a decade.

  • @BOOLsheet Labrie is fucking amazing, Listen to Images and Words and tell me those vocals don't blow your mind. Post release of Awake era, he got food poisoning, and was told he would never sing again. Lucky, that was wrong, but his voice has had a trail of recovery. Furthermore, Dominici himself says that his voice didn't have the power Dream Theater needed.

  • @IReallyAmIronMan i've played images probably more than any other record i own. i know what he sounds like for his entire career with dt. yeah he sounded good on images, and that was a long ass time ago. his voice right has anything but power. he sounds old, tired and breathy on every song. you realize that even portnoy wanted to kick him out because of his shitty performances right?

  • @BOOLsheet Portnoy also wanted to go on brief hiatus. Look what the rest of the band thought of that. lol. All I'm saying is, he still has a decent voice, he honestly gets a lot of shit for being the least talented, (he gets ringo'ed) but in all honesty, he has demonstrated in every one of the albums following FII that his voice is still very good.

  • Nobody can touch Dream Theater, you hear me!!!! Nobody!!!!! (Keep it metal \m/)

  • mantap .....

  • 0:53 James... What happened? Did you sleep well or not?

  • You don't choose Dream Theater, Dream Theater choose you.

  • I love that drums part at 00:47

  • @andrew1618 would you mind if i asked why?

  • @mebich1 I like it because it's fast, it change the rythm passing from the riff to the first strophe. In my mind they are 3 seconds really cool of the song...!

  • @zuwig actually I prefer Dominici's voice than LaBrie's, don't know if I'm used to it or what lol. all I know that Dominici's voice in The Killing Hand is priceless, no doubt

  • why isnt when dream and day reunite on itunes?

  • Domnici is BY FAR better

  • @thestormbringer1999

    yeah, but only on WDADU album... james has incredible voice, but like every singer he has bad and good days

  • looks like Petrucci got a lil capt. in him lol

  • why compare DT to A7X???????? A7X has nothing compared to DT, and is nothing compared to them. i like both of them, dont get me wrong, but I cant see how you people are comparing the two :| its quite rediculous. DT and A7X shouldnt even be mentioned together unless your talking about your favorite bands or portnoy playing for them(sevenfold)

  • Petrucci is standing too much still. He is in the same position through the whole song. But however great performance!

  • Comment removed

  • @mrmarinheiro haha listen to any of the kids from dragonforce, that just hurts

  • Correction to my last post: I meant the harmonies in the CHORUS.

  • To be honest: LaBrie is the worst vocalist when it comes to singing live...

    Awful, my ears hurt! They should get Charlie back or maybe ask Ray Alder if he wants to join DT!

  • I really wish this album was on I-Tunes...

  • Who the hell is this AS everybody is talking about???

  • @rydock Avenged Sevenfold

  • AS's afterlife sucks.

    this is art.

  • AS's afterlife sucks.

  • the vocal sucks!!!! that's the reason why mike left this fucking band!!!!

  • THE BEST SOLO DREAM THEATER´S  FOREVER !!!!

  • @bfmv99m4a1 Go die for making such an ignorant comment.

  • @xxCrackZillaxx IGNORANT USER! XD...

    P.S.

    THIS BAND SUCKS! NO WONDER MIKE LEFT!!

  • @bfmv99m4a1 When you will post a video where you play an instrument better than one of Dream Theater call me. Only when you will do that i will decide if you are an arrogant or an idiot...

    (Sorry for English)

  • @LampusGilak I DON'T HAVE TO POST A VIDEO... THIS VIDEO IS A PROOF THAT DREAM THEATER SUCKS ASS!!!!!

  • @bfmv99m4a1 If you judge a band just after seeing a performance on youtube...

  • @bfmv99m4a1 You don't know shit about music.

  • @bfmv99m4a1 youre name is comprised of bullet for my vallentine, and a gun, you know shit

  • Mike left DT 'cause his ears hurt from hearing them vocals..

  • WOW, GREAT STAGE PERFORMACE! lol

  • Avenged Sevenfold's Afterlife - Good song

    Dream Theater's Afterlife - One of the greatest song I have ever heard.

  • lol some idiot sayd that we cant compare nirvana with dream cause nirvana are gods and dream is shit jajajjajajajajjajajaaj lol kurt cubain ??? was he a genious? what a drug addict bastard nirvana ... that grunge shit, they are not even in the dream theater league , thumbs up!

  • so that's why mike left dream theater...

  • It sucks mike left the group but its even more sad the fact that he went to Avenged Sevenfold.

  • i love this version... i suppose it´s better than the album version, isn´t it? however, there are some notes labrie doesn´t hit, but it´s fantastic anyway.

  • @holzfilet94 Check out the live version of this song from SCORE, James sings much better there.

  • Why mike why?

  • the old singers version is much better, check out the studio version

  • I bet this song crosses MP's head everytime he is about the play the Avenged Sevencrap one

  • james labrie dont sing in the same level of the band

    all good musicians ,but james never deserved the place of singer...he is the weak point of the band

    MY OPINION!!!

  • @gambitakerx I could agree to this. Dont get me wrong, I love DT to death. But I think if they have chosen a better singer, they could be as big as Queen was. Haha.

  • @armymanhaha is true the weak point is the singer... a better singer and it would be awesome... what a shame...

  • i think james sings way better since he has a beard

  • keyboard isn't very loud :/

  • John Petrucci is GOD. And James Labrie is nowhere near Dominici.

  • @NisseEricsson Nah. have you heard Charlie live? Its AWFUL.

  • AS's afterlife - 14 million views

    DT's afterlife - 121,000 views..

    WTF!?

  • @toppoxpocky Remember that DT doesn't use mainstream advertisement whereas AS does. 

  • @toppoxpocky ^^

  • @toppoxpocky The generation of the EMO's

  • @toppoxpocky

    new generation of stupid guys...

  • @toppoxpocky this world is not fair

  • @toppoxpocky Comparing Dream Theater with Avenged Sevenfold just because of the same song title is just absurd.

    What's next? Justin Bieber?

  • @zuwig uh, are you stupid or what?

  • @toppoxpocky

    Quality has nothing to do with Quantity

  • @DerTeke K

  • @DerTeke go suck a hardcore cock!!

  • @ToMAHHsTheRocker How mature... why don´t you suck a comforter? It would fit , you know?

  • @DerTeke sorry dude, but I 'm a Dream theater fan, and hearing that A7X has more quality than DT... i just didn't get it!@!

    but fuck this shit!!

  • @ToMAHHsTheRocker Why don´t you just ask what i mean then?

    AS might have 14 million views (quantity) but they don´t have the quality DT has even though DT has only 150000 views. It was not against DT.

  • @DerTeke wtf

    I thought there were more DT views than A7X's...

    i fuckin misenderstood this whole shit, really sorry man!! ahhahahahaha

  • @toppoxpocky That can be explained that the Dt fans actually listened to the song on the album, unlike these A7X fans who don't care about supporting an artist and buying the music and rather download it.

    what a sad world...

  • @SilenceScreamMetal what are you talking about? i bought every single on of there albums?

  • @jadonsmith that's right, A7X fans don't care and they go on youtube to listen to their music.

  • @toppoxpocky not many people have heard DT's afterlife due to it being on probably their least known album originally whereas on of A7x's most popluar albums both kickass in my oppinion

  • @toppoxpocky Both songs are Great, but Dream Theater is Dream Theater!!!

    also AS Afterlife are one of my fav song ever, i a Sevenfold and a Theater fan \m/

  • @toppoxpocky Well a lot of people have fucked up taste and goes for 'fashionable' music and 'what's in or popular'

  • @toppoxpocky well i guess most people gets more identified with smiple songs.A7x is a great band, but i agree...this should have more views.

  • @toppoxpocky AS is like Britney or Nsync, all kinda people listen to them, but with DT, only superior minds and culture are chosen.

  • @toppoxpocky both songs are amazingly epic

  • @toppoxpocky

    avenged sevenfags. go to hell sevenfold.

  • @toppoxpocky

    i believe now it's:

    A7x's afterlife - 24,000,000 views

    DT's afterlife - 147,000 views

  • @toppoxpocky

    Cause its 14 million times better!

  • @toppoxpocky first: A7x and not AS xD second: A7x afterlife maybe is more listened because it's easier to be listened and more modern and so more known.. i think you know that not every people are able to listen ProgMetal because it is a kind of music only for people whit particular music taste ;)

  • @KobibaFanNumberOne AS, A7X I don't give a fuck. And "more modern" ? U SRS BRO? 

  • @toppoxpocky Both nice but prefer the DT's one as my cellphone ringtone :-P

  • Charlie had voice of gay xD

  • @Akinito10

    ? that doesn't make sense

  • No disrespect, but this whole album is the worst performance from Labrie that I've heard. He's good on this song but the rest I can barely listen to.

  • Comment removed

  • @destructionman1 I agree, this show was definitely not LaBrie's best night.

  • james sounds better now then when he's young

  • Listen to the first album, and you understand why Dominici left : he was a very good singer, but his voice didn't suit with the rest of the band.

  • A SUUURCCCHHHH WIYUTH NNNNNNNN BENAYTH THU SKIYUN

  • im starting to really like progressive metal becuase of these guys and pagan's mind.

  • @TheSonsofHorusx Check out Pain of Salvation if you haven't already. I recommend checking out their first four albums. Now back to Dream Theater. I've been listening to them since 2001 but I never listened to their first album until 2010. Weird, I know! I prefer the live version of this album with LaBrie singing.

  • ahhaah dominici better than labrie? JAMES IS THE BEST

  • Dominici is so much better then labrie.

  • @mtllc555 I agree

  • they're like a glorified soft rock band.

  • @begajmani This song was recorded with Charlie, and he had a very different voice from La Brie, so it isnt made for him . Quit being a fag about it

  • @begajmani man you dont know a shit. if you dont like james thats your problem but he is a great singer. if you cant apreciate that you are the one that should quit from listening music.

  • @begajmani I'd like to see you do better with damaged vocal chords because you were violently ill from food poisoning.

  • Better with Dominici

  • @zuwig Agreed, if only for the harmonies in the solo.

  • @zuwig you are right! definitely a lot of pitch problems. and yes for all those thumb down hair triggers, I CANNOT do better.

  • @zuwig Better in "Score", I think...

  • 0:54 mmmmmmmmm

  • Sounds like an auto tuner. lol.

  • @KornSOAD jaja ;)

  • Oh wow, I used to always think that bit in the solo at 4:30 was tapping haha.

  • in my opionoin this is the best version!!

  • I still enjoy the days when Petrucci, Portnoy and Myung were still with Dominici, Moore and Sherinan. Even today, they were still good but unfortunately in my opinion Labrie sucked compared to DT's previous keyboard players. But I still like them until today.

  • labrie sucked compared to dt's previous keyboard players? This is so wrong it has to be a troll. Labrie is the singer man, the current keyboardist is jordan rudess

  • @nwawallace I'm sorry, I'm sorry; I know that I made a mistake when typing. I mean Rudess, not Labrie.

  • sorry - I didn't see your correction before I responded to your other post. But still - have you heard the keyboards on A Nightmare to Remember, the Count of Tuscany or or anything off of Scenes From A Memory? Rudess is a god!

  • @KornSOAD Well, not to be insulting, but I just want to tell my opinion. Rudess is good, but Moore himself, in my opinion, is far better. When Moore was still in the band, the keyboard solo and verses sounds... Well, you know, more authentic, especially their song Ytse Jam. And ever since Moore left the band, it seems Petrucci and Portnoy practically dominates the band, so the keyboard is pretty vague when Rudess and Sherinian is in.

  • Um... James LaBrie isn't the keyboard player.

  • I love this song and DT allways. But cant stand it while LeBrie sings this masterpiece and ruins it >=(

  • randy whooo????? if ur a true Dream Theater fan u shouldnt name that in this vid dishonnor..

  • i can not hear any similarity with the eagles, for one, note for note it's different, in that case i want a D7sus2/F# named after me!!!!

  • @nerevarine1991

    Since when is the circle of fifths "owned" by the Eagles. They used an E chord in this song too and so did Led Zepplin in Good Times Bad Times, did they copy them too.

  • Why don' t they have Charlie sing this hes backstage?

  • @jesse1291 they wanted to do the album with labrie because everyone has hear the Charlie version. the idea is to have labrie singing this songs and then have Charlie sing metropolis which was being written when Charlie left

  • I love that Randy Rhoads-style section of the solo.

  • lucky jues

    THEATER RULZZZZZZZZZ

  • ZZZZZZZ......

  • 0:54 EPIC fail!!

    We love you though labrie!! maybe wasnt ur day... though i like this song with dominicci's voice =P

    love you dt hope i can see u in march!!!

  • @pekisi don't nitpick over a minor common mistake

  • @JakeTF2 I dont think is a minor common mistake, is the first time i see someone failing to get a note on a live performance ( i mean, important bands) and he is a singer as a profession. Anyway, as i sayed, we all had our bad days... and i still prefer dominicci's voice on this song...

  • @pekisi he hits the note at least 3 times after through the entire song, and higher at the end, and dominici's voice is good but doesnt compare to labrie's, it takes immence practise to sing dream theater songs, so a small voice crack is nothing to whinge about

  • no jak on psuje ta kapele , tym swoim słabym vocalem :(

  • Comment removed

  • ESSE SOM É MUITO FODA

  • Comment removed

  • still good tho

  • @nerevarine1991

    not quite. the chord progression of the chorus shares many elements, but its not the same. and the solo it self is totally different. the eagles couldn't do shit compared to DT. and i know that the eagles are not one of DT's main influences (if any influence at all). think of all the songs out there, once in a while, something sounds similar. AND EVEN IF IT WAS RIPPED, they made it so much better than that bullshit song hotel california

  • -.-

  • why are we even mentioning avenged sevenfold? just because they have a song w/the same name. that's stupid. likes like comparing One by Metallica to One by Creed

  • This solo kicks so much ass

  • Much better than Avenged Sevenfold's song.

    Petrucci FTW

  • i think you can not compare this 2 songs,

  • yea, thats true, plus its always personal opinion

  • man i cant wait to see the new mc hard on and dj dickcheese colaboration.

  • i think it depends with this album. charlie is better on a fortune in lies, status seeker and afterlife, but labrie is better on all the other songs. and this album is so underrated! it's genius!

  • Labrie doing a fortune in lies back in 93 is way better than charlie imo. But charlie is better compared to this performance!

  • jonnyushereomg..... +10000000000000000000000000000­000000000000000000000000000000­00000000000000000000000 i think that album is one of the best (if not the best IMHO) of dream theater, and yeah, charlie´s voice in those particular songs are great! Labrie simply don´t fit in this song although he is a great singer :)

  • I'd like this singer about 100 times more if he rasped just a little more. He's not bad, but he could do better.

  • i preffer dominici for this songs

  • they should make a "when dream and day unite" remastered it's a great album I just hate the singer.. LaBrie totally kicks his ass

  • agree with ya dude!!james labrie ur the best

  • Best band EVER!!! Saw them live last sunday in progressive nation :D

  • this is much better than avenged sevenfold afterlife

  • I couldn't agree with you more.

  • @jesse1291 OMG! you should not even compare them! AS freakin sucks! and DT is so goddamn epicjuice!!!!

  • @fredvain im a fan of both bands,obviously DT is better,but AS is still a good band,and now that they lost their drummer,it takes big balls to record the new album...and mike portnoy helped out on all the drum tracks for AS!

  • @jesse1291 not the guitar solo

  • @jesse1291 I hope this is Mike's opinion too.

  • @jesse1291 u cant not even compare a shity band like avendeg sevenfold, with this gods

  • @AKtifosi you cant compare both shitty band with gods like Nirvana!

  • @balerinauzicka u must be under drugs like ur idol " the great kurt cubain " lol he was just a bigger with a guitar, hahahhaha

  • the bass is so sick in this song, especially with the slide at 0:44 and the solo

  • Is this song from the "Falling into infinity"?