Added: 3 years ago
From: cuffmasters
Views: 2,385,890
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (2,467)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Sorry Bey, Xtina's version has way more soul & emotion.

  • @WeaponsOfSeduction no it doesn't. Christina sings this with a fraction of the emotion beyonce or ms. etta had.

  • Prefer Christina Aguilera, sorry.

  • Beyonce doesn't have a soul or an ounce of it in her.PERIOD!!!

  • Etta didn't like Beyonce singing this but Beyonce still had respect for Etta. We can get along just look past imperfection.

  • Own style , just perfect B!!!!!!!,that's why you are such a big STAR

  • Beyonce didn't do so bad. But shes a bit too high for Etta

  • Nobody diss Beyonce. Etta James is a legend, and will always be with her phenomenal impact on the soul of music. She is gold. But without the shadow of a doubt. In 50 years, trust me, Beyonce will be seen as the ultimate music genius and we will tribute to her. Generation after Generation.

  • @TheZena56 RIGHT ON!!!!

  • I would love to see Beyonce do an album of all torch songs...

  • Etta's version was ballsy. Beyonce's version is to sanitized

  • I liked it :]

  • blond girl talks to much:/

  • Sorry Beyoncé. Go sing " single girls"...

  • etta james doesnt like beyonce beacuse beyonce was portraying etta james in a movie who she knew nothing about. they have never met before so how would beyonce know how to be etta james. Etta James doesn't like Obama either for allowing beyonce to sing At Last for him.

  • sad still myself. RIP Etta.

  • Beyonce respects her alot she knows that Etta pave the way for black artist. Stop hating on Beyonce or Ettta they were both divas in their time.

  • I never understood why Etta was hatin Bey gave her sooo much credit and respect. RIP Ms.James

  • beyonces good, really good, but singers todays dont have that style, just dont have it.

  • Comment removed

  • Wwwwhhoooooooo else but ettaaaaa  rest in peace ...

  • It's true Beyonce can not sing this song like Etta,but she is very talented and she sang the song very beautifully!

  • I can't believe the haters. So you prefer Etta's version, very highbrow of you. I agree Etta does it better and Xtina is closer. Beyonce is not the right person to sing her music, but you just can't say Beyonce sucks. She sang it beautifully. Haters, why don't you get up and sing it y'all.

  • @raymaleyt um Xtina doesnt have the SOulful "grunts/grouwls/ and melissma SHE Doesnt even sing the lyrics proper she does " YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH " etc riffs there and there it sounds a mess and specialy her STRAINs at B4 and C5

  • Man they needed someone with soul to sing this song!

  • @b4evergra3ce soul? are you kidding??

  • Wow she sucks ass Christina is 100000000000000000000000000000­0 times better

  • Beyonce is not even a real artist anymore. She' s just an Illuminati puppet makin music about sex, and cash. I' m glad people are waking up and rebelling.

  • @saramichealhpt fuck you!

  • @drigao16

    So, yes, fuck you. Because people woke up and are rebelling, and there ain' t nothing you can do about it. It' s called change. Fucking tool.

  • I absolutely concur with most in that this is no where close to how well Ms. Etta James sang this song. Beyonce is good and all, but damn....

  • I love beyonce's version, but why didn't Etta James just sing it?

  • IS THIS HER IDEA OF SULTRY? ETTA' IS BETTER-EARTHIER-STRONGER-IT SENDS CHILLS.BEYONCE IS ALL CHOPS & SURFACE POLISH.YET,SHE DOESN'T INHABIT THE SONG,AT ALL.SHE'S TOO SURE OF HERSELF-TO NARCISSISTIC TO CONVEY THE LONGING OF LOVE FOR ANOTHER~THERE'S NO ONE ELSE ON HER MIND,BUT HERSELF.IT'S,YET ANOTHER SLICK,SHOWY,FLAWLESS,PRETENTIO­US & DULL STAR TURN-WITHOUT ANY SOUL OR CHARACTER.LISTEN,SHE'S A GOOD MIDDLE CLASS KID FEIGNING THE BLUES FOR WHITE PEOPLE~IT'S BLACK-LITE FOR HONKIES

  • She did this performance because she's playing Etta in a movie... She's doing a tribute. I think it's a good thing, not a bad thing so why people has to be so negative??? And Beyonce admires Etta so why hating on her? Anyway, Beyonce is talented too... Of course it won't be the same, it's not her song.

  • @maxbibeau999 I have to agree with you also...good on ya!! x

  • Sing the song.

  • Wow beyonce really sucks bad

  • Dam beyonce sucks......Glad Christina is singing the tribute at the grammys:-) And Etta hated beyonce and loved Christina so very much:-)

  • This is very sweet. Etta said those things because she was suffering from dementia

  • Damnn Bey gave me chills! I hate that Etta said those things about her but she was old lol. Maybe she didn't know what she was saying lol

  • I don't agree she sang it better, she tends to over sing imo

  • Forever Etta.Rip.

  • Beyonce does "At Last" better than Etta ever did, but maybe I prefer feminine women over "bad girls", including Beyonce. Etta's version is one of the 1st 45 RPMs I owned, but not by choice (received as a present). Have you ever listened to this song done by Glen Miller & His Orch. with singers Ray Eberle and Lynn Bari from 15+ years earlier than Etta's version, before the art of pop music started to deteriorate? Take a look at our true American music before you hoist Ms. James up too high.

  • Bey is good but Etta put some jazz in. It. R.I.p Etta

  • Comment removed

  • Maybe Etta was mad cause Beyonce sang it better.. That's not a question. No disrespect, rip Etta.

    Good job Beyonce, love you baby girl! <3

  • One of the meany reasons I love Beyonce <333

    RIP Etta <333 love u.

  • she looks half white.is that right?

  • @tomcat624u Etta said her daddy was the pool player Minnesota Fats

  • linda homenagem. Beyonce com sua voz limpa e melodiosa.,...

  • Why beyonce gotta be so fine!!!?

  • I like the Beyonce version better than the original. No disrespect to Ms. James

  • @MrSam250099- yes its smoother and prettier

  • Etta still sang it best, no'one can do it like her. RIP Etta.

  • WHY IS EVERYONE SO ANGRY AT BEYONCE ! SHE SANG THIS SONG AS A TRIBUTE AS SHE STATED BEFORE SHE CAME ON STAGE COME ON GUYS CANT WE JUST ENJOY THE TRIBUTE AND REMEMBER ETTA IN A HAPPY LIGHT

  • love her!!!!!!

  • I would stick my tongue in her butt, no questions asked.

  • @eiserbud you are nasty

  • @eiserbud lmfao

  • Overplayed, this is not natural.

  • quanti cazzi che volete! ho capito che nn è Etta, ma resta un'intepretazione sublime e nn rompete i cogliioni!!!!!!!

  • 1:22 wow!!!

  • nice... but she ain't no Etta James.

  • Etta should have been flattered by Beyonces tribute to her, That is what it was all about Paying a legend tribute. It is sad that Etta took it as an insult that she was not asked to sing instead. Tributes like this have been given other legends many other times . I prefer to believe it was Etta's dementia that sent her into a dark place of believing she was being disrespected by the president , instead of the truth that she she was being HONORED, and Beyonce did that beautifully !!

  • LOVE THIS!

  • i think etta james was upset because it took so long for people to pay tribute to her. now etta james is only being recognized because of beyonce's role in cadillac records? if you ask me the whole thing was meant to promote beyonce, not to give thanks to etta.

  • Was Beyonce asked to do a parody of Etta James? Probably, not... but it turned out to be just a parody. Complete lack of a human personality under the stage name of The Beyonce.

  • Beautiful Lady, beautiful voice!

  • Some songs should never be covered by others. This is one. Beyonce's OK on pop music radio, but should have left this Ina alone.

  • Beyonce is gorgeous but her voice is incredibly annoying! Even Etta said so... its on YouTube ITN

  • Rest in peace, the incomparable Ms. Etta James, NO ONE will ever come close.

  • I think this was the biggest moment in Beyounce's life ... to finally know that she can't hold a candle to someone with real talent.

  • God job!

  • No one could...can sing like Etta did. RIP Etta.

  •  RIP MS.ETTA JAMES

  • if you watch the videos beyounce, gave etta james praise for her song at last, she stated if it was not for her etta james,i beyounce could have not done it without you so stop hatin and get over it and let ms.etta rest in paradise, her music still lives on forever.......................­.......

  • what a milf.

    

  • Beyonce did her thang in this on yall! And as for as all of her h8ers,keeep on doin it. That's yall job.

  • She look's absolutely LOVELY, but does no justice to this song. Love you Beyonce, but this is not quite right for you, but I appreciate your take on it. 

  • NOT QUIET MS. ETTA, BEYOUCE, BUT SING A WHILE LONGER U MIGHT BE!!

  • What better way to celebrate a phony occasion than with a phony singer.

  • @meanwiddlekid , change your name to 'hater'

  • Love beyonce, she is brought up with respect. R.I.P ETTA JAMES!!

  • Beyonce credited Etta for such talent and triumphs not to mention that she sang her songs so well. I love both of these sings for who they are. Rip Etta James.

  • easy on the eye, but that is not the point; Etta or Beyonce; absolutely NO CONTEST:-

    ETTA every time.

  • Beyonce's tribute was great she can sing anything there is no need for negative comments...... -R.I.P. Etta James.

  • What Etta James had to say about Beyonce...love it!!!

    "You know that woman he had singing for him, singing my song -- she's gonna get her a** whipped. The great Beyonce ... But I can't stand Beyonce. She has no business up there, singing up there on a big ol' president day ... singing my song that I've been singing forever."

  • @someone2know77 "James later said she was just joking, but she also added that she was disappointed that she wasn't asked to sing for the president. James is survived by her husband Artis Mills, two sons, four grandchildren, and a legacy that will no doubt inspire many imitators in the years to come." ;)

  • @someone2know77 I understand why Etta was upset. Remember Etta was raised during a time when she couldn't walk through the front door of the same clubs she would perform in. Her performing for the first Black President would have been a great historic moment for her.

  • Una pena... una gran voz y unos grandes temas para recordar...espero que allá donde estés puedas seguir cantando y emocionando a quienes tengas a tu lado. RIP.

  • Beyonce..VERY FAR from ETTA...please don't sing this kind of songs...you are not be able to do it. PLEASEEEE.

  • Whats the matter with you people with all the hate to Beyonce?!

    She made a tribute , she didn't stole the song or tried to be like Etta..although she sang amazing and her voice is breathtaking , Etta sings is it way better that's true.

    R.I.P Etta <3

  • @CloudxDark

    Preach. What IS up w this Beyonce-Bashing? Is she too pretty or something?

    Far as I can tell, Beyonce ain't gon' be leaving anytime soon - not with THAT talent

  • @Hephaestud It is true that Beyonce is the next Etta James and Ella fitzgerald , Beyonce is amazing in every kind of way..her voice is something that you are born with , a gift.

    you can't learn how to sing like this..

  • @CloudxDark beyonce the next etta, please!!! dont even compare beyonce with Etta, don't even go there cuz beyonce's voice is nothing compared to etta's and she will NEVER be something like etta, she should stick to the dancing and pop music.

  • @Maryland765 She is not trying to be like Etta she just going to be a legend like them , and beside Beyonce is an R&B singer not pop and her voice is timeless

  • @CloudxDark I agree with you completely. There could never be such a Beautiful and Naughty Lady as our Etta. lol This vid was done as a tribute to her and nothing wrong with that. Thank you..x

  • song starts at 1:30

  • Love this song. RIP

  • Rip to a wonderful soulful women

  • I have yet to see a performer as beautiful as Beyonce

  • @TheIrvinlopez Lara Fabian

    ;-)

  • rip etta james

  • RIP ETTA.OXO

  • Great rendition, but it will never replace the original. RIP, Miss James.

  • Great, however, NOT even close to Etta James!

  • talent

  • grande.

  • Beyonce's apppearence is vu distracting. Close your eyes and you can hear the flat notes, and artificial embellishments. She is better off lip syncing to her studio recordings, as live performances bring out her brass. Etta's voice is so raw and passionate. Miss you Etta,! RIP

  • Beyonce

  • No disrespect to Etta James but no 1 gives credit to Ella Fitzgerald , Sarah Vaughan , Billie Holiday or the others .. the made way for Etta. idk i just think ppl by pass the others who open doors as well. BTW Etta didn't even like the fact that she was mimicked but Beyonce

  • @skittleysweet right on!!!

  • Etta....always imitated......never duplicated........

  • Blah blah blah boo hoo take your frustration out on Beyonce. You say all this and that but at the END OF THE DAY youre watching Beyonce not Etta. Beyonce has your mind and your view :)

  • she doesn't even compare to etta.

  • She sounds like a kid singing compared to Etta

  • lol beyonce overchoreographed and staged as usual.

    'etta, turn to me and give me a hug for the cameras'

  • Like Etta Said , this is her song not Beyonce's

  • RIP Etta .. 

  • Well, i think beyonce did a great cover for her tribute. Unlike christina aguilera's who was over the top.

  • Comment removed

  • Ditto to 9sunnydays comment. RIP.

  • excellent, no Etta James, but an excellent job never the less. RIP Etta, you have moved the hearts of thousands with your music <3

  • Comment removed

  • RIP etta! you'll never be forgotten!!!

  • god damn I could stare at Beyonce's boobs forever... listening to this song too of course hahaha

  • @bmadthebeast99 I'm saying. Sweet Dreams is a video I could watch over, and over, and over, and over, and over, and....

    I don't even know if I liked the song at first but I actually think that's a great song. lol

  • FOR ETTA JAMES ALL MY HEART FOR YOU BE IN HEAVEN NOW

  • R.I.P you will always have the best voice!!

    

  • A legend At Last.  Sleep well Etta. Remi

  • I hope that you'll split your vocal cords with these roars that would be a ridiculous imitation of Etta

  • che razza di cretina!... gente così dovrebbe andare a zappare! povera etta...

    

  • @pepilupis cretina? perche?

  • [R.I.P. Etta James] -You always brought Peace, Comfort, and Joy to my heart through your angelical songs, my whole childhood life; and here you are with your sweet lovely anlgelical voice in my ears once again... It's been a long time...

    May peace, love, comfort, and joy find you at Heavens Gates "HE IS YOURS AT LAST!" Until we met again... You will always be alive in my heart. [R.I.P. Etta James] ~♥~Your sister in Christ Debbie ~♥~

  • nice try but no cigar... Etta's soulful singing has depth. this version is very top surface and cute. turned it off in the middle, no hatingnp, just telling truth.

  • Beyoncé what a fitting tribute. X Rip Etta You total legend x

  • Beyonce ruined it. Her voice isn't made for this song. Thanks a lot.

  • @Bran814 Nobody will ever sing this song like Etta, but Beyonce in her own style does a magnificent job...She's an amazing singer, and could never ruined any song.

  • Comment removed

  • That dress almost gave up.

  • I LOVE ETTA JAMES,SUA ESTRELA SEMPRE IRÁ BRILHAR!!!!(1938 à 2012)

  • Good job Beyoncé here. I'm so sad for her murder, she will be a true legend forever, her voice was full of passion, she knew how to make you feel chills. Thank you very much Etta for your music.

  • @JossStoneLetras Her MURDER? what are you talking about?

  • @JossStoneLetras she wasnt murdered she lost her battle with leukemia !!!!

  • @shaeboo113 Oh, I'm sorry, but I speak spanish, only write in english for more people understand me (aggg google translate) Sorry, I know that she has died of leukemia.

  • I'm 14, I remember being two years old and singing this song! I've loved it since. R.I.P. ♥

  • @MsSmokey44 you couldnt even speak at 2 years old. stop lying.

  • Etta, thank you for so beautifully representing my generation. Your life and music will be eternally here on earth for all who come later to enjoy and praise you for a life well lived.

  • R.I.P. Etta J.

  • Just standing there singing, this performance alone by Beyonce leaves her peers biting the dust!! Easily, by far, no argument!!!

  • Etta hated this and her lol

  • Well done.

  • OM, haters.. this was a tribute! how could you not see that?

  • I used to really dislike Beyonce... but after seeing this, and ESPECIALLY her headlining performance at Glastonbury 2011, I have a new found respect in a modern day soul legend!

    And R.I.P. Etta James... Beyonce, and those like her, will continue your legacy!

  • the best

  • Well done Beyonce

  • R.I.P Etta<3

    

  • Comment removed

  • Q maravilhosa ficou essa cançãoo na voz da Beyoncee... ;)

  • Not tonight, I just can`t.

  • RIP Etta James.

  • instead of that crazy hip hop music beyonce should sing slow soul...

  • Beyonce is not the original...but by God..She does this song like a old soul. 

  • R.I.P Etta James B sang this

  • Beyonce doesn't have that depth and soul and power in her voice where as Etta had effortless soul and power in her voice and this is why Etta was pissed at B.

  • Beyonce is a beautiful singer and no one can deny that but her voice is world's apart from Ettas. Etta's voice was like a fog horn with soul and force. Beyonce's voice is more pop.

  • Why do people not want to come into the 21st Century and stop putting singers of today down as just 'entertainers.' Their is still good music today it has just evolved. Some people seem to just hate change.