I miss Carly. The fact she was bumped off when she was caused me to lose faith in Idol. I've paid a small amount of attention since then but I realized how off-base it is when she and the only other good contestant that broadway night were in the bottom 2.
ooohhh did that make you abit angry look i dont care!! if ya look closey i wrote this about 3 monthes ago, what i do care about is people like you who cant mind there own business so butt out dick head
In my honest opinion,it isn't fair that Carly Smithson was allowed to remain on American Idol after it was discovered she already had a record deal in the past.But then,maybe she is not to blame as much as the show itself for changing the rules!
I miss Carly. The fact she was bumped off when she was caused me to lose faith in Idol. I've paid a small amount of attention since then but I realized how off-base it is when she and the only other good contestant that broadway night were in the bottom 2.
RonQE 9 months ago
36,495,800 irish in america my god !!!
so thats about 30,000,000 more irish people live in america than ireland,
balf1111117373 2 years ago
why's an irish girl in american idol, so the best singer in america is'nt even american, same as britons got talant there was a swedish lady in??
balf1111117373 2 years ago
it doesnt matter if the person who is in the competition is living in that country. and learn how to spell Britain. dumbass
BixZsc 2 years ago
why does it not matter?? and i do know how to spell britain i just couldnt be botherd at the time so im not a dumbass.knobjockey
balf1111117373 2 years ago
America is often thought of as pot that everyone from every culture smokes...or something like that.
zarconeus 2 years ago
lol, I think you mean the "melting-pot"
JoeNobody247 2 years ago 2
balf she was scottish
Videowatcher76 2 years ago
Coz shes is living in american has been since she was 13 now shes 25 got a problem take it up with one who cares
eileenregina 2 years ago
ooohhh did that make you abit angry look i dont care!! if ya look closey i wrote this about 3 monthes ago, what i do care about is people like you who cant mind there own business so butt out dick head
balf1111117373 2 years ago
Carlys amazing..honestly..
shaka055 2 years ago
American Idol is FAAAAKE!!!
AnInfant 2 years ago
naa it just sucks
goldencarMH 2 years ago
Carly is awesome, there is no controversy. Facts are stubborn things.
cbotten106 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
In my honest opinion,it isn't fair that Carly Smithson was allowed to remain on American Idol after it was discovered she already had a record deal in the past.But then,maybe she is not to blame as much as the show itself for changing the rules!
xyPERSON 3 years ago
I like it better when the AP covered real news, not karaoke contests.
Bio98765 4 years ago
It's a reality TV SHOW - It's as fake as Professional Wrestling
SASseals 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He man, fuck you. Wrestling ain't fake.
Bio98765 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ccc...fucking fat americans!
zlitombstone 4 years ago
That wasn't so much a news segement as it was an advert for american idol.
johnlepo 4 years ago 5