McNabb one of the few QBs not protected by refs.Brady,Brees,Sanchez all way over protected by refs.Defensive players can't touch Brady without flag and fine.Sanchez if he is hit late flag and fine.McNabb gets hit late all the time and never a flag.Conspiracy in NFL!!!
@xplay101 rivers is not overated hes good ! and flacco isnt overated he is pretty good to and nobody calls him a elite qb hes still young only what 23 in his 3rd year his qb rate was 92 thats good hes a good young qb
@Ernestof48 yea and what was the score of that game? like 17-12? hmm. sounds like only 2 tds were scored by the giants. Sounds more like a DEFENSIVE game to me and i think its funny that the giants had 1 of the best D's in the league. Strahan should've win SB mvp, not eli.
@portugalrocks9 how is cutler overrated? his offense holds him back. He has shitty recievers and a bad line (the line is getting better) and yets he still puts up numbers. So tell me how is he overrated?
@mutarrr his line is fine he's the one who moves around the pocket to long...and his recievers don't suck, no starting recievers suck...and he lost them the game in the championship conference game...he quits and he is not a leader....so there, that is how he is overrated
@portugalrocks9 ok first off all 3 of those statements just proved to me how much you know about football. HIs line is FINE? fuck no they are improving but are not fine. HIs recievers are shit they can't even catch the ball matt forte is their leading reciever. And in the nfc championship game he was injured so how could you quit when your injured dumbass.
@mutarrr umm dumbass he quit, he's a pussy who cant throw for shit...and his recivers would catch it if they would get a good fucking pass...theres a reason why bears will never make it to the superbowl with cutler...and his line isnt the problem...cutler thinks he can stand in the pocket for days...and who the fuck care's its the bears, they suck cock
@portugalrocks9 haha way to prove your football IQ. Hows he a pussy the guys gets hit more than any other qb in the league and gets up and goes back to playing. He can't throw for shit last time i checked he has the strongest arm in the nfl. ANd if you actually watched cutler he throws a perfect pass to his recievers his recievers suck dick. You know why am i wasting my time with you you have no clue what your talking about
@mutarrr youre such a retard and dont know shit about football....you think he has the strongest arm in the league??? wow youre so stupid. and i do watch him play and he doesnt throw good passes dumbass... thanks for proving my point, he gets sacked over and over agian and most the time its his fault for not throwing the ball away or for keeping it too long...i am still laughing that you think he has the strongest arm in the league dumbass...Bears suck and you're NFL IQ sucks
@portugalrocks9 haha way too prove my point dumbass. And he does have the strongest arm in the league. And if you watch him play then you would know that he throws the ball where only the recievers can get it but you forget they can't catch. And how is it a qbs fault when he gets sacked thats the o-line fault. And cutler only has like 2 seconds to make a decision because his o-line sucks (getting better) and yet cutler still puts up good numbers. So i have proven my point you are just stupid
@mutarrr okay listen dumb fuck cutler doesnt have the strongest arm in the league not even in the top ten...and even if he did who cares he still has bad aim.and if you know anything about football you would know that a QB should only take 5 seconds before starting to throw the ball and chiago gives him 5 seconds cause i do watch them play infact i watch more football then you cause you dont know shit, if he was as good as your saying he would at least make it to the SB.hester is the whole team
@portugalrocks9 okay first off cutler does have the strongest arm in the league. And who says he has bad aim he throws the ball where the reciever can catch it but you forget his recievers don't know how to catch the fucking ball. And this is what you said "if he was as good as your saying he would at least make it to the SB" well last time i checked it takes a whole team to make it to the superbowl. And if hester were the whole team then i think he would be able to atleast catch the ball
@mutarrr oh my god your so stupid if you think cutler has a stronger and better aimed arm then Brady, the Mannings, and Big ben, i can name 10 QB's with a better arm..Tom brady and peyton manning work with bad receivers and make them better...who would welker be without Brady and who would Garcon and Wayne be without peyton manning...they can work with anyone but cutler cant work with shit...and hester and their Defense are the Chicago Bears, Cutler can easliy be replaced
@portugalrocks9 lol first off comparing cutler to hall of famers is pathetic. And cutler has a stronger arm than all of them maybe not accurate but stronger. Brady has an o-line that gives him all fucking day and has recievers who can CATCH the ball dumbass. And if you actually watch football cutler has been playing very well with nothing so he is working with nothing dumbass. and again hester can return but he can't catch the ball. Your a fucking moron so fuck off
@mutarrr stupid ass Brady's recivers can catch because brady can throw accurate to them, welker is as small as Desean Jackson but Brady makes perfect passes so he can catch it..you sound like a fucking retard when you say Cutler has the strongest arm in the league, but even if he did so what? he still has shitty aim...stop blaiming Chiago's recivers when its that dumb little pricks fault. cutler is not a good QB or leader... go suck cutlers dick if you like him so bad you dumb fucker
@portugalrocks9 lol this is the last thing im gonna say you are fucking retarded. Yeah brady throws perfect passes his recievers can catch the ball and they know how to get open. And when i mentioned that cutler was doing great and used what he has you didn't respond to that now did you? Why don't you go watch some football and actually learn something dumb one. And if cutler is so bad why is he ranked 12th in the league for qbs?
2 seasons and already everyone says hes overrated? Jets are a running team so how can the QB be overrated? Statistically, Sanchez has improved from rookie year but has a long way to go. Its also New York media i hope you relize this...
who said delhomme is underated? he sucks so bad he dosent even deserve to be noticed
brady is overrated so is drew brees they play 2 hand touch football, mcnabb is one of the few quarterbacks that gets hit, this video is garbage.brady would not survive in washington behind that o line and of course nfl did right thing and take away bullshit pamper privilages away
So many Mcnabb haters huh? Thats how good he is. Pity is for free but envy is to be earned. Donovan Mcnabb is one of the most underrated QB of all time. cchank1, now check your list and get it right dog.
3.Jay Cutler 2.Donovan McNabb 1.Eli Manning and dont give me that "Eli has a superbowl ring" bullshit because Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson have a superbowl ring and they sucked asshole, teams win superbowls.
@Curran430 Oh my lord, dude stop talking. I am the biggest Brady Quinn/ND fan ever but you have embarrassed yourself and me included. Brady Quinn never won the heisman. As a matter of fact, he came in third place behind Troy Smith and Ray Rice.
wtf donavan isnt overrated all these pussy cowboy fans trashing him is why people think hes overrated cause people posting videos of his screwups he had a hell lot of more good plays then bad plays fucking tired of you god damn cowboy fans go suck tony homos dick ya fuckin cunts
no, its the pussy eagle fans trashing him is why people think he's overrated. Starting from day 1 at the draft the eagle fans booed him. Us cowboys fans want to know why they trash him so much. He's a great QB. I wouldn't mind having Mcnabb on my team.
Don't say anything bad about Donovan or Wilma will come after you. If she doesn't find you then I will. McNabb is a stud and I love the way his butt looks when he dances.
Mcnabb is an overrated QB. He sucks. He throws the ball to the dirt all the time when he has a guy wide open. Look at the Cardinal game last year. They need to release him and start Vick or Cobb
Dude wtf, McNabb is the most consistent quarterbacks ever. (Cept in the post-season) how can you even say that, Look at his numbers dude. he only throws like 8 interceptions a year. and he always tosses at-least 21 td's
McNabb is fourth among active quarterbacks in career touchdown passes, trailing only Brett Favre(, Peyton Manning and Tom Brady. He's got the third-best touchdown-to-interception ratio in NFL history, behind only Brady and Steve Young. His career winning percentage is an outstanding .651. A paltry 2.09% of his throws are intercepted, which beats Brady Manning Joe Montana Dan Marino or anyone else you want to name. Hes the Eagles all-time leader in yards, attempts and touchdowns
lol what's a qb percentage? do you mean rating? if so 86.2 is a very good career qb rating. Troy Aikman's is only 81.6 and Brett Favre's is 85.7 in their careers and McNabb never has had the pro-bowl receivers they did. Although he lacks a super bowl he has a much better playoff record than Peyton Manning and heh Tony Romo
Haha who cares about winning Playoff games if you don't win the Superbowl. Thats all that matters, all those playoff games just gave the Eagles a worse pick in the draft. Starting on a team of Eagles caliber for 10 years without winning the Superbowl is pathetic. At least Kolb is white and so he can make smart decision as he gets more experience.
Too bad Mangina told us D.A. would start on Wednesday, cause I hear if you keep it a secret your opponet is forced to forfeit from the sheer suspence.
D.A. Pro-Bowl QB in 2007 that makes 20 and 30 yard gains to Braylon Edwards and converts on 3rd downs so we keep the ball and have a chance to score a touchdown Brady Quinn- Overrated Rookie that's never played a game and can't throw for shit especially on 3rd downs and can't move the ball so we have one touchdown in the past what 30 quarters!? Who should we start? Mangina: "QUINN!"
dude are you still talking??! nobody gives a shit DA is better thats it i dont care about statistics if quinn was a better player last year he shouldve started if hes a better player this year, he'll start we cant judge this year yet because it hasnt started but what we have seen so far anderson is a better player
Dude you just proved that Derek Anderson is better. Derek Anderson was a 6th rounder and he finished his first full season with a record of a 9-6 as a starter. That's better than Quinn ever did in his whole life. I'm a diehard Oregon State Beavers fan and I remember that Derek Anderson was probably the best QB we have ever had. Quinn has proved that he can't start. Why else is there a QB competition?
Jesus relax buddy. It was just a pre-season game. They barely put Anderson out on the field anyway. Anderson has already proved himself in 2007 that he is the starter. The only reason he sucked last year was because Braylon Edwards kept dropping those deep balls, Kellen Winslow was out for a few games, and he lost his best 3rd down target in Joe Jurevicious.
if garcia was the starter for the egales at least the eagles have a chance at another super bowl. now with mcnabb no chance in hell for that to happen. i hope he gets injuried and kolb takes the team to the payoffs and maybe even the superbowl(farfetched though) if it happens i bet you kolb would be traded off next season to keep dicknabb happy.
i like the eagles and mcnabb is overrated piece of shit. ever since he had that sports hernia he started to suck. befroe that injury he was good. now all he does is play catch with the ants. i think its time to get rid of andy and mcnabb both are fuckiong the team over.
Thank you for agreeing with me. I always thought he lost everything when he got injured. I think it's time to develop Kevin Kolb or draft another QB next year in the draft.
i agree with kolb. but this whole bull shit with mcnabb could have been avoided if they just kept jeff garcia. garcia brought the team to the playoffs one year when mcnabb was hurt. when mcnabb was healthy they sucked. jeff steps in then all of a suddden the eagles did good. granted they lost to the saints but with mcnabb they wouldn't gotten to the playoffs that year. what did the agles do they got rid of jeff so they could keep mcnabb happy. bad move there.
Yeah totally. I was shocked when Philly didn't resign Jeff Garcia cuz he could have at least competed for the starting job with McNabb. Garcia did fantastic for Philly in 2006.
i hope the eagles fans that go to see the games i hope they boo mcnabba nd andy to show how they feel about their performances. its ridicouls how andy calls the plays and mcnabb just does what he does best throws terrible balls.
you think Donovan McNabb is the most overrated? he is WAAAYYY underrated. are you fucking kidding me? people and critics always say how he sucks. he is WAAAYYY underrated, he is the 2nd best QB in the league today behind ONLY Payton Manning. no i am not mistaking, he is better than Tom Brady. yes i am an Eagles fan but that is not the only reason why i'm saying this. you must be stupid.
ok, now your even putting him in the same class as Warner and Rivers? wow. McNabb is the 2nd est QB in he league today. and why do you think he is overrated? i never hear a good thing said about him by the critics or anybody else. where did you get that he is overrated? he is way underrated compared to what he does and has accomplished.
How dumb can you get? Warner is a beast and reads defenses and takes advantages of them. Rivers is my type of QB. Quick, consistent, west coast style QB. Yes, SD doesn't run the west coast offense but if u put him in the west coast offense, watch out! McNabb throws to Westbrook over 70% of the time. Look it up idiot.
tell me if he under rated then why does he 1 throw the ball to high or 2 throw to low? he e has all the time the oline gives him to throw the ball but he holds it holds it and then throws a bad pass happens a lot with mcnabb.
heres my top 3 most overrated qbs off the top of my head #3 tony romo #2jake delhomme #1 vince young and i can nmae like 50 people more overrated than these guys ; "big ben', carson palmer, micheal vick(when he played), phillip rivers, and jay cutler
LMFAO!!!!! Wow! And you call me stupid! Ok i'll give u Delhomme but Romo and Young? Ok yeah I kno they suck but they are not overrated. And you put Big Ben, Rivers, and Cutler who are more overrated then these guys I have. Whats the matter with you? Big Ben wins games when it matters, and Rivers?!?!?! He should have been a pro bowler this year or at least in contention for MVP. You are stupid. And Cutler? His team screwed up cuz of their running game and front 7 dumbass.
you are dumb as carp you all wrong in all 3 picks. hows brady quinn overrated when noone talks about him i dont think you kno what overrated means? overrated is when people think your good and you arent. nobody thinks hes good. #2 bulger has no line and his recievers are 65 years old. #1 i think you are straight up retarded your probabaly some dumbass cowboy fan. if mcnabbs overrated tell me how he gets to the playoffs practicly every year with no recievers? bitch!
First of all u ashould respect ppls opinions. I picked Brady Quinn becuz he had high expectations and he couldn't beat Charlie Frye or Derek Anderson for the starting job. Marc Bulger becuz even without a line and ur so called 65 year old receivers he can't play no matter what. Only reason why he did good in 2006 was becuz Jackson was in his prime and Holt and Issac were the best duo. Mcnabb becuz he has Brian Westbrook to throw to. He throws to Westbrook at least 60% of the time dumbass. BITCH!
ok well that makes you sound even more stupid cus when you have high expectations and they dont work out.... those are called bust you should just take this video off youtube and throw your computer out the window i dont have the slightest clue why you made this video its one of the dumbest ive seen in a while and marc bulger was actually good but he just dosnt have what he used too. and donovan mcnabb is one of best qbs in the leugue maybe
not the smartest but hes in the top five. you honestly think mcnabb is overrated? yuo probably think tom bradys overrated too now dont you? so all those passing yards and tds were all westbrook? no i dont think so i think your the only person on the earth that think donovan mcnabb is overrated i kinda think he underrated nobody reall ever talks about him.
DA is the shit the entire browns offense did bad last year people dropped passes cough Braylon edwards cough K2 and Donte were injured and all brady did was dumpoffs to his HB or FB if braylon hadnt have dropped all thoose balls granted some were bad passes DA would have been ALOT better
i totally agree except for bulger but mcnabb hasnt won shyt he always ends up choking or throwing up during the super bowl and brady quinn is going to fail as a starter hes at best a back up he didnt win no bcs bowl games in college
Quinn and Bulger have been on rather crappy teams the past few years and Quinn hasn't been given the chance to really start much.
But McNabb? 6 3000 yards pasing seasons, 5 NFC championship appearances, a super bowl appearance, five pro bowls, 194 TDs in 10 seasons, only 4 of them starting all 16 games.
hmmm well brady hasnt played enough yet but i do agree that bulger hasnt lived up to what he is payed for and mcnabb isnt underrated but i read that you took that back....my 3 would be...vince young, romo, maybe delhomme
lol this guy is a gigantic idiot....? how is brady quinn overrated nobody expected anything from him, then comes marc wowowowow they shouldnt even be rated.... mcnabb shouldn't be on here either... i mean hes a streaky player but he still raw as H#ll
First of all Brady Quinn was a top 10 draft pick worthy. And Marc Bulger signed the biggest contract in Rams history and never lived up to the 65 million dollars. And i'll admit I take back Mcnabb cuz I realize that he does a lot even without a go to receiver.
mmm okay so marc bulger was overpayed so all of a sudden u say hes overrated? um thats seriously retarded. if u actually watch him play hes a really good quarterback with no offensive line to help. are u 5?
lol did you hear what I said? I said that he never lived up to 65 million dollars. I think every o-line is good because of the QB. Cuz if u kno the basics of Football you kno that the QB communicates with the o-line and i've noticed Bulger can't read blitzes at all. He was just a one year wonder in 2006. You must be 2 years old.
um ya have u ever played football? and its cuz the o-line cant BLOCK. sure communication can be off sometimes but it sucks wen orlando pace is the only legit blocker on the line. and now hes not even there. so before u start talking about how much bulger gets payed and doesnt live up to it, think about the thousands of dollars the line is getting payed to let defensive lineman sack bulger
Ya the o-line makes about 500 grand i would say each. Besides Orlando Pace but he's gone. I admit though the o-line does suck balls but it still the QB's job to be succesful. Look at the o-line Brady had for his first 4 years. And yet he still did a good job. You obviously don't kno anything.
The guy who made this list should have his fingers ripped off! McNabb is not overrated! He spreads the ball TOO EVERY FUCKING PERSON! T.O was the best thing he had. Him ovverated thats bullshit. hes #4 in passing yards right now without a dominant reciever. Your a fucking idiot, dont ever make a video on youtube again. Sure he hasnt been healthy, but when he is healthy theres not doubt hes in the top 5. Rivers, Leinhart, Romo, Eli r overrated.
Ok I admit Donovan Mcnabb has impressed me and the Eagles have been my pick to go to the super bowl along with the Ravens since the playoffs began. But that crappy receiver thing is stupid. A quarterback makes a receiver not the other way around. Why was Roddy White doing so good when he actually had a passing quarterback and not a scrambling quarterback. And I could go down the list. So the whole receiver thing is no excuse at all.
man this roddy white argument is flat out STUPID. Roddy white is one of the leagues premier receivers. he only had his first 2 seasons with Vick and then he broke out his third year(like most receivers) with JOEY HARRINGTON for his qb for a 1200 yard season. The only year McNabb has had an elite receiver the eagles went to the super bowl. btw look at what acquiring Randy Moss has done for Tom Brady's qb stats. Do you honestly think receivers matter for the qb?
When did he threw for over 4000 yards? Last time I checked he had like 3916 yards. Not 4000 yards. Yea I'll admit McNabb has impressed me and the Eagles are my pick to go to the super bowl but I believe the Ravens will win it all. Get your facts straight.
Brett is highly overrated... He sucked it up in NY.. he had most of his td's in THREE games... He is a product of the WCO and really can't do crap outside of it...
SO.. YES he is overrated.. and bluntly he isn't even the best QB the Packer's have ever had.
This was retarded.Quinn at 3? Bulger at 2? Bulger isn't overrated because he isn't considered 'good'.McNabb, eh he has ups and downs but at least he can throw touchdowns.
lol if Bulger isn't considered good then explain his huge contract he got back in 2007.
He was considered to be one of the greats just 2 years ago and now what happened to him. All he does is throw INT's. I can see why ppl would consider McNabb not overrated but in my opinion i think he is.
You'd know that it is hard to throw touchdowns behind swiss cheese while throwing to receivers with stone hands.
I hate McNabb.But why he's on here is beyond me.He has consistently put up decent numbers, despite his primary receiver being a running back.Quinn has made what? 2 starts? And he's on here? Wow.
I live in the Cleveland area and i hear all th people talk about Brady Quinn being the next Tom Brady, Joe Montana or whoever else. I am not a brown fan so this just cracks me up everytime i hear it. Based off of expectations he is extremely overated. mcnabb is not overated. 5 nfc championships in 8 years. i would say mcnabb is underated. Bulger doesnt get thatt much hype to be considered either in my opinion. Not to mention his O line sucks and steven jackson is never healthy
I know, I am too a Rams fan.But nobody considers Bulger good, therefore it cancels out being overrated.
Bulger's a great QB, with a swiss cheese line.The reason I said that is because you can't be overrated if nobody thinks you're good, even though he would be top10, with a competent line.
No Eli Manning?
WORSTEVERR 3 months ago
McNabb one of the few QBs not protected by refs.Brady,Brees,Sanchez all way over protected by refs.Defensive players can't touch Brady without flag and fine.Sanchez if he is hit late flag and fine.McNabb gets hit late all the time and never a flag.Conspiracy in NFL!!!
skywalker71903 5 months ago
@marrsteele2000 yea Aaron Rodgers sucks. I mean he didnt just win the Superbowl and SB MVP or anything lol.
X360ISAIAH 6 months ago
sdouglas is right. eli didnt win the superbowl the rest of the team did
jrgreeny101 6 months ago
@xplay101 rivers is not overated hes good ! and flacco isnt overated he is pretty good to and nobody calls him a elite qb hes still young only what 23 in his 3rd year his qb rate was 92 thats good hes a good young qb
27cringer 8 months ago
@Ernestof48 yea and what was the score of that game? like 17-12? hmm. sounds like only 2 tds were scored by the giants. Sounds more like a DEFENSIVE game to me and i think its funny that the giants had 1 of the best D's in the league. Strahan should've win SB mvp, not eli.
sdouglas28 10 months ago
how is it the most overrated if everyone says they suck? being overrated means people say their good and no one says they are.
1. Eli Manning
2. Tony Romo
3. Jay Cutler
4. Ben Roethlisberger (I know people will hate on me for this)
5. Brett Favre
sdouglas28 10 months ago 2
@sdouglas28 dude cutler, Rothlisberger, and farve are not overrated. cutler is a very underrated qb, rothlisberger is a good qb, and farve is good
mutarrr 7 months ago
@mutarrr cutler is overrated but i agree with the other 2
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
@portugalrocks9 how is cutler overrated? his offense holds him back. He has shitty recievers and a bad line (the line is getting better) and yets he still puts up numbers. So tell me how is he overrated?
mutarrr 3 months ago
@mutarrr his line is fine he's the one who moves around the pocket to long...and his recievers don't suck, no starting recievers suck...and he lost them the game in the championship conference game...he quits and he is not a leader....so there, that is how he is overrated
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
@portugalrocks9 ok first off all 3 of those statements just proved to me how much you know about football. HIs line is FINE? fuck no they are improving but are not fine. HIs recievers are shit they can't even catch the ball matt forte is their leading reciever. And in the nfc championship game he was injured so how could you quit when your injured dumbass.
mutarrr 3 months ago
@mutarrr umm dumbass he quit, he's a pussy who cant throw for shit...and his recivers would catch it if they would get a good fucking pass...theres a reason why bears will never make it to the superbowl with cutler...and his line isnt the problem...cutler thinks he can stand in the pocket for days...and who the fuck care's its the bears, they suck cock
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
@portugalrocks9 haha way to prove your football IQ. Hows he a pussy the guys gets hit more than any other qb in the league and gets up and goes back to playing. He can't throw for shit last time i checked he has the strongest arm in the nfl. ANd if you actually watched cutler he throws a perfect pass to his recievers his recievers suck dick. You know why am i wasting my time with you you have no clue what your talking about
mutarrr 3 months ago
@mutarrr youre such a retard and dont know shit about football....you think he has the strongest arm in the league??? wow youre so stupid. and i do watch him play and he doesnt throw good passes dumbass... thanks for proving my point, he gets sacked over and over agian and most the time its his fault for not throwing the ball away or for keeping it too long...i am still laughing that you think he has the strongest arm in the league dumbass...Bears suck and you're NFL IQ sucks
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
@portugalrocks9 haha way too prove my point dumbass. And he does have the strongest arm in the league. And if you watch him play then you would know that he throws the ball where only the recievers can get it but you forget they can't catch. And how is it a qbs fault when he gets sacked thats the o-line fault. And cutler only has like 2 seconds to make a decision because his o-line sucks (getting better) and yet cutler still puts up good numbers. So i have proven my point you are just stupid
mutarrr 3 months ago
@mutarrr okay listen dumb fuck cutler doesnt have the strongest arm in the league not even in the top ten...and even if he did who cares he still has bad aim.and if you know anything about football you would know that a QB should only take 5 seconds before starting to throw the ball and chiago gives him 5 seconds cause i do watch them play infact i watch more football then you cause you dont know shit, if he was as good as your saying he would at least make it to the SB.hester is the whole team
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
@portugalrocks9 okay first off cutler does have the strongest arm in the league. And who says he has bad aim he throws the ball where the reciever can catch it but you forget his recievers don't know how to catch the fucking ball. And this is what you said "if he was as good as your saying he would at least make it to the SB" well last time i checked it takes a whole team to make it to the superbowl. And if hester were the whole team then i think he would be able to atleast catch the ball
mutarrr 3 months ago
@mutarrr oh my god your so stupid if you think cutler has a stronger and better aimed arm then Brady, the Mannings, and Big ben, i can name 10 QB's with a better arm..Tom brady and peyton manning work with bad receivers and make them better...who would welker be without Brady and who would Garcon and Wayne be without peyton manning...they can work with anyone but cutler cant work with shit...and hester and their Defense are the Chicago Bears, Cutler can easliy be replaced
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
@portugalrocks9 lol first off comparing cutler to hall of famers is pathetic. And cutler has a stronger arm than all of them maybe not accurate but stronger. Brady has an o-line that gives him all fucking day and has recievers who can CATCH the ball dumbass. And if you actually watch football cutler has been playing very well with nothing so he is working with nothing dumbass. and again hester can return but he can't catch the ball. Your a fucking moron so fuck off
mutarrr 3 months ago
@mutarrr stupid ass Brady's recivers can catch because brady can throw accurate to them, welker is as small as Desean Jackson but Brady makes perfect passes so he can catch it..you sound like a fucking retard when you say Cutler has the strongest arm in the league, but even if he did so what? he still has shitty aim...stop blaiming Chiago's recivers when its that dumb little pricks fault. cutler is not a good QB or leader... go suck cutlers dick if you like him so bad you dumb fucker
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
@portugalrocks9 lol this is the last thing im gonna say you are fucking retarded. Yeah brady throws perfect passes his recievers can catch the ball and they know how to get open. And when i mentioned that cutler was doing great and used what he has you didn't respond to that now did you? Why don't you go watch some football and actually learn something dumb one. And if cutler is so bad why is he ranked 12th in the league for qbs?
mutarrr 3 months ago
@mutarrr 12 exactly not even in the top ten....how does cutlers dick taste?
portugalrocks9 3 months ago
yes bulger does suck but steven jackson is awesome but now we have sam bradford he is a legend!!!!
mrmathardyfan 11 months ago
why does everyone think Sanchez is overrated?
2 seasons and already everyone says hes overrated? Jets are a running team so how can the QB be overrated? Statistically, Sanchez has improved from rookie year but has a long way to go. Its also New York media i hope you relize this...
who said delhomme is underated? he sucks so bad he dosent even deserve to be noticed
MrMDV96 11 months ago
brady is overrated so is drew brees they play 2 hand touch football, mcnabb is one of the few quarterbacks that gets hit, this video is garbage.brady would not survive in washington behind that o line and of course nfl did right thing and take away bullshit pamper privilages away
skywalker71903 1 year ago
Right now I'd say Sanchez, Romo, and Eli are the most overrated.
BroncosXNumberX1 1 year ago
McNabb is the 5th best Q.B. in the league right now, and the greatest Eagles Q.B. of all time. All the McNabb haters are just crazy.
WR12MSH 1 year ago
Where is Rivers. or Flacco
xplay101 1 year ago
So many Mcnabb haters huh? Thats how good he is. Pity is for free but envy is to be earned. Donovan Mcnabb is one of the most underrated QB of all time. cchank1, now check your list and get it right dog.
Don't hate, appreciate
AkeemDenim 1 year ago
Comment removed
AkeemDenim 1 year ago
Top 3 underrated qbs
3. Carson Palmer
2. Joe flacco
1. Matt scaub
3 overated qbs
3. Mark sanchez
2. Eli manning/ Jake dehlomme
1. Donavan mcnabb
player93ify 1 year ago
fuck donovan mcnabb. hes a bitch
wackymac28 1 year ago
3.Jay Cutler 2.Donovan McNabb 1.Eli Manning and dont give me that "Eli has a superbowl ring" bullshit because Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson have a superbowl ring and they sucked asshole, teams win superbowls.
FistsOfFury21 1 year ago
@Curran430 Oh my lord, dude stop talking. I am the biggest Brady Quinn/ND fan ever but you have embarrassed yourself and me included. Brady Quinn never won the heisman. As a matter of fact, he came in third place behind Troy Smith and Ray Rice.
kizzela12 1 year ago
i hate the qb position they get all the credit just for throwing a ball
drumba5 1 year ago
McNabb is OD overrated.
blazinpyromaniac 1 year ago
@blazinpyromaniac OD?
Codyeagle1 1 year ago
@blazinpyromaniac Mcnabb is one of the best in the league? just write I HATE MCNABB instead of making lies about him.
Codyeagle1 1 year ago
@Codyeagle1 i FUCKING hate this bitch ass McNabb. That work out fine?
blazinpyromaniac 1 year ago
@blazinpyromaniac its alright u have to hate great players
Codyeagle1 1 year ago
@Codyeagle1 the eagles cant win a superbowl
Luke16510 1 year ago
@Luke16510 every team can win one look at the saints ahah
Codyeagle1 1 year ago
@Codyeagle1 and the saints deserved it
duckjockey10 1 year ago
if anything mcnabb is underrated
SteelSnarf 1 year ago
last time i checked donovan isnt overrated
D7a7v9e7 1 year ago
you dont know shit about football, go die
bran0bran0 2 years ago
This video is retarded. Mcnabb isnt the most overrated. Eli Manning is
Codyeagle1 2 years ago
MCNABB SUX i love the eagles but i CANT STAND mcnabb PUT IN VICK
Dawkinsdude20 2 years ago
Vick sucked so bad Philly would barely let him throw.
Codyeagle1 2 years ago
wtf donavan isnt overrated all these pussy cowboy fans trashing him is why people think hes overrated cause people posting videos of his screwups he had a hell lot of more good plays then bad plays fucking tired of you god damn cowboy fans go suck tony homos dick ya fuckin cunts
ricky4975 2 years ago
no, its the pussy eagle fans trashing him is why people think he's overrated. Starting from day 1 at the draft the eagle fans booed him. Us cowboys fans want to know why they trash him so much. He's a great QB. I wouldn't mind having Mcnabb on my team.
scowboys18 2 years ago
Philly fans dont want to be wrong they hated him because they wanted someone else. Idiots i tell u
Codyeagle1 2 years ago 2
Dan Marino is overrated too I take it?
roccovaleriano 2 years ago
Don't say anything bad about Donovan or Wilma will come after you. If she doesn't find you then I will. McNabb is a stud and I love the way his butt looks when he dances.
BelmontShore1 2 years ago
Mcnabb is an overrated QB. He sucks. He throws the ball to the dirt all the time when he has a guy wide open. Look at the Cardinal game last year. They need to release him and start Vick or Cobb
shiest13 2 years ago
Huge Philly fan and I completely agree, Kolb will be a much accurate, smarter, and all around better QB for the eagles to win the Superbowl.
TheUFCfreak 2 years ago 2
Do you watch football child?
Codyeagle1 2 years ago
hey wth donovon mcnabb is a beast this year cuz he actually got pplz to throw to, and hes got better linemen protectin him
BlinkxD27 2 years ago
lmao where's tony the choke romo?
Laogangstaa 2 years ago
nahhh trey it should be
1. jamarcuss russell
2.jake delhomme
3. jay cutler
McNabb is one of da best rite now since he finally has someone to throw 2 and dem fat ass linemen finally decided 2 block 4 him
kevon0000 2 years ago
Worst Starting Quarterbacks in the NFL 2009
***************************************
1 Jake Delhomme =Mr. Interception
2 Donovan McNabb =Mr. Inconsistant
3 Jay Cutler= Mr No Scoring of TD in the red zone
treybrothacomedy 2 years ago
"McNabb mr inconsistant"
Dude wtf, McNabb is the most consistent quarterbacks ever. (Cept in the post-season) how can you even say that, Look at his numbers dude. he only throws like 8 interceptions a year. and he always tosses at-least 21 td's
Synicaalescape 2 years ago
@Synicaalescape McNabb is pretty consistant, but he isn't the most consistant ever. That's obviously a false statement.
NicksSportsPicks 2 years ago
the guys a moron dont even bother reading his trash
Codyeagle1 2 years ago
Umm post-season is all that matters, so if he's inconsistant then, he is Mr. Inconsistant. His stats are good when it's games that mean nothing.
TheUFCfreak 2 years ago
wtf list is that????
Codyeagle1 2 years ago
McNabb is fourth among active quarterbacks in career touchdown passes, trailing only Brett Favre(, Peyton Manning and Tom Brady. He's got the third-best touchdown-to-interception ratio in NFL history, behind only Brady and Steve Young. His career winning percentage is an outstanding .651. A paltry 2.09% of his throws are intercepted, which beats Brady Manning Joe Montana Dan Marino or anyone else you want to name. Hes the Eagles all-time leader in yards, attempts and touchdowns
alexoneilmovie 2 years ago 2
Yet his qb percentage is only 86.2 and he chokes in big games.
prooc 2 years ago
lol what's a qb percentage? do you mean rating? if so 86.2 is a very good career qb rating. Troy Aikman's is only 81.6 and Brett Favre's is 85.7 in their careers and McNabb never has had the pro-bowl receivers they did. Although he lacks a super bowl he has a much better playoff record than Peyton Manning and heh Tony Romo
alexoneilmovie 2 years ago
Yeah and that's why McNabb has won 10 playoff games.
Synicaalescape 2 years ago
Haha who cares about winning Playoff games if you don't win the Superbowl. Thats all that matters, all those playoff games just gave the Eagles a worse pick in the draft. Starting on a team of Eagles caliber for 10 years without winning the Superbowl is pathetic. At least Kolb is white and so he can make smart decision as he gets more experience.
TheUFCfreak 2 years ago
Too bad Mangina told us D.A. would start on Wednesday, cause I hear if you keep it a secret your opponet is forced to forfeit from the sheer suspence.
CallOfDutyPOW 2 years ago
D.A. Pro-Bowl QB in 2007 that makes 20 and 30 yard gains to Braylon Edwards and converts on 3rd downs so we keep the ball and have a chance to score a touchdown Brady Quinn- Overrated Rookie that's never played a game and can't throw for shit especially on 3rd downs and can't move the ball so we have one touchdown in the past what 30 quarters!? Who should we start? Mangina: "QUINN!"
CallOfDutyPOW 2 years ago
Romo should be placed second.
yana1music 2 years ago
where is jake the fake delhomme
texasman75147 2 years ago
is it for sure yet?
MegaSammich 2 years ago
all the people that were cheering for quinn last year are gonna start chanting DA
MegaSammich 2 years ago
quinns garbage dude
get it through your thick melon
and if you reply to this dont friggn sugar coat it
there was nothing good about the way he played
MegaSammich 2 years ago
it shouldnt be long until he gets his job back
MegaSammich 2 years ago
quinn played absolutely spectacular!!!
(sarcasm)
if he keeps up the way he played against the vikings
it shouldnt be long until DA gets his job back
man did he play bad
MegaSammich 2 years ago
your very very dumb
they have not released the starting quarterback position
eric mangini said he wanted to keep the vikings guessing
i dont like you
stop commenting
MegaSammich 2 years ago
it hasnt been called yet butthole
MegaSammich 2 years ago
how the fuck iscampbell overated if everyone including his coaches thinks he sucks
vcownzraptors 2 years ago
3 quarters of quinns completions are to running backs
Derek takes chances
thats part of being a quarterback
quinn throws the ball 7 yards and cribbs or edwards of lewis takes it another 18
MegaSammich 2 years ago
Bulger is a fine QB when the o-line actually blocks for him like they will this year and Bulger will be tight again.
happyjoe4ever 2 years ago
yup
MegaSammich 2 years ago
canada
MegaSammich 2 years ago
shall we get back into your conversation about preseason?
derek anderson looked alot better than quinn last week
MegaSammich 2 years ago
no it wasnt
they played DA to see if he could play well
if he didnt, they would automatically put it quinn
he played well,
and led them to a successful season
MegaSammich 2 years ago
quinn is better. i love DA believe me but he became too predictable
FamilyGuy1019 2 years ago
fav teams seattle eagles vicking ravens chargers and giants
rockeagle9938 2 years ago
MegaSammich 2 years ago
Dude you just proved that Derek Anderson is better. Derek Anderson was a 6th rounder and he finished his first full season with a record of a 9-6 as a starter. That's better than Quinn ever did in his whole life. I'm a diehard Oregon State Beavers fan and I remember that Derek Anderson was probably the best QB we have ever had. Quinn has proved that he can't start. Why else is there a QB competition?
cchank1 2 years ago
quinn played 3 games
he did not play very well
MegaSammich 2 years ago
i didnt say he sucks,
i said DA is better
true fact
MegaSammich 2 years ago
exactly butthole
2 passes
HE THREW TWO PASSES
that leaves no room to prove what you can do
what do you mean dropped pass?
he threw a pick
your a complete idiot
MegaSammich 2 years ago
Jesus relax buddy. It was just a pre-season game. They barely put Anderson out on the field anyway. Anderson has already proved himself in 2007 that he is the starter. The only reason he sucked last year was because Braylon Edwards kept dropping those deep balls, Kellen Winslow was out for a few games, and he lost his best 3rd down target in Joe Jurevicious.
cchank1 2 years ago
you dont know shit man
anderson is alot better than quinn
MegaSammich 2 years ago
Comment removed
MegaSammich 2 years ago
1.Tom brady
2.Eli Manning
3.Donovan Mcnabb
4.Drew Brees
5.Carlson Palmer
chargersLT2118 2 years ago
tom brady
d mcnabb
matt hasselbeck
carson palmer
marc bulger
eli manning
Triple3Deuce2 2 years ago
1. Peyton Manning
2. Tom Brady
3. Ben Rothleisberger
4. Drew Brees
5. Carson Palmer
Sandman9283 2 years ago
i agree with donovan and marc bulger but i dont think brady quinn is overrated hes not even the starter for the browns
nitsuaeleets 2 years ago
if garcia was the starter for the egales at least the eagles have a chance at another super bowl. now with mcnabb no chance in hell for that to happen. i hope he gets injuried and kolb takes the team to the payoffs and maybe even the superbowl(farfetched though) if it happens i bet you kolb would be traded off next season to keep dicknabb happy.
deathjoker666 2 years ago
i like the eagles and mcnabb is overrated piece of shit. ever since he had that sports hernia he started to suck. befroe that injury he was good. now all he does is play catch with the ants. i think its time to get rid of andy and mcnabb both are fuckiong the team over.
deathjoker666 2 years ago
Thank you for agreeing with me. I always thought he lost everything when he got injured. I think it's time to develop Kevin Kolb or draft another QB next year in the draft.
cchank1 2 years ago
i agree with kolb. but this whole bull shit with mcnabb could have been avoided if they just kept jeff garcia. garcia brought the team to the playoffs one year when mcnabb was hurt. when mcnabb was healthy they sucked. jeff steps in then all of a suddden the eagles did good. granted they lost to the saints but with mcnabb they wouldn't gotten to the playoffs that year. what did the agles do they got rid of jeff so they could keep mcnabb happy. bad move there.
deathjoker666 2 years ago
Yeah totally. I was shocked when Philly didn't resign Jeff Garcia cuz he could have at least competed for the starting job with McNabb. Garcia did fantastic for Philly in 2006.
cchank1 2 years ago
i hope the eagles fans that go to see the games i hope they boo mcnabba nd andy to show how they feel about their performances. its ridicouls how andy calls the plays and mcnabb just does what he does best throws terrible balls.
deathjoker666 2 years ago
you think Donovan McNabb is the most overrated? he is WAAAYYY underrated. are you fucking kidding me? people and critics always say how he sucks. he is WAAAYYY underrated, he is the 2nd best QB in the league today behind ONLY Payton Manning. no i am not mistaking, he is better than Tom Brady. yes i am an Eagles fan but that is not the only reason why i'm saying this. you must be stupid.
Frost99030507 2 years ago
You must be stupid for putting McNabb in front of Tom Brady who threw over 50 TD's and plays consistent, Kurt Warner, and Phillip Rivers?
cchank1 2 years ago
ok, now your even putting him in the same class as Warner and Rivers? wow. McNabb is the 2nd est QB in he league today. and why do you think he is overrated? i never hear a good thing said about him by the critics or anybody else. where did you get that he is overrated? he is way underrated compared to what he does and has accomplished.
Frost99030507 2 years ago
How dumb can you get? Warner is a beast and reads defenses and takes advantages of them. Rivers is my type of QB. Quick, consistent, west coast style QB. Yes, SD doesn't run the west coast offense but if u put him in the west coast offense, watch out! McNabb throws to Westbrook over 70% of the time. Look it up idiot.
cchank1 2 years ago
tell me if he under rated then why does he 1 throw the ball to high or 2 throw to low? he e has all the time the oline gives him to throw the ball but he holds it holds it and then throws a bad pass happens a lot with mcnabb.
deathjoker666 2 years ago
Brady Quinn is a Beast!! GO BROWNS!!!
TheJameezy 2 years ago
brady quinn is faaaar from a beast
MegaSammich 2 years ago
heres my top 3 most overrated qbs off the top of my head #3 tony romo #2jake delhomme #1 vince young and i can nmae like 50 people more overrated than these guys ; "big ben', carson palmer, micheal vick(when he played), phillip rivers, and jay cutler
jamxkvids 2 years ago
LMFAO!!!!! Wow! And you call me stupid! Ok i'll give u Delhomme but Romo and Young? Ok yeah I kno they suck but they are not overrated. And you put Big Ben, Rivers, and Cutler who are more overrated then these guys I have. Whats the matter with you? Big Ben wins games when it matters, and Rivers?!?!?! He should have been a pro bowler this year or at least in contention for MVP. You are stupid. And Cutler? His team screwed up cuz of their running game and front 7 dumbass.
cchank1 2 years ago
how but next time you make a video when your not drunk
jamxkvids 2 years ago
you are dumb as carp you all wrong in all 3 picks. hows brady quinn overrated when noone talks about him i dont think you kno what overrated means? overrated is when people think your good and you arent. nobody thinks hes good. #2 bulger has no line and his recievers are 65 years old. #1 i think you are straight up retarded your probabaly some dumbass cowboy fan. if mcnabbs overrated tell me how he gets to the playoffs practicly every year with no recievers? bitch!
jamxkvids 2 years ago
First of all u ashould respect ppls opinions. I picked Brady Quinn becuz he had high expectations and he couldn't beat Charlie Frye or Derek Anderson for the starting job. Marc Bulger becuz even without a line and ur so called 65 year old receivers he can't play no matter what. Only reason why he did good in 2006 was becuz Jackson was in his prime and Holt and Issac were the best duo. Mcnabb becuz he has Brian Westbrook to throw to. He throws to Westbrook at least 60% of the time dumbass. BITCH!
cchank1 2 years ago
ok well that makes you sound even more stupid cus when you have high expectations and they dont work out.... those are called bust you should just take this video off youtube and throw your computer out the window i dont have the slightest clue why you made this video its one of the dumbest ive seen in a while and marc bulger was actually good but he just dosnt have what he used too. and donovan mcnabb is one of best qbs in the leugue maybe
jamxkvids 2 years ago
not the smartest but hes in the top five. you honestly think mcnabb is overrated? yuo probably think tom bradys overrated too now dont you? so all those passing yards and tds were all westbrook? no i dont think so i think your the only person on the earth that think donovan mcnabb is overrated i kinda think he underrated nobody reall ever talks about him.
jamxkvids 2 years ago
exactly, people think quinns good
but he isnt
MegaSammich 2 years ago
DA is the shit the entire browns offense did bad last year people dropped passes cough Braylon edwards cough K2 and Donte were injured and all brady did was dumpoffs to his HB or FB if braylon hadnt have dropped all thoose balls granted some were bad passes DA would have been ALOT better
alexVL44 2 years ago 2
THANKyou
MegaSammich 2 years ago
i totally agree except for bulger but mcnabb hasnt won shyt he always ends up choking or throwing up during the super bowl and brady quinn is going to fail as a starter hes at best a back up he didnt win no bcs bowl games in college
mrblowit 2 years ago
Quinn and Bulger have been on rather crappy teams the past few years and Quinn hasn't been given the chance to really start much.
But McNabb? 6 3000 yards pasing seasons, 5 NFC championship appearances, a super bowl appearance, five pro bowls, 194 TDs in 10 seasons, only 4 of them starting all 16 games.
You don't know shit.
TheGreatBobRoss 2 years ago 2
Quinn is fucking overrated.
Caligula42 2 years ago 2
for me its palmer, bulger, anderson. i sorta disagree with mcnabb though. He is preety good
TimkaV86 2 years ago
u a fucking hater r u in the nfl
SpitAsIgo 2 years ago
How is Mcnabb overated?
batista1987777 2 years ago
I almost completely agree. If only Quinn was 1.
ManikMan3 2 years ago
brady quinn is better than u u fagot
abledrn 2 years ago
hmmm well brady hasnt played enough yet but i do agree that bulger hasnt lived up to what he is payed for and mcnabb isnt underrated but i read that you took that back....my 3 would be...vince young, romo, maybe delhomme
JayEye015 2 years ago
to me its
1.romo
2.hasselbeck
3.garcia
pacmangilley2436 2 years ago
Garcia is HELLA UNDERRATED are u serious?
JayEye015 2 years ago
Who ever made this video is a pretty retarded person
wolfpack07 2 years ago
lol this guy is a gigantic idiot....? how is brady quinn overrated nobody expected anything from him, then comes marc wowowowow they shouldnt even be rated.... mcnabb shouldn't be on here either... i mean hes a streaky player but he still raw as H#ll
hien2b 3 years ago
First of all Brady Quinn was a top 10 draft pick worthy. And Marc Bulger signed the biggest contract in Rams history and never lived up to the 65 million dollars. And i'll admit I take back Mcnabb cuz I realize that he does a lot even without a go to receiver.
cchank1 3 years ago
mmm okay so marc bulger was overpayed so all of a sudden u say hes overrated? um thats seriously retarded. if u actually watch him play hes a really good quarterback with no offensive line to help. are u 5?
crankerkidd 3 years ago
lol did you hear what I said? I said that he never lived up to 65 million dollars. I think every o-line is good because of the QB. Cuz if u kno the basics of Football you kno that the QB communicates with the o-line and i've noticed Bulger can't read blitzes at all. He was just a one year wonder in 2006. You must be 2 years old.
cchank1 2 years ago
um ya have u ever played football? and its cuz the o-line cant BLOCK. sure communication can be off sometimes but it sucks wen orlando pace is the only legit blocker on the line. and now hes not even there. so before u start talking about how much bulger gets payed and doesnt live up to it, think about the thousands of dollars the line is getting payed to let defensive lineman sack bulger
crankerkidd 2 years ago
Ya the o-line makes about 500 grand i would say each. Besides Orlando Pace but he's gone. I admit though the o-line does suck balls but it still the QB's job to be succesful. Look at the o-line Brady had for his first 4 years. And yet he still did a good job. You obviously don't kno anything.
cchank1 2 years ago
I think you are smoking crack how is Donavan McNabb over rated he is one of the best qurterbacks in the NFL he was
4th in the NFL so how is he overrated DUMBASS!
eaglezallday 3 years ago
I aint done yet! The Eagles is my favorite team and they are just a
xxMMECxx 3 years ago
The guy who made this list should have his fingers ripped off! McNabb is not overrated! He spreads the ball TOO EVERY FUCKING PERSON! T.O was the best thing he had. Him ovverated thats bullshit. hes #4 in passing yards right now without a dominant reciever. Your a fucking idiot, dont ever make a video on youtube again. Sure he hasnt been healthy, but when he is healthy theres not doubt hes in the top 5. Rivers, Leinhart, Romo, Eli r overrated.
xxMMECxx 3 years ago
I agree completely on Marc Bulger and Donovan McNabb, but I would put Brett Favre at #1 on that list.
Mozicon 3 years ago
It ain't Bulger's fault.Blame his unhealthy o-line,and his very overrated Halfback.
firebirdgomez 3 years ago 3
bulgers not really overrated everybody already knows he sucks
OrangeArsen 3 years ago
lol you're right mcnabb is overrated! what has he done besides 5 nfc championships appearances with shitty recievers?
alexoneilmovie 3 years ago
Ok I admit Donovan Mcnabb has impressed me and the Eagles have been my pick to go to the super bowl along with the Ravens since the playoffs began. But that crappy receiver thing is stupid. A quarterback makes a receiver not the other way around. Why was Roddy White doing so good when he actually had a passing quarterback and not a scrambling quarterback. And I could go down the list. So the whole receiver thing is no excuse at all.
cchank1 3 years ago
man this roddy white argument is flat out STUPID. Roddy white is one of the leagues premier receivers. he only had his first 2 seasons with Vick and then he broke out his third year(like most receivers) with JOEY HARRINGTON for his qb for a 1200 yard season. The only year McNabb has had an elite receiver the eagles went to the super bowl. btw look at what acquiring Randy Moss has done for Tom Brady's qb stats. Do you honestly think receivers matter for the qb?
alexoneilmovie 2 years ago
Yea, sure McNabb is overrated. That's why he threw for 4000 yards.
letsgowhitesoxfilms 3 years ago
When did he threw for over 4000 yards? Last time I checked he had like 3916 yards. Not 4000 yards. Yea I'll admit McNabb has impressed me and the Eagles are my pick to go to the super bowl but I believe the Ravens will win it all. Get your facts straight.
cchank1 3 years ago
Close enough.
letsgowhitesoxfilms 3 years ago
1. Brett Favre
2. Carson Palmer
3. Derek Anderson
Enough said
MichaelBearwalf 3 years ago
you gotta be outside your mind to put the Brett Favre in there...
swright4488 3 years ago
Brett is highly overrated... He sucked it up in NY.. he had most of his td's in THREE games... He is a product of the WCO and really can't do crap outside of it...
SO.. YES he is overrated.. and bluntly he isn't even the best QB the Packer's have ever had.
Top 25 QB of all time.. top 10 HELL NO
MichaelBearwalf 3 years ago
Why Carson Palmer is up there is beyond me.
MackTen187 3 years ago
Quinn is not overrated. Everyone knows he sucks.
mcxpart1 3 years ago
You Got it All Wrong
gnrforever960 3 years ago
This was retarded.Quinn at 3? Bulger at 2? Bulger isn't overrated because he isn't considered 'good'.McNabb, eh he has ups and downs but at least he can throw touchdowns.
MackTen187 3 years ago
lol if Bulger isn't considered good then explain his huge contract he got back in 2007.
He was considered to be one of the greats just 2 years ago and now what happened to him. All he does is throw INT's. I can see why ppl would consider McNabb not overrated but in my opinion i think he is.
cchank1 3 years ago
If you're a Rams fan.
You'd know that it is hard to throw touchdowns behind swiss cheese while throwing to receivers with stone hands.
I hate McNabb.But why he's on here is beyond me.He has consistently put up decent numbers, despite his primary receiver being a running back.Quinn has made what? 2 starts? And he's on here? Wow.
MackTen187 3 years ago
I live in the Cleveland area and i hear all th people talk about Brady Quinn being the next Tom Brady, Joe Montana or whoever else. I am not a brown fan so this just cracks me up everytime i hear it. Based off of expectations he is extremely overated. mcnabb is not overated. 5 nfc championships in 8 years. i would say mcnabb is underated. Bulger doesnt get thatt much hype to be considered either in my opinion. Not to mention his O line sucks and steven jackson is never healthy
csean019 3 years ago
I am a Rams fan and look at the numbers Bulger used to put up. If a sponge wasent blocking for him he would be an elite QB.
jockelite 3 years ago
I know, I am too a Rams fan.But nobody considers Bulger good, therefore it cancels out being overrated.
Bulger's a great QB, with a swiss cheese line.The reason I said that is because you can't be overrated if nobody thinks you're good, even though he would be top10, with a competent line.
MackTen187 3 years ago
Sorry I disagree with the swiss cheese, Swiss Cheese is to strong, we need something more permeable... I belive the line is more of a styrofoam...
jockelite 3 years ago