I wouldn't call Aretha the greatest singer ever, because I don't believe in the concept... we NEED Aretha in our lives, we're grateful to have her, but we also need Billie, Dinah, Nina, Ella, Mahalia, and many more... they're all literally irreplaceable.
Estimated friend, if you want to listen again this song and an endless number of successes of the love I suggest you to visit Radio MUSICA PARA MIMOS - looks for his direction URL in Google ( search Musica para Mimos in Google)-. best romantic music of all the times in Internet, is great, is very good ...!!!
I Just love Aretha singing this song i have this on the queen in waiting album for you guys who want to buy it .i love Billys version as well .So no arguments there .Aretha is and always will be one of the true greats artists of our time .Thankyou for posting
@whatigot2say - You should be ashamed of yourself for disrespecting Aretha Franklin like you did. Only ignorant and small people talk like that. You are a hater, and the person that you hate the most is yourself.
I think when we are talking about the Queen and the Lady,comparisons are pointless.Two incomparable artists who did what they did better than anybody else.
Excellent piece of work!! Thank you very much for Sharing!!!!!
What a way of meeting people and get to see their talent. At first was reluctant being on youtube, but getting to do this has brought me into the houses of some very special people. You are one of them. Life; isn't it wonderful!!! Keep up the good work. Hope You Are Having A Splendid Day!!!!
That voice! I love Aretha Franklin! If she hadn't signed with Atlantic and revolutionized R&B she would have been one of the best modern jazz singers, easily in the ranks of the great Dinah Washington.
I just heard the version of Billy holiday, Aretha Franklin, Diana Ross and Whitney Houston. respect to the one who made, props to the one who sang it in the movie, thumb us to MIss franklin , but RESPECT to the one that OWNED with her voice MISS WHITNEY HOUSTON.
Seems when you see a picture of Billie Holliday nearly stripped of her clothings, and sometimes you do, she's miserable. As far as singing... huh. You have to admire Aretha and others like Whitney Houston. But Billie, well, people underestimate the power of simplicity and honesty. But it wins in the end.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
@yaskam gretest singer ever?? hardly. this is loud and brash. but then so is everything else she sings. you mikste loud for good singing. it isn't . she doesn't respect the songs form or genre. she's going to turn it tinto a gospel song rrespective of its form. but at least her voice had clarity during this period. it sounds like shhit toda clarity is gone and it's gruffy. the price of smoking cigarettes is a destroyed voice. or maybe its all the fat around her throat.
@whatigot2say You don't know the first thing about Aretha if you think that! So say all you want but until you actually know what the hell you are talking about Shut the fuck up! And yes smoking did effect her voice but Aretha doesn't sound like shit she is still today the greatest singer around and i will repeat THE GREATEST.
Aretha Franklin when she was a Jazz and Blues singer. Before Soul music dropped in the mid 60's Aretha wanted to be like her idol Jazz Diva, Dinah Washington.
Aretha never forgot her Jazz, Blues & Gospel roots [without them there would be no Soul] when she signed with Atlantic. She would always include a Jazz or Blues tune on every LP. Between 1960 and 65 Jazz was her style on Columbia. Aretha tore it up as a Jazz diva! Aretha is really the Queen of Rhythm n Blues & all its many styles!!
Aretha Franklin when she was a Jazz and Blues singer. Before Soul music dropped in the mid 60's Aretha wanted to be like her idol Jazz Diva, Dinah Washington.
Aretha never forgot her Jazz, Blues & Gospel roots [without them there would be no Soul] when she signed with Atlantic. She would always include a Jazz or Blues tune on every LP. Between 1960 and 65 Jazz was her style on Columbia. Aretha tore it up as a Jazz diva! Aretha is really the Queen of Rhythm n Blues & all its many styles!!
@zankhe43 I also love Lou Rawl's version. This is what I call the theme song of my life. God bless the child that can stand up anywhere and say I've Got My Own.
How true is this song, I'm finding this out for myself. Funny how when you're down on your luck that "your friends" are nowhere to be seen. As Billie wrote.... "empty pockets don't make the grade". I think this song is a lesson for all of us. Good luck to you all during this recession.
I've heard Aretha sing Jazz standards before the Atlantic era and some of those she did better than the original artist, "Only The Lonely" originally by Frank Sinatra was transformed into a song with the elements of longing and regret...Aretha's interpretation of that song is unparalleled! This one she could have done without but oh well.
Well it shows that she is young here. She sang this song as if, she did not know it meaning. Her inflection and intonation is off. It was not appropriately intrepreted, I fear.
I am neither....You know as well as I do, that this song is not Aretha. This lady really knows how to sing, but here she misses the true meaning of this song. She needs to bring it down a bit. Show the emotion that this song conveys...
Who are you to say that this song is not Aretha. Aretha has lived a life of hardships and pain throughout her whole life. This is Aretha interpretation not Bille's or Diana's. And whether or not you like it or not has nothing to do with her great version. Her passion and her feeling is there. It has always been there and has never left Aretha. Diana i can't say that because Diana hasn't been through half of what Aretha's through and has never given me anything that brings you that feeling.
Diana grew up poorer than Aretha in fact. Aretha's father was a celeb preacher with money. AF parents were divorced and she was preg 2x by 16 yrs. Diana's mother was quarrantined for TB when she was a girl. Her brother was beaten and jailed by racist cops in the south. Her brother was murdered and many other things. Aretha has had very hard times; Diana too. There is no measuring of people's pain. Ross and Retha sing with passion. Ross in pop and Ree in soul. Let's respect both talented ladies.
I think this is a bit loud. It takes some of the feeling out of the song. Yes, Aretha can sing, but I don't think this is her song. Her register seems a bit high. Oh well, to each his own. However, I think Diana does a better job. Aretha's version doesn't convey the sadness that is in this song.
Just Listen to this lady's voice. She is so bad!!! There is no one who can float a note out of their mouth like Queen Aretha Franklin. Queen of Soul you are and forever will be the best!!!
You call this floating a note....I call it a note out of control. She might be the Queen of Soul, however, she is no Queen of Jazz. As far as I am concerned she completely misses the mark. I love most of her work, but on this one, she shows her lack of maturity....."Living and loving, in the world of hard knocks...Sometimes, if you haven't lived it or experienced it, you cannot convey it.
Out of control! Get yourself together. Before Aretha was a major star she was singing jazz and has tons of amazing interpretation from this time. She hasn't missed anything. She did an amazing version. This is Aretha and whether you like it or not this is her interpretation and Ross by no mean is the interpreter Aretha is. If anyone know what living a hard life, it's Aretha. At this time in her career she possessed the same feeling she does now.She's lived throught trouble and heartaches.
Hey TheQueenAretha, why don't you compare Aretha's version with the original's..Lady Day? Personally, I think Diana's version or interpretation is more closely related to Billie's version. Again, I think Aretha's version is sang in too higher of a register. Everything does not have to be screamed, to convey its effect.
Because you are comparing Diana's version to Aretha. Aretha isn't trying to copy Billie. She is doing her own interpretation. If you knew anything about Aretha or her as interpreter, you would know that Aretha isn't about high note, she is about getting her point across. Aretha is not a screamer, she is a singer. She is soaked with passion and feeling. So don't come on here trying to tell an Aretha fan anything about conveying and effect because Aretha could right a book about it.
The reason I said to compare Aretha's interpretation to the Original...Lady Day, you will see that she does not sing in a very high register. It is rather smooth and mellow...Personally, I think that Aretha's version is just too high...Well the Queen of Soul, isn't the Queen of Jazz. It is my opinion, that she does not convey the true meaning of the song. It isn't about screaming...
That is your opinion, I am not on here saying that Aretha's version is better than Billie, but i am not going to say that it is too high. Aretha has sung jazz, broadway, gospel,. blue, pop, you name it. She is able to cross genres. You are failing to get that. This is Aretha's interpretation, not Billies. Also if you knew anything about Aretha you would know that Aretha purpose when doing a cover is to convey her the meaning. Aretha doesn't scream, she sings.
Damn Ahkielove, so you consider a person that gives his or her opinion a hater..interesting. In addition, if that isn't good enough, you try to personally attack someone you have never seen. What does that say about you? I am glad I live in America, where one can express his or her opinion without fear. That is called Freedom of Speech. Personally I don't hate anyone, especially someone I have never met. However, I stand by my opinion of Aretha's interpretation of this song.
Oh by the way Ahkielove, I am 5'10", 175 lbs. I have a 32" waist 44" chest and a muscular tight physique. Unlike Aretha and perhaps you. I've tried to keep myself fit. So thinking about what you said about my physical appearance man/woman, You sound like the hater. I truly think Aretha sang that song too loudly, and it lack the feelings of someone who had experienced life. Whether you agree with what I have said, that is up to you. It is my opinion.
This is why I love Aretha so much too! Ofcourse, i adore her gospel inflections, but for me, it was always her sense of melody and line that was fantastic. The way she changed the line and still made it fit with the music. Even the first word "THEM that's got", is just placed perfectly. Although it's a bit off topic, this is why i love Whitney Houston too - she is very good at phrasing :)
I prefer Aretha Franklin's arrangement. A Billie Holiday diehard wanted to kick my ass for saying so, but we were at work. The song of Billie's that no one can ever reporduce well, in my opinion, is "Fine and Mellow", accompanied by Lester Young. D. Washington's best is "Baby Get Lost", and the hilarious, naughty "Long John." Have you heard either?
Brilliant analysis. Very few singers have such exquisite phrasing matched by a voice of power, depth and passion. (Maria Calas did, but that's a different genre) When I became a jazz fan at 8, I was so awestruck by her voice & her gifts as a pianist that I began to prefer her earliest work, such as Trouble in Mind, Running Out of Fools, Muddy Water, Blue Holliday,and this one. Etta James' tribute to Holiday is great-but raw. The modern R & B singers overindulge in melisma, not Aretha.
I actually have not heard that one. Thank you very much for the suggestion. Several things just occurred to me. There is a difference between a cover and a new arrangement; the terms are NOT interchangeable but does everyone know or care? Jazz and blues classics become so when they are well-composed. After the song is validated by time, the challenge is for the singer. Aretha Franklin, like Sinatra, ALWAYS rose to the occassion. Her jazz arrangement of "Trouble in Mind" SWINGS!
You would love it. Like i said before it is from her Soul 69 which is a album of covers. With Aretha singing mostly jazz tunes. Like Gentle On My MInd, Crazy He Calls Me, I'll Never Be Free, and many others.
@TheQueenAretha I agree! Her version of "Crazy He Calls Me" is one of the best things that she has ever recorded. She takes you there. Only a true fan would cite that recording. Simply phenomenal!!
This song is almost unrecognisable. Aretha can sing, we all know that. But this is OVER-sung. Billie, diana, etc were very understated in their approach and works much better. In this version the focus is more on the voice and not on the powerful and haunting lyrics of the songs.
This is not over sung. Aretha took the sung and made it hers. She changed the arrangement and turned it into her own work of art. And i don't too much care for Billies version or Diana's as well. Aretha is not just about her power that just comes natural. But her phrasing is very dominant.
Well i like Aretha's version a little bit better. I felt that her interpretation was more evoked a little more emotion. But if you like Billie's version by all means. I have no problem with that.
"Among a mainstream and white consumer public, Franklin was arguably the most popular black woman artist since Bessie Smith and Billie Holiday and was clearly more accessible to these audiences than Smith and Holiday. Like Smith and Holiday, Franklin infused public narratives of black and militancy, with nuanced demands for human respect and human decency".
yes i completely agree i was wrong you were right that's i told you maybe it' s my poor english anyway the fact is billie holiday sang hits at each time in a peculiar way so i did'nt recognize ir sang by aretha sorry
wow
CARIBNATURALS 1 week ago
Arethaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
4realpeepl 1 month ago
from one queen to another thankyou for the tribute so many different perspectives and so little time
MrFalconford 2 months ago
This is amazing.... wow. I love auntie ree ree
NoSuchThingAsTrinity 4 months ago
OMG!! That has to be the BEST version of that song that I have EVER heard! I just shit my pants listening to it! SUPERB!!!
LUckybones25 5 months ago 2
I wouldn't call Aretha the greatest singer ever, because I don't believe in the concept... we NEED Aretha in our lives, we're grateful to have her, but we also need Billie, Dinah, Nina, Ella, Mahalia, and many more... they're all literally irreplaceable.
773SleepyHollow 5 months ago 2
@773SleepyHollow Very well said!!
MrPistolMason 2 weeks ago
BEAUTIFUL
lecha2344 6 months ago 2
They both are amazing....Arteha this is wonderful! ;)
doaee1 6 months ago 2
I love that little instrumental bit at the beggining.
DWSimmy 7 months ago
A legend singing for a legend. I wonder what Billie would of thought of Aretha...
cjacja21 8 months ago 2
ARETHA...your voice makes me cry everytime I hear it...GOD bless you sister
amenic1894 8 months ago 2
Billie is such a timeless beauty. Simply flawless beauty.
Cimone09 8 months ago
The queen of soul.
oldman66able 8 months ago
amazing! i love both versions!
jungleVIP 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Estimated friend, if you want to listen again this song and an endless number of successes of the love I suggest you to visit Radio MUSICA PARA MIMOS - looks for his direction URL in Google ( search Musica para Mimos in Google)-. best romantic music of all the times in Internet, is great, is very good ...!!!
robertoamor2011 10 months ago
I can say this is the best version I HAV EVER HEARD!!! Thank you Lord for Starbucks MP3 PLAYLIST ;) #InMyIpod
datboywitdemvocals06 10 months ago
I Just love Aretha singing this song i have this on the queen in waiting album for you guys who want to buy it .i love Billys version as well .So no arguments there .Aretha is and always will be one of the true greats artists of our time .Thankyou for posting
iwillliftupmyeyes 11 months ago
NEVER heard this before. Got the goose bumps. I love that early stuff by Areatha.
And what an absolutely beautiful picture of Billy. Thanks for posting this rare one.
justplainpissed 11 months ago
@justplainpissed
AMEN!
I've NEVER heard this version either... I got chills, too
Getrealpeeps 9 months ago
@Getrealpeeps - little chills here too
dgswilson 8 months ago
I have loved Aretha since I was a kid in Flint Michigan. Way back in the late 60's. The Queen of Soul! Get better gal...we miss you!
bungalowmo 11 months ago
@whatigot2say - You should be ashamed of yourself for disrespecting Aretha Franklin like you did. Only ignorant and small people talk like that. You are a hater, and the person that you hate the most is yourself.
1437andialwayswill 11 months ago
LONG LIVE THE QUEEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
bubba198706 11 months ago
I think when we are talking about the Queen and the Lady,comparisons are pointless.Two incomparable artists who did what they did better than anybody else.
bluesborn 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
WELL WELL WELL
sobleton01 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Excellent piece of work!! Thank you very much for Sharing!!!!!
What a way of meeting people and get to see their talent. At first was reluctant being on youtube, but getting to do this has brought me into the houses of some very special people. You are one of them. Life; isn't it wonderful!!! Keep up the good work. Hope You Are Having A Splendid Day!!!!
A New Friend
Erick
erickdircks 1 year ago
The voice of Aretha with the face of Billie is speechless... i'm in love <3
FreddieWolf 1 year ago
Billie waz so beautiful...
mssusan1961 1 year ago
Pure Joy !
Tejano44 1 year ago
Maaaaaann!! Billie Holiday looks like my grandma back in the day....RIP Billie & Grandma "Honey" much love for Aretha, Grt Post!
Thekeeper1106 1 year ago
baltimore own billie holiday bless you
keith8462000 1 year ago
Lovely!
shanithurmon1 1 year ago
önskar Karl grattis och lycka till, where ever you are...
sharkolux 1 year ago
That voice! I love Aretha Franklin! If she hadn't signed with Atlantic and revolutionized R&B she would have been one of the best modern jazz singers, easily in the ranks of the great Dinah Washington.
pnyc1969 1 year ago
I just heard the version of Billy holiday, Aretha Franklin, Diana Ross and Whitney Houston. respect to the one who made, props to the one who sang it in the movie, thumb us to MIss franklin , but RESPECT to the one that OWNED with her voice MISS WHITNEY HOUSTON.
lindsay304 1 year ago
@lindsay304 The only one that OWNS this song is Billie Holiday.
TheQueenAretha 1 year ago
Na fotografii jest Billie Holiday, a śpiewa Aretha Franklin
jazzforrum 1 year ago
which one of Aretha'ss albums is this on??
meagalitious 1 year ago
@meagalitious I have this on/ A queen in waiting/ its a great double album with all her songs on .great buy .
iwillliftupmyeyes 11 months ago
Aretha best singer in the world
doveside1 1 year ago
Seems when you see a picture of Billie Holliday nearly stripped of her clothings, and sometimes you do, she's miserable. As far as singing... huh. You have to admire Aretha and others like Whitney Houston. But Billie, well, people underestimate the power of simplicity and honesty. But it wins in the end.
brelfan 1 year ago
This is Billie Holiday on the picture
mpi4 1 year ago 11
@mpi4 YES, of course!" Cause, the Greatest SINGER Ever" pays homage to "The Greatest LADY Ever". Aretha and Billie.
yaskam 1 year ago 14
@yaskam ,So true .
Tejano44 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@yaskam gretest singer ever?? hardly. this is loud and brash. but then so is everything else she sings. you mikste loud for good singing. it isn't . she doesn't respect the songs form or genre. she's going to turn it tinto a gospel song rrespective of its form. but at least her voice had clarity during this period. it sounds like shhit toda clarity is gone and it's gruffy. the price of smoking cigarettes is a destroyed voice. or maybe its all the fat around her throat.
whatigot2say 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@whatigot2say You don't know the first thing about Aretha if you think that! So say all you want but until you actually know what the hell you are talking about Shut the fuck up! And yes smoking did effect her voice but Aretha doesn't sound like shit she is still today the greatest singer around and i will repeat THE GREATEST.
TheQueenAretha 11 months ago
Aretha Franklin when she was a Jazz and Blues singer. Before Soul music dropped in the mid 60's Aretha wanted to be like her idol Jazz Diva, Dinah Washington.
Aretha never forgot her Jazz, Blues & Gospel roots [without them there would be no Soul] when she signed with Atlantic. She would always include a Jazz or Blues tune on every LP. Between 1960 and 65 Jazz was her style on Columbia. Aretha tore it up as a Jazz diva! Aretha is really the Queen of Rhythm n Blues & all its many styles!!
DJDJANGO1 1 year ago 8
My favorite version...
zankhe43 1 year ago
Aretha Franklin when she was a Jazz and Blues singer. Before Soul music dropped in the mid 60's Aretha wanted to be like her idol Jazz Diva, Dinah Washington.
Aretha never forgot her Jazz, Blues & Gospel roots [without them there would be no Soul] when she signed with Atlantic. She would always include a Jazz or Blues tune on every LP. Between 1960 and 65 Jazz was her style on Columbia. Aretha tore it up as a Jazz diva! Aretha is really the Queen of Rhythm n Blues & all its many styles!!
DJDJANGO1 1 year ago
@zankhe43 I also love Lou Rawl's version. This is what I call the theme song of my life. God bless the child that can stand up anywhere and say I've Got My Own.
oaklandonthecomeup 1 year ago
Comment removed
zankhe43 1 year ago
Aretha = extraordinary!
paz1969 1 year ago
That's not Aretha...
EretzLaAm 2 years ago
This is ARETHA, oh yesssss! The best singer in the musical history.
yaskam 2 years ago 7
"The Greatest SINGER Ever" pays homage to "The Greatest LADY Ever". Aretha to Billie.
Picture: BILLIE
Voice: ARETHA.
yaskam 2 years ago 2
It''s not her voice, or her accent.
EretzLaAm 2 years ago
@yaskam Great comment. I LOVE Bilie's version, but this is better, I think. Who knew?
BlakeBarbieDoll 1 year ago
OK OK OK :) This is Elvis PRESLEY!!!!!!!!!!!!
yaskam 1 year ago 12
. . . BEST version I've ever heard. ;-)
SexyProfess 2 years ago
God bless the child that's got his own...including, opinions!
nubianqueen04 2 years ago
beautiful.
ty
rosesredvioletsblue 2 years ago
The more things change, the more they stay the same. The beautiful words in this song says it all.
MrBlackman4ever 2 years ago
How true is this song, I'm finding this out for myself. Funny how when you're down on your luck that "your friends" are nowhere to be seen. As Billie wrote.... "empty pockets don't make the grade". I think this song is a lesson for all of us. Good luck to you all during this recession.
TheSlyStone 2 years ago
This is amazing!!!
civicplayer 2 years ago
I've heard Aretha sing Jazz standards before the Atlantic era and some of those she did better than the original artist, "Only The Lonely" originally by Frank Sinatra was transformed into a song with the elements of longing and regret...Aretha's interpretation of that song is unparalleled! This one she could have done without but oh well.
PrettyVillan 2 years ago
oh que oui!
viktordelaplace 2 years ago
straus your crazy or white..
TALBROZMAN 2 years ago
Well it shows that she is young here. She sang this song as if, she did not know it meaning. Her inflection and intonation is off. It was not appropriately intrepreted, I fear.
strausd02 2 years ago
You know, I wanted to disagree with you but couldn't. Her technique was great here but the emotion was not entirely shown.
Anyway, no one could beat Aretha in her prime EVER.
devilmirror1 2 years ago 3
I am neither....You know as well as I do, that this song is not Aretha. This lady really knows how to sing, but here she misses the true meaning of this song. She needs to bring it down a bit. Show the emotion that this song conveys...
strausd02 2 years ago
That is your opinion but to be she is an amazing job and didn't bring anything down.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
Who are you to say that this song is not Aretha. Aretha has lived a life of hardships and pain throughout her whole life. This is Aretha interpretation not Bille's or Diana's. And whether or not you like it or not has nothing to do with her great version. Her passion and her feeling is there. It has always been there and has never left Aretha. Diana i can't say that because Diana hasn't been through half of what Aretha's through and has never given me anything that brings you that feeling.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
Diana grew up poorer than Aretha in fact. Aretha's father was a celeb preacher with money. AF parents were divorced and she was preg 2x by 16 yrs. Diana's mother was quarrantined for TB when she was a girl. Her brother was beaten and jailed by racist cops in the south. Her brother was murdered and many other things. Aretha has had very hard times; Diana too. There is no measuring of people's pain. Ross and Retha sing with passion. Ross in pop and Ree in soul. Let's respect both talented ladies.
missbirdsong 2 years ago 30
You are right Aretha grew up in a quite wealthy home where as Diana, who lived just a block away live in poverty in the project of Detroit.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
My point was that Aretha is able to express her feelings better.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
@missbirdsong ,100 % Correct !
Tejano44 1 year ago
Nothing is off but your understanding. This is her interpretation. Her inflections and intonation are perfectly suited for her arrangement.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
I think this is a bit loud. It takes some of the feeling out of the song. Yes, Aretha can sing, but I don't think this is her song. Her register seems a bit high. Oh well, to each his own. However, I think Diana does a better job. Aretha's version doesn't convey the sadness that is in this song.
strausd02 2 years ago
Diana fan here. Damn, Miss Areatha sang the hell out of this song.
swso2000 2 years ago
Ree, sounds sensational.
SoulSir 2 years ago
fom billie to aretha to jennifer hudson---marvelous---she should play aretha if they make a movie---i think ms. franklin would approve
EMCEMITCH 2 years ago
Just Listen to this lady's voice. She is so bad!!! There is no one who can float a note out of their mouth like Queen Aretha Franklin. Queen of Soul you are and forever will be the best!!!
ceekher 2 years ago
You call this floating a note....I call it a note out of control. She might be the Queen of Soul, however, she is no Queen of Jazz. As far as I am concerned she completely misses the mark. I love most of her work, but on this one, she shows her lack of maturity....."Living and loving, in the world of hard knocks...Sometimes, if you haven't lived it or experienced it, you cannot convey it.
strausd02 2 years ago
Out of control! Get yourself together. Before Aretha was a major star she was singing jazz and has tons of amazing interpretation from this time. She hasn't missed anything. She did an amazing version. This is Aretha and whether you like it or not this is her interpretation and Ross by no mean is the interpreter Aretha is. If anyone know what living a hard life, it's Aretha. At this time in her career she possessed the same feeling she does now.She's lived throught trouble and heartaches.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
Hey TheQueenAretha, why don't you compare Aretha's version with the original's..Lady Day? Personally, I think Diana's version or interpretation is more closely related to Billie's version. Again, I think Aretha's version is sang in too higher of a register. Everything does not have to be screamed, to convey its effect.
Strausd2 2 years ago
Because you are comparing Diana's version to Aretha. Aretha isn't trying to copy Billie. She is doing her own interpretation. If you knew anything about Aretha or her as interpreter, you would know that Aretha isn't about high note, she is about getting her point across. Aretha is not a screamer, she is a singer. She is soaked with passion and feeling. So don't come on here trying to tell an Aretha fan anything about conveying and effect because Aretha could right a book about it.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
The reason I said to compare Aretha's interpretation to the Original...Lady Day, you will see that she does not sing in a very high register. It is rather smooth and mellow...Personally, I think that Aretha's version is just too high...Well the Queen of Soul, isn't the Queen of Jazz. It is my opinion, that she does not convey the true meaning of the song. It isn't about screaming...
Strausd2 2 years ago
That is your opinion, I am not on here saying that Aretha's version is better than Billie, but i am not going to say that it is too high. Aretha has sung jazz, broadway, gospel,. blue, pop, you name it. She is able to cross genres. You are failing to get that. This is Aretha's interpretation, not Billies. Also if you knew anything about Aretha you would know that Aretha purpose when doing a cover is to convey her the meaning. Aretha doesn't scream, she sings.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
damn stausd your a real hater. i bet your a fat slob in a wheel chair on Youtube all day criticizing people.
ahkielove 2 years ago
Damn Ahkielove, so you consider a person that gives his or her opinion a hater..interesting. In addition, if that isn't good enough, you try to personally attack someone you have never seen. What does that say about you? I am glad I live in America, where one can express his or her opinion without fear. That is called Freedom of Speech. Personally I don't hate anyone, especially someone I have never met. However, I stand by my opinion of Aretha's interpretation of this song.
Strausd2 2 years ago 2
Oh by the way Ahkielove, I am 5'10", 175 lbs. I have a 32" waist 44" chest and a muscular tight physique. Unlike Aretha and perhaps you. I've tried to keep myself fit. So thinking about what you said about my physical appearance man/woman, You sound like the hater. I truly think Aretha sang that song too loudly, and it lack the feelings of someone who had experienced life. Whether you agree with what I have said, that is up to you. It is my opinion.
Strausd2 2 years ago
damn she wails
raymondi1234567890 2 years ago
Love it love it love it!
venus3003 2 years ago
Beautiful, beautiful song!! Nobody can do it like Aretha. ;-)
God bless the child that's got his/her own...
SexyProfess 2 years ago 2
except billie....
luke2thab 2 years ago
Thanks for posting this song! Damn, this is a beautiful song
pjlove76 2 years ago
never heard this before...im confused now. hey ill just like the both of them.
davidt1066 2 years ago 2
I love this, thanks for posting
oneloveatatime 2 years ago
excellently described!
This is why I love Aretha so much too! Ofcourse, i adore her gospel inflections, but for me, it was always her sense of melody and line that was fantastic. The way she changed the line and still made it fit with the music. Even the first word "THEM that's got", is just placed perfectly. Although it's a bit off topic, this is why i love Whitney Houston too - she is very good at phrasing :)
bonjour100 2 years ago
a1d2h:
I prefer Aretha Franklin's arrangement. A Billie Holiday diehard wanted to kick my ass for saying so, but we were at work. The song of Billie's that no one can ever reporduce well, in my opinion, is "Fine and Mellow", accompanied by Lester Young. D. Washington's best is "Baby Get Lost", and the hilarious, naughty "Long John." Have you heard either?
acotw67 2 years ago
a1d2h:
Brilliant analysis. Very few singers have such exquisite phrasing matched by a voice of power, depth and passion. (Maria Calas did, but that's a different genre) When I became a jazz fan at 8, I was so awestruck by her voice & her gifts as a pianist that I began to prefer her earliest work, such as Trouble in Mind, Running Out of Fools, Muddy Water, Blue Holliday,and this one. Etta James' tribute to Holiday is great-but raw. The modern R & B singers overindulge in melisma, not Aretha.
acotw67 2 years ago
I also loved what Aretha did with Billie's Crazy He Calls Me. From her Soul 69 album.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
TheQueenAretha:
I actually have not heard that one. Thank you very much for the suggestion. Several things just occurred to me. There is a difference between a cover and a new arrangement; the terms are NOT interchangeable but does everyone know or care? Jazz and blues classics become so when they are well-composed. After the song is validated by time, the challenge is for the singer. Aretha Franklin, like Sinatra, ALWAYS rose to the occassion. Her jazz arrangement of "Trouble in Mind" SWINGS!
acotw67 2 years ago
You would love it. Like i said before it is from her Soul 69 which is a album of covers. With Aretha singing mostly jazz tunes. Like Gentle On My MInd, Crazy He Calls Me, I'll Never Be Free, and many others.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
@TheQueenAretha I agree! Her version of "Crazy He Calls Me" is one of the best things that she has ever recorded. She takes you there. Only a true fan would cite that recording. Simply phenomenal!!
lewistevena 1 year ago
@lewistevena Well thank you!
TheQueenAretha 1 year ago
This song is almost unrecognisable. Aretha can sing, we all know that. But this is OVER-sung. Billie, diana, etc were very understated in their approach and works much better. In this version the focus is more on the voice and not on the powerful and haunting lyrics of the songs.
MercedesSantiaga 2 years ago
This is not over sung. Aretha took the sung and made it hers. She changed the arrangement and turned it into her own work of art. And i don't too much care for Billies version or Diana's as well. Aretha is not just about her power that just comes natural. But her phrasing is very dominant.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
Billies version is Portland sea level,all the rest are just transfered levels,up and down,but never improved on.
GILLYRUTH 2 years ago
Well i like Aretha's version a little bit better. I felt that her interpretation was more evoked a little more emotion. But if you like Billie's version by all means. I have no problem with that.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago 2
Yes your spot on.For a sympathetic cover,try and catch Sam Cooke s version.
GILLYRUTH 2 years ago
acotw67:
Right!
"Among a mainstream and white consumer public, Franklin was arguably the most popular black woman artist since Bessie Smith and Billie Holiday and was clearly more accessible to these audiences than Smith and Holiday. Like Smith and Holiday, Franklin infused public narratives of black and militancy, with nuanced demands for human respect and human decency".
Marc Anthony NEAL, What Music said..., (1998).
yaskam 2 years ago
yes i completely agree i was wrong you were right that's i told you maybe it' s my poor english anyway the fact is billie holiday sang hits at each time in a peculiar way so i did'nt recognize ir sang by aretha sorry
dirtyfrenchie 2 years ago
it's not god bless the child i think and there are stinky back violins but she's great of couse
dirtyfrenchie 2 years ago
No he was right . The name of the song is god bless the child.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
it is definitely nobody's perfect!
dirtyfrenchie 2 years ago
No it's not the name of the song is GOD BLESS THE CHILD. That is a fact. Look it up it was written by Billie Holiday.
TheQueenAretha 2 years ago
She is singing by heart and by soul! It takes my breath away!
mormi27 2 years ago
Perfection!!! God bless Aretha and her amazing voice!!!
Cissyskin 3 years ago 2
this is amazing!!!
pirategrl87 3 years ago
Baby you can sing it..
Peace.
wahnano 3 years ago
Wow Perfection............A Pop Idol Detox !!!!
TheAremo 3 years ago 2
shes showing out lol
bemaniac2 3 years ago
This is a amazing cover, and Aretha always showed that She was the queen of soul.
TheQueenAretha 3 years ago
Her rendition is very bluesy mixed with alot of Gospel.
Darneloh 3 years ago 2