@TodayFreedom lol you don't even need to go to a police station to get a person's IP adress. There are plenty of websites that will not only give you the person's ip adress but also any other personal information that is available (adress, telephone number, dob and workplace to name a few)
@Timebubbles I guess I'd find your racism annoying but for the fact that you're actually from exactly the same background as I am (most Brits are 1/3 Celt) and for the fact that we run the world's most powerful nation - the US of A, my dear. As for "bog trotters" - when my ancestors were writing Brehon Law and creating the Book of Kells yours were living in mudhuts and swinging from the trees. Look at your comment - you can't even write your own language!! Know what a plural is?? Ignoramus.
@Timebubbles Maybe bother to read more before making silly comments - where do you think "English" clog dancing has its origins? Where do you think tap dance has its origins? All north American folk dance of the "tap" variety is a combination of black African and Irish folk dancing. "English" clog dancing, like "English" folk music is neither English nor original. But thanks for the innacurate condescension.
Cheers Pashken thanks for the info mate much appreciated ,a very talented man indeed,it also reaffirms my initial impression of him as being a man of good intention and nature, from watching Zatoichi" just a chance encounter with SBS tv the other night ,we wondered why we never knew of it before.
It is just no wonder that Mr. KITANO is that good at tap dancing if you take a time to read his biography. As a youth, he was working as an "elevator operator" at a vaudeville and he took a great courage, one day, to talk to a veteran comedian to ask to become his apprentice. The comedian glanced at KITANO and asked if he could do any performance like tap dance, demonstrating it wonderfully before exiting the elevator. This is said to be when KITANO decided to pick it up.
"Beat" Takeshi Kitano is the best. In ZATOICHI he had blond hair. In HANA-BI he was the policeman Nishi and he was the brutal teacher in BATTLE ROYALE and the yakuza killer Yamamoto in Brother. I also know him from TAKESHI`S CASTLE! This man is a genius!
While Fred Astaire was a great performer, African American dancer John Bubbles of the dance pair "Buck and Bubbles" was the father of modern tap. He was the first to add heel taps on the off-beat in addition to taps performed using the toes.
Takeshi Kitanos many interests skills and talents shows us what human genius can achieve if there is a will and dedication to do it right! Love him, great role model for us all!
Pretty hefty praise throughout this thread. . . The tap dancing is just fine. He's no professional dancer or anything, but it is pretty impressive that someone develops a skill late-in-life.
Doesn't really sound good. He is a brilliant film maker and actor, but this sounds like popcorn. To be fair, it was just a bit off, but still off. I was trying to love this, but could not follow the story.
Did the Japanese already danced tapdance during the Edo period as in Takeshi Kitano's Zatoichi or did he made his last scene with it because he likes this dance ?
Actor, writer, director, producer, artist, musician, comedian, and now tap dancer. Damn you Beat Takeshi, you have too many talents. Give me one of those talents and I'll be happy. Not a great dancer but not bad considering he's supposed to be paralyzed on one side of his body.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
hes OK, but he wouldnt last a minnie in the world of street tap. tap's evolved a lot since the 60s. we're doing flips now, incorporating movements from breakdance, jazz, and crumpin, incorporating yo mama jokes, wearing ridickulous jewels on our fingers.
Este cabron es el mejor, todo un estuche de monerias... pinche takeshi, de buen comediante a buen actor y de ahi a buen director y despues diseñador de videojuegos y ahora bailarin... genial. Mucho exito
Ma cazzo, possibile che quest'uomo sappia fare di tutto?? Cioè, è uno dei più grandi registi attualmente in circolazione, un comico eccezionale, un disegnatore da non sottovalutare, un poeta, il geniale ideatore del folle Takeshi's Castle, suonatore di piano, e ora...pure un esimio ballerino di Tip Tap??
Davvero, non ho parole...anzi, una parola in realtà ce l'avrei:
@easterncinema So far, I've read his books, watched his films, viewed his TV programs, loved his film performances, listened to his music, witnessed his comedy, and marveled as his paintings. So, no.
Ahh Beat Takeshi and his tapdancing... Reminds me of Zatoichi with the completely absurd shots of tapdancing farmers - and then the tap-dance finale. Still, the man's a genius.
若干走り気味です
mastergroove666 3 weeks ago
入場から、最後の表情まで
絵になるな この人は・・・
YOHUKASHIOOKAMI 1 month ago
かくし芸だっけ
hiroaki08315 1 month ago
この歳でこの動きを続けることがすごすぎる!
takuthin0827 1 month ago
Beat Takeshi is GOD
Rossea666 1 month ago
This is me, giving a fuck.
Snaggbash2000 1 month ago
This man is better than Chuck Norris.
Agroulinggrwaler1999 1 month ago 9
多忙な時間の中で練習するのって相当体力使うんだろうな。そう考えるとすごいなー。いつか自分もタップをしてみたい。
michitaka03 1 month ago
Takeshi is the Best!!!Superrrrrrrrrr!!!Bravooooooooo!!!!!!!!
OlegBaksheev 2 months ago
うちもタップやってるけど、
そんなにうまくないな
1208juri 2 months ago
外国からのコメントの多さに驚いた やっぱ すごい コノ人
Doburoku55 2 months ago
@Timebubbles Beautifully said
s4262248 3 months ago
Comment removed
TodayFreedom 4 months ago
@TodayFreedom lol you don't even need to go to a police station to get a person's IP adress. There are plenty of websites that will not only give you the person's ip adress but also any other personal information that is available (adress, telephone number, dob and workplace to name a few)
OokamiG 2 months ago
@Timebubbles I guess I'd find your racism annoying but for the fact that you're actually from exactly the same background as I am (most Brits are 1/3 Celt) and for the fact that we run the world's most powerful nation - the US of A, my dear. As for "bog trotters" - when my ancestors were writing Brehon Law and creating the Book of Kells yours were living in mudhuts and swinging from the trees. Look at your comment - you can't even write your own language!! Know what a plural is?? Ignoramus.
TodayFreedom 4 months ago
@Timebubbles Maybe bother to read more before making silly comments - where do you think "English" clog dancing has its origins? Where do you think tap dance has its origins? All north American folk dance of the "tap" variety is a combination of black African and Irish folk dancing. "English" clog dancing, like "English" folk music is neither English nor original. But thanks for the innacurate condescension.
TodayFreedom 4 months ago
siempre y toda la vida seras mi mejor artista beat.
pataderana 4 months ago
かっこいいな
sekiyuo 4 months ago
So weird to think this whole craze started in Ireland and now folk tap dance is found from New York to Alabama to London to Tokyo!
TodayFreedom 4 months ago
Great Kitano!!!!!!
matefrio 5 months ago
カッコいい
kanta3737 5 months ago
просто красавец))!!
Pashken11 6 months ago
Cheers Pashken thanks for the info mate much appreciated ,a very talented man indeed,it also reaffirms my initial impression of him as being a man of good intention and nature, from watching Zatoichi" just a chance encounter with SBS tv the other night ,we wondered why we never knew of it before.
currawongee1 5 months ago
It is just no wonder that Mr. KITANO is that good at tap dancing if you take a time to read his biography. As a youth, he was working as an "elevator operator" at a vaudeville and he took a great courage, one day, to talk to a veteran comedian to ask to become his apprentice. The comedian glanced at KITANO and asked if he could do any performance like tap dance, demonstrating it wonderfully before exiting the elevator. This is said to be when KITANO decided to pick it up.
yokomitz 7 months ago
たけしは今でもヒマを見てはやってるらしいね
だからタップダンス暦はふつうに30年くらい?
だからそのへんのヒヤカシとはわけが違う
ybkj 7 months ago
Rushing the beat just a tad but for not being a professional, very very very well done.
ganixaba 8 months ago
@UnyieldingDefiance No.
batatshi 8 months ago
Is there anything this man can't do?
UnyieldingDefiance 8 months ago 31
@UnyieldingDefiance Yes, he cannot be Justib bieber
HaideryJatt 4 months ago 3
@UnyieldingDefiance I second that.
NekoArts 2 months ago
@UnyieldingDefiance the only thing that takeshi cannot do is stop being famous
he is too awesome
iblisrapper 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@UnyieldingDefiance Asian Chuck Norris
dondopa 1 month ago
@MssBecca Didnt expect this from him.
hopala007 8 months ago
Zatoichi, the blind swordsman???
hopala007 9 months ago
good ! but, his rhythm is not a tap dance but Irish dance.
bingoclub54 9 months ago
this is utterly charming! I feel charmed!! :)
LornaInRed 9 months ago
A fockin genius...
Feydrautha33 9 months ago
This man was in Zatoichi. He's awesome.
ShonPhoenix 9 months ago
While Astaire was certainly an excellent performer, African-American dancer John Bubbles was the father of modern tap dance.
ORVIENTO 9 months ago
Takeshi Kitano... He could find himself in any profession.
batatshi 10 months ago 2
"Beat" Takeshi Kitano is the best. In ZATOICHI he had blond hair. In HANA-BI he was the policeman Nishi and he was the brutal teacher in BATTLE ROYALE and the yakuza killer Yamamoto in Brother. I also know him from TAKESHI`S CASTLE! This man is a genius!
mc77ification 10 months ago
@mc77ification Don't forget the fact that he's a magnificent director
anhpho 10 months ago 13
Fantastican umetnik! :-)
bboymcKick 10 months ago
Wow, is there anything he can't do?
Staudinka 10 months ago 2
Takeshi Kitano is a true artist.
DimebagVision 10 months ago
I LOVE this man! Beat Takeshi is truly one of my heroes and always will be! Lottsa of respect from a fan!
bizchazlien 10 months ago
Now that's entertainment!
felixlinquist 11 months ago
Fred Astaire was a father of Tap dance, Gene Kelly made tap dance famous, Kitano Takeshi is a masterpiece of tap dance.
ParkJongBum 11 months ago
While Fred Astaire was a great performer, African American dancer John Bubbles of the dance pair "Buck and Bubbles" was the father of modern tap. He was the first to add heel taps on the off-beat in addition to taps performed using the toes.
ORVIENTO 9 months ago 2
Takeshi Kitanos many interests skills and talents shows us what human genius can achieve if there is a will and dedication to do it right! Love him, great role model for us all!
pascoett 11 months ago
kitano thanks for your beautiful work.
rigelmarzio 11 months ago
omfg!!!
44mushroom44 11 months ago
Pretty hefty praise throughout this thread. . . The tap dancing is just fine. He's no professional dancer or anything, but it is pretty impressive that someone develops a skill late-in-life.
chipperprime 1 year ago
@chipperprime I gotta agree, he's no picasso at tapdance, but he isn't bad either. Good for him.
CowboyGhostie 11 months ago
è proprio il mejio
Stazzo82 1 year ago
Q: Surreal? A: Yes!
To say this man is multi-faceted would be putting it mildly: He's uncomparable.
RedBryn 1 year ago
he must be illuminati... hahahahaha
gleninnes01 1 year ago
The music is from an italian song "Pregherò" by Celentano
youtube.com/watch?v=neid3-6gHCE
Kazanian2 1 year ago
@Kazanian2 The music is from "Stand by me". "Pregherò" is the italian version of that song.
89maxx 11 months ago
takeshi is god!!! xDDDDDD
nemp5 1 year ago
And the music is Canon D? Pachelbel?
~
Kitano! You're the one man! :)
Greetings and love from Turkey! :)
rslylmz 1 year ago 2
GOD, IS MY GOD (L)
MotelCactus 1 year ago
タップはHideboに弟子入りして、少しモダンで高度な事をやろうとしてるから少し無理があるかもね
でも浅草時代に身に付けた殺陣とジャグリングは本当に凄い。
特に殺陣師が「早くて近い」ともろ手を挙げて絶賛してた
kimurajirou 1 year ago
この人のすごいところは
もちろん才能もあるけど
何よりもそれを表に出さない謙虚さだと思う
まさに日本人の象徴と言うべき存在
kotaabc 1 year ago
@kotaabc なんという謙虚さのカケラもない文章ww
fwmalto1 1 year ago
BEAT!! I never knew you so talented in so many things!
rivercityhobo 1 year ago
God bless Takeshi Kitano, I love him, he is a maestro.
Rebel2814 1 year ago
Valholm is right. I love Takeshi's films and acting but his rhythmic timing on this is just awful.
tcoffeen 1 year ago
Doesn't really sound good. He is a brilliant film maker and actor, but this sounds like popcorn. To be fair, it was just a bit off, but still off. I was trying to love this, but could not follow the story.
Valholm 1 year ago
@Valholm if this wasn't Kitano I would turn it off in 30 sec and say "whatever".
Valholm 1 year ago
i can do that...
no, not really
Salvac88 1 year ago
his very old man now. well, not so in this vid but in recent interviews.
ptlofts 1 year ago
Takeshi Kitano: almost chuck norris
Salvac88 1 year ago
あれほど忙しい中で、練習時間を作り、この年齢で、ここまで踊れるのは驚愕に値する。
soutarou7227 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
本人真剣にやってるみたいだけど、タヌキが踊ってるみたい、みっともない・・・
ceg86647 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
確かにあまり評価できない。ガチャガチャうるさいだけ!!
ceg86647 1 year ago
Stand by me!
XxKID1xX 1 year ago
そうなんです。。こん人は芸人とは・・エンターテイナーとは・・・って昔から意識してる気がする
Tokoro2ten 1 year ago
wat a man
proudnorrie 1 year ago
It's song of Adriano Celentano :) It was nice! I like him
slavsh 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
芸人なんだから、これ位たいしたことない。
それ言ったら今の「こんなことすらできない」事務所の力だけで番組に出れてる芸人なんて
芸人失格ですね。ちなみにたけしはタップのほかにジャグリングも一流ですよ。
roman7484 1 year ago
Comment removed
3musician 1 year ago
Pura vida!!!!
cotoocho 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
芸人なんだから、これ位たいしたことない。
Viggobrun 1 year ago
@Viggobrun i agree........ i hope :-)))))
proudnorrie 1 year ago
I was wondering if he could actually tap dance, since it's featured in his films Kikujiro and Takeshis'
AnarchoRich 1 year ago
@AnarchoRich Oh, and I forgot the tap dancing scene in Zatoichi...
AnarchoRich 1 year ago
Kitano is great!!
pablohanc 1 year ago
@nenecoco789 確かにバックの音楽とはズレてるところありますけど、北野武のこのタップは、小堺一機のやるタップとは時代が違って、高度なタップをこなしていると思いますよ。十二分に「かくし芸」。
Ringsjp 1 year ago 3
「俺、芸人なのに芸がないから」って急にタップダンス始めて、軍団のメンバーが凍りついたらしいですね。
trkykul547 1 year ago 4
タップのスイング感はオーケストラと合わない…
tahla001 1 year ago 3
not beat takeshi,its offbeat takeshi^^.....but hes a genius in other things
Benjahmmin 1 year ago
Kitano-san, quit beat-ing around the bush and just take over the world already
kblargh 1 year ago 3
i was just listening to stand by me.... this is blowing my mind
bce5150 1 year ago
4連すごい!!
Ringsjp 1 year ago 3
There's no end to Beat's talent.
PresidentRich 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
リズム感ないね。
suckyourtube 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@suckyourtube たけしさんを否定する気はないですけど確かにそんなに絶賛されるほどではないですよね・・・。
たけし=すごい 大物=すごい とメディアは言うけど「これに関しては大した事ないですね」と正直に言える国になって欲しいですね。
nenecoco789 1 year ago
>Yofure0033
No, nobody brought tap dance into Japan during the Edo period...
it might be brought here around 1931.
He put tap dance scene in the ending firstly firstly because he wanted to have an unconventional Samurai movie ending.
He chose tap dance as the one because he had learned tap dance for a long time and was familiar with it...
I also want to add more infor about the film relating to tap dance.
he edited this film with the rhythm of tap dancing.
sho0809 1 year ago
@sho0809
Alright ! Thank you for these informations ! :)
Yofure0033 1 year ago
Awesome !
Did the Japanese already danced tapdance during the Edo period as in Takeshi Kitano's Zatoichi or did he made his last scene with it because he likes this dance ?
Thank you !
Yofure0033 1 year ago
I believe he was 60 when he did this two years ago, well done Takeshi!
InformationMinister 1 year ago
殿・・カッコイイ・・
lefaism 1 year ago
まぁあんま必要のないコラボ
wave0730 1 year ago 3
why?
ferhound 1 year ago
c'est magnifique
onizakira 1 year ago
oh dear... that is soooooooo awesome
slyintennis 1 year ago
武士!!日本の誇り!
casinoparatodos 1 year ago
ただ芸は芸でも人に見せられるような芸を持ってるなと感心しました
mocciye 1 year ago 4
凄いなあ。何でも出来るねこの人。
kazujp 1 year ago 3
Actor, writer, director, producer, artist, musician, comedian, and now tap dancer. Damn you Beat Takeshi, you have too many talents. Give me one of those talents and I'll be happy. Not a great dancer but not bad considering he's supposed to be paralyzed on one side of his body.
Devilock79 1 year ago
本当に昔横山やすしさんに洋七と二人おいてきぼりにされて東京まで歩いてかえる道すがらつぶやいた「金で買えるものなら芸を買いたい」という言葉が胸につきささる。厳しいねえ、芸の世界っていうのは。
この位置にきても修行なんだね。
roman7484 1 year ago 18
wait, nobody knows "stand by me"? com'on it's one of the most famous songs in the world.
millefolie 1 year ago
@millefolie not that i dont know, but yes, its just i forgot and didnt realize that i already had john lennon's version in my pc
renzyrenzyrenzy 1 year ago
He's too talented. There's just nothing he can't do.
JDMdrft6 1 year ago 3
i like him!
its Kikujiro's son!
btw, i like the song that plays with him in this video, the BGM.
is there any of this video without the kitano's tap dance?
renzyrenzyrenzy 1 year ago
or maybe anyone know what the song called?
renzyrenzyrenzy 1 year ago
@renzyrenzyrenzy That song was an orchestral version of Stand by Me.
Zekkron 1 year ago
Cet homme est tres fort!!!!
beatpault 1 year ago
自分の息子みたいな若い奴に教えてもらってるんだよな。へんなプライドがないんだろうね。
他にジャグリングもプロ級。万物創世記で牧瀬里穂の前でやって驚かせていた。
roman7484 1 year ago 12
This has been flagged as spam show
Do you know that he also has a deep understanding in mathematics?
What a man!
Tiptrie 1 year ago
Comment removed
Tiptrie 1 year ago
Takeshi Kitano=Beat Takeshi is the most famous Talented Hero in Japan.
jobsjp2008 1 year ago 3
He is simply talented...
tate136 1 year ago 2
He's a painter, pianist, director, screen-writer, actor, published author, comedian AND a tap dancer! This man is the fucking renaissance!
vicepresidentfru1tly 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hes OK, but he wouldnt last a minnie in the world of street tap. tap's evolved a lot since the 60s. we're doing flips now, incorporating movements from breakdance, jazz, and crumpin, incorporating yo mama jokes, wearing ridickulous jewels on our fingers.
adamndirtyshame 2 years ago
Takeshi san, Ichi bahn!
BerlinBunker1 2 years ago
This man is a legend
AequitasVeritas92 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
Takeshi is great! love this guy!
MrUmbra1 2 years ago
This just completely blew me away....this made my day. You're the best Takeshi!!!
Bobsagetlives 2 years ago
Sorry to be negative, but to think they give awards to no accounts like Sean Penn with THIS guy in the world?
yaknbo 2 years ago
Favorited....made my day.
OshidaYaguchi 2 years ago
Takashi really is great, espcially on Takashi's Castle, he's hilarious.
Headbanger142 2 years ago 5
a true renaissance man
mradamcooley 2 years ago 6
Este cabron es el mejor, todo un estuche de monerias... pinche takeshi, de buen comediante a buen actor y de ahi a buen director y despues diseñador de videojuegos y ahora bailarin... genial. Mucho exito
sygmundsucre 2 years ago
takeshi astaire!!! hahaha!!!! love this guy...
aljoscja 2 years ago
Takeshi Kitano is a bad ass, and no this is not sarcasim. I truly mean that, His movies are kewl and Zatoichi was great!
Googopqp 2 years ago 2
Ma cazzo, possibile che quest'uomo sappia fare di tutto?? Cioè, è uno dei più grandi registi attualmente in circolazione, un comico eccezionale, un disegnatore da non sottovalutare, un poeta, il geniale ideatore del folle Takeshi's Castle, suonatore di piano, e ora...pure un esimio ballerino di Tip Tap??
Davvero, non ho parole...anzi, una parola in realtà ce l'avrei:
M-I-T-O!
VulgarHurricane 2 years ago
かなりかっこいいです!
音のズレと書いているので覚悟しましたが全然ズレてないです!かっこいいです!
ホントに多才な方でビックリします
chocomint15436 2 years ago
多趣味な方ですね。
大好きです!
haaaaaaaaaa079 2 years ago
kitano you are the best!! i love your movies!! one of my favorite director and actor
Spartan290288 2 years ago 2
Ahhh... ahhh... grande Kitano!!
calpont 2 years ago
Everytime i see Battle Royale or Kitano and see this, I laugh cause Beat seems too tough to do this haha
supatoker420 2 years ago
Is there anything on this earth this man cannot do? Kitano is genius.
easterncinema 2 years ago 77
@easterncinema teach Madonna to act?
IrateJazzBadger 1 year ago 3
@easterncinema So far, I've read his books, watched his films, viewed his TV programs, loved his film performances, listened to his music, witnessed his comedy, and marveled as his paintings. So, no.
dainumo 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what is this? japanese dancing with the stars? If not it's just embarrassing
ericdxx 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
リズム感が.........
nabe3kanagawa 2 years ago
супер такеши молодец
semrichards 2 years ago
Maybe hes a little too old for this... He lost the tempo so many times... Although I couldn't even think of doing that xD
leonlares 2 years ago
Takeshi the great, well done man!!
popbadajoz 2 years ago
Grande Vito Takeshi!!!
soteccomnsite1 2 years ago
!!! Is somethin' that Kitano can't do? He's so great man!
27rav 2 years ago 8
No
Definitly not
drugeye 2 years ago
stand by me + tapdance
norhafizi 2 years ago
!!
That man is a genious!
Songoku93 2 years ago 20
Ahh Beat Takeshi and his tapdancing... Reminds me of Zatoichi with the completely absurd shots of tapdancing farmers - and then the tap-dance finale. Still, the man's a genius.
WithinTimeandSpace 2 years ago 7
OMG. ITS A TAP DANCE.
PLUS MY FAVORITE SONG IS PLAYING IN THE BACKGROUND.
i remember once my friend said they could tapdance.. i totally fell for it too.. grrr! not nice! they also said they could play guitar... psh. =]
sweetcherry202 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He hasn't got sense of rhythm at all !! '_'
elle3elle 2 years ago
i can see that in the way a person walks lol its all good thou he's a crazy good actor!
mantagrae 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I agree! He looses the beat 100 times in this video!!! I dont understand what impresses you people so much!
RamonElRockero 2 years ago
WOO!!!
patrickjgourley 2 years ago 2
I am spanish and only can say: Awesome
uriol21 2 years ago 2
Awesome!
KIQIU 2 years ago 3
Takeshi Kitano is the best man in the world.
asterexcel 2 years ago 7
My god...
Kitano the best.
leny14 2 years ago 4
kitano capo
rigobertigo 2 years ago
芸が好きなんだなぁ
根っからの芸人だよな
すごい!
hiyoblog 2 years ago 8
Who knew?
vladimir998 2 years ago
WOW! i've never thought Takeshi Kitano can do such an amazing thing
ragevou 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
rin9203 2 years ago
increible!!! bravo!!!! Es incrible el talento que tiene!!!!!
Muchas gracias por subirlo aqui!!!
Neaya91 2 years ago 4
¡¡¡genial!!!
cosasdebara 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
not good match music and tapping.
hiptrip99 3 years ago
Excelente en todo! un placer verlo siempre (Excellent. It´s a pleasure to see him always)
porsiemprescarlett 3 years ago 3
Really beautiful. I liked it.
MinaICCS 3 years ago 3
god he's so talented
fifithebunni 3 years ago 4
本物の芸人ですね
最近は芸の無い芸人が多い
waspnest45 3 years ago 26
Takeshi Kitano vit sa vie. On ferait bien de l'imiter.
hoteltassel 3 years ago