Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (107)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • really good such a haunting song when it comes down to it, do you guys have a band ?

  • @1cardigans sure do - man bites dog - acoustic-duo.co.uk

  • the three people who clicked dislike have no taste in music... amazing cover:) I hope i become as good as you guys.

  • @emmaw123999 cheers matey, we aren't so good, just spend ages on our arrangement

  • love this , great version

  • Top fuckin draw fellas. Love it. The dining chairs are nice as well. How about some more Roses up there? ANother good one for you would be Chasin Rainbows by Shed Seven. NNNNNNNNNNice OOOOOnnnneee

  • @redi2032 great taste in music you have, shed 7 amazing band, so underrated

  • amazing i love that :)

  • yeah would be well good to to do the end dance solo bit lol really good cover loved it!

  • A pretty nice cover,well done guys,nice voice

  • It's a pretty nice cover,well done guys

  • erm no.. James Blunt indeed...

  • James blunt vocals ?

  • would be funny if you done the really long rocking bit at the end still really good

  • really enjoyed listening

  • Very good indeed. I'm certain that there is a film somewhere that is crying out for this cover as part of it's soundtrack, it definitely has a big screen feel about it.

  • Why do people do things like this to perfect songs?

  • Good grief, this is something else!

  • here no a bad version boi`s like it,man !!!

  • Keep it up troops.

    Lovely wee version man.

    Pity the sounds mucked up

  • Quite Simon and Garfunkel - love it.

  • Nice version of a great song youv made it your own

  • Great cover... I was wondering how you guys would cover such a huge song acoustically but great job.

  • awesome cover guys like your version !

  • good job, very tame from the original but thats not a bad thing

  • beautiful

  • excellent version of a quality tune, nice one, im gonna go learn this now

  • guys, your cover is absolutely outstanding, with a friend we just uploaded a slow version of this song also but with only one guitar, would love it if you had a look. Your version is really extraordinary

  • Just seen your version and it's really nice guys. Well done. Watch out we will be putting a few more vids up soon of new songs

  • ive met ian a few times comeing from manchester next time i see him ill tell him to watch this wicked mate

  • Why thanks deanpeterclarke that would be really good. We totally love the Roses - as big a part in the history of music as the Beatles and Stones, in our humble opinions

  • i think ian brown would approve.

    nice job

  • good job lads, a real original track to do as an acoustic......really good!

  • thanks madmanc - you are most kind. And from mchester no doubt? Where were you in '92...

  • I love this,really well done.spot on

  • Nope, doesn't work, just being honest.

  • Very well done. But not sure this stlye suits the song.

  • love this tune. that was a decent version. well done

  • I really adore this song and I have to say that was a top cover, absolutely lovely, well done guys!

  • Guys that was so Good! I really enjoyed that. your voice was so mornful. it just suited the song perfect. Do you have the tab for this? It's mint!!

  • stunningly good! really really brilliant! well played lads

  • bastard fuckin awesome - ive just been out round the northern quarter and this is perfect man!!!!!!!!!!! love it!

  • Amazing stuff guys!!

  • you remind me of Simon and Garfunkel abit... you should play some of their tunes

    good stuff

  • Techincally speaking it was all very good. But I cant help thinking that the lyrics and tone of the original requiring a snarling and resentful vocal. It was a bit like Enya doing Cigarettes and Alcohol.

  • Nice analogy. Dido singing frigging in the rigging maybe? lol

  • Excellent. Beautiful.

    Peace

    Joe

  • Wow....amazing!

  • hi guys if you like this version we have a studio recording (better quality) in our videos section. cheers

  • I never normally write on these comment sections but felt necessary after seeing this wonderful version- straight out the top draw. Any chance you could cover Waterloo sunset by the kinks

  • Gentlemen...have been raving to all about this since I heard it. Most mellow and superbly arranged and executed. Everyone who hears it thinks it's the dogs danglers. Thumbs up!

    How about a cover of Going Down or She Bangs the Drums? I reckon you'd have the making of both, no bother!!

  • Nice job guys...could do with a bit more umph if you know what I mean...but then I suppose it's your cover :)

  • yes it is theirs.

    so do a better one or fuck off

  • Why are you so angry?

  • this is a nice version :)

  • Can i down load this for my mp3 or buy a copy

  • We have just recorded this in a studio so once it's mixed we will let you have a copy. Thanks for your comments

  • Am a massive stone roises fan didnt think i would like this cover but it was a shit hot cover keep up the good work boys

  • Comment removed

  • AMAZING! KEEP IT UP!!

  • Totally agree with gazadub. This is my all time favourite song (and i have many) but this is the greatest piece of rock ever. And you made it so diffrent but brilliant. It really works. You 2 fellas should be proud- that's a great cover of a flawless song.

  • would of liked to hear your interpretation of the extended version with the guitar riff at the end , just a thought if your goin to record...

  • wow this blew me away , the original is 1 of my favorite tunes of all time and I've heard countless covers , but this is just so different and it works ...thanx :)

  • This is the absolute ticket!! Seriously didnt think when i heard the intro that it would work, but fluck me..Top top cover lads!

  • I'd pay for this. Very very good in deed. You got a clean version (i.e. less crackles)?

    Seriously - will buy if you sell, or lots of gratitude for a download...

  • Thanks for your comments Phil we appreciate it.

    We are going into a studio end of Jan to record a demo. We will happily send you a copy then - or an MP3. All the best

  • Just listened again and this is really good, totally different vibe to the original but yet it really works. Your playing and singing is excellent! do you have she bangs the drums?!

  • The start sounds like Just Looking by the Stereophonics, esp that chord change at 0.16..."there's things I want....there's things I think I want"....!!

    But apart from that, really good! Sound is a bit off though

  • that was superb lads, great singing!

  • Nice version of a classic tune!!

  • Jaw droppingly amazing, turns an excellent song into a beautiful piece of poetry

  • i felt that!!!!

  • fantastic job!!!!! GREAT!!!

  • i actually love this version more thn the original!!!!

  • do u have the file o this for my ipod?

  • ill sort it bud

  • my favourite stone roses song n you two boys fuckin made it your bitch. absoloutly top draw. i wanna get it on me i pod . cheers

  • Always said the mark of a good song is one whose feeling could be completely changed yet still sound great. This is a good song. well done.

  • Absolutely stunning work chaps..one of my favourite songs to play, and your arrangement gave me goosebumps!

    Sung with a lot of soul, and chilled me to the core

  • Excellent Stuff !

  • Brilliant cover!

  • I initally watched this video thinking it would be two guys murdering one of my favourite songs of all time. But wow its amazing

  • Really quite moving...

  • Couldn't imagine this song being done accoustically. brilliant! well done

  • Sound very nice more subtle and subdued than ian and roses and all the better for it. excellent :-)

  • very good job.

  • I felt a tingle in my clangers, whilst listening to this! Bravo!

  • im usual quite critical and a grumpy fucker when people on here do cover because more often than not they ruin the song, but this was great stuff

  • that was amazing, i could listen to you two lads all nite, BRILLIANT!

  • superb...really bloody good.

  • Wow I actually didn't like that, it was like a church choir version. sorry

  • Great cover lads, this song suits that melody very well, I've done a slightly different cover of a stone roses track check it out if you have time. Well done

  • Great cover

  • Crikey, this is mega. As said elsewhere, nailed it :)

  • Superb

  • actually great.

  • amazing lads

  • Nice cover indeed

    like another comment said not at all what i was expecting

  • Nailed it Lads, best version ever

  • Thumbs Up!!

  • This is wicked!

    This is one of my all time favorite songs and you guys do it brilliantly!

  • Beautifuly done guys, never expected this and was totally blown away by it!! I love the Stone Roses being from where there from and gettin caught up in the whole Madchester thing back in the day...this is kinda bringin the curtain down on that generation, almost soundtrack like. Wonderful;)

  • thanks mudman that's a really nice feedback - makes it all worthwhile :-)

    Can you think of any other tracks from the Madchester era (where were you in 92?) we could cover. We got some Oasis and we are both massive fans of that whole Madchester sound. Happy to take requests! We play in Midlands, Lincs - so if you are from round there and know of good music pubs we could play let us know. All the best

  • I guess other obvious choices from that period would be The Charlatans "The Only One I know" Any Stone Roses especially "Waterfall" and maybe Northside "Shall We Take a Trip" In answer to ya question i'm from Manchester (well Salford). Keep up the great work fella's:)

  • The stone roses steered well clear of the "madchester" scene they didnt want to be associated with it

    just thought is mention that

  • Ya right sid they did'nt want to be associated with it, but had no choice since they themselves had created it...it was only when everyone else jumped on the bandwagon that they wanted to get off, just thought i'd mention that;)

  • great cover guys.5stars

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more