The technical requirement of hte Waldstein Piano Sonata surpass any czerny's piano exercises. If you think you can master the Czerny Op 740 you are only at the tip of this Piano Sonata !
smithsherman makes some telling points. In terms of interpretation, I would say idiosyncracies or a more liberal interpretation of the piece shouldn't be supressed. You're a clinical technician but there's a bit of the sterile coming through here. I would love to hear more of your stuff. You are incredibly talented. Reach for some depth of contrast. Dramatize those pianos and fortes and linger on the phrasing. I can imagine you play Bach with some dexterity.
Read his whole comment: he said "Youare incredibly talented". Sirrom thinks this guy is a genius, and is giving him pointers on how to be even better. No problem with that.
i hate people like you who think people have to be better to criticize on someone. Criticism is criticism, no matter how good you are or if you are better than the person. Unless your saying positive criticism is bad too?
Everyone is talking about the Barenboim interpretation, is there a video of him playing on youtube (playing Waldstein i mean)? Great video by the way.
Wonderful. You started playing and never stopped, and all of your notes were so clean and even, which is a sign of excellent technique. I can always compare this piece(and Bach's "Solfeggietto") to trains that never stop to rest and just keep going. Beautiful.
Wow ! This Sonata is SOOO beautiful and you have done a very precise work on it. Your musical involvment is quite perfect, your technique is well employed. It's so clean !!
awesome! this is one of my favorite songs ever! i like to call them songs just to piss of the people who get mad.
great technique. it sounds so clean. nice voicing and coloring too. and you have a really great touch. it's so light and playful during the right parts. good job. and you play the really melodic part with the chords so nicely!
Very nice, although the repeated chords @ the start and elsewhere in the piece seemed too slow to me: i heard repetition instead of a mystery. I am not a piano teacher, but since the speed you have chosen seems to fit your style very well in the rest of the piece, perhaps you should sustain those repeated chords (c+ and later f+) a little more; or make them grow, to get rid of the chop-chop-chop feeling. U're a very good player.
Very nice. I think your performance may not 'seem' as fast as others because you maintain clarity at all times-clarity of notes and clarity of phrase.
I would suggest experimenting with your posture. Try sitting further from the keyboard so that you can lean in and get more weight into your hands. Also your shoulders slouch a bit. Try a more upright posture and deep breaths, without tensing up.
thought it was a good steady tempo not too fast, not too slow. Fantastic technique. I'm learning the piece now and it's dang hard specially some of those trills/oscillating passages. Your tone in some of the slower passages was beautiful would have been better live - is that a steinway you're playing on?
It's a piece, and there's NO way this would sound better faster. It will lose its musical sense. I've heard it played faster, and it sounds pretty ridiculous. This tempo is pretty good.
Everything he plays is excellent. Love it!
lllllllllllllll88 1 year ago
This is my favourite performance of this piece. Excellent. 10 out of 5.
onezeroeightzero 1 year ago
Perfect.... what more can I say?
BehindThatLockedDoor 2 years ago
This performance is just perfect. Nobody could play it better and nobody ever has. Thank you, Mr. Lenner!
fredericko9 2 years ago
@fredericko9 Maybe Beethoven himself mate...
chensey 1 month ago
Edward Lenner is /the/ most underrated pianist I've heard on youtube. Simply wonderful playing.
romman0012003 2 years ago
I love the volume control. I agree, world class.
analyzingfunny 3 years ago
that was a world class performance.
raptors4444 3 years ago 2
Good. Very good.
dolofonos 3 years ago
Perfect!
fystasjoppheng 3 years ago
highschool 1st grade piece.
konzolmester 3 years ago
show a video of you playing it then mate
peggo8 3 years ago 10
i love this sound
ack0328 3 years ago
DanielBeetsma you really have no idea what you're talking about. That was great tempi at intro! Not slow at all.
SailorVVV 3 years ago 2
holy shnikeys you r tottay awesome
jacon954 4 years ago
u r tottaly awesome . dood you could play for a livin one day
jacon954 4 years ago
dood that was awesome
jacon954 4 years ago
Superb - reminds me of a recording by Dubravka Tomsic; you've made it your own tho' .
snazzyboy4077 4 years ago
you have perfect finger movements
Gozaburo1 4 years ago
I'm not worthy!
Spectrarocks 4 years ago 2
The technical requirement of hte Waldstein Piano Sonata surpass any czerny's piano exercises. If you think you can master the Czerny Op 740 you are only at the tip of this Piano Sonata !
canman5060 4 years ago 5
Great performance. Love the theme from 1:26~1:40 (and its repetitions / evolutions afterwards)
t3hwasabi 4 years ago
sounds better than other recordings!
seahyimin 4 years ago 2
perfectly articulated, on beat, and great interpreation, emotion, tempo was not rushed as well. great!
koreanjeenyus 4 years ago
It's a little cold... No?... It's very exact, but too dry I think. Good job anyway.
godelike 4 years ago
awesome performance! the opening theme always reminds me of the neverending story for some reason.
brazjol 4 years ago
Super, époustouflant, toutes mes félicitations ! Mais vous pourriez peut-être prendre un peu plus de temps dans le "choral".
AmelieP85 4 years ago
That was great. I'm trying to learn this one but just in the beginning stages. You seem to have a built-in metronome in your head. Anyhow, great job!
cflboy1968 4 years ago
beutiful interpretation. I love this sonata. You play it superb
eifeldude1 4 years ago 2
smithsherman makes some telling points. In terms of interpretation, I would say idiosyncracies or a more liberal interpretation of the piece shouldn't be supressed. You're a clinical technician but there's a bit of the sterile coming through here. I would love to hear more of your stuff. You are incredibly talented. Reach for some depth of contrast. Dramatize those pianos and fortes and linger on the phrasing. I can imagine you play Bach with some dexterity.
sirromtrebor 4 years ago
if you cant do better shut up...i hate people like you
bfoolish2006 4 years ago
Read his whole comment: he said "Youare incredibly talented". Sirrom thinks this guy is a genius, and is giving him pointers on how to be even better. No problem with that.
7beers 4 years ago
i hate people like you who think people have to be better to criticize on someone. Criticism is criticism, no matter how good you are or if you are better than the person. Unless your saying positive criticism is bad too?
xxh3llfir3xx 3 years ago
Nice.. you play very fluently...
globe014 4 years ago
Everyone is talking about the Barenboim interpretation, is there a video of him playing on youtube (playing Waldstein i mean)? Great video by the way.
Chazdaspazzzz 4 years ago
Lovely. My favorite sonata is definetly this one.
Havenscope 4 years ago
Wonderful. You started playing and never stopped, and all of your notes were so clean and even, which is a sign of excellent technique. I can always compare this piece(and Bach's "Solfeggietto") to trains that never stop to rest and just keep going. Beautiful.
scottturner1994 4 years ago
Dear Ed,LVB is on to something here.Acquire the
Bärenboim and use it as a compedium on interpretive
strategies that can turn Beethoven from a vital
disturbing fantastical thing to such a benignely
refined creme-puff lullaby,that even the most
inveterate sleep-apniasts will finally get some
rest.Your Friend,Smith
smithsherman 4 years ago
You are an awesome kid! I LOVE your playing!
FIVE STARS, favored, and SUBSCRIBED!
LOVE it!
Keep up the excellent work! I love that kids still love the classic.
(^o^)
(> <)
hugz!
YGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYGYG 4 years ago
OwarrO, are you Eduard Lenner? Anyway, nice playing.
Have you seen Daniel Barenboim's master class on the
Waldstein? It is a wealth of great information that you may want to see on DVD! It's worth every penny!
LVB1770 4 years ago
great job, i didn't like it as much until i heard this
narcolepsybraids 4 years ago
Wow ! This Sonata is SOOO beautiful and you have done a very precise work on it. Your musical involvment is quite perfect, your technique is well employed. It's so clean !!
Bravo bravo !
mumultiple 4 years ago
What I liked most in your playing was a tendency
towards tongue and cheek.The structure was at times
almost subtle and almost not predictable.I wish
that you would build on these characteristics
and make your Beethoven experience a delightfully
unpredictable,unmechanical,rhetorically inventive
experience.Don't look to your contemporaries for
inspiration in this,though!
smithsherman 4 years ago
Bravo dude. That was excellant. It was nice that you didn't play it too fast.
Thaugn 4 years ago
brilliant.
rstylee1 4 years ago
I like it fast good job dude must of worked very hard 5 stars
lordlactose 4 years ago
just awesome, so flawless played
dxl1337 5 years ago
fantastic interpretation. I love this Sonata, it is one of my favorites
eifeldude1 5 years ago
perfect
doctorwho888 5 years ago
:-) Thanks for the recording... enjoyed it much.
MikeAndersenPiano 5 years ago
awesome! this is one of my favorite songs ever! i like to call them songs just to piss of the people who get mad.
great technique. it sounds so clean. nice voicing and coloring too. and you have a really great touch. it's so light and playful during the right parts. good job. and you play the really melodic part with the chords so nicely!
goosiedragon 5 years ago
very well played!
maybe a little bit opening in crescendos but overall is very clear and solidly played, I think the tempo is fine, it does not need to be faster...
ritorenello 5 years ago
sounds nice. i'll learn that
seahyimin 5 years ago
Not as fast!? Any faster and it would be a stream of white noise. I prefer this performance to Gilel's.
fernando5821 5 years ago
Very nice, although the repeated chords @ the start and elsewhere in the piece seemed too slow to me: i heard repetition instead of a mystery. I am not a piano teacher, but since the speed you have chosen seems to fit your style very well in the rest of the piece, perhaps you should sustain those repeated chords (c+ and later f+) a little more; or make them grow, to get rid of the chop-chop-chop feeling. U're a very good player.
DanielBeetsma 5 years ago
Very nice. I think your performance may not 'seem' as fast as others because you maintain clarity at all times-clarity of notes and clarity of phrase.
I would suggest experimenting with your posture. Try sitting further from the keyboard so that you can lean in and get more weight into your hands. Also your shoulders slouch a bit. Try a more upright posture and deep breaths, without tensing up.
Overall, very nice.
igdonp 5 years ago
thought it was a good steady tempo not too fast, not too slow. Fantastic technique. I'm learning the piece now and it's dang hard specially some of those trills/oscillating passages. Your tone in some of the slower passages was beautiful would have been better live - is that a steinway you're playing on?
bungu1984 5 years ago
great job!
your technique is awsome the only thing is that the song is acually alot faster then you play it. but its still amazing. :)
ironmaiden4580 5 years ago
It's a piece, and there's NO way this would sound better faster. It will lose its musical sense. I've heard it played faster, and it sounds pretty ridiculous. This tempo is pretty good.
Anyway. Great performance :) How old are you?
AngelinaTaylor 5 years ago
ironmaiden4580,
Oh, so you are a scholar on Beethoven tempi?
Many pianist's play it at this tempo. Just because
you may have heard pianist's play it faster doesn't
mean anything. By the way, its not a song. A song has lyrics.
LVB1770 5 years ago
Listen to Arrau's version... ;)
godelike 4 years ago
i like Arrau's playing, this is pretty good also :)
imaoldkidnow 3 years ago
??? show me a recording that is "a lot faster" please O_o
godelike 4 years ago
really good!
wonderful!
exellent!
Slava69 5 years ago