Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (445)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I like GHWT better than Rock Band just because it's just a blast on every instrument. There's not really any bad songs to play in GHWT while some songs in Rock Band 2 are just not fun.

  • If you ever get bored of guitar hero try heroine hero ;D

  • ROCK BAND is a lot better than Guitar hero is notable i like some guitar hero games but they r losing they style coping from rock band : i like a lot more rock band

  • Rockband, GH blah blah blah who cares, just grab them both..theyre both fun in their ways, why not have ALL the fun by getting both of them, seriously these arguements are getting crude and just plain obsolete.

  • Harmonix: Quality rhythm games 4life.

    ActiVision: DOSH DOSH DOSH DOSH DOSH DOSH DOSH DOSH

  • Rock Band Tbh :L its clearer for me

  • guitar hero of course...

    rock band sucks

  • rock band failed

  • guitar hero has to many notes on the screen, rockband feels as if its playing the actual song you're playing the actual notes to the song. yes i can play on expert im not complaining about the amount notes im complaining about realism. im a nub i know

  • right.... of course....

  • @Killa1949 Don't worry, I agree. After 5*ing all of GH3 (Bonus Songs not included), I went to rock band and have never looked back. Songs don't need to be overcomplicated to be fun.

  • cada cual tiene lo suyo y es cuestion de gustos, a mi me gusta mas guitar hero, pero tal vez rock band le guste a otros, es como la comida, aun asi que ganamos en ponernos haber cual es mejor, mejor juguemos el que mas nos guste y ya

  • RoCk BaND rUlE"S

  • i bought Guitar Hero Metallica... its k but i'm not really a metallica fan.. Does the guitar work on Rock Band 2 cos i'm thinking of getting it (GH:Metallica was made after GH:WT i believe) its on the Wii if that helps...

  • So, witch is better overall 4 cotrollers, playlist(un-locking) and career mode!!!!!!!!???????

  • true very true.

  • rock band its 1234451235 times more than real than guitar hero but the guitar hero its more for the family

  • pura mierda esto que se ponen a peliar por mera estupides lo dos son muy buenos juegos!

  • yeah but just instrumental, no vocals and its very boring to be editating all the damn day

  • You lot seem to know your stuff, i have neither game. Basically from this i have gathered that ghwt guitar is better but rb drums are more sensitive. Any more tips? And can i buy rb starter kit (I want the paramore songs) and then just get the ghwt game and use the drums etc from rb with the other game?

  • thats a lie he is saying that the drums in GHWT is hard its not is expert because im on expert in drums of everlong and memorize it and just saying that so that RB2 is better which it izn't

  • they look the same fools

  • i like challenging games i say ghwt is better no offense to those rock BAND lovers i ve played rock band before and its fun but i just have to go with ghwt again no offense to those rock band lovers

  • rock band 2 is party friendly. ghwt is just harder with the kids that dont know the song. rock band is better

  • i think if u showed the intro would have made it better cuz its awesome on expert drums

  • i do like hte song system in tour is better then world tour

  • rock is better than guitar hero guitar hero is not good

  • rock band looks funner to play

  • my dick hallsocker go suck on ur socks...srry that was lame but ur wrong hallsocker(lmao)rockband is better to me

  • the hard on ghwt is just as hard as the expert on rb

  • GHWT is better

  • Those who are saying Rock Band is a Rip-Off should do their homeowrk. GH1 and GH2 are made by Harmonix, who makes Rock Band now.

  • @Jordey24

    I know I got fags on other videos who need to know that and they are retarded.

  • @Jordey24 and GH: rocks the 80's

  • You know, I think it would be a better nerd world if this happened: Microsoft, Nintendo, and Sony combined to form Microninony. Also, that Harmonix and Neversoft combined to form Musicsoft? Imagine a combinded version of the drums. (Who cares about the mics) Guitars that are godly. And tracks that feature metal (sorry i'm like that). And like Rock Bands BAND gameplay feel. And Guitar Hero's difficulty. But screw that I play all that on real instruments :)

  • That;d be awesome. Or even better , how about a Dual-neck guitar controller ? >:-D

  • rock band. the full band play is alot better and i feel guitar hero kinda just copied what they did in world tour. other than that guitar hero is branching off way too much. i liked GH when it was just 1 2 and 3. after WT, smash hits, metallica etc etc etc its getting out of hand. im not gonna buy all that shit just to play more songs. ima stick with rockband and its great DLC and now customs ^^

  • You know... I think GH:WT has the better overall trackset (but WTF @ "On The Road Again"?) and better drums (oh, the irony)... and I like it's encore system for unlocks a little more, too; but RB2 has the better scoring and tour system, the better guitar controllers, and probably the better interface as well. I also liked how "Play Challenge" had CONSIDERABLY more (and more sensible) tracklists to play, than simply featuring them all once.

    I still miss the indie/bonus influence that GH2 had.

  • Guitar hero has always had the better tracks...

  • rock band ownz guitar hero. RB FTW!!

  • The GHWT side is Full Expert also dude

  • rock ban 2 looks moe energenic

  • Lets see:

    How many of the people who prefer GH have ever played GH2? Not many.

    Everyone who knows a quality game would choose RB2. The critics did, and so did all the hardcore players. And oh yeah, so did the creators of Guitar Hero.

  • I stopped playing GH after 3 >.>. Rock Band just powned ass so hard...

  • Yeah. I like Guitar Hero for lead/rhythm Co-Op, and i wish they'd make more games like that, but leave full band stuff to Rock Band, they no how to do it. :D

  • the guitar playing is more fun on rb but the drums sucks

  • Rock bands drums are so booring, ghwt drums look more real than rockbands,and rockband has 4 colours,5 with the pedal...and the songs sucks

  • rock band 2 has an ion kit with is 100000000000000000000000000000­0000000000000000000000 better than stupid, fragile damn ghwt drums

  • rb2 is better than ghwt cuz it has a complete band w/ teh bass while ghwt dosen't.

  • both are shit get a real guitar and learn to play!

  • 2 rite m8!

  • i have rock band 2 for ps3 and rock band 1 for ps2. can i still export

  • nope

  • i got rb2 and ghwt an rb its better

  • The drums on world tour are expert not hard

  • The DLC for Rock Band is just so much better, which makes it superior to GHWT.

  • Huh?

  • Comment removed

  • yeah i totally agree dude

  • which game is better, guitar hero world tour or rock band 2?

  • GHWT except the drums in rockband have better sensitivity than the GHWT drums

  • Who gives which ones better

  • both of the games were made by the same company

  • No, i heard that rock band 1 & 2 were made by the guys that made GH1

  • kool thanx for the info

  • gh1 gh2 and gh 80s

  • no.

    Harmonix dose Rock Band. they did the earlyr guitar heros, guitar hero 1,2 80's.

    Activision dose guitar hero

  • thanx

    what rock band is better 1 or 2

  • rock band 2 of course! if you have rock band 1, you can import all songs from rock band 1 into rock band 2 and future rock band games. they will save to the hard drive and loaded from there. it works on Both Playstation 3 and Xbox 360. also 300+ downloadable songs win.

    guitar hero instraments are compatible with rock band 2. i recomend using a guitar hero guitar over a rock band guitar for guitar/bass playing.

  • thanx

    im ganna buy both games

  • make sure you have 5$ to spend to buy and download the export key for importing songs on both consoles.

    then just go to on rock band 1, go to extras, and export.

  • wow,i would never figured that out by myself

    thanx for helping me out a lot

  • no problem

  • Me too i already got GHWT but i will also buy Rb ;)

  • i prefer Rock Band, GHWT was just a cheap rip off of RockBand just so it wouldnt run out of buisness and also GHWT Has shitty Songs

  • rock band2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!

  • Why does everyone feel the need to offend each other?

    Personally, I prefer Rock Band, as it has a much clearer picture, easier to play but harder to master, and has more of my favourite tracks. But I can understand why some prefer Guitar Hero.

  • GH Metallica FTW (i know its not in the vid =P)

  • wtf

    guitar hero has sold twice as many copies than shit band get your fucking facts straight

  • yea seriously.. and second off.. their both made by harmonics.. their both gernally good game.. so everyone plz... stfu

  • ghwt isnt made by harmonix, only gh1 gh2 and gh 80s were harmonix, and now harmonix is making rock band

  • guitar hero is SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOO MUCH BETTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • yea right is that why ghwt sold only 1 mil copies and rb sold 6.5 yeaaa get raped

  • wtf bitch gh sold more

  • Sorry, but on the GHWT side, everybody is on expert.

    By the way, RB2 = GHWT

  • Guitar hero is sooooo much better than rock band

    rock band is a piece of shit!

  • ya right

  • they are basically both the same. neither is harder then the other.....

  • wow you put the song at a spot where on rockband 2 is a little easier then guitar hero wt still the whole song is way harder on rb2 guitar hero wt suks

  • gth ftw

  • Comment removed

  • dude GHWT and Rock Band are all in expert and GHWT drums have it in expert 4reals i have GHWT and i play the drums so everlong on GHWT is in expert if u dont belevie me see it for ur self

  • Rock Band is better. Better quality. Guitar Hero delivers as a cheap game. The little circle icons bugs me rather as in RockBand they hava large Rectangles.

  • I own both, and I like both for different reasons :)

  • Honestly, Gameplay wise I like Rock Band 2. Their downloadable content is superior as well.

    But without downloadable content, GHWT has the better playlist.

  • I can't get why people think RB2 is easier than GHWT... GHWT is not a hard game at all and RB2 is a lot harder, due to songlist and tighter timing window.

  • tbh, as far as guitar goes, I found them both pretty easy :(

    I miss challenge :)

  • @Kostaja93 which is why i fail at fail at guitar hero

  • 2Gpop i sooo agree with you man...people say for example; ''i like rb2 better'' its because they own rb2 and not ghwt, so if someone owns ghwt theyre gonna say GHWT is better but i own rb2 in this case so RB2 is better!!

  • rock band 2 is better because of the playlist AC/DC & Guns N' Roses the only one you hav to worry about is fallout bitch

    GHWT has got ozzy,SOAD and motoerhead but it has more crap than rock band like 30 seconds to mars and those songs witch arnt even english. guitar hero 3 has the best playlist so far i think.

  • This is how I break it down.

    World Tour is for Hardcore people, whom like a challenge.

    Rock Band 2 slightly easier, easy for the whole family, hence the No Fail mode.

  • i love guitar hero, but i dont hate rock band.

  • I personally think rock band 2 is a better game, in overall presentation, to the song list, to the fact that the tour mode doesn't consist of you picking posters from a room, with no real motivation other than to get the next song. Rock band 2 gets you to keep playing. Plus, it's note layout makes more sense. though i do agree that GH intrustments (with the execption of the drums) are better

  • theonly reason why people licertain ones is because they own it, say like me, i own ghwt so i like it better than rockband 2, but if i owned rockband 2 i would probablly like it more if i didn't own ghwt. u get what im saying?

  • I have both, and GH all the way, RB makes the songs too easy, and RB was a plain copy to start with, even though they both copied guitar freakz and beat mania

    the GH3 guitar is much better than the RB one (which has the tendency to fall apart) and the GH drumkit is way better than the RB one, the kick pedal is stronger, and the whole kit is quieter, plus the RB soundtrack rips from GH

    RB is just wayy too easy

  • Actually, if you consider Rock Band a copy of Guitar Freaks and drum mania, then you should also look at the fact that GH:WT is a copy of Guitar Freaks and Drum mania AND Rock Band since it was released after Rock Band.

    I agree that the Guitar Hero peripherals are superior, but the bass pedal certainly isn't. It's cheaply made, and is nothing like the real thing.

    Also, it's the Guitar Hero soundtrack that ripped from RB because of reasons stated before.

    Guitar Hero fanboy is obvious.

  • Although I should mention that I DO own both games. They're both pretty good, but really in all honesty I can say that Rock Band has a superior songlist, but only because it has songs that I like.

    The drums for GH are alright, but with only 3 drum pads will limit itself a lot because the charting for drum fills will not look as nice as Rock Band 4 pads.

    btw MY OPINION. I'm alright with everyone's opinion as long as they state some strong factual points and not go fanboy for either games.

  • even though the RB soundtrack, and songpack 1 ripped tracks from GH 1 through to 3?

    I prefer the challenge of GH, makes the game last much longer seeing as i can pretty much FC every song on RB1, songpack 1 and AC/DC RB

    The plastic in the RB kick pedal is weaker than that in the GH one mind

    but they are both enjoyable games

    though I did laugh when EA had a lawsuit brought out against them due to copyright infringement (due to Konami being patent holders of instrument controllers)

  • you are right

  • The games are equal to me. :/ And I have both.

  • i agree i wouldve liked GH if it stayed with guitar but its new drums just killed it.

    i think Rock Band 2 beats GH

  • i aqree

  • Guitar Hero is for guitar. That's how it should have stayed.

  • i have both... guitar hero has songs for old people and a has great graphics.. rrockband has WAY more songs than GH and is quite harder to play songs with hammerons. my vote is rockband 2 since the GHWT music and online suck bad. 1 OUT OF 20 TRYIES FOR GOING ONLINE ON GH WORK WHERE AS ROCKBAND 2 WORKS EVERY SINGLE TIME.

  • i prefer of all the GH games.... my ps2 and gh1 =D

  • then that means you like Rock Band.

    get with the program!

    GH:3 and GH:WT are a piece of crap.

  • u know what would be the best??? turntable hero

    or dj hero i dunno somethin like that

  • that was called Beat Mania.

    made mid to late 90's.

  • that was the cheesiest gh4 gameplay ever (no offence)

  • the only thing i dont like about guitarhero is how it doesnt look like they r really strumming or picking right for example ghwt and the past guitarhero games(gh1 2 3, encore, etc) ive playd guitar for awhile now and i think i should know.

  • The gh drums are on expert not hard

  • These 2 games should put away their differences and combine the 2 games. Rock Hero.

  • NO, that sounds gay and cheesy

  • wt is better, rockband was just a rip off of guitar hero, they just tried to make it better and it ended up being shitty anyway.. they rushed what guitar hero was planning out ahead of time; to even compare a game like that to gh is like comparing Marisa Miller to your mom

  • Comment removed

  • GHWT :)

  • rock band 2 beats guitar hero world tour its better graphics and songs

  • who cares about the graphics

  • activision does.

  • just think this:

    rockband came out with drums,guitar,microphone, and bass. next year guitar hero came with drums,guitar,microphone, and bass. make sense?

  • what else can they add to it?

  • keyboard lol

  • yeh but think about it

    how many ROCK bands/songs have keyboard in them? not the fact that it has to have a good chart etc..

    it probably wouldnt work

  • guitar hero is the best and rock band 2 is the worst because of harmonix and mtv

  • rock band 2!!! wins plus way better songs

  • W Wolrd Tours!!!!!!!!!!!! Wolrd Tours win

  • its not the same ROCK BAND CHART SUCKS... GUITAR HERO OWNS!

  • GH FOR LIFE:::::::

  • guitar hero copied rock band

  • Just think. Who copied guitar hero in the first place???

  • umm, you know the people who made rock band were the original makers of GH, right?

  • harmonix didn't make GH Activision and neversoft did

  • Activision and neversoft made GH3, not GH1 and 2. Harmonix got bought by MTV and neversoft took over GH.

    So Harmonix are the original creators of GH.

  • No, Activision and Neversoft and Harmonix all helped with the first GH. Harmonix quit before GH2 was thought of. Activision and Neversoft then created the next 3 GHs and Harmonix started making RB 1 and 2

  • umm.............no

  • No, idiot. Harmonix made Guitar Hero 1, Guitar Hero 2, and Rocks the 80s. They then sold the franchise to Activision, who, IMO, ruined the series. Harmonix went on to create Rock Band, which Activision (Neversoft) then copied for WT.

  • UnknownRider94

    HMX and MTV games created GH1,GH2,GH:80's.

    after that they dropped and created Rock Band

    from then on out Neversoft/Activision made GH3,GHA,GHWT,GHM,ETC.

    do some research before opening your mouth you dumbass.

  • i love guitar hero because of their songs

    they r so international! puting not only "USA songs" and "British Songs" i loved la bamba so much!

  • me 2!

  • rock band looks way better

  • rb2 is the best!!!!!!!!!

  • Rock Band Looks To Easy, So Should I Get Guitar Hero

  • yes

  • rock band 2 is the best!!!!!!!!!

  • i know right

  • wow...all the people who watch this video are GH fanpussies.

  • so you must be talking about your self

  • umm...i'm not a GH fanpussy. I'm an RB fanpussy (lol). GH sucks

  • who cares which is better (gh:wt) is but still everyone has an opion that GUITAR HERO WORLD TOUR KILLS RB2!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • guitar heroes drums on hard are more challenging then rock band 2 on expert.

  • Demonhawk,

    First off Withough guitar hero there wouldent be guitar hero 3 because Harmonix (makers of rockband (2) guitar hero (2)) sold their game to actavision after GH2 because they wanted to do something els.

    Also i have played guitar hero and rock band and rock band is BY FAR more challenging because of the DLC and songs like visions and panic attack.

  • rb the best gh looks kidish

  • both look awsome but guitar hero world tour is better

  • Rock band 2 is better for multiplayer, and Guitar Hero World Tour is better for single player. All in my opinion of course.

  • GH = TEH HARDCORZ!!!

  • does guitar hero world tour have thos things that the rock band 2 has at 0:10-0:12? if u know plz w/b.

  • no. guitar hero you have to hit the two top cymbals to use star power.

  • thats stupid i want rock band.

  • hmmm there both good games but rock band is better @ drums and mic it sucks at guitar tho but there both good games but i like rb2 better

  • obviously ghwt owns rb2, it is just so much more fun.

  • how did gh copy off of rock band.

  • RB copied GH, any fan of GH converted to RB still calls overdrive "Star Power"

  • Harmonix, the people who made Rock Band made Guitar Hero. Then Activision and Neversoft bought the rights to Guitar Hero. Therefore, Harmonix didn't COPY Guitar Hero, they just moved on to bigger and better things.

    And let me tell you, Harmonix is definitely doing a better job with their games.