I almost expected jazz hands, I mean you all have wonderful voices, but this was just a horrible rendition of the song. The song is extremely solemn an still, your movements and theatricality kinda ruined that.
amazing, but a tad too upbeat for my taste. sufjan's music is extremely soft and emotional, and i feel as though a lot of that was lost in this version.
You need a stronger bass... the chords all mash together with really no discernible change in chords. I was only able to follow because I know the chords of the original. Either that or the sopranos are too loud... I think it could be good with some work!
i think the lead should in a higher register.
bplumser 1 month ago
makes me think of egypt.... totally the opposite of what the song means
netforce0 11 months ago
I almost expected jazz hands, I mean you all have wonderful voices, but this was just a horrible rendition of the song. The song is extremely solemn an still, your movements and theatricality kinda ruined that.
KidsNeedToSwear 1 year ago
amazing, but a tad too upbeat for my taste. sufjan's music is extremely soft and emotional, and i feel as though a lot of that was lost in this version.
nonetheless you all have amazing voices
kiao1208 1 year ago
I quite agree with the other comments. You all sing perfectly and it's quite powerful too, but it lost a bit of the emotion of the original version .
unitespeciale 1 year ago
you are good, but the arrangement is too jazzy. It takes away the stillness and introspectiveness of the original song.
dunkelhaven 1 year ago
It's not the same as when Sufjan Stevens sings it, but it's beautiful. I wish I could hear it in person-- the acoustics don't do the group justice.
commentxxpolice 1 year ago
Great, but the ladies overpower the guys sometimes.
purlywhites 1 year ago
the last half was really beautiful
Stephie7932 1 year ago
Ay [=
you came to my school oday haha i just remembered this song and i looked it up and found this, so just wanna say that you guys were really good [=
ViccMuffin 2 years ago
You need a stronger bass... the chords all mash together with really no discernible change in chords. I was only able to follow because I know the chords of the original. Either that or the sopranos are too loud... I think it could be good with some work!
dynamitewalls 2 years ago
I love it :-) Very clever arrangement
moviekisses 2 years ago 2
simply great
Dimitrie24 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
they are ruining the song
marylarockeuse 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
if i had heard this song, i never would have bothered to listen to the original.
dummblonde345 2 years ago
tapping your foot is also suffice, after all, they all have the same tempo. i understand the need for artistry, but to a certain extent.
1889390 2 years ago
sufjan is quite conducive to a cappella cuz there are so many freakin layers. nice.
another1shortdaymore 2 years ago 5
doesn't capture the same feelings
lchialisa 2 years ago 15
all the moving around was too visually distracting from an otherwise great musical performance.
1889390 3 years ago