AMERICAN IDOL 7, Final 5 - NIEL DIAMOND THEME WEEK- My Top 3

[qg6ff]

your choices suck..

[kisser66]

u fucken fag

[Flighn]

heh you watched it mate.

[Deathrayfromheck]

What the fuck man Jason should have been in top 3 of 60s 80s top 9 top 8 top 7 top 5

[tallderektoronto]

sorry man, not a fan of castro - he had a few good weeks for sure but ya

[harrypotter1224]

HI!! To the one who posted this video, thank you VERY MUCH for giving David Archuleta a nice review! At first when I heard you praising Cook, I thought you will be bashing on DA and so I gave you one star for the rating ooopsss sorry!!! But thank God I finished the video, I was wrong, you were fair about your judging and I was amazed coz usually Cook fans will be rude to DA, but again, THANK YOU!! I'll give you a 5 star now!!!

[tallderektoronto]

Thanks. Yes, I don't see the need to insult other singers in a harsh manner. If I do say something negative about one, it's for one of two reasons. Either 1- I never really liked the singers style & sound or 2- A singer did a really bad job & ended up safe over one that I really enjoyed who performed way better and ended up getting the boot ! :) I proudly paised "Cook" as the best this week, but ya, I admit "Archie" did very well with what he chose to sing that night.

[inoue03hana]

THE WINNER IS DAVID COOK!!! YAY!!!

[blueeyez4u23]

Anybody want to tell me what happened last night I had to work late again and didn't get a chance to watch anything.

[justinwalker30]

The top 4 performed, David Cook got good revivews from his 1st song & amazing reviews for his 2nd. David A got good reviews for both songs. Seyesha got mixed reviews for both songs and Jason got average critique from Randy & Paula but a harsh review from Simon on his first and a real clobber on his 2nd !

[auntieks]

jason castro left!!

[tallderektoronto]

yes we know- this video was created and posted the week before.

[TwistedTeezey]

Derek, please get all your fans to go and sign the petition on AI to get the studio version of this song released to ITunes. I tried putting the addy in here but it won't post with it!!

Thanks so much

[tallderektoronto]

I believe I added that during tonight's criqitue Teezey - I'm gonna sign it myself

[tallderektoronto]

All David Cook fans, I am getting this funny feeling that happens every year when there's less than 4 pr 5 people left - the IDOL elimination shocker, we had two allready with David Hernadez and Michael Johns but let's vote for David (as much as we can, if money is tight vote free with your cellphone) so it does not happen - we don't want another "Daughtry" or moment that fans of his are still upset about.

[TwistedTeezey]

Hi Derek, Love your videos!! Love your comments. Come each week to see anything new that you posted!

A TallDerek and David Cook Fan!

[tallderektoronto]

LOL hey that was so cool, thanks - but David is the one we should be proud of, keep voting for him.

[BeeBee207]

UGH...I will not be satisfied with your liking of DC until you realize that he NEVER HAD A FREAKIN EGO!! Yes, I know, I have said this various times on many of your vids. But it just bothers me, how ppl can call such a nice guy and someone who has been through a lot and humbled by it all, an ego-maniac (exaggerated).

I love Cook, and it's all well n good he has another fan but the ego thing really bothers me. like a lot.

[tallderektoronto]

Hi beeBee207, I agree - perhaps ego is not the right word. I appologize for using it during my previous critiques. I think overly stafised and very proud is more appropriate to which he has every right to be. Like you said, he and been through alot himself and with close people to him. If anything, he deserved praise for overcoming any of these obstacles while pulling off excellent performances weekly. Thanks for your comment.

[BeeBee207]

Yay! Now I can gladly say...WOOT WOOT COOKIE we have a new fan!! :) :D

I just think he was having the time of his life and wasn't gonna pretend that he wasn't. And that's what I'd do.

[tallderektoronto]

WOOT WOOT back at ya ! Yes, David Cook won me over almost 2 months ago and I proud to say I am a big fan :) He's living his dream and we can see it on his face every week ! He would be the BEST winner of IDOL'S History for sure.

[othelloisyellow]

nice video! i oveeee david cook!!!!! his second song was awesomee! :)

[tallderektoronto]

Thanks and yes I loved the 2nd song as much as the first

[miknge]

that's why Brooke left cos a lot of ppl thought she'd surely be safe. i'm very sad. her elimination is just so sad and difficult to watch. did you cry too??? but i'm glad she left on a good high note. and oh yeah, Carly Simon loves her!!!!!!!!!!! anyway, David C and Brooke are only my top 2. no top 3. was hoping for a Cook and Brooke finale, now it's never gonna happen

[tallderektoronto]

Awe, well Cook is still in the running - I know what you mean though, Jason should have left before her... but you never know right !

[mrc926]

thanks for post. Good insight.Good review.

[tallderektoronto]

thanks

[mrc926]

Neverheless, taylor Hicks beat Daughtry 'cause it is the number of votes that count-bottom line. Just vote each week & only for one (1) person-not split vote.

[tallderektoronto]

True but taylor was from the south, a large voting block - plus he was so crazy acting that the site that enocurages ppl to votefortheworst (and I am not crediting them at all because they help take away the shows credibility) kept asking people to vote for him thus Daughtry going home early.

Your right about the vote splitting, I myself admit I have given a vite for 2 different people - if you really only want your fave to stay then you should only vote for your #1

[joshlogan1979]

Brooke went home before Jason, crazy

[tallderektoronto]

Should have been Castro

[MEFIDRAM]

I still can't understand all the 'love' and support for Brooke. Her singing makes me nervous. Now, don't get me wrong, I don't dislike her. I think she'd make a great neighbor. But since people like Derek enjoy her- and Derek truly seems like a nice person- then I can accept that there is a fanbase of good folks out there who would buy what she is selling. And although David A. has the much better voice, I think Brooke is more marketable.

[tallderektoronto]

Thanks for the comment Mefidram ! If you can search for Brooke White : Let It Be, Your So Vain & Love Is A Battlefield.

[justinwalker30]

Brooke redeemed herself a bit, Seysha is an actor, Jason should not have made it further than 10th and that's being fair so he can go on tour cause he was a C+ at most times this season - but I agree with alot of people that Michaels Johns, David Hernadez deserved to be there over those 3 fools

[mediajunkie29]

well if your going to put them into your top 5 (and that's what I assume your talking about) then throw Carly in there

[blueeyez4u23]

Well I didn't get to watch anything last night I was at work from what I have seen from your video I really liked David C he was really good

[tallderektoronto]

wicked stuff !

[HollisterDude1978]

STANDOUTS : DAVID C, BROOKE "YES!"